Ralph Holloway, Anthropologist Who Studied Brain's Evolution, Dies at 90
Ralph Holloway, an anthropologist who pioneered the idea that changes in brain structure, and not just size, were critical in the evolution of humans, died on March 12 at his home in Manhattan. He was 90.
His death was announced by Columbia University's anthropology department, where he taught for nearly 50 years.
Mr. Holloway's contrarian idea was that it wasn't necessarily the big brains of humans that distinguished them from apes or primitive ancestors. Rather, it was the way human brains were organized.
Brains from several million years ago don't exist. But Dr. Holloway's singular focus on casts of the interiors of skull fossils, which he usually made out of latex, allowed him to override this hurdle.
He 'compulsively collected' information from these casts, he wrote in a 2008 paper. Crucially, they offered a representation of the brain's exterior edges, which allowed scientists to get a sense of the brain's structure.
Using a so-called endocast, Dr. Holloway was able to establish conclusively, for instance, that a famous and controversial two-million-year-old hominid fossil skull from a South Africa limestone quarry, known as the Taung child, belonged to one of mankind's distant ancestors.
The Taung child's brain was small, leading many to doubt the conclusion of Raymond Dart, the anatomist who discovered it in the 1920s, that it was a human ancestor.
In 1969, Dr. Holloway took his family to South Africa to meet the elderly Dr. Dart, to examine the natural limestone endocast that the Taung child's positioning in the quarry had created and to make an endocast of his own.
'I became convinced that the Taung endocast needed independent study,' he wrote in 2008, in order to 'find an objective method(s) for deciding whether the cortex was reorganized as Dart had previously claimed,' so many years before.
Dr. Holloway focused on a crescent-shaped furrow, called the lunate sulcus, at the back of the endocast. In his view, it was positioned like a human's, which suggested to him that Dr. Dart had been right all along.
Others in the field had insisted that the Taung lunate sulcus was in a 'typical ape anterior position,' he wrote.
By now, the conclusions made by Dr. Holloway and Dr. Dart about the lunate sulcus have largely been accepted: The Taung child is a human ancestor.
'If you can define where it is and prove it, then you can really demonstrate that it is an aspect of reorganization,' Dr. Holloway told an interviewer for Archaeology magazine in 2007.
That concept — the brain's structure rather than its volume — was the decisive factor in proving human ancestry.
'I was taking the position, as had Dart before me, that reorganization took place prior to the increase in brain volume,' Dr. Holloway wrote in 2008.
'I believed then and remain convinced today that the earliest hominids, i.e., Australopithecus africanus, A. afarensis, and A. garhi, had brains that were definitely different from any ape's, despite their small size,' he added.
Early in his career, he had decided, unlike many of his peers, that the mere study of apes wasn't enough. 'I could not fathom using baboons as a theoretical model for understanding human evolution because I regarded each species as a terminal end product of their own line of evolutionary development,' he wrote.
It was humans, and the fossils of their ancestors, that needed to be the focus. 'He was very important in paleoanthropology, in bringing the study of brain evolution from being a marginal enterprise to the center,' said Chet C. Sherwood, a biological anthropologist at the George Washington University, in an interview.
'And he did it by innovating methods for reconstructing cranial morphology,' said Dr. Sherwood, who studied under Dr. Holloway at Columbia in the 1990s.
The confrontation between Dr. Holloway and his 'reorganization' partisans, on the one hand, and neuroanthopologists who insisted that Taung and similar specimens were more likely apes, on the other, could become 'extremely emotionally charged,' Dr. Holloway wrote. Of one such encounter, he wrote that 'fortunately, at 430 ml, the endocasts could not do much damage even if thrown, despite being made of plaster.'
Dr. Holloway was in some respects a traditional anthropologist, committed to what the discipline once called the 'four fields' of anthropology: archaeology and cultural, biological and linguistic anthropology. But that multidisciplinary approach has long fallen out of favor, with biologists increasingly pushed aside.
'I was quickly isolated and marginalized at Columbia, and remain so,' he wrote in 2008.
He was further isolated when he defended the educational psychologist Arthur R. Jensen, remembered for a deeply contested 1969 Harvard Educational Review article positing a genetic explanation for a divergence in I.Q. scores between Black and white people. One fellow anthropologist called him a 'racist,' Dr. Holloway wrote, after 'I had the temerity to defend Arthur Jensen' from an 'assertion that Jensen was a bigot.' Some who knew him said the charge was deeply unfair.
Ralph Leslie Holloway Jr. was born on Feb. 6, 1935, in Philadelphia, to Ralph Holloway, who was in the insurance business, and Marguerite (Grugan) Holloway, a secretary. He attended high school in Philadelphia and enrolled in Drexel Institute of Technology's metallurgical engineering program.
He later moved with his family to Albuquerque, where he studied anthropology and geology at the University of New Mexico, graduating in 1959 with a degree in geology.
After working for a time in the oil fields of southwest Texas and for Lockheed Aircraft in Burbank, Calif., he entered the graduate program in anthropology at the University of California, Berkeley, where he received his Ph.D. in 1964. That year, he was recruited by Columbia as an assistant professor, and he remained there until his retirement in 2003.
He was the author of or contributed to several books, including 'The Role of Human Social Behavior in the Evolution of the Brain' (1975).
Dr. Holloway is survived by his daughter, Marguerite Holloway, and two grandchildren. Two sons, Eric and Benjamin, and his first and second wives, Louise Holloway and Daisy Dwyer, are deceased.
For his entire career, Dr. Holloway remained focused on a single organ, the brain, and on the three-dimensional modeling he perfected to study its development.
'Because the human brain is the most important constructor of experience and reality, it would be important to know how it came to its present state,' he explained at the end of his career.
'Endocasts, i.e., the casts made of the internal table of bone of the cranium, are rather impoverished objects,' he continued, 'to achieve such an understanding, but these are all we have of the direct evolutionary history of our brains and should not be ignored.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Let's celebrate: Today is the summer solstice, the longest day of the year
Editor's note: This story was first published on June 21, 2013 Welcome to the best day of the year. Today is the summer solstice, the longest day. In North Jersey, we'll get more than 15 hours of daylight. Go ahead and gloat — that's nearly an hour and a half more daylight than Key West, Florida, will get today. For those who like daylight — pretty much everyone save Dracula — today is a day to celebrate. In past eras, they actually did. "The summer solstice was a carnivalesque feast day," said Pamela H. Smith, a European history expert at Columbia University. "In England, there were bonfires, lots of beer drinking, cannons being fired off, masqueraders — people dressed up as devils and demons. "Days like the solstice were important for ancient peoples in terms of trying to find patterns in nature that were important for their livelihood, like knowing when to plant crops. All cultures had megaliths like Stonehenge," Smith said. The Earth's orbit around the sun is slightly elliptical, but not enough to cause the seasons, said Carlton Pryor, an astronomer at Rutgers University. In fact, at the summer solstice, the North Jersey region is 94.4 million miles from the sun. At the winter solstice, it's only 91.4 million miles away. The seasons are caused by the Earth's axis being tilted at a 23.5 degree angle. When the Northern Hemisphere is tilted toward the sun, the hemisphere receives sunlight more directly, for longer periods, increasing temperatures. More: Make one of these 10 books that are set in New Jersey your next beach read for summer 2025 In winter, the Northern Hemisphere is tilted away — even though it is closer to the sun in miles — so the light is less direct, more angled. The sun is lower in the sky and appears for fewer hours, causing cooler temperatures. On the summer solstice, the Earth's northern axis is tilted at its most extreme angle toward the sun. Today in North Jersey, the sun at its zenith will be at an angle of nearly 73 degrees above the horizon. On Dec. 21, it will be only 26 degrees above the horizon. The Earth's axis tilt also affects where the sun rises on the horizon. Conventional wisdom that the sun rises in the east and sets in the west is true only twice a year — at the spring and fall equinoxes. During the summer solstice, the sun rises at its northernmost point on the horizon. This morning in Hackensack, if you had faced due east, the sun would have risen about 32 degrees to the north (or to your left). At the winter solstice, it will rise 32 degrees to the south of due east (or to your right). Though the summer solstice once triggered celebrations, that's rarely the case anymore. After the Protestant Reformation in Europe, religious leaders started to call for an end to the celebrations. "A lot of Protestant pastors criticized midsummer night's eve, saying people were drinking too much, fighting," Smith said. Another reason we don't celebrate the solstice is the shift from an agrarian lifestyle. "We live in a more urban society, and we have colonized the night," said Sara Schechner, an expert on science history at Harvard University. "So we are not as bound to the cycles of nature in how we go about our lives." This article originally appeared on Summer solstice 2025 is here
Fox News
2 days ago
- Fox News
Eating more fruits and vegetables linked to surprising effect on sleep
Your daily meal selections could influence the quality of your sleep, new research says. A study from the University of Chicago Medicine and Columbia University found that increasing your intake of fruits and vegetables could help promote more restful sleep. Previous research has shown that people who lack quality sleep may be more likely to indulge in unhealthy foods that are high in fat and sugar — and now this new finding sheds more light on how consumed foods impact sleep. In the small study — which was published in "Sleep Health: The Journal of the National Sleep Foundation" — 34 healthy young adults reported their daily food consumption and wore a tracker to measure how often they woke up or changed sleep patterns during the night, according to a press release. Those who reported eating more fruits and vegetables during the day were found to have "deeper, more uninterrupted sleep." Greater amounts of healthy carbohydrates, like whole grains, were found to have that same benefit, the study found. "Dietary modifications could be a new, natural and cost-effective approach to achieve better sleep," said co-senior author Esra Tasali, MD, director of the UChicago Sleep Center, in the release. "The temporal associations and objectively-measured outcomes in this study represent crucial steps toward filling a gap in important public health knowledge." Based on the study findings, the researchers concluded that people who eat at least five cups of fruits and veggies per day could have a 16% increase in quality of sleep compared to those who eat none of those foods. "Small changes can impact sleep. That is empowering — better rest is within your control." "16 percent is a highly significant difference," Tasali said in the release. "It's remarkable that such a meaningful change could be observed within less than 24 hours." "Based on current data, the experts confidently advise that regularly eating a diet rich in complex carbohydrates, fruits and vegetables is best for long-term sleep health," the release stated. The American Heart Association provides the following examples of fruit and veggie servings that equate to 1 cup of produce. Dr. Chelsie Rohrscheib, head sleep expert at Wesper in Michigan, said that most sleep professionals recognize that a healthy diet supports overall well-being, including sleep quality — "so the findings of this study are not entirely unexpected." "However, it's important to note that this was a relatively small study composed primarily of young adult male participants, which limits generalizability," Rohrscheib, who was not involved in the study, told Fox News Digital. "While the results were statistically significant, the overall reduction in sleep fragmentation was modest, about 16%." The study was also observational in nature, she noted, which means it lacked the control of a randomized trial. "Ideally, future research would compare a group consuming a fruit- and vegetable-rich diet to a control group with limited intake to better establish causality," the doctor added. The researchers plan to conduct more studies to confirm that eating produce causes better sleep and to determine the "underlying mechanisms of digestion, neurology and metabolism" driving this impact, the release stated. For more Health articles, visit "People are always asking me if there are things they can eat that will help them sleep better," said co-senior author Marie-Pierre St-Onge, PhD, director of the Center of Excellence for Sleep & Circadian Research at Columbia, in the release. "Small changes can impact sleep. That is empowering — better rest is within your control."
Health Line
2 days ago
- Health Line
Autophagy: What You Need to Know
Autophagy is a self-preservation mechanism in which your body removes damaged or dysfunctional parts of cells in order to regenerate newer, healthier cells. 'Auto' means self and 'phagy' means eat. So the literal meaning of autophagy is 'self-eating.' It's also known as 'self-devouring.' While that may sound like something you never want to happen to your body, it's actually beneficial to your overall health. Board-certified cardiologist Dr. Luiza Petre explains that the purpose of autophagy is to remove debris and self-regulate back to optimal smooth function. 'It is recycling and cleaning at the same time, just like hitting a reset button to your body,' she says. 'Plus, it promotes survival and adaptation as a response to various stressors and toxins accumulated in our cells.' Let's learn more about the process. What are the benefits of autophagy? The main benefits of autophagy seem to come in the form of anti-aging principles. In fact, Petre says it's best known as the body's way of turning the clock back and creating younger cells. Priya Khorana, PhD, in nutrition education from Columbia University, points out that when our cells are stressed, autophagy is increased in order to protect us, which helps enhance your lifespan. Additionally, registered dietitian, Scott Keatley, RD, CDN, says that in times of starvation, autophagy keeps the body going by breaking down cellular material and reusing it for necessary processes. 'Of course this takes energy and cannot continue forever, but it gives us more time to find nourishment,' he adds. At the cellular level, Petre says the benefits of autophagy include: removing toxic proteins from the cells that are attributed to neurodegenerative diseases, such as Parkinson's and Alzheimer's disease recycling residual proteins providing energy and building blocks for cells that could still benefit from repair on a larger scale, it prompts regeneration and healthy cells Autophagy is receiving a lot of attention for the role it may play in preventing or treating cancer, too. However, it's important to note that autophagy may also promote the growth of cancer. This is because it works as a survival mechanism and can make it easier for possible resistance in therapies. 'Autophagy declines as we age, so this means cells that no longer work or may do harm are allowed to multiply, which is the MO of cancer cells,' Keatley says. While all cancers start from some sort of defective cells, Petre says that the body should recognize and remove those cells, often using autophagic processes. That's why some researchers are looking at the possibility that autophagy may lower the risk of cancer. While there's no scientific evidence to back this up, Petre says some research suggests that many cancerous cells can be removed through autophagy. 'This is how the body polices the cancer villains,' she explains. 'Recognizing and destroying what went wrong and triggering the repairing mechanism does contribute to lowering the risk of cancer.' In this way, autophagy may eventually become a therapy for cancer. Diet changes that can boost autophagy Remember that autophagy literally means 'self-eating.' So, it makes sense that intermittent fasting and ketogenic diets are known to trigger autophagy. 'Fasting is [the] most effective way to trigger autophagy,' Petre says. ' Ketosis, a diet high in fat and low in carbs brings the same benefits of fasting without fasting, like a shortcut to induce the same beneficial metabolic changes,' she adds. 'By not overwhelming the body with an external load, it gives the body a break to focus on its own health and repair.' In the keto diet, you get about 75% of your daily calories from fat, and 5% to 10% of your calories from carbs. This shift in calorie sources causes your body to shift its metabolic pathways. It will begin to use fat for fuel instead of the glucose that's derived from carbohydrates. In response to this restriction, your body will begin to start producing ketone bodies that have many protective effects. Khorana says research suggests that the ketogenic diet can also cause starvation-induced autophagy, which has neuroprotective functions. 'Low glucose levels occur in both diets and are linked to low insulin and high glucagon levels,' Petre says. And glucagon level is the one that initiates autophagy. 'When the body is low on sugar through fasting or ketosis, it brings the positive stress that wakes up the survival repairing mode,' she adds. One non-diet area that may also play a role in inducing autophagy is exercise. According to a 2024 rat study, physical exercise may induce autophagy in organs that are part of metabolic regulation processes. This can include the muscles, liver, pancreas, and adipose tissue. Bottom line Autophagy will continue to gain attention as researchers conduct more studies on the impact it has on our health. For now, nutritional and health experts like Khorana point to the fact that there's still much we need to learn about autophagy and how to best encourage it. But if you're interested in trying to stimulate autophagy in your body, she recommends starting by adding fasting and regular exercise into your routine. However, you need to consult with a doctor if you: are taking any medications are pregnant or wish to become pregnant are breastfeeding
