A girl and her father wash up in mysterious shelter by the sea, where they meet a trio of philosophers
Over the next few years, Lina's timeless neighbors become a chosen family. From their home in Foshan, Lina's father has brought only three volumes of a 90-book series named 'The Great Lives of Voyagers.' The books tell the life stories of historian Hannah Arendt, best known for her work '
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
With a setting as fascinating and surreal as The Sea, it's slightly disappointing that the alternating biographies of Arendt, Spinoza, and Du dominate the book. Lina's narration takes a distant backseat to the philosophers' trials, tribulations, and travels. These biographies are supposed to be instructive to Lina's quest to learn why she and her father have come to The Sea without her mother and brother. But this plotline feels largely inert because while readers are reminded of the dangers of totalitarianism and the tragic toll of forced migration and exile, Lina is like us: a passive receiver of familiar messages.
Advertisement
Arendt and Spinoza, in particular, take center stage. We follow Arendt through the formative traumas of her life, including her imprisonment by the Gestapo for researching antisemitism, and eventually, her perilous escape from Nazi-controlled France into Spain. Once in Spain, she travels to Lisbon and boards a ship to America, where she eventually settled and became renowned as an author and thinker. Spinoza's life story follows a similar arc. His pantheistic opinions lead to his expulsion from the Portuguese Jewish community in Amsterdam. Spinoza's philosophies cross over into Arendt's storyline, because her work was strongly influenced by his.
The backstory of Lina's father's involvement in the creation of The Sea is delivered to the reader whole, via flashback, again without Lina having to do very much. This revelatory section happens in a futuristic China where hundreds have died in a Tiananmen Square-like 'catastrophe.' Lina's father finds himself working for a company named Days and Months Technology Corp Ltd., and with a name like that, it's easy to tell that this firm is up to no good.
Advertisement
Lina's father's backstory only makes The Sea more fascinating, and this reader wanted to understand the mechanics of its construction. The payoff, however, stops well short of explaining the science fiction, and Lina's father's betrayal will feel expected for anyone familiar with the Cultural Revolution. The Lina storyline, already hampered by a lack of movement, gets bogged down by repetition and a penchant for mysterious philosophical statements from her neighbors that, unfortunately, recall the musings of Yoda. 'You must let go of your fear
,'
Du Fu's father tells himself at one point. Meanwhile, one of the scholars instrumental to the design of the Sea says, 'The deeper you fall into the architecture of the system…the closer you come to reality.' It's a sentiment Bento and Lina will repeat. 'Time never goes missing,' Bento proclaims. 'I think the structure of reality can be no other way.' While the musicality of such sentences is pleasing, their meanings remain elusive.
Fans of books like Mohsin Hamid's '
Though one can't help but admire the breadth of Thien's imagination, it's the child's story by the sea that this reader wanted more of.
Advertisement
Leland Cheuk is an award-winning author of three books of fiction, most recently '
THE BOOK OF RECORDS
By Madeleine Thien
Norton, 368 pages, $28.99
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
a day ago
- Boston Globe
Vicki Goldberg dies at 88; saw photography through a literary lens
'Goldberg,' she added, 'brought a broad education, insatiable curiosity, and relentless ambition to her work. She showed us that photography was part of our social and cultural landscape.' Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up Ms. Goldberg had a windfall in the case of Bourke-White. In 1973, two years after the photojournalist's death, 8,000 of her photographs and other artifacts were discovered under a stairway in her house in Darien, Conn. Bourke-White had burned most of her diaries, Ms. Goldberg told The New York Times in 1986, but had 'saved everything but the Kleenex,' including menus, receipts, and Time Inc. memo pads. On one pad she'd written, 'Should I marry Erskine Caldwell?' (She and the novelist had a brief and stormy marriage.) Advertisement Ms. Goldberg pored over the trove for an article in New York Magazine and soon embarked on her Bourke-White biography. Advertisement Bourke-White was America's first female photographer to be accredited to cover World War II, a swashbuckling personage who worked for Fortune and then Life magazines. She shot Nazi rallies, and, in agonizing images, the liberation of Buchenwald in Germany. She flew in a Flying Fortress bomber to get shots of a raid on Tunis, Tunisia. She photographed a smug-looking Josef Stalin. Away from the war, she perched on a gargoyle atop the Chrysler Building in Manhattan to photograph its twin and made perhaps what is the most famous portrait of Mahatma Gandhi, sitting cross-legged with his spinning wheel. Ms. Goldberg captured her contradictions. As an ambitious photojournalist, Bourke-White was wily, opportunistic, and courageous, but she was also manipulative, doing whatever it took to get her shot, including crying on cue. Writing in The New York Times Book Review, Timothy Foote, a former foreign correspondent for Life magazine, called Ms. Goldberg's biography 'an intricate and provocative portrait, as revealing as fiction, part 'Great Gatsby,' say, part 'I'll Take Manhattan.'' Ms. Goldberg's scholarship was rigorous and her knowledge expansive. Yet as a critic for the Times, where she was a regular contributor during the 1990s, her tone was light and often slightly bemused. When Madonna's much-ballyhooed 'Sex' book appeared in 1992, wrapped in Mylar, like a condom, Ms. Goldberg had this to say: 'This must be the most gorgeously, even lavishly, produced piece of junk food since Midas tried to sneak a potato chip and found his touch had turned it to gold.' In 1997, she wrote about Irving Penn, the celebrated Vogue photographer. 'Penn has spent over half a century wielding a camera against the most implacable enemies: disorder, imperfection, the distracting natural world, mortality. He has not exactly come to terms with any of these but erected what barriers he could -- a stringent sense of order to fend off chaos, a fierce devotion to a kind of photographic purity, a stripped-down sense of isolation to counter the world's insistent clutter.' Advertisement Victoria Hesse Liebson was born on July 24, 1936, in St. Louis to Alice (Schwarz) and Louis Liebson, a shoe company executive. She earned a bachelor of arts at Wellesley College in 1958. A year earlier, she had married David Goldberg, a banker. After the couple moved to New York City, Ms. Goldberg worked as a publishing assistant at Simon & Schuster and began pursuing a doctorate in art history at the Institute of Fine Arts at New York University. She didn't get around to defending her thesis, however; instead, she went to work as an editor for American Photographer magazine when it was launched in 1978. In addition to her son Eric, she leaves another son, Jeremy, and six grandchildren. She and David Goldberg divorced in 1973. Another marriage, to Loring Eutemey, a graphic designer and illustrator, also ended in divorce. Her third husband, Laurence Young, a professor emeritus of astronautics at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, died in 2021. She lived in Waterville Valley, N.H., before moving to the Manhattan assisted living facility. Ms. Goldberg was a frequent lecturer on photography and the author or editor of a number of books, including 'Photography in Print: Writing From 1816 to the Present' (1981), a collection of essays by photographers such as Alfred Stieglitz and critics Charles Baudelaire and Susan Sontag. Advertisement Another book by Ms. Goldberg, 'The Power of Photography: How Photographs Changed Our Lives' (1991), is a lively history of the medium and its cultural impact, from daguerreotype to X-rays, moon shots, and Photoshop. Even back in 1991, Ms. Goldberg cautioned readers about the tricky nature of photography, writing, 'We could end up being more copiously supplied with news and less concerned, as well as less willing to believe the reports, than any society in history.' She added, 'These photographs walked into our lives and in some way managed to change them. So it seems appropriate to ask the questions one would ask any intruder: How did you get in? And what are you doing here anyway?' This article originally appeared in
Boston Globe
2 days ago
- Boston Globe
The OUTLOUD festival had options for expansion, but picking Boston was no accident
Advertisement That mission transcends state lines, too. After five previous editions in West Hollywood, Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up The fact that Consoletti chose Boston over a larger market like New York City for the festival's East Coast expansion feels like a point of pride (no pun intended) for the community. Consoletti has lived and worked in Los Angeles for the past 20 years, where he runs his live event and entertainment agency JJLA. His roots as an event producer, however, trace back to his childhood in Milford, where he was, he said, 'always looking for opportunities to put on shows' for friends and family. (His first-ever event was a puppet show hosted within his parents' garage around age 4 or 5; it drew dozens of his neighbors, although his parents made him give back the money from his hard-earned ticket sales). Advertisement But Consoletti didn't select Boston strictly as a homecoming. The event producer says the city 'inherently felt like a great next place for OUTLOUD to grow in,' particularly because of the local government's advocacy for queer citizens. In 'Standing up and declaring Boston a sanctuary city for transgender individuals and [ensuring] gender-affirming care aligns greatly with the backbone of what OUTLOUD wants to do as well,' he says, emphasizing OUTLOUD's role as a safe, welcoming cultural experience. Consoletti doesn't envision a third location for the festival – not during Pride month, at least – although he hopes OUTLOUD can expand its Boston edition in future years, either by adding another stage, or making it a two-day event like its California counterpart. Advertisement Another future expansion might take the form of a touring show with 'a consortium of artists' that brings similar music experiences to cities that might have fewer resources and accessible environments for the LGBTQ community. 'Some of our cities of interest are D.C., Philadelphia, Columbus, Nashville, Atlanta, Dallas, and Denver – places where [the community] could use some more visible queer representation, and OUTLOUD wants to be that,' Consoletti says. Cali-born reggae rockers Slightly Stoopid head to The Stage at Suffolk Downs on Friday. (Keith Zacharski) Keith Zacharski GIG GUIDE Outdoor concert season is finally in full swing, as Cali-born reggae rockers fans are already speculating about whether or not the Watertown resident and folk artist will appear to perform their collaboration 'Northern Attitude'). Outside of the city, Mexican singer-songwriter Passim honors Pride month on Advertisement Also on Kawaii metal band Babymetal perform at MGM Music Hall at Fenway on Wednesday. (Capitol Records) Capitol Records Lansdowne Street welcomes a particularly sundry mix of talent this week, with visits from Croatian cellist ( King Isis's new EP 'SIRENITY' flaunts all of modern pop's best angles. (Hunter Cates) Hunter Cates NOW SPINNING King Isis, Advertisement Nyah Grace's sophomore record "Divinely Devoted" is a descent into silken neo-soul. (Maisie Dickinson) Maisie Dickinson Nyah Grace, Philly's Mo Lowda & the Humble recorded their fifth LP, "Tailing the Ghost," entirely from the road. (Luda Ronky) Luda Ronky Mo Lowda & the Humble, BONUS TRACK (Sunday). Keep an eye out for Western Massachusetts artists on the lineup, such as Victoria Wasylak can be reached at . Follow her on Bluesky @
Boston Globe
3 days ago
- Boston Globe
At last, a good long look at Jeremy Allen White as Bruce Springsteen in ‘Deliver Me from Nowhere'
Cooper is perhaps best known as the director of ' Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up Springsteen has been much in the news of late. The 75-year-old singer made headlines a few weeks ago when, during a concert in England, he criticized President Trump, calling him 'corrupt, incompetent, and treasonous.' (Trump responded by calling Springsteen a ' Advertisement Springsteen is also set to release a slew of songs that have not been heard before. Called 'Tracks II: The Lost Albums,' the collection, due out next week, includes 83 songs, 74 of which have not been previously released in any form. Springsteen told Advertisement It's clear in the Times story that the author of 'Born in the USA' is distraught about what is happening in America at the moment. Explaining Trump's rise, Springsteen said the country's 'incredible increase in wealth disparity left so many people behind…It was ripe for a demagogue.' 'While I can't believe it was this moron that came along, he fit the bill for some people,' Springsteen said. 'What we've been living through in the last 70 days are things that we all said, 'This can't happen here.' 'This will never happen in America.' And here we are.' Mark Shanahan can be reached at
