Employees Or Independent Contractors? How To Classify Workers
A business' tax and benefit obligations are limited when a worker is a contractor. But misclassification can be costly.
getty
When you're a small business, you may not have the resources (nor the need) for a full-time staff. You might choose to have one or two employees who work part-time, one or two who work full-time, or, depending on your circumstances, you might fill in the gaps seasonally by hiring temporary employees. From a tax and employment law perspective, all of them could potentially be your employees.
Sometimes employers assume that only full-time, permanent workers are employees. This is not true. Employees can be full-time or part-time, seasonal or year-round, temporary or permanent. The question of how to classify workers as employees versus independent contractors depends on many factors, but the length of employment is not one of them.
What distinguishes an employee from an independent contractor? If a worker is an employee, the employer has certain tax obligations on behalf of the worker. In contrast, an employer does not withhold any payroll taxes, including Social Security and Medicare taxes, nor does it pay the employer portion of those taxes for an independent contractor.
The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) says that the general rule is that an individual is considered an independent contractor if the person paying for the work has the right to control or direct only the result of the work, not the manner in which it is done. Or, to put it simply, it's a question of control: The more you control the terms of the employment, the more likely it is that you are an employer.
Obviously, control is relevant and cases are fact-specific. In an effort to clarify this, in 1987, the IRS developed a list of 20 factors to be considered. Those were memorialized in Revenue Ruling 87-41. (A revenue ruling is an official interpretation by the IRS of the Internal Revenue Code, related statutes, tax treaties, and regulations, and indicates how the IRS believes the law should be applied to a specific set of facts.)
The 20 factors identified by the IRS in Revenue Ruling 87-41 are listed below. The more the answer to each question is yes, the more likely it is that the worker is an employee and not an independent contractor.
Of course, that list isn't written in stone, just in a Revenue Ruling. Some of this is subjective, and there's no magic number of times you can answer yes that conclusively determines the outcome.
Since that time, the IRS has updated its checklist to three categories of factors to be used alongside the 20 questions.
For IRS purposes, as an employer, you must weigh all these factors to determine whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor. The IRS also has a helpful section on its website that provides examples and definitions.
So is this just about a paycheck? Not at all. Employers have different obligations towards employees than they do towards independent contractors—and that extends beyond tax obligations. For example, an employer is not responsible for providing the same benefits and tax-favored opportunities, such as health care insurance and retirement plans, to an independent contractor that they provide to those workers who are considered employees. An employer is not required to offer stock options or other incentive plans to an independent contractor. And when an independent contractor leaves, for whatever reason, there is generally no severance or unemployment compensation payable. In short, an independent contractor is, well, independent.
Worker classification can also impact wages and overtime pay. That's why, as part of its efforts to address worker misclassification, the Wage and Hour Division of the Department of Labor (DOL) published a final rule, effective March 11, 2024, revising its guidance on how to analyze whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). Additional information is available on the DOL website.
Worker misclassification issues aren't limited to small businesses. Several high-profile companies, including Microsoft, Time Warner, and Lyft, have faced court cases over allegations of worker misclassification. Perhaps the most famous case involved FedEx, which was accused of classifying and paying its drivers as independent contractors for years (when they should have been classified as employees). After extensive litigation in multiple states, FedEx paid nearly half a billion dollars in settlement payments for misclassification.
What happens if you do it wrong? As court cases around the country have demonstrated, if you erroneously classify an employee as an independent contractor and you have no reasonable basis for doing so, you may be held liable for employment taxes for that worker. Depending on circumstances, you may be required to retroactively apply benefits.
If you have concerns, you can get out in front of the problem. If you want the IRS to make a determination, you can file Form SS-8, Determination of Worker Status for Purposes of Federal Employment Taxes and Income Tax Withholding. (The form may be filed by either the business or the worker.) The IRS will review the facts and circumstances and officially determine the worker's status. But it's not quick: it can take at least six months to get a determination.
If you've misclassified a worker as an independent contractor, but you have a reasonable basis for doing so, you may qualify under a safe harbor for tax relief. The relief, sometimes referred to as section 530 relief, requires you to meet certain criteria, including treating the worker consistently for filing obligations (for example, you filed Form 1099-NEC for a worker you considered an independent contractor). You must also have treated similar workers as independent contractors.
The IRS also offers a Voluntary Classification Settlement Program (VCSP) that allows employers to reclassify workers as employees for future tax periods and obtain some tax relief. To participate, a business owner must meet certain eligibility requirements (similar to those for section 530 relief).
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNET
25 minutes ago
- CNET
Early July 4th Deals: Save Hundreds at Amazon, Best Buy, Target and More Before The Holiday Weekend
Retailers like Best Buy, Walmart and Amazon are gearing up for the July 4th, even though we are still a few weeks away from the holiday weekend. But in anticipation of this occasion, some companies have already released some fantastic deals. If you're anticipating July 4th sales, you're probably also tracking Prime Day. This sales event also occurs in July, on July 8th, to be exact. So, there will be plenty of opportunities to snag all of the items on your summer wish list at a discount. These deals will save you tons on TVs, laptops and outdoor items. It also includes your favorite brands, like Apple and Anker. Just make sure to dive into the offers quickly because these pre-holiday sales may not last long. Don't forget to check back often because we're constantly updating this page as items sell out or new deals become available. Early July 4th tech deals These are the best tech deals we've found so far among the early Fourth of July sales. We've spotted deals on some of our favorite TVs, tablets and more. Insignia 50-Inch F50 4K Smart TV: $180 This TV has a great size, loads of features and a good picture. It's also 40% off right now, so getting it for $180 is a chance you shouldn't miss. Details Save $120 $180 at Amazon Close Apple M3 MacBook Air 13-inch laptop: $899 We named the M3 MacBook Air the overall best laptop of 2024, and this discount makes it even sweeter to upgrade to a model with a 13.6-inch Liquid Retina display, an 18-hour battery life, 256GB of storage and 8GB of RAM. Details Save $200 $899 at Best Buy Close More early July 4 tech deals: Early July 4th home and kitchen deals Dyson V8 Plus cordless vacuum cleaner: $350 Dyson has often earned spots on our list of best vacuums, and the V8 Plus model is perfect for tackling dust and debris. If you've been considering an upgrade, don't sleep on this vacuum deal -- the V8 is now just $350, the lowest price we've seen. Details Save $120 $350 at Amazon Close Ring Battery Doorbell: $50 The Ring Battery Doorbell is an excellent way to add a bit more security and convenience to your home. And it's now half off if you're a Prime member, which is a great deal. Details Save $50 $50 at Amazon Close Ninja Creami ice cream maker: $169 Make your own ice cream concoctions at home with the viral Ninja Creami, thanks to this rare discount. It's easy to use and makes restaurant-quality frozen desserts with the click of a button. Details Save $30 $169 at Walmart Close More early July 4 home and kitchen deals: Early July 4th mattress deals Now is a great time to upgrade your mattress and score a great deal. Here are our favorite mattress deals to shop during early Fourth of July sales. Nectar mattresses Score a new mattress for as low as $349, plus 66% off bundles. Choose from tons of styles and designs. Details Up to 50% off mattresses See at Nectar Close Mattress Firm You can get up to 20% off adjustable bases and up to 60% off Mattress Firm's bestsellers. Pillows and sheets are also 20% off. Details Save up to 60% See at Mattress Firm Close DreamCloud DreamCloud is offering some significant savings, offering up to 60% off mattresses. (So, you could potentially score a mattress for as low as $299) Plus, you can also save $599 with the included accessories and get 66% off bundles. Details Save up to 60% on mattresses See at DreamCloud Close More early Fourth of July mattress deals: Early July 4th outdoor deals Upgrade your backyard or prep for your next summer camping trip with these hot early Fourth of July outdoor deals. Solo Stove sales Solo Stove, which offers a wide selection of fire pits and accessories, is currently offering up to $230 off bundles. In addition to fire pits and accessories, the company also has pizza ovens and other outdoor goodies, including furniture. Details Save up to $230 bundles See at Solo Stove Close Christopher Knight 2-piece mesh chaise lounge set: $329 Reduced by almost $200, these Christopher Knight chairs are now a good 37% off. The clean lines of these lounge chairs will complement any outdoor decor, and they feature adjustable backs, so you can go from sitting to napping in seconds. Details Save $193 $329 at Amazon Close Anker Solix C1000 portable power station: $449 If you're going camping this summer, a portable power station is an asset -- coming in handy if you unfortunately lose power at home. This model has 11 versatile ports and is strong enough to keep an electric grill, projector or coffee maker powered up. It has a maximum rated power of 1800W, but can reach a peak power of 2400W. Details Save $350 $449 at Amazon Close More of the best early Fourth of July outdoor deals: When do July 4th sales start this year? Independence Day falls on July 4th every year. Fourth of July sales often tend to hang around for a few days before and after the holiday. Amazon also announced that its next Prime Day will take place from July 8 to 11, so the two sales may blend. Where are the best pre-July 4th sales? Fourth of July sales offer some of the best prices on tech, appliances, mattresses and fashion, making it a great time to snag stellar prices on must-have items, and there are a ton of retailers still participating in the holiday savings. Unsurprisingly, Amazon is usually one of the best places to buy since it sells products from almost all major brands across these popular categories, making it a tremendous one-stop shop for all of your Fourth of July buys. Outside of Amazon, we recommend checking out appliance and tech sales at Best Buy, Home Depot and Lowe's, as well as holiday sales on a large variety of categories at Walmart, Target and Nordstrom, among others. Should I shop July 4th sales or wait for Prime Day deals? There's no definitive way to say whether Fourth of July sales or Prime Day deals are best. Both sales offer plenty of deals, including some of the best prices we'll see all year. Plus, it's likely the two sales will blur into one big discount extravaganza, given their expected proximity. Fourth of July sales offer more variety in retailers, though much of your shopping may take place on Amazon anyway. There are also plenty of non-Amazon retailers that will keep their sales rolling through mid-July, often directly competing with Amazon Prime prices. Since you'll be able to shop so many Fourth of July sales in just a few weeks, grab what you need and then keep tabs on Prime Day deals later for anything you miss out on. How to keep up with the best July 4th sales There are a lot of ways to ensure you're getting the latest scoop on Fourth of July offers. The CNET Deals team covers all the best price drops, discounts and deals every day from across the web, highlighting the best offers. We'll be tracking all the major retailer sales following the Fourth of July holiday and sharing the promotions you need to hear about, and there are plenty of ways to hear from us. One option is to bookmark to check out our latest coverage. You can also follow @CNETDeals on X to see everything we publish or sign up for our CNET Deals newsletter for a daily digest of deals delivered to your inbox. Another great option is to sign up for CNET Deals text alerts for curated deals during major shopping events. Remember to install our CNET Shopping browser extension to help ensure that purchases you make all year round will be at the lowest price available.
CNN
26 minutes ago
- CNN
Why aren't tariffs causing inflation?
Why aren't tariffs causing inflation? For the past year, many economists warned that tariffs would increase prices, but inflation is lower today than when President Trump took office. CNN's Matt Egan breaks down why this might be the case and how economists expect that to change in the coming months. 01:09 - Source: CNN Vertical Trending Now 15 videos Why aren't tariffs causing inflation? For the past year, many economists warned that tariffs would increase prices, but inflation is lower today than when President Trump took office. CNN's Matt Egan breaks down why this might be the case and how economists expect that to change in the coming months. 01:09 - Source: CNN 50 years of 'Jaws' and shark attacks As Steven Spielberg's summer blockbuster 'Jaws' turns 50, CNN's Harry Enten figures out how likely it is to be attacked by a shark and whether we should fear the waters. 01:57 - Source: CNN Erupting volcano puts Indonesians on high alert Mount Lewotobi Laki Laki, one of Indonesia's most active volcanoes, erupted Tuesday, sending an ash cloud high into the air. The country's volcanology agency has raised the alert level to the highest. 00:59 - Source: CNN The NHL Stanley Cup's perfect imperfections The Stanley Cup is one of the most iconic trophies in all of sports, but one of the reasons the NHL's championship trophy is so lionized is its perfect imperfections. CNN's Coy Wire spoke to The Keeper of the Cup Howie Borrow for a tour of some of the trophy's character-building bloopers. 01:02 - Source: CNN Storm chaser captures 'unprecedented' view of monster hailstones falling from sky Storm chaser and research scientist Sean Waugh has documented softball sized (or greater) hailstones in freefall with an ultra-high-tech camera mounted on a retrofitted research vehicle. The goal – to study and better understand what makes gigantic hail form, and how to better detect it and ultimately improve severe weather warnings. Sean speaks with CNN Meteorologist Derek Van Dam while on the road, capturing imagery of this very impactful and expensive natural phenomenon. (edited) 01:47 - Source: CNN Flash flood destroys apartment building An apartment building in West Virginia partially collapsed as flash floods hit the area. The governor's office said at least five people are dead and four people remain missing following the floods. 00:31 - Source: CNN After talking to hundreds of dads, this podcaster shares his two biggest lessons Dr. John Delony speaks to millions of listeners on his popular podcast about mental health, family and relationships. As a therapist, he's used to offering advice to struggling fathers, but we asked him about the biggest lessons he's learned as a dad. 01:32 - Source: CNN Rare deep-sea squid filmed alive for first time Scientists have captured the first-ever footage of the elusive Gonatus antarcticus squid alive in its deep-sea habitat. CNN's Jeremy Roth describes the rare encounter. For more on this story, visit 01:12 - Source: CNN Trump draws boos and cheers at Kennedy Center President Donald Trump drew charged reactions of both admiration and ire at the Kennedy Center's opening night of "Les Misérables." 00:29 - Source: CNN The many adventures of the Stanley Cup Winner's of the NHL's Stanley Cup each get to take the cup for a day and do whatever they want with it. CNN's Coy Wire recounts some of the Cup's wildest days out. 00:43 - Source: CNN BTS members discharged from South Korean military One of the world's biggest boybands could soon be making a comeback with six out of seven members of K-Pop supergroup BTS now discharged from South Korea's mandatory military service. The band plans to reunite at some point later this year. 00:47 - Source: CNN Combs requests mistrial for a second time CNN's Elizabeth Wagmeister explains that Sean "Diddy" Combs' defense team requested a mistrial for a second time, which was denied. Combs' team accused the prosecution of presenting false testimony from Bryana Bongolan, a friend of Cassie Ventura's, who testified that Combs dangled her over a balcony. 01:26 - Source: CNN Tennessee sheriff's office airlifts escaped zebra to safety DEK: A zebra, that escaped from its owner in Christiana, Tennessee was captured on Sunday and airlifted to safety by the local sheriff's office. The animal, named Ed, had been reported missing just a day after he was acquired by its owners in Rutherford County. They have since been reunited. 00:35 - Source: CNN Jamie Foxx breaks down during BET Awards acceptance speech Jamie Foxx was overcome with emotion while accepting the Ultimate Icon Award at the BET Awards. He reflected on his 2023 health scare. 00:45 - Source: CNN See what's coming to your iPhone and other Apple devices Apple announced major software updates at its annual Worldwide Developers Conference. Most of the new features won't reach users' devices for a few months when OS 26 releases this fall. 01:49 - Source: CNN
Bloomberg
27 minutes ago
- Bloomberg
Trump Says Iran Wants to Speak With US, Not Europe
Bloomberg Markets: The Close President Donald Trump says two weeks is the maximum amount of time he will allow to pursue diplomacy with Iran while speaking with reporters. (Source: Bloomberg)
