The Art of Grief, Violence, Death and a Genocide
Menu
हिंदी తెలుగు اردو
Home Politics Economy World Security Law Science Society Culture Editor's Pick Opinion
Support independent journalism. Donate Now
Top Stories
The Art of Grief, Violence, Death and a Genocide
Pariplab Chakraborty
14 minutes ago
Curated by Amit Mukhopadhyay and organised by SAHMAT, 'The Body Called Palestine' is an ongoing exhibition at Jawahar Bhawan, New Delhi. It features digital prints of Palestinian artists' works along with works from artists worldwide in solidarity with the Palestinian people.
Sliman Mansour's work at the exhibition 'The Body Called Palestine'. Photo: Pariplab Chakraborty.
Real journalism holds power accountable
Since 2015, The Wire has done just that.
But we can continue only with your support.
Contribute now
'Here, where the hills slope before the sunset and the chasm of time
near gardens whose shades have been cast aside
we do what prisoners do
we do what the jobless do
we sow hope…'
– Mahmoud Darwish, A State of Siege, 2002
Palestinian art, by existing, challenges the very foundation of Israeli-settler colonialism. Every occupation tries to destroy the idea of the people they occupy and in order to accomplish that, it inflicts violence on the occupied bodies. It tries to obliterate memories, truths and traces of genocidal violence. But can it omit the idea of the people resisting the occupation and defending their own land?
Curated by Amit Mukhopadhyay and organised by SAHMAT, 'The Body Called Palestine' is an ongoing exhibition at Jawahar Bhawan, New Delhi. It features digital prints of Palestinian artists' works along with works from artists worldwide in solidarity with the Palestinian people. Primarily, the exhibition seeks to remember. It is an attempt to challenge our 'monocular vision' of seeing and to engage with a new artistic language that stems from Palestinian artists across fields who are living under and resisting a genocidal regime.
'The Body Called Palestine' showcases works of Palestinian artists and their expressions of living under a never ending system of occupation, ethnic cleansing, everyday violence and utter dehumanisation. It witnesses alienation, loss, grief, and anger.
Malak Mattar, a young Palestinian artist, grew up in the Gaza strip witnessing occupation and military siege. She had created a series of monochrome and grayscale drawings and paintings – documenting the genocide in her homeland – during a residency programme. She later combined all of those images into this monumental grayscale painting titled 'No Words… (For Gaza)'. This work explicitly tells the horrors and devastation of occupation and a vicious cycle of displacement and ethnic cleansing of the people of Palestine.
While working on this painting she said 'It needs to be completely horrific,' 'otherwise it will not accurately reflect the genocide.'
Malak Mattar's 'No Words…(For Gaza)'. Photo: Pariplab Chakraborty.
Malak Mattar's art. Photo: Pariplab Chakraborty.
Maisara Baroud is a Palestinian artist from Gaza city. As a witness, his works evoke a sense of the unfathomable and the familiar, both. It is like a never-ending blur between the blacks and whites, like a nauseating fever – akin to the experience of a relentless cycle of atrocities.
'He consistently highlights topics such as war, immigration, political prisoners, illegal arrests, and occupation. Baroud's works reflect dramatic and tragic scenes, dominated by grief, death, violence, peace, hope, and freedom. His art mirrors how life is intertwined with a fresh, continuous scent of death that never seems to fade.' the artist's statement reads.
Maisara Baroud's 'The Artistic Diary of Maisara Baroud'. Photo: Pariplab Chakraborty.
The artworks show resilient acts of recording, embedded in personal and political experiences, ensuring that the grand sweep of historical injustice and the records of deafening silence from those in power are not erased.
Digital prints of noted Palestinian artist and art historian Vera Tamari's works are also on display in the exhibition. Vera was only three years old during the first Nakba in 1948. She grew up seeing a perpetual state of occupation, war and violence inflicted upon the Palestinian lives. Her vast body of ceramic, sculpture and installation works intensively talk about seeing the Palestinian reality up front and with its innumerable layers of memories, the undaunting resilience Palestinian identity and its cultural heritage.
Vera Tamari's 'Palestinian Women at Work' (ceramic relief). Photo: Pariplab Chakraborty.
The exhibition also featured an excerpt of a presentation by Vera Tamari along with the digital prints of her works. Presented originally in a conference titled 'Art and War', organised by the Goethe Institute in Ramallah, in November 2004, it goes like this:
Going for a Ride?
(Installation, 2002)
Cars are powerful icons in our society. Other than being urban household commodities, cars have become a metaphor of daily life. These inanimate objects even carry an emotional significance for most people. Not for me; I never owned a car nor learnt to drive one, but seeing my friend Liza's Volkswagen Beetle as I peeked from behind the shutters of my window one morning made me shudder.
That quaint red car in which we often rode, was visibly smashed. It was lying on its hood wheels up, almost like a dead real beetle.
In Going for a Ride? those inanimate objects, symbols of well-being, status, and freedom have in an act of vindictive violence, perpetrated by the Israeli military tanks in the 2002 invasion of Ramallah, taken on a new reality. They metamorphosed from once practical objects to become subjects of vengeful voodooism. Do we hurt the Palestinians more by destroying their cherished personal belongings?
My idea in making this installation was not to merely to fashion junk as an art form or an anti-gesture as advocated by Nouveau Realiste or Dada artists such as Marcel Duchamp and Cesare in their crashed car compositions. Both artists challenged the conventional notion of art as an aesthetic exercise. I simply wanted to make a statement about how a mundane logical reality becomes totally illogical through the violence of the war machine. It is hard to see my installation of smashed cars as not carrying a political meaning. Seven hundred private and public cars were smashed in the military incursion of Ramallah alone. I wanted to give those cars a voice – an ironic reflection on the unnecessary nature of violence whose authors were the Israeli occupation forces. This act of destruction became like action art disturbing the status quo of matters.
The soldiers in this case have become the artist creators.
The soldiers the viewers.
The soldiers as re-creators.
The installation piece kept changing.
It had a new energy each time – more violent than the previous one.
I was merely the curator.
Basma Al Sharif's work. Photo: Pariplab Chakraborty.
Basma Alsharif is an artist and filmmaker of Palestine heritage. A series of Basma's six photographs are on display in this exhibition. Her works explore the cyclical political histories and confront the 'legacy of colonisation with satire, doubt and hope'.
SAHMAT's continued solidarity with the Palestinian people finds a vivid expression in this exhibition, where, as the curator articulates 'the response to the Palestine question across the world has become a unifying force that creates new solidarities as an antidote to the atomising effects of a military-industrial complex'.
'The Body Called Palestine' aims to remember the history and presence of Israeli settler colonialism and its genocidal military offence as it is. This is valuable at a time when the larger mediascape peddles false narratives without any accountability and often erects a smokescreen of half-truths and lies, that help those in power obfuscate historical facts and cultivate public apathy.
Aban Raza, a Delhi-based artist who also co-curated an art exhibition in solidarity with Palestine last year titled 'Fida-e-Filistine' and organised by SAHMAT, says, 'This exhibition is a testament to artists' solidarity from around the world with the Palestinian struggle and our collective resistance, despite all odds and silencing.'
Labani Jangi's 'Even after a genocide, the rising moon doesn't burn our eyes'. Photo: Pariplab Chakraborty.
This watercolour painting by artist and scholar Labani Jangi from Nadia, West Bengal, explores the difference in her perception of the moon between her childhood and the present, where there's a full scale massacre of Palestinian lives happening in every passing day.
'The moon that once used to bring Eid, festivals or fantastic stories from Naani now stands still – in silence like a representative of those who can afford to dwell in apathy. Those who remain silent even after seeing a genocide in front of their eyes – drenched in the propagandas of fascist regimes,' says Labani.
The exhibition is on view until May 31, from 9.30 am to 7 pm at Jawahar Bhawan, New Delhi.
Make a contribution to Independent Journalism
Related News
Why Israel's New Aid Delivery System for Gaza Is Sparking Outrage
Concerns Expressed Over Gaza Situation, Modi Government Accused of 'Assisting Genocide'
'This Genocide Implicates Us All': 380 Writers, Organisations Call on Israel to Cease Fire in Gaza
Humanitarian Crisis in Gaza: Families Forced to the Shore Amid Escalating Conflict
For Your Own Sake, Please Care for Palestine
From Colonial Loot to Cultural Genocide at the British Museum
What the 'Cauliflower' in BJP Karnataka's X Post Means
Judge's Order Frees Indian Scholar Detained in US Over Support for Palestine
'We've Killed So Many Children – It's Hard to Argue with That': Tel Aviv Protesters in Silent Vigil
About Us
Contact Us
Support Us
© Copyright. All Rights Reserved.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Wire
3 days ago
- The Wire
CBFC Directs Sitaare Zameen Par Makers to Include Quote by Modi Mentioning the Year 2047: Report
Film The suggestion to include Modi's quote is part of the five changes/suggestions to the film which the CBFC has directed the makers to incorporate. Videograb from the trailer of Sitaare Zameen Par. Photo: New Delhi: The Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) has directed the makers of the Aamir Khan-starrer movie Sitaare Zameen Par to include a quote by Prime Minister Narendra Modi mentioning the year 2047 in the opening disclaimer. The suggestion to include Modi's quote is part of the five changes/suggestions to the film which the CBFC has directed the makers to incorporate, reported Hindustan Times. The film was subsequently issued a U/A certification on June 17, which confirms that the modifications were done, with the Prime Minister's quote inserted after the film's opening disclaimer, which has also been changed as per the CBFC's directions. The newspaper reported that it was not immediately clear what the quote is about. The movie, which is set to release on June 20, stars Aamir Khan and Genelia Deshmukh, and tells the story of a basketball coach who teaches the sport to a team of intellectually disabled people as community service after the directions of a court. The other changes in the movie directed by CBFC were the replacement of the term 'business woman' with 'business person'; a 30-second disclaimer at the beginning of the film be replaced with a 26-second voice-over; a visual containing the word 'kamal' (lotus) be removed, along with its appearance in subtitles; and 'Michael Jackson' be replaced with 'Lovebirds' in the subtitles. In recent years, the CBFC has increasingly been suggesting cuts and modifications in movie scenes. In April this year, the CBFC had asked the makers of the film Phule to remove several caste-based terms, after objection from Brahmin outfits, resulting in the postponing of its release. The directive of CBFC included removing terms such as 'Mahar', 'Mang', 'Peshvai', and 'Manu's system of caste', with the censor board terming them as 'sensitive.' Ananth Mahadevan, the director of Phule had told The Wire that he didn't agree with the modifications suggested by the CBFC. The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.
The Wire
4 days ago
- The Wire
‘Can't Allow Mobs to Take Over the Streets': SC Says State Must Ensure Thug Life Release
Menu हिंदी తెలుగు اردو Home Politics Economy World Security Law Science Society Culture Editor's Pick Opinion Support independent journalism. Donate Now Law 'Can't Allow Mobs to Take Over the Streets': SC Says State Must Ensure Thug Life Release The Wire Staff 4 minutes ago The apex court expressed concerns over the "extra-judicial ban" on the screening of the movie starring Kamal Haasan and directed by Mani Ratnam, in Karnataka. View of the Supreme Court of India, in New Delhi. Photo: PTI. Real journalism holds power accountable Since 2015, The Wire has done just that. But we can continue only with your support. Contribute now New Delhi: While hearing a public interest litigation (PIL) seeking directions to allow the screening of the Tamil feature film Thug Life, the Supreme Court on Tuesday (June 17) said that mobs cannot be allowed to take over the streets and rule of law must prevail. The apex court expressed concerns over the 'extra-judicial ban' on the screening of the movie starring Kamal Haasan and directed by Mani Ratnam, in Karnataka. 'We can't allow mobs and vigilante groups to take over the streets. The rule of law must prevail. We can't allow this to happen. If somebody has made a statement, counter it with a statement. Somebody has made some writing, counter it with some writing. This is proxy…' Justice Ujjal Bhuyan orally told the counsel representing the State of Karnataka, reported LiveLaw. The bench comprising Justice Bhuyan and Justice Manmohan asked the State to file its counter and said that the matter will be heard on Thursday (June 19). 'Rule of law demands that any film which has a CBFC certificate must be released and the State has to ensure its screening. It can't be that at the fear of burning down the cinemas, that the film can't be shown. People may not watch the film. That is a different matter. We are not passing any order that people must watch the film. But the film must be released,' said Justice Manmohan. 'Rule of law is important. State has to ensure that anyone who wants to show a film, that film must be released after it has got a CBFC certificate,' Justice Manmohan added. During the previous hearing date, the counsel for the petitioner, AoR A Velan had submitted that the state of Karnataka has 'capitulated' to extremist elements who were attacking linguistic minorities and calling for the burning of theatres. 'It is argued that a duly CBFC-certified Tamil feature film 'Thug Life' is not allowed to be screened in the theatres in the State of Karnataka. The so-called ban under threat of violence stems not from any lawful process but from a deliberate campaign of terror, including explicit threat of arson against cinema halls, incitement of large-scale violence targeting linguistic minorities. Considering the urgency shown and the issue brought before this court, we issue notice to the respondent,' the bench observed in the order. The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments. Make a contribution to Independent Journalism Related News Kamal Haasan Film Stalled in Karnataka as Actor Refuses to Apologise Over Remarks on Kannada Bengaluru Stampede: Those Arrested Include Top RCB Official, Three From Event Management Company Central Hall | Governors Increasingly Acting like Political Agents as Constitutional Morality Erodes Brazil Holds Social Media Platforms Accountable for Users' Posts 'Hasn't Learnt Any Lessons After SC Verdict': Tamil Nadu CM Stalin Launches Fresh Attack on Governor 'Misuse of Authority': SC Advocates-on-Record Association Condemns ED Summons to Senior Lawyer Karnataka Govt to Constitute Special Action Force in Three Districts to Tackle Communal Incidents State Can't Object to Two Consenting Adults From Different Religions Living Together: Supreme Court 'Same Sex Marriage Not Legalised But Couples Can Very Well Form A Family': Madras HC View in Desktop Mode About Us Contact Us Support Us © Copyright. All Rights Reserved.
The Wire
5 days ago
- The Wire
‘Second Chance': Subhadra Mahajan's Debut Is an Assured Tale of a Reawakening
Menu हिंदी తెలుగు اردو Home Politics Economy World Security Law Science Society Culture Editor's Pick Opinion Support independent journalism. Donate Now Top Stories 'Second Chance': Subhadra Mahajan's Debut Is an Assured Tale of a Reawakening Tatsam Mukherjee 6 minutes ago In this day and age, where films tend to boast of a scope of cinematic universes, giant problems, global disarray, Second Chance is a relatively contained effort. A still from 'Second Chances.' Real journalism holds power accountable Since 2015, The Wire has done just that. But we can continue only with your support. Contribute now Nia (Dheera Johnson) is scared. In the first scene of Subhadra Mahajan's Second Chance, we hear the protagonist's voice over a black screen. She's calling Kabir – her partner, presumably. She's pregnant, and doesn't know what to do. 'Please call me back when you see this,' she drops him a text, one of the many that have gone unanswered. The screen comes to life, and she's in the middle of thick snow. It takes a while for us to register that she's in some remote corner in Himachal Pradesh. As details trickle down, we learn that Nia comes from a rich Delhi family, who own a holiday home in the hills. Overcome with fear about the pregnancy, Nia flees from the capital. With limited network coverage in the home (near a bedroom window), a silent boyfriend, and seemingly supportive-yet-distant parents, Nia finds her refuge among the caretaker family of the home: Raju (Rajesh Singh), his son Sunny (Kanav Thakur) and mother-in-law Bhemi (Thakri Devi). Mahajan's directorial debut is shot in black-and-white by cinematographer Swapnil S. Sonawane, also a producer on the film. Second Chance is a breathtaking film to look at, framing Nia's initial isolation among snow-capped peaks, as if her world is caving in. The class commentary is not particularly novel here; with Nia refusing Raju and Bhemi's meticulously prepared meals in the first few days, too consumed by her own grief to be considerate of their labour or the wasted food. As Raju has to step out of town for a court hearing, Nia is left with Bhemi's caution and Sunny's unapologetic wonder. It takes a few days for her to warm up to them – but it takes the extreme winter to thaw their differences. Second Chance could initially appear like it's unfairly indulging its protagonist, given the sparse dialogue, the focus on Nia's grief, and the aesthetically-framed black and white frames of her isolation. But then the film slowly tilts towards the environment and her caretakers. An older shepherd, who brings raw wool to Bhemi to be spun into yarn, appears in two superb scenes, presenting the film's wider eye on the world. 'The weather has changed, man's principles have changed,' he bemoans to Bhemi in one scene. He imparts another gem when Bhemi and Nia visit him, after what appears to be an arduous uphill trek: 'Racing is no way to conquer mountain tops,' he notes. A still from 'Second Chances.' To Johnson's credit – Nia is equally believable as wasted youth, but also as something more. After a stomach ache reveals that her initial abortion attempt wasn't successful, the doctor asks her questions about a possible sexual assault being the cause for the pregnancy. Johnson's face shrinks, her voice quivers as she confesses – ' Meri marzi se hua tha (it happened consensually).' She tries to numb herself with alcohol and cannabis at first, but discovers peace the more she immerses herself into the lives of Bhemi and Sunny. The eight-year-old boy lost his mother during childbirth. In the midst of all his naughtiness, he doesn't forget to kiss his mother's portrait hung in their home. Looking after Nia following her abortion, Bhemi concedes her own secret. The two women both make mental notes of each other's kindness and discretion. A still from 'Second Chances.' A chance visit by a childhood friend reveals that Nia is one of those bratty drifters, responsible for a couple of failed ventures – vegan organic nighties, and vague tea concoctions – which she says were her ideas, but things she was pushed into. We are taken through a journey at the end of which Nia discovers what she wants and is unafraid to communicate it. With its glacial pacing and its silent, observational style, Subhadra Mahajan's film is a modest and assured film of a reawakening. In this day and age, where films tend to boast of a scope of cinematic universes, giant problems, global disarray, Second Chance is a relatively contained effort. While an individual's coming-of-age through trauma and betrayal might seem like a minor undertaking, it's still undoubtedly a well-made film. By the end, Nia is less scared. Maybe that's what we need today, a few more people, less scared than they were yesterday. *Second Chance is playing in theatres. The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments. Make a contribution to Independent Journalism Related News Delays, a Half-Built Campus, and No Amenities: Inside the Protests at FTI Arunachal Pradesh Post Op Sindoor, Experts Say India Should Look Beyond Traditional Suppliers For Defence Procurement 'Stolen' Embraces Contemporary India With All its Faults and Messiness Two Books Remind Us of the Importance of June 4, 2024 Raj Rachakonda's '23' Takes a Hard Look At Caste and Social Justice Russian Ambassador Says 'Discussion Ongoing' On India Getting More S-400 Air Defence System Units: Report 'Sister Midnight' Is a Feel-Bad Fable That Liberates Radhika Apte From Bollywood Changing Direction: The Wire's Short Film Festival 'India's Foreign Policy Has Collapsed,' Says Rahul Gandhi Targeting Jaishankar View in Desktop Mode About Us Contact Us Support Us © Copyright. All Rights Reserved.
