Inaccurate claims about Philippine juvenile justice law surface online

"Go Kiko! Thanks to RA 9344, all 18 years old and below are protected against criminal liabilities only discernment (sic), they can kill, use drugs and they won't be held accountable by the LAW," reads a Facebook post published May 22, 2025.
"You could be stabbed by a child in Tondo or Mandaluyong, and they can't be jailed. THANK YOU, Senator KIKO! Because of you, all minors are protected from prosecution."
The post refers to Senator Francis Pangilinan and the Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act of 2006 (RA 9344), which he authored (archived link).
It also references the 2021 murder of the Maguad siblings in Cotabato, where 18-year-old Gwynn and 16-year-old Louis were stabbed to death by their 17-year-old adopted sister (archived link). The suspect initially posed as a survivor before later admitting she committed the crime with a friend, also a minor.
The post appears to suggest the suspects were not fully held accountable due to their age, framing the law as overly lenient toward youth offenders.
"The suspects should be imprisoned for life. The justice system in the Philippines really is something," reads the caption.
Image
Screenshot of false post taken June 7, 2025
After his failed 2022 vice presidential bid, Pangilinan made a political comeback as an independent senatorial candidate in the May 12 midterm elections, which saw disappointing results for President Ferdinand Marcos's party (archived link).
If Vice President Sara impeachment trial extends into the next Congress, Pangilinan will join in the case against his former opponent and Marcos's former ally turned political rival, who could be permanently barred from public office if convicted.
The claim spread widely across social media, triggering reactions from users who believed the law grants blanket immunity to juvenile offenders.
"I will never vote for him," one user said.
Another commented: "Hopefully this law gets repealed. Because of this law minors can easily commit crimes."
But legal experts told AFP the claims misrepresent the scope of the .
'Not automatically exempt'
The Juvenile Justice and Welfare System, established under a 2006 law sponsored by Pangilinan and amended in 2013, outlines specific provisions for holding minors accountable depending on their age and whether they acted with (archived link).
"The law clearly establishes that minors are not automatically exempt from criminal liability," , told AFP on May 30 (archived link).
Citing section 3, Villarin explained that children 15 and below are exempt from criminal liability under all circumstances but remain civilly liable and subject to intervention programs depending on the offence.
Meanwhile, "children above 15 but below 18 may be held criminally liable if they are proven to have acted with discernment, especially when the crime is punishable by more than 12 years of imprisonment, or if diversion is not appropriate or unsuccessful," she said.
, also told AFP on June 5 that the post "misrepresents both the intent and actual provisions of the law" (archived link).
He said the law had improved the juvenile justice system by creating ways to handle repeat and serious offences, including placing children who commit heinous crimes in intensive rehabilitation, while ensuring accountability matches their age and capacity for reform.
"It's important to note that this was never about excusing wrongdoing -- it's about making sure children are held accountable in a way that reflects their age, capacity and potential for reform," he said, noting that before the law was passed, children as young as nine were jailed as adults, exposing them to abuse, criminal influence and trauma.
Abitria said the Maguad siblings' case is a "powerful and painful example that accountability is very much possible" under the law.
"Two minors were found to have acted with discernment -- that is, the court was convinced they understood the nature and consequences of their actions. As a result, they were tried, found guilty and sentenced to 30 years of imprisonment," he said.
Philippine news outlet Inquirer.net reported in May 2022 that the court denied parole for both minors and that they were placed in the custody of the social welfare and development agency upon conviction (archived link).
The law mandates that children be placed in youth care facilities offering intensive intervention programs for serious or repeat offenders before being transferred to an adult correctional facility after turning .
AFP has debunked more misinformation on the Philippine midterm elections here.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

France 24

3 hours ago

• France 24

Gulf states begin diplomatic scramble to end Israel-Iran conflict

As Iran and Israel trade strikes and the US weighs joining in, wealthy Gulf states on the conflict's doorstep are engaged in frantic diplomacy to halt the war – but solutions remain elusive. A spillover of the conflict or the Iranian government's collapse are both worrying outcomes for the energy-rich region, which hosts several major US military bases. Peace and stability have been central to the rise of Gulf powers including Qatar, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates, who are pivoting their economies towards business and tourism. Hoping to avert the crisis, Saudi Arabia, the world's biggest oil exporter, has been talking to Iran and the United States since "day one", Ali Shihabi, an analyst close to the royal court, told AFP. "But it does not look promising that something will happen very soon," he added. Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, the de facto Saudi ruler, and the UAE's President Sheikh Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, have both spoken to Iran's President Masoud Pezeshkian in recent days. The Emirati president also held a phone call on Wednesday with Russia's President Vladimir Putin, an ally of Iran, who offered to mediate in the conflict. Israel's launching of the war scuppered Oman-brokered talks between Tehran and Washington that were supported by Gulf nations, who have been pursuing a détente with their giant neighbour after years of strained ties. 'Reckless and miscalculated' On Tuesday, US President Donald Trump demanded Iran's "unconditional surrender" and warned it could easily assassinate its supreme leader, fuelling fears of American intervention. Hours later, the UAE's Foreign Minister Sheikh Abdullah bin Zayed Al Nahyan said the Gulf country's president had "conducted intensive diplomatic calls ... to de-escalate tensions and prevent the conflict from spreading". Sheikh Abdullah warned against "reckless and miscalculated actions that could extend beyond the borders of the two countries", in a strongly worded statement published by the official WAM news agency. Trump had initially urged Iran to come to the negotiating table, but an official briefed on talks said Tehran told Qatar and Oman that it "will not negotiate while under attack". Oman, Iran's traditional intermediary, said it was engaged in diplomatic efforts as the daily strikes continue. Meanwhile Qatar, a key mediator in the Israel-Hamas war and a negotiator with Iran in the past, has also been "engaging daily" with the US, its foreign ministry spokesperson said on Tuesday. Former Qatari Prime Minister Hamad bin Jassim Al Thani warned on X that "it is not in the interest of the Gulf states to see Iran ... collapse", adding that they would be "the first to be harmed" by the war's repercussions. 'Almost no influence' An Arab diplomat told AFP: "Everyone in the Gulf is going to say we are better off making sure we have a deal with Iran, a diplomatic solution with Iran." Shihabi, the Saudi analyst, echoed the sentiment, saying the best outcome was "obviously an agreement between Iran and (the) US". Diplomatic intervention by Saudi Arabia, once a fierce critic of Iran, comes two years after they restored ties. The UAE, which recognised Israel in 2020, has also patched up relations with Tehran since 2022. "Whereas the Saudis may have once called for 'cutting off the head of the snake', their approach toward Iran has shifted dramatically," said Hasan Alhasan, a senior fellow for Middle East policy at the International Institute for Strategic Studies. However, "the Arab Gulf states have almost no ability to shape Israel's or Iran's behaviour or influence the outcome of this war", he told AFP. "It is difficult to see how Israel's military campaign against Iran, whose objectives seem to have quickly metastasised from eliminating Iran's nuclear and missiles programmes to overthrowing the regime, ends well for Iran's Arab Gulf neighbours," Alhasan added.

Local France

4 hours ago

• Local France

Protesters slam war profiteering, Israel at French air fair

The long-planned protest at the Paris Air Show outside the French capital also comes as Israel's war with Iran drags on into a ninth day, with Tehran threatening to hit back in force at Israel's offensive against its arch-rival. The presence of Israeli defence firms at the show has already become a bone of contention, with the French government on Monday sealing off the booths of five Israeli firms on the grounds that they were displaying offensive weapons that could be used in Gaza. "Their wars, their profits, our deaths, stop the genocide in Palestine," read the banner at the head of the march, which organisers claimed drew more than 4,000 protesters. "As we speak, people are dying and our governments are not doing anything to stop it," Nora, 29, told AFP at the protest. Draped in a Palestinian flag, the project leader in the pharmaceutical industry said that she felt "rage" at the footage coming out of Gaza, including that of "mothers kissing their dead children" in the besieged Palestinian territory. Police have arrested seven people aiming to disrupt the trade fair, the Paris public prosecutor office said, with officers discovering a helium canister and nearly 200 balloons during the searches. Six of the arrests were made on Friday and the other on Saturday, the prosecutor's office added. Drawing some 100,000 visitors a day, the Paris Air Show at the Le Bourget airfield, nine kilometres (five miles) to the north of the capital, is usually dominated by displays of the aerospace industry's latest cutting-edge planes. Advertisement But Monday's shuttering of the stands of Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI), Rafael, UVision and Elbit, as well as Aeronautics, which make drones and guided bombs and missiles, sparked a row with Israel. Israel's President Isaac Herzog branded Paris's closure of the Israeli firms' booths "outrageous", comparing it to "creating an Israeli ghetto". It came days after Israel, claiming Iran was on the verge of obtaining a nuclear bomb, launched a surprise barrage on June 13 which killed top Iranian commanders and nuclear scientists. Tehran immediately hit back with a flurry of missiles, with the two countries trading wave after wave of devastating strikes since.

France 24

4 hours ago

• France 24

At least three impacts in Israel during Iran missile attacks, 23 hurt

Several buildings were heavily damaged in the Ramat Aviv area in Tel Aviv, with holes torn in the facades of apartment blocks. "Houses here were hit very, very badly," Tel Aviv mayor Ron Huldai told reporters at the scene. "Fortunately, one of them was slated for demolition and reconstruction, so there were no residents inside. "Those who were in the shelter are all safe and well. The damage is very, very extensive, but in terms of human life, we are okay." The Israeli police said in a statement that they had been deployed to at least two other impact sites, one in Haifa in the north and another in Ness Ziona, south of Tel Aviv. A public square in a residential area of Haifa was left strewn with rubble and surrounding shops and homes have been heavily damaged, AFP photos showed. Eli Bin, the head of Israeli rescue service Magen David Adom, told reporters that a total of 23 people had been wounded nationwide in the attacks, with "two in moderate condition and the rest lightly injured." Two waves of missiles were launched at Israel from around 7:30 am (0430 GMT), the Israeli military said. Sirens rang across the country, with air defences activated shortly afterwards, causing loud explosions heard in Tel Aviv and Jerusalem. Israeli police reported "the fall of weapon fragments" in a northern area encompassing the port of Haifa, where local authorities said emergency services were heading to an "accident site". Reporting on missile strikes is subject to strict military censorship rules in Israel, but at least 50 impacts have been officially acknowledged nation-wide and 25 people have been killed since the war began with Iran on June 13, according to official figures. Tel Aviv, the southern city of Beersheba and the northern port of Haifa have been the three areas most frequently targeted by Iran.