Watches, coins, flat: Properties linked to Nirav Modi worth Rs 60 crore to be restored to PNB
A special court permitted restoration of properties linked to diamond merchant Nirav Modi valued at over Rs 60.33 crore, to the Punjab National Bank (PNB), allowing the bank's plea which said that the consortium of banks led by it has incurred losses of Rs 8526 crore in the alleged fraud.
The restored properties include valuables worth Rs 40.83 crore, including jewellery, coins, watches and cash, from the Worli residence of Nirav Modi and a flat worth Rs 19.50 crore in Breach Candy.
These properties were attached by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) in 2018-19 under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, as part of its probe in to the fraud, where Nirav Modi and others are alleged to have connived with bank officials in issuing fraudulent Letters of Undertaking from 2008, causing losses to the banks.
The PNB, citing the Prevention of Money Laundering (Restoration of Confiscated Property) Rules, 2016, said that the banks have a legitimate interest in the properties as they have suffered cumulative loss of more than Rs 8526.20 crore due to the fraud.
It said that the value of the properties attached by the ED is around Rs 2,324.97 crore.
It sought exemption of the two properties, including the valuables seized from the Samudra Mahal flats of Nirav Modi and a flat in Diamond Head building in Breach Candy, which was in the name of his sister, Purvi.
The ED gave its no-objection to the plea. Purvi's lawyer, Manavendra Mishra, submitted that she is not the beneficial owner of the flat, and has no objection for the PNB plea to be allowed.
Special Judge A V Gujarathi said that the case is pending since 2019 and the proclamation is issued against the diamond merchant and others in 2019, as they are absconding.
A plea to declare Nirav Modi a fugitive economic offender is also pending. He is currently in the UK facing extradition proceedings. The court also noted that the ED and Purvi have not objected to the plea. It directed PNB to file an undertaking to return the amount with interest, in case the court deems it fit.
Previously too in separate orders, restoration of properties was allowed to the PNB.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
32 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Bombay HC discharges CA of Chhagan Bhujbal, family in money laundering case by ED
The Bombay High Court Monday discharged the chartered accountant (CA) of NCP leader and minister Chhagan Bhujbal and his family from a money laundering case registered by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) in 2015. The high court, while hearing the criminal revision application by CA Shyam Radhakrishna Malpani, noted that the special court committed an error in rejecting the discharge plea in March 2021. A single-judge bench of Justice Rajesh N Laddha observed that 'mere absence of due diligence by applicant does not amount to the commission or omission of an offence under Section 3 (money laundering) of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA).' The ED had lodged a case against Chhagan Bhujbal and others based on a complaint filed by the state Anti-Corruption Bureau (ACB) in 2015. It was alleged that land belonging to the Regional Transport Office (RTO) in Andheri was handed over to a developer firm when Chhagan Bhujbal was the deputy chief minister and the state Public Works Department (PWD) minister of Maharashtra from 2004 to 2014. As per the agency, the said project was awarded to the developer in lieu of the construction of Maharashtra Sadan in Delhi and the RTO building in Tardeo. The ED had arrested Chhagan Bhujbal in 2015 for alleged money laundering, and he remained in custody until 2018, when the Bombay High Court granted him bail. Chhagan Bhujbal, his son Pankaj Bhujbal, nephew and former MP Sameer Bhujbal and five others were discharged by a special court in 2021 from the ACB case. In the case of Malpani, the ED had alleged that he actively participated in the offence of money laundering while serving as the CA for the entities controlled by the Bhujbals. As per the central agency, Malpani was responsible for auditing financial records and was aware of the suspicious transactions and sham arrangements carried out by these entities. Advocate Hiten Venegaonkar for ED argued that the applicant conducted audits of companies controlled by Bhujbals and, in doing so, camouflaged illicit transactions and concealed the unlawful flow of proceeds of crime generated by the Bhujbals. However, senior advocate Pranav Badheka for Malpani submitted that Chhagan Bhujbal and his family members were discharged by the special court in two predicate offences on which ED had lodged its case. Badheka argued that Malpani, who was a statutory auditor, had a limited role to form an opinion on whether company accounts are properly maintained or not and the auditor is not expected to function as an investigator. The plea claimed that Malpani audited financial accounts only for a period from the financial year ending March 2012 to 2015, and alleged proceeds of crime are claimed to have originated around 2007-08. Badheka argued that there was no evidence or material on record or in complaint to show that Malpani failed in his duties as auditor, and so he should be discharged from the case. Justice Laddha, in his order, observed that 'the role of the auditor is inherently distinct from that of the investigating agency.' 'The complaint lacks material to establish a nexus between the applicant and the alleged criminal conspiracy or money laundering activities. Moreover, the applicant has neither been named nor charge-sheeted in the related crimes, which further reinforces the absence of any direct or indirect involvement in the purported criminal conduct,' the high court held and set aside a special court order, discharging Malpani from the money laundering case.
Deccan Herald
33 minutes ago
- Deccan Herald
BJP accounts for nearly 45% of total election spending in 2024 Lok Sabha polls: ADR
The Congress followed next with Rs 620 crore or 18.5 per cent of the total expenses among the 32 national and regional parties whose records were analysed, the ADR said.
Time of India
34 minutes ago
- Time of India
Once lauded by PM in Mann ki Baat, women-led millet factory in Bageshwar shuts down
1 2 3 4 5 6 Bageshwar: In Bageshwar's Munar village, a once-thriving women-led millet factory, praised by Prime Minister Narendra Modi during his 'Mann Ki Baat' address in April 2018, now lies abandoned, leaving 900 women jobless. The Maa Chiltha Cooperative Group, which ran the factory, has struggled for two years to maintain operations, and the unit has remained shut for the past year. "We turned our traditional grain into gold. The country recognised our work, but the system didn't support us. Policies changed, interest vanished, and we were left behind," said Tara Takuli, 60, who led the initiative. The women had successfully transformed mandua (finger millet) into nutritious biscuits that gained national recognition. Their products were once part of govt schemes for Anganwadi centres and pregnant women, and the enterprise had reached a turnover of Rs 15 lakh, providing livelihoods to over a thousand women and their families. The biscuits were also sold in stalls at govt-organised events. The decline began post-Covid, as govt support and bulk orders dwindled. A project once showcased as a model of rural entrepreneurship gradually faded from official priority. "The Prime Minister called Munar's women a national example. Today, those same women are back to square one: jobless and forgotten," said Gopa Dhapola, a local resident. "Ragi biscuits, rich in nutrition, were once sent to pregnant women. Then the govt policy changed and now they get only wheat and rice in the name of nutrition. This is not just a failure, it's betrayal." However, officials denied that policy changes led to the factory's closure. "The govt had no direct role. Internal disputes within the committee caused the shutdown. We've issued notices and are planning to form a new committee to restart operations," said chief development officer R C Tiwari. Local leader Harish Aithani said after the PM mentioned the initiative, the popularity of the biscuits soared and farmers' income tripled. "Mandua prices rose from Rs 20 to Rs 60 per kilo, and jobs flourished. But now, with the factory shut, it's all come to a halt. The administration hasn't stepped in since," he added. The factory's closure underscores the fragility of grassroots initiatives lacking sustained institutional backing and how political recognition without practical assistance proves ineffective.
