Driver who killed eight-month-old baby in pram has sentence reduced

Driver who killed eight-month-old baby in pram has sentence reduced
Bridget Curtis pressed down on the accelerator of her car after stopping outside Withybush Hospital, killing Mabli Cariad Hall who was sitting in her pushchair
Bridget Curtis killed Mabli Cariad Hall after she pressed down on the accelerator of her automatic BMW 520d car after stopping outside Withybush Hospital in Haverfordwest, Pembrokeshire, on June 21, 2023
(Image: WALES NEWS SERVICE )
A driver who struck and killed an eight-month-old baby in her pram outside a hospital has had her prison sentence reduced at the Court of Appeal, in what judges described as a "truly tragic" case.
Bridget Curtis pressed down on the accelerator of her automatic BMW 520d car after stopping outside Withybush Hospital in Haverfordwest, Pembrokeshire, on June 21 2023, causing it to mount a kerb and collide with the pushchair of Mabli Cariad Hall.
‌
Mabli, who had just said a final goodbye to her paternal grandmother Betty Hall, who was receiving end-of-life care at the hospital, sustained fatal head injuries and died in hospital days later.
‌
Eight-month-old Mabli Cariad Hall, who died when she was struck in her pushchair by driver Bridget Curtis outside Withybush Hospital in Haverfordwest, Pembrokeshire in June 2023.
(Image: Copyright remains with handout provider )
Curtis, who was 69 at the time of the offence and is now 71, pleaded guilty to causing death by dangerous driving last September and was jailed for four years at Swansea Crown Court in January.
At the Court of Appeal on Tuesday, her barrister said the sentence was "manifestly excessive" and should be reduced, stating that the case concerned a "lapse of concentration."
Article continues below
Three senior judges ruled that Curtis's sentence was "manifestly excessive" and reduced it to one of three years, while increasing her disqualification from driving from six years to seven-and-a-half years.
Mr Justice Butcher, sitting with Lord Justice Bean and Judge Richard Marks KC, said: "We say at once that this is a truly tragic case.
"We have read the very moving victim personal statements of Mabli's parents, expressing their grief at the death of their beloved baby.
‌
"No one could fail to sympathise with them for the appalling loss that they have sustained."
Curtis, who attended the appeal via video link from HMP Eastwood Park in Gloucestershire and sat in a wheelchair throughout, had no previous convictions at the time of the incident and had held a clean driving licence for more than 50 years.
Her sentencing hearing at Swansea Crown Court heard that on the day of the collision she had driven her daughter to an outpatient appointment at the hospital.
‌
When her daughter struggled to find her handbag in the rear of the car, Curtis unlocked the door and turned around to assist her.
But as she did so, she pressed down on the accelerator of her car, which had been left running and was not in park mode.
The car reached speeds of more than 29mph and travelled 28 metres in around four seconds, mounting the kerb of a grass seating area and causing Mabli to be thrown out of her pushchair.
‌
The car only stopped when it collided with a tree, having also caused injuries to Mabli's father Rob Hall.
Mabli, the youngest of six siblings, received treatment at the Withybush Hospital, as well as hospitals in Cardiff and Bristol, dying in the arms of her parents on June 25.
Her mother, Gwen Hall, told the sentencing hearing that her daughter was "so bright, so beautiful, so full of love and life."
‌
Mabli Cariad Hall was killed
(Image: PA Media )
She said: "She hadn't crawled yet. She had said 'Mama' for the first time only the day before. We had so much planned with her.
"It was nowhere near the time for her to be taken away from us. She was my baby. My eight-month-old baby."
‌
John Dye, for Curtis, told Swansea Crown Court that she was a mother-of-four and grandmother of 10, who was "absolutely devastated" by the incident.
Appearing again for Curtis at the Court of Appeal on Tuesday, Mr Dye said: "This is a tragic case, but the issue really was one of pedal confusion."
He continued: "Objectively, this is clearly dangerous driving, but in terms of culpability, these four seconds of driving were more akin to, maybe not a momentary lapse, but a lapse of concentration."
‌
Craig Jones, for the Crown Prosecution Service, made no oral submissions to the court.
Reducing the sentence, Mr Justice Butcher said: "True it is that the appellant did not intend to cause any harm, and true also that the mistake was of a short duration, but the driving was well over the threshold of dangerousness."
He continued that Curtis would have known that she had stopped "in a busy area outside a hospital with potentially very vulnerable pedestrians around", and that four or five seconds "is far from being a negligible duration."
Article continues below
He added that the court accepted that Curtis's remorse was "genuine", stating: "It was inattention and confusion as to which pedal she was pressing that caused this tragedy."

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

South Wales Argus

4 hours ago

• South Wales Argus

Caerphilly drug dealer used runners to sell cocaine

Kyle Humphries, 27, was caught when officers boxed in his Vauxhall Astra, Newport Crown Court was told. 'He attempted to drive away and collided with a police car,' Elin Morgan, prosecuting, said. 'The driver's window was smashed and a Taser was drawn.' Humphries was found with 32.2g of cocaine which had a potential street value of £4,280. Text bombs were discovered on his phone advertising the class A drug and ketamine for sale. The defendant gave a 'no comment' interview when he was questioned by detectives at Ystrad Mynach police station. 'He played a leading role with runners working below him in the chain,' Miss Morgan added. Humphries, of Brynhyfryd, Pontlottyn, Caerphilly pleaded guilty to offering to supply cocaine and offering to supply ketamine in February last year. The offences were committed after he had been released from prison on licence for a similar offence. He was locked up for 34 months in 2022 for possession with intent to supply crack cocaine. Hashim Salmman, mitigating, told the court: 'The defendant knows that any representations I make on his behalf today will only go towards determining the length of his custodial sentence.' His barrister added that his client had been assessed by the probation service as presenting 'a low risk of reoffending'. Humphries, he revealed, had recently tried to take his own life and had been placed in an induced coma in hospital. 'The defendant has a long history of drug misuse,' Mr Salmman continued. 'He wants to get his life back on track. 'The defendant is well on his way to conquering his drug addiction.' The court was told that Humphries' grandmother is 'severely unwell' and had open heart surgery and that he had been caring for her. Judge Carl Harrison said to the defendant: 'You had an operational function in the chain and this was a street dealing. 'Your previous conviction for a similar offence is an aggravating feature.' Humphries was jailed for three years and eight months and ordered to pay a £228 victim surcharge following his release from prison.

Wales Online

13 hours ago

• Wales Online

Drugs runner caught delivering £2,000-worth of cannabis to addresses around Cardiff

Drugs runner caught delivering £2,000-worth of cannabis to addresses around Cardiff Shakr Hamad, 30, was stopped twice by police after they could smell cannabis emanating from his car Shakr Hamad had been sent a list of postcodes by his dealer (Image: South Wales Police ) A drug runner who was found in possession of more than £2,000 worth of cannabis had been sent a list of postcodes by his dealer to deliver to. He was released on bail following his initial arrest but was caught delivering cannabis again almost a year later. Shakr Hamad, 30, was stopped by police driving a Ford Focus in Cardiff on April 10 last year after they could smell cannabis emanating from his car. He also appeared to be under the influence and tested positive for cannabis. ‌ A sentencing hearing at Cardiff Crown Court on Thursday heard a carrier bag was found and when searched it was found to contain eight zip lock bags containing cannabis, worth up to £400 in total. For the latest court reports sign up to our crime newsletter. ‌ Also found in the car was £440 in cash and an iPhone which revealed the defendant had been sent a number of postcodes in quick succession. Prosecutor Sol Hartley said Hamad was working as a drugs runner for an organised crime group who was directed to deliver cannabis to various addresses in Cardiff. The defendant was released on bail but on March 15 this year he was stopped by police in Llansannor Way, Butetown, after he was seen interacting with a man from inside his BMW. Article continues below The vehicle was searched and a black rucksack was found to contain 30 snap bags of cannabis worth up to £1,700, £525 in cash and a knuckleduster. His phone was seized and Hamad was found to be a member of a Whats App group with several other people who were working as drugs runners. During his police interview, the defendant became agitated and began punching himself in the head. ‌ Hamad, of Rhymney Street, Cathays, later pleaded guilty to two counts of possession with intent to supply class B drugs, possession of criminal property, possession of an offensive weapon and driving whilst disqualified. The court heard he has one previous conviction for motoring offences, for which he was disqualified from driving. In mitigation, Harry Baker said his client had made an asylum application to remain in the UK, which had been unsuccessful, but he has since made another application. Article continues below Judge Paul Hobson sentenced Hamad to 18 months imprisonment and disqualified him from driving for 18 months. The judge told the defendant steps may be taken to deport him, but this decision would be made by the Home Office.

BreakingNews.ie

18 hours ago

• BreakingNews.ie

Sliabh Liag killers denied legal aid for third barrister over concern for 'the public purse'

A judge has denied legal aid for a third senior barrister to represent each of the Sliabh Liag murderers Alan Vial and Nikita Burns in their bid to overturn their convictions, noting he had to have 'some regard to the public purse'. Vial and Burns, a former couple, were convicted by a Central Criminal Court jury last March of murdering Robert 'Robin' Wilkin, whose body was thrown over the cliffs in Co Donegal almost three years ago. Advertisement Vial (39), from Drumanoo Head, Killybegs, and Burns (23), of Carrick, Co Donegal, had pleaded not guilty to murdering Mr Wilkin in Co Donegal on June 25th, 2023. The trial heard the 66-year-old suffered at least two depressed fractures to his head before being put over Sliabh Liag, which ranks among Europe's tallest sea cliffs. Vial's application for legal aid was one of eight before the Court of Appeal on Friday. Mr Justice John Edwards said he had considered matters in chambers and in Vial's case approved legal aid for two counsel. Defence barrister James P O'Brien told the court Vial had been represented by three counsel in the trial. He said the trial had been long and involved a significant amount of disclosure and asked that three counsel also be allocated for his client's appeal. Advertisement Mr Justice Edwards said his briefing note had been for two counsel. He questioned whether three counsel were needed, going on to say he could not recall any case in the Court of Appeal where a party had been represented by more than two barristers. Joseph Mulrean BL, representing Burns, said he had a similar application to make for three counsel. Burns case was listed today for an application to extend the deadline for lodging her appeal against her conviction, which the court granted. 'What's so complex about this case that it requires three counsel as opposed to two?' Mr Justice Edwards asked. 'If there is some reason I'm open minded about it but simply to maintain parity with the court below is not a good reason,' said the judge, going on to note: 'I do have to have some regard to the public purse'. Advertisement He said the appeal hearing would be shorter than a trial and did not involve live witnesses or live exhibits. He noted transcripts are provided, legal submissions are prepared in advance, and the appeal is usually presented by one counsel. Mr Mulrean said the case had involved a significant amount of documentary evidence and had been 'extremely exhibit heavy'. Mr Justice Edwards asked if it was the State's intention to have three counsel for the appeal and Emmet Nolan BL, for the Director of Prosecutions, confirmed it was not. The judge then told the defence lawyers he would only certify for two counsel. The Irish Coast Guard recovered Mr Wilkin's body from the sea eight days after he was thrown from the cliffs. Due to predator damage and decomposition, State Pathologist Dr Margaret Bolster was unable to identify a cause of death. Advertisement She noted multiple fractures to Mr Wilkin's face but could not say which had been caused by the fall from the cliff and which related to a prior assault. Ireland Man who drove with Lidl manager on car bonnet afte... Read More However, the jury heard the two fractures to the back of his head were not consistent with a fall down a cliff, but were 'entirely consistent' with injuries that could have been caused by a bloody rock found by gardaí at the top of the cliffs. DNA testing showed blood and hairs on the rock were Mr Wilkin's. Each accused claimed the other used the rock to beat Mr Wilkin about the head before he was put over the cliffs. However, the prosecution argued they were part of a joint enterprise to cause serious injury to Mr Wilkin and therefore both guilty of murder.