Five attempts too many? Ex-IPS officer's ‘wasting youth' comment on UPSC topper Shakti Dubey sparks aspirants' debate
Shakti Dubey's ascent to UPSC 2024 topper after six years and five attempts sparked debate when ex-IPS officer Yashovardhan Azad criticized the exam's lengthy preparation, calling it a waste of youth and urging limits on attempts and age. Supporters argue inclusivity and perseverance matter, while critics warn reforms could harm underprivileged aspirants and fail to address deeper coaching-driven issues.
Tired of too many ads?
Remove Ads
From Celebration to Controversy in Seconds
Is the UPSC Marathon Robbing Youth of Their Prime?
Tired of too many ads?
Remove Ads
The Road to Rank One: Tribute to Tenacity
When Shakti Dubey clinched the coveted Rank 1 in the UPSC Civil Services Exam 2024 , the country erupted in applause. Yet amid the jubilation came a seismic jolt: a former IPS officer's blunt critique of Dubey's six‑year journey—and five attempts—through the grueling preparation cycle. His comments have thrown the spotlight on whether India's premier exam is costing its brightest minds their youth.As news portals and social feeds buzzed with praise for Dubey—whose Political Science and International Relations optional brought her to the summit—Yashovardhan Jha Azad, once an IPS officer himself, seized the moment on social media. 'Congratulations to Shikha Dubey, ranking first in UPSC result,' he began on X (formerly Twitter), 'But five attempts means six years of toil—the best years of youth gone in coaching?'Azad's message did more than question Dubey's personal sacrifice. It painted a broader picture of a system in which half a million aspirants chase a handful of vacancies year after year, often investing vast sums in coaching institutes. 'This obsession with UPSC is costing the nation huge,' he wrote, 'Employing our youth wrongly for five to six years. Coaching institutes are laughing all the way to the bank.'At the heart of Azad's argument lies a provocative proposal: cap attempts at two and lower the age ceiling to 25. By his reckoning, this would force an earlier specialization—allowing unsuccessful candidates to pivot into other careers rather than lingering in endless exam cycles.Critics were quick to catch fire. One commentator warned that stricter limits would penalize those from humble backgrounds who rely on time and perseverance to level the playing field. Another pointed out that the true beneficiaries of repeated attempts are not the candidates but the coaching industry itself—while successful officers emerge underprepared in leadership and common sense.Regardless of the controversy, Dubey's success story is undeniably inspirational. Over six years of rigorous study and repeated mains, she shattered stereotypes and climbed to the very top of India's most competitive exam. Her achievement is mirrored by the Commission's broader efforts toward inclusivity: among the 1,009 recommended candidates, representation spans General, EWS, OBC, SC, and ST categories.Behind her victory lies the closing chapter of UPSC 2024: the interview round. Conducted for 2,845 candidates and wrapped in April, it distilled aspirations into 1,132 appointments across IAS, IPS, and other premier services. For Dubey and her peers, it was the final hurdle in a marathon that Azad—and many others—now argue might need drastic reform.As debate rages, one thing is certain: India's obsession with UPSC—the allure, the agony, the academy-driven coaching culture—has once again taken center stage. Will policymakers heed calls for age and attempt restrictions? Or will they find other ways to preserve both the integrity of the exam and the prime years of its aspirants?For now, Shakti Dubey's triumph and Yashovardhan Azad's stark question linger together, challenging the nation to balance excellence with empathy—and to decide whether the cost of greatness should be measured in lost youth.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
an hour ago
- News18
Jagan Mohan Named As Accused After Vehicle In His Convoy Runs Over YSRCP Supporter
Last Updated: A case had been registered against Jagan Mohan for the death of Cheeli Singayya, who was reportedly run over by the ex-Andhra CM's convoy in Guntur district. A case has been registered against YSRCP chief and former Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister, YS Jagan Mohan Reddy, after a party supporter lost his life after being run over by a vehicle that was part of Reddy's convoy in Guntur district. Guntur SP Satish Kumar said a case had been registered against Jagan Mohan for the death of Cheeli Singayya. On June 18, Jagan Mohan Reddy visited Rentapalla with a convoy of three vehicles to call on a family member of a YSRCP leader who had died by suicide a year ago. The event turned tragic as Singayya, who had gathered along the roadside with other YSRCP supporters, was knocked down by a vehicle in the convoy and sustained serious bleeding injuries. As the tragedy unfolded, eyewitnesses rushed to his rescue and alerted the law enforcement. Soon after, the man was taken to Guntur Government Hospital for treatment but he succumbed to his injuries. The tragedy raised concerns over crowd management and sparked widespread criticism regarding the lack of security oversight. 'After analysing various evidence, it was found that the deceased was seen under the wheels of Jagan Mohan Reddy's vehicle," said Guntur district Superintendent of Police (SP) S Satish Kumar, addressing a press conference late on Sunday. A case was initially registered under Section 106(1) of BNS (causing death by negligence) based on a complaint by his wife, Cheeli Lurdhu Mary, at the local police station. However, the SP said that after examining CCTV footage, drone videos, eyewitnesses, and other technical evidence, the case has been updated to include Sections 105 and 49 of the BNS, and legal action will be taken against all those present in the vehicle, including Jagan Mohan. Other accused include Jagan Mohan Reddy's driver Ramana Reddy, Personal Assistant K Nageshwar Reddy, senior YSRCP leader YV Subbareddy, former MLA Perni Venkataramaiah, and former Minister Vidadala Rajini, Kumar told reporters. (with agency inputs) First Published:
India Today
2 hours ago
- India Today
Bypoll results in 5 states today, BJP, AAP, Congress to battle it out
The results of the bypolls held in five seats across four states - Gujarat, Punjab, Kerala and Bengal - will be announced today. The counting will begin at 8 am, with trends emerging soon after. The bypolls were held on June 19 for two seats in Gujarat - Visavadar and Kadi assembly seats - and one each in Punjab (Ludhiana West), Bengal (Kaliganj), and Kerala (Nilambur).advertisementThe bypolls, considered a precursor to Assembly elections slated in some of the above-mentioned states, are crucial as both the BJP-led National Democratic Alliance (NDA) and the INDIA alliance have fielded BYPOLLSThe BJP is looking to take back the Visavadar assembly seat, which the party hasn't won since 2007. The seat has been vacant since 2023 after the then AAP legislator Bhupendra Bhayani resigned and went to the BJP's side. For this bypoll, the BJP has picked Kirit Patel, while the Congress and AAP has fielded Nitin Ranpariya and its ex-Gujarat President Gopal Italia, respectively. The Kadi seat, meanwhile, has been vacant since February owing to the death of BJP MLA Karsan Solanki. Coming under the Mehsana district, the constituency is reserved for Schedule Caste candidates. The BJP has fielded Rajendra Chavda from the constituency, while the Congress and the AAP opted for Ramesh Chavda and Jagdish Chavda, BYPOLLadvertisementThe Nilambur seat in Kerala is seen as a prestige battle for Congress's Priyanka Gandhi Vadra. The seat falls within her Wayanad constituency, and she had held a roadshow in the region ahead of the June 19 bypolls. The bye-election had to be conducted in the constituency after the switching of two-time MLA OV Anvar - earlier backed by the Left - to the Congress party. He contested the bypoll as an Left Democratic Front (LDF) has fielded M Swaraj for the crucial test, while the Congress-supported United Democratic Front (UDF) has fielded Aryadan Shoukath. The BJP has fielded Advocate Mohan George for the Nilambur BYPOLLIn Bengal's Kaliganj constituency, which falls under Nadia district, the bypoll was necessited due to the death of Trinamool Congress MLA Nasiruddin Ahamed in February. Now, his daughter, Alifa Ahamed, is hoping to retain the seat as the ruling party's candidate. The BJP has fielded Ashis Ghosh for the seat, while the Congress picked Kabil Uddin Shaikh who contested with the backing of the CPI(M).The Kaliganj bypoll is seen as a vital face-off between Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee's Trinamool and the BJP ahead of next year's Assembly elections, where the saffron party is hoping to dethrone the BYPOLLadvertisementThe Ludhiana West seat in Punjab fell vacant after sitting AAP MLA Gurpreet Bassi Gogi died of a self-inflicted bullet injury in January. The AAP, which has been striving to retain power in Punjab since the brutal loss in the Delhi Assembly elections, will aim to retain the seat. The BJP, meanwhile, hopes to wrest the seat will see a three-way battle among AAP's Sanjeev Arora, BJP's Jeewan Gupta, and Congress veteran Bharat Bhushan Ashu. Shiromani Akali Dal has fielded Parupkar Singh Ghuman as its candidate for the bypoll. IN THIS STORY#Kerala#West Bengal#Gujarat#Punjab#All India Trinamool Congress
India.com
10 hours ago
- India.com
IAS Smita Sabharwal's class 12th marksheet goes viral, she scored 97 marks out of 100 in…, 94 in...
IAS officer Smita Sabharwal is a well-known Indian Administrative Service (IAS) officer. She is widely known as the 'People's Officer'. This title has been conferred on her not only because of her transparent administration, efficient governance, and people-centric policies, but she has also proactively used technology and social media to provide reforms and innovation that facilitate the efficiency of public service. As a benchmark in administration excellence and public welfare, the role of the IAS officer, as documented under Smita Sabharwal, will continue to positively impact many facets of public welfare. At 23, Smita Sabharwal cleared the 2000 UPSC CSE examination. She secured an All India Rank(AIR) of 4 in the UPSC Civil Services Examination reportedly in her second attempt. Sabharwal, who was currently Special Chief Secretary, Youth Advancement, Tourism & Culture (YAT&C) and Director, Archaeology, has been transferred to the post of Member Secretary, Telangana Finance Commission, which she previously held prior to her transfer to YAT&C in November 2024. The 2001-batch IAS officer had recently been transferred because of the protests of HCU students, environment activists, and opposition parties regarding the alleged destruction of forest on the Kancha Gachibowli land. The IAS officer from the 2001 batch very recently re-shared the post during the protests by HCU students, environmental activists, and opposition parties regarding the alleged deforestation of trees on Kancha Gachibowli land. IAS officer Smita Sabharwal is a name that inspires thousands of civil service aspirants and students across India. She has made her mark through her exemplary governance and participation on social media. She has gained a strong following in the youth community through her past professional accomplishments, but also through her role as a disciplined student, dedicated to her academics. Speaking about her educational qualification, Smita Sabharwal completed her schooling at St. Ann's High School in Secunderabad, Telangana. In 1995, she took her Class 12th Examination under the Indian School Certificate (ISC) board through Council for the Indian School Certificate Examinations (CISCE), New Delhi, receiving a Grade A in SUPW & Community Service. Her subjects were English, Hindi, Economics, Structure of Commerce, and Principles of Accounts – a varied and titaniacally engineered mix that helped to lay the foundations from which she would go on to succeed in the civil services. Smita Sabharwal had an impressive overall academic performance according to her CISCE ISC (Class 12th) mark sheet. During the 1995 Indian School Certificate Examination, she scored 94 out of 100 in both English and Hindi, 90 out of 100 in Economics, 86 in Structure of Commerce, and 97 in Principles of Accounts. She is one of India's youngest female IAS officers. IAS officer Smita Sabharwal is known for her dedication and approachability, and she is often referred to as the 'People's Officer.'
