Another federal judge strikes down Trump's ban on trans people in the military: ‘Plainly discriminates'

A second federal judge has blocked Donald Trump 's ban on transgender service members in the U.S. military, a 'plainly' discriminatory directive with 'no evidence' to support the administration's claims, according to the ruling.
'The government's arguments are not persuasive, and it is not an especially close question on this record,' George W. Bush-appointed District Judge Benjamin Settle wrote in a 65-page opinion Thursday.
— one of several that explicitly removes federal recognition of trans people — claims that the 'adoption of a gender identity inconsistent with an individual's sex conflicts with a soldier's commitment to an honorable, truthful, and disciplined lifestyle, even in one's personal life.'
'The government has … provided no evidence supporting the conclusion that military readiness, unit cohesion, lethality, or any of the other touchstone phrases long used to exclude various groups from service have in fact been adversely impacted by open transgender service,' Settle wrote.
'The Court can only find that there is none,' he said.
Settle's decision — the second nationwide injunction targeting the Trump administration's policy — follows a lawsuit from the Human Rights Campaign Foundation and Lambda Legal representing seven actively serving trans troops.
'Transgender service members meet the same rigorous standards and requirements as any other soldier and this ban does nothing other than compromise our country's national security for the sole purpose of discrimination,' Human Rights Campaign Foundation legal vice president Sarah Warbelow said in a statement after the decision.
The decision 'affirms what we have long maintained: that banning Americans from military service solely because they are transgender is not only unconstitutional but undermines our national security and military readiness,' according to Lambda Legal counsel Kell Olson. 'These brave individuals deserve to be judged on their ability to serve, just like everyone else. While this injunction is an important step forward, we continue to fight until this discriminatory ban is permanently struck down.'
Last month, the Department of Defense ordered that the removal of all trans service members across all branches of the military 'must be completed' no later than June 25. The order also immediately bans access to gender-affirming care for all trans service members.
Following a separate lawsuit from more than 20 plaintiffs, including decorated trans service members, Washington, D.C., District Judge Ana Reyes temporarily blocked what she called a policy that is 'soaked with animus and dripping with pretext' to discriminate against trans people.
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and Pentagon officials scrambled to issue new guidance, but District Judge Ana Reyes ruled this week that the government's arguments supporting the changes — which scrutinized service members' history of gender dysphoria — were 'equally unpersuasive.'
'Defendants cannot evade discriminating against transgender people simply by labeling the policy as addressing gender dysphoria,' she wrote in a scorching opinion Wednesday.
The Trump administration has appealed both rulings.
'Thousands of transgender service members currently serving have clearly demonstrated they meet all military standards, with many deployed to critical missions worldwide, proving their capabilities beyond question,' according to Jennifer Levi, senior director of transgender and queer rights at GLAD Law, which is suing the Trump administration on behalf of two dozen trans service members.
'President Trump's executive order and Secretary Hegseth's implementation represent a policy that cannot be constitutionally justified,' she added.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

NBC News

3 hours ago

• NBC News

Iran retaliation a growing concern in the U.S. after strikes

Concerns about a potential retaliation from Iran are growing after President Trump revealed that the U.S. attacked three nuclear sites in the country. NBC News' Hallie Jackson discusses how Americans are reacting to the strikes.

Daily Mirror

7 hours ago

• Daily Mirror

Donald Trump's four-word update as he weighs up military action against Iran

Donald Trump, who has yet to decide on US involvement in the Israel-Iran conflict, has issued a four-word update on Truth Social within the last couple of hours Donald Trump has issued a four-word update as the world awaits his decision on whether to join in the conflict against Iran. The US president said on Thursday that he would make a call within the "next two weeks" but since then tensions have escalated further after Tehran declared it would not enter negotiations over its nuclear programme. Iran 's Isfahan nuclear facility - one of country's largest - was struck by Israel but did not result in a hazardous waste leak. ‌ It comes after air raid sirens sounded across parts of central Israel at around 2:30am as the military warned of an incoming missile barrage from Iran. Explosions echoed across Tel Aviv as interceptions lit up the sky, with the Israeli military scrambling to respond. ‌ Yesterday spirit warplanes, capable of delivering nuclear weapons, appeared to be on the way to Guam in the Pacific Ocean, where the US has multiple military installations. Multiple US aerial refueling tankers have been spotted on commercial flight tracking services - and commentators say their flying flight patterns are consistent with aircraft moving from the central US to the Pacific. B-2 bombers, which are the only US aircraft that carry large 'bunker buster' bombs, are based at an Air Force base in Missouri, but are often moved to the Pacific when on foreign deployments. It was not clear whether the aircraft being escorted earlier today were prepared for an operation, or merely moving to airbases closer to Iran as a show of force. Within the last couple of hours president Trump took to his social media platform Truth Social ahead of arriving at the White House to drop an enigmatic message about his intentions for US military intervention in Iran. Alongside a clip from a Fox News broadcast discussing the 'two- week' time frame Trump said: "Only time will tell." ‌ It comes after Tehran's foreign minister has warned that US involvement in the conflict would be 'very very dangerous'. In the latest missile strikes Saeed Izadi, head of the Palestinian Division of Iran's Quds Force, is believed to have died in a pinpoint "revenge" attack on a safe house in the Iranian city of Qom. The IDF says Izadi was one of the masterminds of the 2023 attacks in which 1,200 died and 250 were kidnapped. The US ambassador to Israel says the government has begun "assisted departure flights" for the first time since the October 7 attacks. Americans living in in Israel and the West Bank who need help have been urged by Mike Huckabee to complete a form on the US state department's website. It comes after Foreign Secretary David Lammy said the UK government is now arranging charter flights to bring home British nationals from Israel once the nation's airspace reopens.

Economist

a day ago

• Economist

Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, Iran's great survivor

JUST OVER a week ago it seemed as if Iran's supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, might be part of a breakthrough with America. Talks involving the two countries were approaching decision-hour. The Americans were offering to lift sanctions in exchange for Iran rolling back its nuclear programme. Some spoke of diplomatic relations between the Islamic Republic and its forever foe. The more optimistic predicted a photo-op of their two supreme leaders shaking hands.