Gold Guitar winner criticises awards, says ‘brown faces' were treated unfairly
Micro-aggressions and a difficult history with te reo Māori is why last year's Gold Guitar winner says she won't return to the ceremony or its homeland of Gore.
Country singer and 2024 Gold Guitar main prize winner Amy Maynard has vowed publicly to never return to the ceremony and its host town of Gore, after facing what she believes were racially-charged micro-aggressions. She said the ceremony has a history of failing to recognise te reo Māori, and hopes her experience could push the Gold Guitar organisers to create a safer environment for Māori performers and punters. But the organisers say they'd rather sort out their differences in private.
Aotearoa's premier country music awards, the Gold Guitar Awards, have been held every year since 1974 (excluding 2020) in Gore, as the last hurrah in the Tussock Country Music Festival schedule. Its honourees include the likes of Tami Neilson and Kaylee Bell, and in 2024, Maynard picked up the ceremony's senior award.
Maynard told The Spinoff she had spent most of the festival last year – her first time at the ceremony – keeping to herself, and focusing on performing in several spots across the awards circuit.
Returning this year as a one-off performer and attendee, Maynard says the environment at the awards was 'really disheartening'. She said that in her experience, the awards' security were more likely to reprimand 'brown faces' for actions such as singing, dancing or talking during performances. Her 16-year-old son, dressed in baggy clothing, was also stopped multiple times and questioned about why he was at the awards.
It was not just staff, but attendees that Maynard said made the awards feel unwelcoming. While one singer performed a reo Māori waiata, Maynard said an older Pākehā couple made disparaging comments about the choice of song.
When The Spinoff called the Gold Guitar office, convener Phillip Geary answered. 'I don't want to comment in a public forum,' Geary replied, when asked about Maynard's experience.
In 2012, a Gore District Council employee left their job after criticising the Gold Guitar Awards. She had competed in the Gold Guitar Young Ambassador Awards, and wrote on Facebook that she 'kicked ass at everything and then didn't win, go figure … I think I was too brown for them bro'. At the time, Geary said he didn't believe Green needed to resign. 'With the way social media is these days, we've got to expect stuff like this. We're not overly concerned about it.'
'As a Māori woman in this industry, it's hard when you're constantly fighting this uphill battle,' Maynard told The Spinoff. 'These people have built this idea of what you're going to be in their minds'.
Maynard also criticised the awards' policy that bars anyone other than the slated performer from appearing onstage. Maynard requested her mother and daughter sing with her, as 'you should be allowed to provide and perform the show that you would like to put on for people … for me, that includes highlighting and showcasing my family, because whakawhanaungatanga is always going to be something I'm huge about'. The response from the awards was that it would 'set a bad precedent'.
The rule affected another act, Sharon Russell and Lesley Nia Nia, who had won the previous year's classic award. Russell had travelled to the ceremony without Nia Nia, who could not attend for personal reasons, but with her grandson as a replacement. Maynard claims Russell was told she couldn't perform and her act was replaced.
Maynard shared these experiences in a long social media post, which The Spinoff understands the Gold Guitar organisers have seen. Television personality Mike Puru, who MC'd the event, left a message of support on Maynard's post promising to take her comments to the ceremony's board. 'I'm so sorry that happened – I had no idea … I'm saddened by all of that, especially being a Māori fella from Gore,' Puru wrote. 'I know what you mean.'
In the last year, against the backdrop of the Treaty principles bill and Toitū Te Tiriti hīkoi, Maynard said she had noticed anti-Māori rhetoric had become more 'vocal'. The singer, who lives in Hamilton, said she doesn't feel comfortable returning to Gore or to the Gold Guitar Awards.
'I hope this opens a conversation for them.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
15 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Listener's Song of the Week: ‘It seems 2025 has got its own Poi E'
Matariki Hunga Nui – Calling Me Home by Troy Kingi, Rob Ruha, Kaylee Bell Well, it seems like 2025 has got its own Poi E. Written by Troy Kingi, Rob Ruha, Kaylee Bell and Professor Rangi Mātāmua (the rangatira of Māori astronomy), this is a big-hearted country-soul waiata
Otago Daily Times
18 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Community spirit shines
For the 16th year in a row, Kahu Youth will be igniting the community spirit on Matariki day with performances, traditional food and storytelling. The appearance of the Matariki cluster of stars is a significant event in the Maramataka, marking the Māori New Year. These stars, also called Pleiades, become visible in June. The Maramataka is deeply connected to the environment, particularly the ocean and its tides, as the moon influences them. In 2022 Matariki became an official public holiday in Aotearoa, but Kahu Youth had already taken the lead on the celebration with an event that began in 2010. The Wānaka Matariki celebration had humble beginnings with just a potluck meal and some storytelling. It has since flourished into a local highlight, complete with local kapa haka, Māori storytelling about Matariki from local kaumātua Darren Rewi and a traditional hangi feeding over 600 people. Kahu Youth operations director Anna Sutherland said despite the event growing over time, some things had not changed. "The thing that has stayed the same is that this event has been run by community spirit," she said. For her, the value of the celebration was its ability to bring the Upper Clutha community together and teach local rangatahi about Māori heritage. Ms Sutherland said around 30 young volunteers were involved this year in the making of the event, giving them the opportunity to learn more about Māori history. "It's really inclusive, and it allows everybody to be involved and learn. So, through that it brings diversity and respect for other cultures," Ms Sutherland said. Leading up to the big day, the event has strung together a network of groups eager to contribute such as the local primary and secondary schools, Te Kakano Trust and the Mana Tahuna Trust which provides support for migrant communities in the lakes district. The seven kapa haka groups performing are from across the region, including groups from Wānaka Primary School, Hāwea Kindergarten and Matariki Tupu Hou, an inclusive group of young and adult performers. Chairman of the Mana Tahuna Charitable Trust Darren Rewi will be doing Māori storytelling relevant to the Lakes region. "Because we're surrounded by the mountains, the arrival of Puanga, which is another star, is what the local tribe used to focus on rather than the Matariki constellation because it sits so low," Mr Rewi said. He highlighted the importance this knowledge has for all attendees, especially young people and the immigrant community. The Matariki or Pleiades constellation holds a special place in many indigenous cultures and Mr Rewi believed this presented a unique opportunity to bring together different ethnic groups across the whole region. "What we find is that a fair amount of people that listen to those stories are overseas visitors," he said. "It gives them an understanding of why New Zealand is celebrating Mātariki and why it's worthy of a holiday." As well as enjoying the new year, the event also aims to represent the values of this holiday, which includes honouring the past, celebrating the present and having hope for the future. Despite the growth of this celebration over the years, the event has managed to maintain respect for the environment and uphold the principles of Matariki. "We don't want this event to be commercialised or about stuff," Ms Sutherland said. "It's about people and place." Set to take place at the Dinosaur Park from 2pm, the celebration will also include a weaving workshop, a lakefront bonfire and a community waiata from 5:30pm.
Otago Daily Times
18 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Waimate artist's work in Met exhibit
Waimate-based artist Fiona Pardington at the Elephant Rocks near Duntroon in the Maerewhenua Valley. PHOTO: MEEK ZUIDERWYK Esteemed Waimate artist Fiona Pardington ONZM is riding a career high. Pardington was recently made an Officer of the New Zealand Order of Merit for her services to photography around the same time as her artwork became part of the permanent collection in the Arts of Oceania Galleries at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York. The Arts of Oceania exhibit, overseen by Māori (Ngāi Tai) curator Dr Maia Nuku and curators for the Arts of Oceania at The Met, is part of a significant transformation at the museum, which houses the collections of the Arts of Africa, the Ancient Americas, and Oceania. Her work is featured among more than 650 works representing 140 cultures from around Oceania, including Australia, Papua New Guinea and New Zealand. Pardington was excited to attend the official opening night of the reopening of the gallery last month. "This is kind of a big deal for a person like me. "I don't even really have words for how it makes me feel because I'm not even sure. I'm just feeling quite surprised. "A big black tie dinner and all these super-famous people and I'm going, 'oh my God'." Pardington was among seven invited Māori and Pasifika artists to attend the reopening supported by Creative New Zealand. Before the opening night she received another surprise. "You never really imagine you're going to be sitting in New York and attending something like this and then to receive an email saying you're in the New York Times today. "I mean, it's just a little mention, but it's awesome," she said. Earlier this year, the South Canterbury-based artist, a photographer of Maori (Ngai Tahu, Kati Mamoe and Ngati Kahungunu) and Scottish (Clan Cameron of Erracht) descent, was also selected to represent New Zealand at the Venice Biennale next year. She said New Zealand was "a tiny little place full of very powerful creativity" and to be selected for the biennale was a "great honour". " I am really going to do my best to uphold the honour that has been bestowed upon me." Pardington recently announced the name of her exhibition, "Taharaki Skyside". She said her work built on the content of her 2024 series Te taha o te rangi, "the edge of the heavens", which consists of photographs of Aotearoa New Zealand birds preserved as taxidermy specimens in museum collections. Pardington is known for her investigation of traditional and forgotten objects in her still-life photography and her focus on taonga, such as the hei tiki and the extinct huia. She said her relationship with birds was "very personal". "Birds can symbolise familial love, romantic attachment, ecological warnings — they can be intimations of mortality — and in my work they can also represent individual people in my life," Pardington said. In 2011, Pardington became a New Zealand Arts Foundation Laureate, and in 2016 was named a Knight (Chevalier) in the Order of Arts and Letters by the French prime minister, the first New Zealand visual artist to receive this honour. Since 2017, Pardington has represented New Zealand at the London Art Fair and Art Basel Hong Kong, participated in the 2018 major international exhibition "Oceania" at London's Royal Academy of the Arts, and was the first New Zealander invited to participate in the Sharjah Biennial 16 in the United Arab Emirates in 2024. Despite all her career successes she remains grounded and says persistence is key. "You really don't want to get a big head and start thinking that you're special, because everybody's got talents. "And people that work hard and persevere and push through — if you want to do something, you just stick to your guns and keep going."
