Self-declared Michael Gaine murder ‘suspect' gave court ‘untrustworthy testimony'
American was involved in a bitter dispute with his ex partner over their two daughters
The district court findings were made against failed asylum seeker and father-of-two Michael Kelley, who is originally from Waldo County, Maine in the US, during a bitter custody dispute with former partner Alicia Snow in 2009.
Publicly available documents obtained by the Sunday World confirm the former US soldier made 'unsupported' allegations against Ms Snow during the dispute of 'practising witchcraft on the couple's children'.
Kelley, who has denied any involvement in Michael Gaine's murder, was arrested on May 18, just over 36 hours after the victim's body parts were discovered in slurry being spread on his farm.
Mike Gaine went missing on March 20
He was later released without charge.
Gardai believe Mr Gaine was dismembered after he was killed and that the body parts were dumped in a 50,000-gallon slurry tank on the property.
As part of the garda investigation, a full background check is being carried out on Kelley, who had been living 'underground' on Mr Gaine's farm and working as a 'farmhand'.
Enquiries carried out by this newspaper have now established that Kelley is a father-of-two who was involved in a bitter dispute with his former partner Alicia Snow, which was ultimately decided in her favour by Maine's Supreme Judicial Court in 2009.
Legal documents outlined Michael Kelley's 'untrustworthy' statements
News in 90 Seconds - June 1st
Records of this nature in the US are, unlike in Ireland, publicly available. According to court documents, Kelley and Ms Snow were involved in a romantic relationship and are the biological parents of two daughters.
After they separated, Kelley brought a parental rights action.
In 2006, a family law magistrate held a hearing and issued an order allocating shared parental rights between the parties, but stated 'in the event the parties are not able to agree, final decision-making is allocated to Ms Snow'.
The order also awarded primary residency to Ms Snow.
The 2006 order included a written agreement which afforded reasonable rights of contact with the children and stipulated that Kelley would not pay child support. After the original order was made, the former couple maintained a cordial relationship.
Gardai on site
Ms Snow was able to attain a nursing degree and begin a relationship with a new partner.
Ultimately, however, the situation began to deteriorate, culminating in a series of miscommunications between Kelley's wife and Ms Snow.
After a disagreement over a brief trip to Chicago for the children, Kelley filed a motion to enforce the 2006 parental rights order which he alleged prevented Snow from sending the children out of state without his consent.
Kelley also filed a motion for contempt, alleging that Ms Snow violated the 2006 order by taking the children to visit their grandfather in Chicago.
The court held a hearing on all of the motions on January 14, 2009.
After hearing testimony from Kelley, his then wife, Snow, and Snow's father, the court made a number of 'findings of fact.'
These included:
Snow, meanwhile, was found by the court to be 'logical and rational and her abilities to act as an effective parent are far superior to those of Kelley'.
Mike Gaine captured on CCTV before he disappeared
The court ordered that Snow have sole parental rights.
In his appeal to the Supreme Judicial Court, Kelley argued that the District Court erred when it awarded sole parental rights to Ms Snow. But the Supreme Judicial Court found: 'After a review of the record, it is evident that the court's findings are supported by the record as a whole.
'Because there is competent evidence in the record to support the court's decision, and it is clear that the court considered the best interests of the children in its award of parental rights, the judgment must be affirmed.'
Mike Gaine's wife and sister
The investigation into the murder of Michael Gaine is now in its tenth week. The popular farmer vanished on March 20.
Mr Kelley worked on Gaine's farm for a number of years.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
an hour ago
- Sunday World
Teen (13) speeding on e-scooter ‘drove recklessly' to avoid capture by Gardaí
The teenager was eventually caught and is now being dealt with through the Juvenile Diversion Programme The teenager was apprehended by Gardaí and the e-scooter was seized. Photo: An Garda Síochána Kildare A teenage boy who was caught speeding on an e-scooter in Co Kildare refused to stop for Gardaí and "drove recklessly' in order to avoid capture. While on patrol in Newbridge in Co Kildare, the Naas Roads Policing Unit spotted a young teenager driving an e-scooter travelling at speeds of up to 50kmh on the R445, despite the law stating that e-scooters must not exceed 20kmh. The teenager was apprehended by Gardaí and the e-scooter was seized. Photo: An Garda Síochána Kildare News in 90 Seconds - June 21st Additionally, e-scooters can only be driven by those aged 16 years and over and must not be fitted with a saddle. The 13-year-old driver of the e-scooter refused to stop for Gardaí and 'drove recklessly' in an attempt to avoid capture by Gardaí. The young teenager was finally apprehended by Gardaí and will now be dealt with under the Juvenile Diversion Programme, while the e-scooter was seized. "E-scooters are not toys, they are motorised vehicles and must be used responsibly,' said a Garda spokesperson. 'Misuse can lead to serious injury and legal consequences. "Let's work together to keep our roads safe.'
Sunday World
5 hours ago
- Sunday World
Disgraced terror chief plans life outside Ireland after conviction for gun running
It is the latest blow in what has been the most dramatic fall from grace of any loyalist paramilitary leader. The disgraced former UVF commander has accepted it will be difficult for him to return to his previous life. And fanciful notions that he would be able to pick up where he left off and resume control of 'B' Company are now in tatters. His expulsion from the UVF put paid to any notion of a comeback and now in a fresh blow to the convicted gun runner and suspected British agent, his hopes of a new life away from Belfast have been put on hold. He now faces the prospect of his 30-month sentence being increased after the Public Prosecution Service decreed the tariff is unduly lenient. It is the latest blow in what has been the most dramatic fall from grace of any loyalist paramilitary leader. The Sunday World understands he has confided in family and friends that he will seek to make a fresh start outside Northern Ireland. Irvine has said he does not see how he can make a safe return to live in Belfast and is believed to be concerned about his personal security while in prison. John 'Bunter' Graham There had been speculation he could be moved to the wing housing sex offenders and vulnerable inmates. The Sunday World understands there are no plans as yet for that to happen. He is currently being housed on the loyalist wing and an order issued by the UVF's Shankill leadership that he is to be left alone, stands. The majority of UVF prisoners in Maghaberry no longer swear allegiance to the organisation, many of them having been stood down including the five jailed for the murder of Ian Ogle and those serving 30 years for the sectarian murder of schoolboy Thomas Devlin. Sources have told us Irvine feels 'vulnerable'. The consequences of his fall from grace continue to play out. Last week the Sunday World revealed 'Harmless' Harry Stockman is now in the firing line after going behind the back of Chief of Staff John 'Bunter' Graham in an attempt to save Winkie's skin. We now understand the man credited with compiling the internal report, senior veteran loyalist Gerry Vinton has come under suspicion by UVF members. According to sources, secretive Vinton has long been close to Graham and was tasked to compile a dossier into Irvine's behaviour during his time as B Company and commander and subsequently. Vinton has previously denied any involvement in criminality and paramilitarism. Vinton and Irvine were at loggerheads but despite allegedly being the leading architect in Irvine's downfall, there is a feeling he is Bunter's patsy under orders to get rid of a problem and save the UVF leadership from closer inspection. Well placed sources have told us that the membership will not stop at Irvine's expulsion. They want Stockman out and are now questioning the content of Vinton's report. Harry Stockman 'Irvine was thrown aside to save the command staff,' one source told us. 'Vinton was Bunter's eyes and ears, he knew everything and in turn everything Irvine did Bunter and Stockman knew about it because it was lining their pockets. 'If they think getting rid of Irvine is where it ends they've another thing coming. There was nothing independent or objective about this so called report, his mission was to heap it all on Irvine.' The disquiet in UVF ranks could lead to the biggest shake up at the top for years. A vote of no confidence in Stockman has been proposed and question marks hang over the future of Chief of Staff Graham. Alleged Shankill commander Sam Austin is the preferred choice of the rank and file to take the reigns, although others are advocating an Army Council style leadership. Meanwhile this week the PPS have recommended that the sentence handed down to Irvine should be extended. Irvine, 49, from Ballysillan Road in north Belfast, was given a two-and-a-half year sentence last month after admitting to firearm and ammunition offences. The sentence was half the minimum recommended term, with the judge citing 'exceptional circumstances'. The PPS said it will now appeal the sentence. Irvine's sentence – half of which is to be served on licence – was below the minimum sentence of five years and attracted criticism from some politicians. A spokesperson for the PPS told the BBC: 'After careful consideration of the sentence handed down in the case of Winston Irvine, including with the benefit of advices from independent Senior Counsel, we have determined that there is a sufficient legal basis to refer the sentence to the Court of Appeal.' The PPS referral has now been lodged with the Court of Appeal. The sentence must not just be lenient, but must be unduly lenient. During sentencing Judge Gordon Kerr KC said despite Irvine's guilty plea, he had declined to give any explanation to the police or the court for having the guns and bullets in the boot of his car. However, the judge said he did not consider the crimes to be connected to terrorism. The judge cited Irvine's 'character and long-term commitment to peace building in Northern Ireland' among exceptional circumstances relating to the case. The court was told he had worked at the highest levels of government and had 'devoted most of his adult life to peace'. The PPS said it would not be appealing the five year jail term handed to co-accused Robin Workman. The pair were arrested in June 2022 after police intercepted Irvine and their search of his car uncovered a cache of guns and ammunition.
Irish Daily Mirror
6 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Ted Bundy uttered 12 chilling final words as he was led to electric chair
By the time Theodore Robert Bundy, infamous as Ted Bundy, was led into the room housing 'Old Sparky', Florida's notorious electric chair, he seemed to have come to terms with his impending demise. Leading up to his state-sanctioned execution, the convicted killer no longer exhibited his usual bravado but instead, looked sombre as he approached the death chamber. The LA Times reported that Bundy had spent the night before weeping and praying in the run-up to what would be his last hours. Bundy's charm fascinated the American public; many viewed him as an enigmatic figure. Ann Rule, his biographer and former police officer, branded him a "sadistic sociopath" revelling in others' pain. Yet, ironic was her failure to see through him when they both volunteered at Seattle's Suicide Hotline Crisis Center in 1971, years before Bundy's initial arrest, reports the Mirror US. In her work, 'The Stranger Beside Me', Rule painted a picture of Bundy during their acquaintance as "kind, solicitous, and empathetic". Such characteristics sharply contrasted the man behind heinous acts of femicide, which, alongside Bundy's bold antics in court, underscored his prowess in masking his true self. Throughout his life, Bundy was handed three death sentences. He managed to postpone the inevitable through a series of cunning tactics over this extended period, including a successful escape and some shrewd legal manoeuvring. Bundy utilised various strategies that led to prolonged proceedings, and the prosecution, who were initially open to removing the death penalty in exchange for a lengthy sentence spanning several decades, grew weary of his tactics. By the time he reached his final trial in 1980, prosecutors were resolute in their desire for Bundy to face his end in their state's most lethal chair. In many respects, the trial was groundbreaking, with coverage from 250 journalists from five continents, marking it as the first televised trial in the United States. There was a palpable sense of anticipation, as if Bundy's long-awaited justice was finally on the horizon. Despite having five court-appointed lawyers, Bundy conducted much of his own defence, seizing the opportunity to grandstand before the cameras. At times, the courtroom drama seemed more akin to a soap opera than a criminal trial with a defendant facing the death penalty. Bundy was highly intelligent, but his showboating, delusions of grandeur and persistent need to maintain control ultimately worked against him. He wasn't just content with dragging out proceedings, Bundy also took advantage of an obscure Florida law to propose to girlfriend and witness Carole Ann Boone, who accepted, from the stand. The unorthodox Florida law dictated a marriage declaration provided in court, in the presence of a judge, constituted a legal marriage. After Boone accepted - to the shock of many - Bundy announced that they were legally wed right there in the courtroom, turning the trial into even more of a media circus. As his sentence was handed down, he reportedly stood up and declared, "Tell the jury they were wrong!". Bundy's enigmatic character fascinated the public to the extent that approximately 500 folk gathered outside the north Florida jail on January 24, 1989, eagerly anticipating news of his end, while numerous others were glued to media updates. Refusing his final meal, Bundy was led to the electric chair where he spent his last moments, with the preparation process witnessed by 42 individuals. In the lead-up to his execution, which was slated for around 7:15 pm, Superintendent Tom Barton offered Bundy one last chance to speak. With little time left and as preparations for his death sentence neared completion, Bundy briefly hesitated before addressing Jim Coleman, one of his attorneys, and Fred Lawrence, the Methodist minister who had prayed with him the previous evening. The man facing his imminent demise left a final message with them, stating: "I'd like you to give my love to my family and friends." A broad strap was then secured across Bundy's mouth and chin, followed by the chair's metal skullcap being firmly fastened into place. A heavy, black veil was draped over his face, concealing it from view. Barton gave the signal, and an unnamed executioner pressed the button, unleashing two thousand volts of electricity through the chair's wires. Bundy's body tensed from the voltage, and his hands clenched into fists as a small plume of smoke rose from his right leg. After a minute, the machine was switched off, and his body went limp. A paramedic opened Bundy's blue shirt to check for a heartbeat, while another man shone a light into his eyes. At 7:16 am, it was official: Ted Bundy was pronounced dead, prompting cheers from the crowd outside the prison. Shortly after, the witnesses to Bundy's execution filed out of the facility in a somber mood. Some appeared taken aback by the jubilation unfolding before them in the chilly morning air. "Regardless of what Bundy did, he was still a human being," remarked Jim Sewell, the police chief of Gulfport, Florida, who had witnessed the serial killer's demise. Even Sewell, fresh from the shock of witnessing the execution, felt a profound sense of relief that Bundy was dead – a sentiment that seemed to resonate with many across the nation, particularly women who now had one less ruthless predator to fear in their daily lives. (Note: The original text is already written in a style consistent with British English conventions, and only minor adjustments were made to maintain the same tone and style. ).
