Felda's offer to take FGV private seen as fair
TA Researc said Felda's offer price of RM1.30 per share was 26% above its target price of RM1.03 per share for FGV.
PETALING JAYA: The Federal Land Development Authority's (Felda) renewed takeover offer of FGV Holdings Bhd 's (FGV) remaining shares that it does not already own at RM1.30 per share has been deemed fair in terms of valuation and the prospects for FGV, analysts say.
Research houses such as BIMB Research, Hong Leong Investment Bank Research (HLIB Research), TA Research and MIDF Research have advised FGV shareholders to accept the offer price.
The latest takeover offer marks the second attempt by Felda to privatise FGV, following a similar offer made in 2020 that also proposed RM1.30 per share.
Felda, together with persons acting in concert (PAC), including the state government of Pahang, now collectively control 86.93% of FGV's issued share capital.
BIMB Research said in a report it believes the likelihood of the shareholding crossing the 90% threshold is high.
'While the offer premium is relatively modest, we believe it is sufficient to attract acceptance given FGV's subdued earnings outlook, prevailing plantation sector volatility and lack of foreseeable near-term re-rating catalysts,' said the research house.
TA Research, meanwhile, said Felda's offer price of RM1.30 per share was 26% above its target price of RM1.03 per share for FGV.
Based on FGV's forecast earnings for this year (FY25), the offer implies an acquisition at 15 times FY25's price-earnings ratio (PER).
Notably, the offer is priced at a steep 71.4% discount to FGV's initial public offering price of RM4.55 per share in 2012.
Since Felda's initial privatisation attempt in December 2020, FGV's share price has been volatile.
It rose to RM1.46 in May 2021 after the first bid failed but steadily declined thereafter to RM1.13 by March 14, 2025, and RM1.01 by April 9, 2025, a 22% drop from the offer price.
'The current attempt would also be the second time investors are presented with an opportunity to realise the value of their investment through a cash offer,' TA Research said.
Given the potential price risk post-general offer, TA Research has advised FGV minority shareholders to accept the offer.
'We also advise investors to switch to other undervalued plantation stocks with more compelling stories and potentially higher earnings growth,' said the research house.
Similarly, HLIB Research also advised existing shareholders of FGV to accept the latest offer, as 'the offer price is higher than our sum-of-part derived target price of RM1.26'.
The research house maintained its 'hold' rating on FGV with a revised target price of RM1.30 from RM1.26 earlier, based on Felda's latest offer.
MIDF Research said in a note to clients that Felda's RM1.30 offer price represents a 12% premium over its fair value of RM1.16.
Currently, the stock is valued at 16.7 times PER based on forecast for FY25 earnings per share of 7.60 sen, 8.6% below the integrated plantation sector average PER of 18.3 times.
According to MIDF Research, the latest development reaffirms Felda's objective to fully privatise FGV and consolidate its ownership and strategic control over the group.
Felda has clearly stated that it does not intend to maintain FGV's listing status upon completion of the offer.
'Should Felda and its PAC reach the 90% ownership threshold, Bursa Malaysia will suspend the trading of FGV shares within five market days, after which the delisting process will be initiated in accordance with Bursa's listing requirements,' it said.
If successful, the privatisation is also expected to streamline Felda's operational oversight, align FGV's strategic direction with broader national interests and potentially unlock long-term value through improved efficiency and coordination across the group.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
6 hours ago
- The Star
Hire local TVET grads first before foreign workers, Johari tells plantations
KUALA KANGSAR: The Plantation and Commodities Ministry has mandated that plantation industry players must hire graduates from Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) programmes before filling the same jobs with foreign workers. Minister Datuk Seri Johari Abdul Ghani said industry players must provide proof of their efforts to hire TVET graduates to the ministry before they are permitted to recruit foreign workers. "We are currently facing a situation where many industries are unwilling to hire graduates who have completed their training. They are reluctant to provide these students with the opportunity to gain practical experience because they prefer to take the easier route. "Although the government has approved foreign workers for the plantation sector, I will not allow it unless industry players contribute to our local youth," he said when met at the Dialog@MPIC session here on Sunday (June 22). Johari said the ministry will train about 250 TVET students annually in the plantation sector, and they will be placed in the industry based on the specific needs of the industry players. He said industry players must train these students until they become skilled and future specialists in the plantation sector. "I want to commend Sime Darby and FGV for their dedicated initiatives to provide accommodation and decent salaries for young individuals who did not attend university. These youths can earn a salary of RM2,500 if they develop their skills and complete a TVET Level 3 qualification, and in another eight months, they could earn up to RM3,500. "…we must support these students in developing their careers. Otherwise, we're abandoning these youths, and that's not what we promised. Some industry players even refuse to hire them, and that's why I want to enforce this prerequisite. Currently, we depend on nearly 260,000 foreign workers to manage our plantations," he said. Johari said the sector is vital as it represents the world's third-largest export industry, and within the national commodity sector, Malaysia exports approximately RM168 billion. He emphasised the need for industry players to take responsibility for mentoring and supporting these young talents. - Bernama
The Star
2 days ago
- The Star
PMCK poised for growth with IPO plans
PETALING JAYA: PMCK Bhd, a private healthcare provider enroute to listing on the ACE Market of Bursa Malaysia, intends to pay at least 20% of its net profit as a dividend going forward. TA Research assumes a dividend payout of 20% to 44% across financial year 2025 (FY25) to FY27 and projects forward yields to be at 1.3% to 2.1%. TA Research said for its initial public offering (IPO) price of 22 sen a share, PMCK is priced at a trailing price earnings ratio (PE) of 15.9 times based on FY24 earnings per share (EPS). The research house forecast a target PE of 16 times FY26 EPS for the counter, while deriving a fair value of 23 sen a share. PMCK is operating the Putra Medical Centre in Alor Setar, Kedah and has been in the business for over 30 years, offering specialist consultant services and clinical support, with 40 consultants across 17 specialisations. PMCK will raise RM60mil through its IPO on Bursa Malaysia. It wants to strengthen its presence in northern Malaysia to attract patients and drive long-term revenue growth. Thus far, Kedah has one of the lowest private hospital bed densities in Malaysia, highlighting a significant gap in private healthcare access. As part of its expansion, PMCK is constructing a new medical centre, PMC Kulim, with operations targeted to start by the first quarter of financial year 2028 (1Q28). The 12-storey private medical centre comes with a seven-storey mixed development comprising a four-storey hotel with a two-storey food court and carparks. PMCK will consolidate the RYM DX Laboratory Sdn Bhd (medical lab) into PMC Kulim by 1Q28 to cater to increasing demand for diagnostic services. It will upgrade the equipment and facilities in PMC Kedah under clinical support services (medical lab) and facilities services (radiology unit). TA Research projects net profit to contract by 24.8% to RM11.3mil in FY25, as it expects patient numbers to drop by 20% due to the flooding in Alor Setar and surrounding areas, which hindered patient access. It expects the profit after tax margin to decline to 12.1% (versus 14.4% in FY24) due to softer patient volumes and higher administrative expenses as PMCK's facilities remained fully operational during the heavy rainfall between September and December 2024.
The Star
3 days ago
- The Star
Oil prices capped despite geopolitical conflict
TA Research has retained its 'neutral' view on the O&G sector. PETALING JAYA: Any further upside to the price premium of crude oil prices fuelled by the Iran-Israel conflict is constrained by ample spare capacity among Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries and its members (Opec) members as well as non-Opec suppliers, TA Research states in its oil and gas (O&G) sector report. It said global demand for energy also remains weaker due to slower economic activity and the increased use of electric vehicles. The research house added the geopolitical premium put on crude oil prices since the conflict erupted is more likely to be transient rather than transformative. 'The global oil supply backdrop remains relatively resilient despite the geopolitical turmoil. Opec, led by Saudi Arabia, holds sufficient spare production capacity to offset most short term disruptions from Iran,' it stated. TA Research added US shale producers continue to deliver robust output levels, averaging a steady 13.4 million barrels per day while other non-Opec producers like Brazil, Canada, and Guyana are also ramping up supply, contributing to a broader narrative of a well-supplied global market. While supply-side fears can generate temporary price rallies, the demand picture remains insufficiently supportive for a sustained oil bull cycle without further macroeconomic improvement, TA Research opined. 'While the war may add volatility, the probability of a sustained supply shock remains relatively low unless additional producers or infrastructure become targets,' it summarised. Hence, TA Research has maintained its average Brent crude oil price forecast of US$73 a barrel for 2025. 'We retain our 'neutral' view on the O&G sector, as we believe the risk-reward balance remains evenly poised. 'We reiterate our preference for oil and gas players with strong export linkages and robust cash generation, such as Pantech Group Holdings Bhd and MISC Bhd ,' the research house noted. It explained that MISC ('buy', target price: RM8.40) stands to benefit from increased demand for tanker freight and floating solutions, particularly as shipping markets remain volatile. Additionally, Pantech ('buy', target price: 96 sen), meanwhile, is well placed to ride on higher project flows for pipeline and industrial fittings, driven by infrastructure upgrades and intensified maintenance cycles in response to supply chain vulnerabilities. That said, TA Research said should diplomacy prevail and the war drums go quiet, it forecasts crude oil prices to correct to US$60 to US$65 a barrel level for the Brent contract. Furthermore, should there be complications in the Straits of Hormuz which disrupt supply lines out of the region, prices could spike to US$100 to US$120 a barrel levels.
