Shatrughan Sinha reacts to Air India Crash, raises concerns over safety lapses
Trinamool Congress MP and Bollywood actor Shatrughan Sinha expressed deep sorrow over the recent
Air India crash
, calling it a "rare catastrophe" that has shaken the nation.
Reflecting on the tragic incident, he questioned possible safety lapses and stressed the urgent need for a thorough investigation to uncover the truth behind the sudden failure of one of the world's most advanced aircraft.
Speaking to the media, Sinha called it one of the most shocking aviation disasters in recent memory. "I am speechless," he said, adding that the incident has not only taken away members of our society and families but also raised serious concerns about safety protocols and accountability.
The veteran actor pointed out the perplexing nature of the crash, particularly the reported simultaneous failure of both engines.
"This is one of the most powerful aircraft in the world. A Dreamliner doesn't just go down like that. If one engine fails, there is always a backup system. For both to fail at once seems highly unusual," he remarked.
He emphasized the need for a comprehensive and transparent investigation. Quoting insights from his close friend and fellow parliamentarian Rajiv Pratap Rudy, a trained pilot, he acknowledged that such a scenario is considered "rarest of the rare."
He urged authorities and aviation experts to explore every angle-from technical failure to potential lapses in maintenance-before arriving at a conclusion.
"It is surprising that such an engine, such a strong plane, such a powerful aircraft - one of the world's strongest, most powerful, and largest planes - our Dreamliner, went down like this. The accident happened within a few seconds or minutes. People are saying that both engines failed at the same time, which seems impossible.
When one engine fails, it is already very difficult, but having both engines fail simultaneously? That's rare, especially when there are systems in place to handle such emergencies.
And all our friends are saying-I was listening to my younger brother-like friend Rajiv Pratap Rudy, who is also a very good pilot and a parliamentarian - and even he said this is one of the rarest of rare cases. This is the case of the Boeing Dreamliner," mentioned Shatrughan Sinha.
He went on to state, "I am afraid to say this, that this is a matter of engine failure, that this is a matter of some kind of failure. I am very afraid to call it a conspiracy. But there are doubts; various things are happening. Now I would like a solution to this. Because it has shaken the whole world. This matter is not only about Putin and Trump; it is not limited to this. In fact, people from all over the world are in so much grief, in so much anxiety, and in so much worry that such a great, technically advanced thing happened with the Dreamliner.
Now what has happened? It is a maintenance failure. I would not like to say anything about the pilots without an inquiry, because our pilots, they had an experience of 8,000 to 10,000 hours, more than that."
The veteran actor called for urgent answers, urging authorities to look beyond the immediate cause of engine failure. Expressing his concern, Sinha said, "I am not saying that anyone did this. But there are questions: whose responsibility was it, and why did it happen?"
He emphasized that while reports suggest maintenance or engine failure, the real concern lies in understanding the deeper cause. "It happened within a few seconds, within a few minutes. How did it happen?" he asked, pressing for a swift investigation. Sinha stressed the importance of addressing these questions promptly to ensure accountability and prevent future disasters.
--IANS
ps/
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Print
an hour ago
- The Print
Carney is repairing what Trudeau left damaged. India and Canada are now on a path to reset ties
In his first few weeks at the helm of affairs, Prime Minister Mark Carney has seemingly been able to reset ties with New Delhi, which had been downgraded with the expulsion and withdrawal of respective High Commissioners around eight months ago. And that is why the reset of India-Canada ties is ThePrint Newsmaker of the Week. After the high of 2015, when Prime Minister Narendra Modi was feted by his then-Canadian counterpart Stephen Harper, the relationship completely unravelled under Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, who sought his 15 seconds of fame by cratering ties with India to protect his own government in September 2023, undoing over two decades of careful diplomacy. New Delhi: The Carney-Modi meet earlier this week signalled a rapprochement between India and Canada, two countries inextricably linked due to the large Indian community in Canada. Also read: India-Canada diplomatic detente, and probe into Air India crash focuses on emergency power generator Snapping of India-Canada relationship Carney's victory in the April federal elections led to the view in New Delhi that a rapprochement is on the cards, with the appointment of High Commissioners, the logical first step. During election season, Carney referred to Canada's relationship with India as 'incredibly important' while deflecting any questions regarding the major irritant in ties — the killing of Hardeep Singh Nijjar. Nijjar, an India-designated terrorist, was gunned down outside a gurdwara in Surrey, British Columbia, on 18 June 2023. Trudeau, three months after the killing, informed the House of Commons that Ottawa was investigating 'credible allegations' that linked Indian officials to the killing of Nijjar. New Delhi called these allegations 'absurd and motivated'. There was no off-ramp for either New Delhi or Ottawa to de-escalate the diplomatic tension, especially as Trudeau's domestic struggles by then were an instrument of foreign policy. By October 2024, ties had effectively been snapped, with India expelling six Canadian diplomats, while withdrawing its High Commissioner and five other diplomats from Canada. Trudeau's minority government, being propped up by the New Democratic Party (NDP), supported Sikh separatists to wield large influence on Ottawa's foreign policy vis-a-vis its ties with India. The NDP at the time was led by Jagmeet Singh, who had in the past indicated support for Sikh separatism. In 2017, he had refused to link Sikh extremists to the 1985 bombing of Air India Flight 182, which left 329 people dead. For New Delhi, these separatists being given space in Canada to promote and fundraise their anti-India plank had real security ramifications – concerns that Ottawa ignored. Carney's approach to this has been to leave the matter of Nijjar's killing and associated irritants to the law enforcement agencies of the two countries, a measure welcomed by New Delhi. Modi's dash to Alberta further indicated the interest in both India and Canada to reset ties in an increasingly unstable world. With the return of Donald Trump to the White House, and the collapse of the NDP, ties between India and Canada were finally given the space for a reset. Also read: Collapse of Jagmeet Singh-led NDP & the waning political clout of Sikh separatists in Canada Trump and the waning star of Sikh separatists Trump's return upended the politics of Canada. For Canadians, the rupture in ties with the US, which accounts for over 70 per cent of Canada's trade, became an existential crisis. If elections were to be held in January 2025, the Conservative Party led by Pierre Poilievre was set to win a large majority, while the Liberal Party led by Trudeau would have potentially collapsed to its lows of 2011. However, Trudeau's resignation and Carney's rise gave the Liberals, which has governed Canada for large parts of the 20th century, a chance to rise in the polls. The question at the time was no longer just the domestic situation in Canada — the affordability crisis or immigration — but rather who would be the better candidate to handle Trump. Poilievre, who ran a Trump-esque campaign, saw his favourability drop in the polls. The Liberals rose, while the NDP support collapsed. With the Liberals winning a large number of seats, a few short of the majority, it meant they no longer had to rely on the NDP to govern the country. From 24 seats in the House of Commons, the NDP fell to 7, which helped stem the power of Sikh separatist groups in the Canadian parliament. The Conservative Party, looking to build a big tent, had sought votes from the Sikh separatists as well. But it seems all that was for nought. In this scenario, Carney, who was elevated to a saviour-like status, has been able to make a break from having domestic vote banks influence foreign policy. For Canada, the need of the hour is to diversify itself from the US. Carney, earlier this month, announced his intention to boost Canada's defence spending, while promising to reduce Ottawa's strategic dependence on the US. The two factors – the collapse of the Sikh separatist leaning parties and the return of Trump – has led to a retooling in Ottawa's approach to New Delhi. The current Liberal cabinet has a number of faces from Trudeau's government. Melanie Joly, who as foreign minister under Trudeau led the charge against India, retains her government role under Carney. Chrystia Freeland, the former deputy prime minister in the previous government, has returned with an important role in Carney's cabinet. However, despite continuity in members, Carney has been able to stamp his authority on foreign policy, with Anita Anand appointed as the new foreign minister, who spoke to External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar within days of her appointment. The challenges Ottawa faces has allowed it to approach New Delhi more effectively, and return a sense of maturity to India-Canada ties. However, as politics is never static, the Sikh separatists may rise again in Canadian politics, but maybe at least this time, the irritants would be dealt with at the appropriate levels, without the need for political brinkmanship from either administration. Views are personal. (Edited by Aamaan Alam Khan)
Hindustan Times
2 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Vir Das posts, then deletes tweet on why he supports ‘airline with problems' Air India, faces flak for praising flier
Actor-comedian Vir Das shared and deleted a post clarifying why he supports Air India after he was criticised for praising their service days after the tragic AI171 crash in Ahmedabad. Taking to X (formerly Twitter), Vir talked about his recent travel from the UK to India by Air India. (Also Read | Vir Das defends Air India after plane crash in Ahmedabad: 'They are the best crew in the sky') Vir Das has been lending his support to Air India since the AI171 crash. Vir tweeted, "I flew Air India home from London. It was all great. The crew, happy to report, still the kindest in the sky. @airindia." A person responded, "The only thing I have to say to whoever came up with this lame PR stunt at @airindia. This is just sad, you're embarrassing yourselves at this point. In a now-deleted tweet, Vir shared that his grandfather worked for Air India. He wrote, "I should clarify. I support the airline because I have very biased history with them. My grandfather worked for Air India. It is an airline with problems, I know. I have flown every circuit and every seat class through my career." Vir had shared that his grandfather worked for Air India. Vir on how AI is better than other airlines Vir explained how Air India's service is better than that of other airlines. "But as someone who is three world tours in and has flown every airline in every country make no mistake….no crew will judge you less, welcome you more, and it's a shame that no one acknowledges their loss too in a tragedy. That warrants my support," he added. Vir earlier supported Air India too post AI171 crash This isn't the first time that Vir is lending his support to Air India. Recently, after the tragic crash of the AI171 in Ahmedabad, he shout-out to Air India. 'It's a tragic day for so many families. And all our thoughts and prayers are with them. I just wanted to add my support for the crew. I've flown Air India all my life. It is not an airline without problems but without fail, I know them to be the best crew in the sky,' Vir wrote. He added, 'Time will tell what happened on this tragic flight. I cannot imagine how hard it is for them to do their job right now having lost their own. For the crew, just to say one stands with you. And hopes to see you soon on a flight'. About Air India plane crash On June 12, a London-bound Air India Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner crashed into a hostel complex of BJ Medical College in the Meghani Nagar area of Gujarat's Ahmedabad shortly after takeoff from Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport. The tragedy claimed 241 lives out of 242 onboard, including former Gujarat chief minister Vijay Rupani.
Hans India
3 hours ago
- Hans India
Cabin crew sacking: Trouble brews for Air India amid CBI probe demand
New Delhi: Air India, currently reeling under the devastating AI 171 Boeing 787 Dreamliner crash that killed at least 270 people, including 241 passengers and crew members, on Friday faced more heat as the Aviation Industry Employees' Guild (AIEG) demanded a CBI probe into the sacking of two cabin crew members by the airline for reporting a technical fault in the aircraft last year. AIEG General Secretary, George Abraham, told IANS that they have demanded a CBI probe into the sacking of two cabin crew members, as this move, after pressure on them by Air India to change their statements after reporting a technical fault in the Dreamliner 787 aircraft, is a very serious matter. "This poses a threat to the safety of the aviation sector. We have also written a letter to Prime Minister Narendra Modi for a fair probe into the matter," Abraham said. He further stated that on May 14, 2024, after the Air India flight from Mumbai to London reached its destination, the slide rafts opened in manual mode due to a technical fault in the door of the aircraft. According to Abraham, the slide rafts are activated only when the plane is in automatic mode. The pilot and the entire cabin crew had also admitted the technical fault in the plane in their initial statements, but due to alleged pressure from the airline's management, the statement was later changed. Abraham said that to suppress the technical fault in the plane, the Air India management allegedly pressured these people to change their statement, and when they refused, both these crew members were fired from their jobs. Speaking to IANS, Abraham further said that due to the seriousness of the matter, both these crew complained about the matter to the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) and the regulator called them to Delhi and heard the whole matter and talked about conducting an "informal investigation". However, eight months have passed, but no result of the "informal investigation" has come out, he noted. According to Abraham, after the deadly Ahmedabad plane crash, the attention of the government and the people is back on this issue. "This is why we have raised it once again and written a letter to PM Modi. We hope that this investigation will be expedited," he said. In a statement to IANS, the airline on Friday said that the "said cabin crew members were terminated for their misconduct and behaviour and continuing to falsify critical information during the course of an investigation". "The said investigation was launched after an emergency slide was activated while opening the aircraft door post landing," said Air India. Slide rafts deploy when a door is opened in "armed" or "automatic mode". The crew alleged the Dreamliner's door had malfunctioned as the slide raft deployed, though the door was opened in the "manual mode". The incident is reported to have occurred on May 14 last year, after the Mumbai-London flight AI-129 docked at Heathrow airport and the passengers disembarked. The two former senior cabin crew members have written to PM Modi, alleging they were wrongfully terminated last year after raising an alarm over technical issues in the Boeing 787 Dreamliner aircraft.
