Commissioner ‘met obligations' after TD criticises Carlow shooting response
The Garda Commissioner 'met his obligations' around whether he was required to inform the Justice Minister about an undercover operation, a spokesman said, after an opposition TD raised questions about a man who died while on bail as a result of the probe.
Labour TD Alan Kelly told the Dáil on Thursday that he had informed Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan about details around the death of a man 'charged after an undercover Garda operation'.
Advertisement
Evan Fitzgerald, 22, from Kiltegan, Co Wicklow, died by suicide with a gun after discharging it at a shopping centre in Co Carlow earlier this month.
He had been awaiting trial on weapons charges from the previous year, which Mr Kelly said related to an undercover Garda operation.
Evan Fitzgerald. Photo: Family handout/An Garda Siochana.
Commissioner Drew Harris is required by law to inform Mr O'Callaghan about 'significant developments' on a range of topics, including the protection of life and matters that may affect public confidence in An Garda Siochana.
While not specifically confirming if the Commissioner had informed the minister about the matter, a spokesman said on Thursday that the Commissioner 'met his reporting obligations' on the matter.
Advertisement
Mr Kelly told the Dáil that Mr Harris had not briefed Mr O'Callaghan about the death of Mr Fitzgerald while on bail after being charged as a result of an undercover Garda operation.
He said: 'On June 1, Evan Fitzgerald tragically and very publicly took his own life after getting bail on being charged after an undercover Garda operation.
'Why did the Garda Commissioner not brief the Minister for Justice on the details of this case and the facts that there was an undercover operation and that the guns were supplied by An Garda Siochana?'
Mr Kelly said he had to ring Mr O'Callaghan about the circumstances of Mr Fitzgerald's arrest.
Advertisement
Alan Kelly TD. Photo: Niall Carson/PA.
'Is it appropriate and right that I, as a member of the opposition, had to ring the Minister for Justice about this and inform him about it?
'Is it correct that I had to tell him to go to the Garda Commissioner to ask him about the full details of this case?'
He questioned whether the full details would have been known if he had not informed the Justice Minister about the matter.
Mr Kelly said the Commissioner had a duty to inform the minister about 'any major issues' under section 41 of the Garda Siochana Act 2005.
Advertisement
Responding to the comments, Tánaiste Simon Harris said it was 'a complex case' and he was not privy to when the Garda Commissioner does or does not use the provision in the Act.
'That is a matter between the Commissioner and the minister, but I understand the Minister for Justice has sought further information from the Garda Commissioner on the case.'
Mr Harris also said he supported comments made by Taoiseach Micheál Martin on the need for a review of bail laws.
Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan. Photo: Brian Lawless/PA.
Mr O'Callaghan previously said he had spoken to the Commissioner about various issues raised about how gardai operate, including the Carlow shooting incident.
Advertisement
On Tuesday, he said: 'I'm not the person who's there to supervise operationally what An Garda Siochana are doing.
'I ask the Commissioner questions that are of concern to me, he gives me answers in respect to them, that communication is confidential.
'I have no difficulty in telling you the issues I raised with him, obviously what he says back to me is a confidential process.'
On Thursday, a spokesman for the Commissioner said An Garda Siochana does not comment on third party remarks.
However, the spokesman noted that the legislation in question had actually been replaced by the Policing, Security and Community Safety Act 2024 at the time of Mr Fitzgerald's death.
Garda Commissioner Drew Harris. Photo: Garrett White/PA.
That Act states that the Commissioner 'shall keep the Minister and the Secretary General of the Department of Justice fully informed' of matters relating to significant developments concerning preservation of peace and public order; the protection of life, property and security; significant developments that might adversely affect public confidence or performance of An Garda Siochana; matters relevant to accountability of the Government to the Oireachtas; and any other matters that the Commissioner believes should be brought to the Minister's attention'.
The spokesman said: 'On this particular matter, the Commissioner has met his reporting obligations to the Minister under 36.1 of the Policing, Security and Community Safety 2024.
'An Garda Siochana does not comment on the detail of meetings between the Commissioner and the Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration.'
The spokesman noted that two other individuals remain before the courts in relation to the offences Mr Fitzgerald was charged with.
He added: 'In general, and without commenting on any specific case, An Garda Siochana uses a range of internationally recognised investigative techniques when tackling serious crimes such as drug dealing and procuring of firearms, either of which could then be used to cause significant harm to the public.
Ireland
'Shocking' level of misinformation around Carlow s...
Read More
'One of these is controlled deliveries. In controlled deliveries if any material is used it is safe or made safe by the law enforcement agency before being used, i.e. firearms are deactivated.'
The spokesman said: 'Following allegations being published by a national newspaper in May, the Garda Commissioner referred these allegations to Fiosru for independent examination in line with the 'incidents of concern' provision in the Policing, Security and Community Safety Act, and relevant material was provided.
'As stated by the Commissioner, Fiosru has informed An Garda Siochana that it would not be taking any further action on the matter.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
2 hours ago
- Telegraph
Farage hits back at former Irish leader's claim he would destroy the UK
Nigel Farage has dismissed claims by Leo Varadkar that he would destroy the UK if he becomes prime minister. The former Irish taoiseach predicted that the push for a united Ireland would take 'centre stage' if the Reform UK leader was to win a future general election. Mr Varadkar told BBC Northern Ireland that a Farage government would 'double down on Brexit', which would bolster Irish unity and Scottish independence. He said it was possible that England's 'volatile politics' could mean Mr Farage would become prime minister after elections in either four or nine years. Mr Farage hit back at the claims by Mr Varadkar, who was Ireland's prime minister during the Brexit negotiations, during which time he became a bogeyman for Brexiteers and unionists. 'I have heard all of this before,' said Mr Farage. 'They said that a vote for Brexit would end the Union. It didn't and nor will the Reform government.' Labour views Reform as its main rival in a future UK parliamentary election, which must take place by 2029, after the latter took hundreds of seats in local elections this year. Last week, a poll said that Mr Farage could win an outright majority and become prime minister if an election was held tomorrow. Mr Varadkar praised Sir Keir Starmer for his reset in relations with Dublin and Brussels since becoming Prime Minister. The former Fine Gael leader played a key role in agreeing the withdrawal agreement, which created the Irish Sea border between Britain and Northern Ireland 'Prime Minister Starmer might be re-elected for a second term. It's equally possible, not probable but possible, that Nigel Farage could be prime minister of the UK in four years' time, or in nine years' time,' he said. He added that Mr Farage and his supporters believed that Brexit 'had not been done properly' and would roll back the reset. 'What you'd see is an attempt to rescind many of the things that Prime Minister Starmer and his Government have done [and this would] bring the United Kingdom even further away from the European Union,' Mr Varadkar said. He added he hoped Mr Farage would not become prime minister but said it 'would change the picture in terms of attitudes towards independence in Scotland'. 'I think it would change the views of some people in the middle ground in Northern Ireland [towards Irish unity],' he added. 'It isn't just because a Right-wing nationalist government in London would want to bring the UK and Northern Ireland away from Europe. It is other things as well,' said Mr Varadkar. He added that Reform-run councils in England were 'preventing people from flying Pride or progress flags'. 'I don't think most people in Northern Ireland would like that,' he told the BBC. The Belfast or Good Friday Agreement states that the secretary of state for Northern Ireland must call a referendum if it 'appears likely' a majority wants a united Ireland. A border poll must also be held in the Republic. While polls show large support for reunification, they also consistently show a majority in favour of remaining part of the UK in Northern Ireland. Mr Varadkar has become an outspoken advocate for Irish unity since he resigned as taoiseach last year because of his low popularity ratings. His successor Simon Harris and coalition partner Micheál Martin, the leader of Fianna Fail, went on to overturn a commanding Sinn Fein lead in the polls to stay in power after elections last year.
BreakingNews.ie
4 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
JP McManus to set record straight over costs that led to International Rugby Experience dispute
Limerick horse racing mogul and philanthropist, JP McManus, is to address the Mayor of Limerick and elected representatives at a closed door meeting at Limerick City and County Council headquarters over why the Council snubbed a 'gift' from him of a €30 million premier building and €1.2 million in funding last year. McManus is understood to be deeply hurt by the joint local authority's controversial decision to decline his offer of the International Rugby Experience (IRE) building, O'Connell Street, Limerick City, as well as funding for operating costs, and he will aim to set the record straight over costs associated with the not for profit charitable venture. Advertisement A difference of opinion between the Council and Mr McManus around the costs of operating the IRE led to the deal falling flat. The red-brick vaulted ceiling monolith, built to honour the global oval ball game, which was red-carpet launched by a host of rugby stars in 2023, has been gathering dust since its shock closure last December. 50 people were employed at the IRE which delivered an estimated €7.8 million boost to the local economy and 60,000 visitors in the 12 months it was open. Mr McManus who secured the 2027 Ryder Cup for Limerick at his five-star Adare Manor Hotel, is to address the Mayor of Limerick, John Moran, senior executives and elected representatives, at an in-camera briefing at Council Headquarters, Dooradoyle, next Thursday. Advertisement Limerick Fianna Fáil TD Willie O'Dea who has been critical of the Council's decision to decline Mr McManus's 'generous offer', said: 'The gift horse is still there and the Council is still looking at it in the mouth.' 'My view is that it is a fantastic facility for Limerick and certain commitments were made by the Council and it seems to me they weren't honoured, it's a tragedy to see it closed down now. 'In fairness to JP, he has put his money where his mouth is, he invested in it and developed it to a magnificent standard, and in my opinion, there is an onus on the council to utilise it in the interests of the people not just locally, but nationally,' added Deputy O'Dea. Local Labour councillor, Joe Leddin, argued, that while he accepted the Council executive, led by Mayor Moran, had bona fide concerns about the cost of running the IRE into the future, the planned meeting with Mr McManus Ono Thursday was a 'welcome' development. Advertisement 'To be fair to JP, he expended €30 million+ on the acquisition of the old building, the design and rebuild and operations, and its unfortunate now to see the facility closed in the heart of the city. 'I along with most, if not all, councillors would like to see the building used for something, but we have to be cognisant that councillors are in charge of public monies and therein lies the challenge,' said Cllr Leddin. Last May, the IRE said that Mr McManus's 'entirely debt free, gift' to the Council to run the IRE until 2028 and then, if it wished, to use the building 'for any civic purpose' thereafter, had been agreed with the local authority when Heads of Terms were signed by both parties in March 2024. The IRE explained it was 'unable to advance' the proposed deal with the Council, leading to the IRE's closure. Advertisement The IRE stated it's thanks to Irish rugby legends Paul O'Connell and Keith Wood for their 'fantastic assistance' in getting the not for profit charitable venture off the ground. In response, Limerick City Council said it was 'disappointed' with the IRE's decision to close its doors, and it argued that it had made 'very effort' to secure the deal. The Council added that it was 'unable to secure a viable path forward' after finding it would have had to find 'substantial operational and capital funding' to continue the project. A counter offer from Mayor Moran to use €300,000 of his Mayoral Fund to help keep the facility open for the next three years, was rejected by the IRE. IRE chief executive Barry Hannon claimed that figures presented to councillors were 'over-inflated and were not included in the heads of agreement' which both parties had agreed in in principal in August 2023. It's understood Mr McManus will address councillors about his disappointment at how the deal has turned sour, and will advise councillors about what he believes is the cost of running the building going forward.
The Independent
6 hours ago
- The Independent
As Musk's 'robotaxi' rollout approaches, Democratic lawmakers in Texas try to throw up a roadblock
A group of Democratic lawmakers in Texas is asking Elon Musk to delay the planned rollout of driverless 'robotaxis' in the state this weekend to assure that the vehicles are safe. In a letter, seven state legislators asked Tesla to wait until September when a new law takes effect that will require several checks before autonomous vehicles can be deployed without a human in the driver's seat. Tesla is slated to begin testing a dozen of what it calls robotaxis for paying customers on Sunday in a limited area of Austin, Texas. 'We are formally requesting that Tesla delay autonomous robotaxi operations until the new law takes effect on September 1, 2025,' the letter from Wednesday, June 18, reads. 'We believe this is in the best interest of both public safety and building public trust in Tesla's operations.' It's not clear if the letter will have much impact. Republicans have been a dominant majority in the Texas Legislature for more than 20 years. State lawmakers and Republican Gov. Greg Abbott have generally embraced Musk and the jobs and investment he has brought to Texas, from his SpaceX rocket program on the coast, to his Tesla factory in Austin. The company, which is headquartered in Austin, did not responded immediately to a request for comment from The Associated Press. The law will require companies to secure approval from the state motor vehicles department to operate autonomous cars with passengers. That approval, in turn, would depend on sufficient proof that the cars won't pose a high risk to others if the self-driving system breaks down, among other reassurances. Companies would also have to file detailed plans for how first responders should handle the cars if there is a problem, such as an accident. The letter asked Tesla to assure the legislators it has met all the requirements of the law even if it decides to go ahead with the test run this weekend. The letter was earlier reported by Reuters. Musk has made the robotaxi program a priority at Tesla and a failure would likely be highly damaging to the company's stock, which has already tumbled 20% this year. Musk's political views and his affiliation with the Trump administration have drastically reduced sales of Tesla, particularly in Europe, where Musk's endorsement of Germany's far-right Alternative for Germany party in February's election drew broad condemnation. Tesla shares bottomed out in March and have rebounded somewhat in recent months. Much of the rise reflects optimism that robotaxis will not only be deployed without a hitch, but that the service will quickly expand to other cities and eventually dominate the self-driving cab business. Rival Waymo is already picking up passengers in Austin and several other cities, and recently boasted of surpassing 10 million paid rides. In afternoon trading Friday, Tesla shares were largely unchanged at $320. ________ AP reporter Jim Vertuno contributed from Austin.
