How this Parisian music streaming service is fighting AI fraud
Music streaming service Deezer said Friday that it will start flagging albums with AI-generated songs, part of its fight against streaming fraudsters.
Deezer, based in Paris, is grappling with a surge in music on its platform created using artificial intelligence tools it says are being wielded to earn royalties fraudulently.
The app will display an on-screen label warning about 'AI-generated content' and notify listeners that some tracks on an album were created with song generators.
Deezer is a small player in music streaming, which is dominated by Spotify, Amazon and Apple, but the company said AI-generated music is an 'industry-wide issue.' It's committed to 'safeguarding the rights of artists and songwriters at a time where copyright law is being put into question in favor of training AI models,' CEO Alexis Lanternier said in a press release.
Deezer's move underscores the disruption caused by generative AI systems, which are trained on the contents of the internet including text, images and audio available online. AI companies are facing a slew of lawsuits challenging their practice of scraping the web for such training data without paying for it.
According to an AI song detection tool that Deezer rolled out this year, 18% of songs uploaded to its platform each day, or about 20,000 tracks, are now completely AI generated. Just three months earlier, that number was 10%, Lanternier said in a recent interview.
AI has many benefits but it also 'creates a lot of questions' for the music industry, Lanternier told the Associated Press. Using AI to make music is fine as long as there's an artist behind it but the problem arises when anyone, or even a bot, can use it to make music, he said.
Music fraudsters 'create tons of songs. They upload, they try to get on playlists or recommendations, and as a result they gather royalties,' he said.
Musicians can't upload music directly to Deezer or rival platforms like Spotify or Apple Music. Music labels or digital distribution platforms can do it for artists they have contracts with, while anyone else can use a 'self service' distribution company.
Fully AI-generated music still accounts for only about 0.5% of total streams on Deezer. But the company said it's 'evident' that fraud is 'the primary purpose' for these songs because it suspects that as many as seven in 10 listens of an AI song are done by streaming 'farms' or bots, instead of humans.
Any AI songs used for 'stream manipulation' will be cut off from royalty payments, Deezer said.
AI has been a hot topic in the music industry, with debates swirling around its creative possibilities as well as concerns about its legality.
Two of the most popular AI song generators, Suno and Udio, are being sued by record companies for copyright infringement, and face allegations they exploited recorded works of artists from Chuck Berry to Mariah Carey.
Gema, a German royalty-collection group, is suing Suno in a similar case filed in Munich, accusing the service of generating songs that are 'confusingly similar' to original versions by artists it represents, including 'Forever Young' by Alphaville, 'Daddy Cool' by Boney M and Lou Bega's 'Mambo No. 5.'
Major record labels are reportedly negotiating with Suno and Udio for compensation, according to news reports earlier this month.
To detect songs for tagging, Lanternier says Deezer uses the same generators used to create songs to analyze their output.
'We identify patterns because the song creates such a complex signal. There is lots of information in the song,' Lanternier said.
The AI music generators seem to be unable to produce songs without subtle but recognizable patterns, which change constantly.
'So you have to update your tool every day,' Lanternier said. 'So we keep generating songs to learn, to teach our algorithm. So we're fighting AI with AI.'
Fraudsters can earn big money through streaming. Lanternier pointed to a criminal case last year in the U.S., which authorities said was the first ever involving artificially inflated music streaming. Prosecutors charged a man with wire fraud conspiracy, accusing him of generating hundreds of thousands of AI songs and using bots to automatically stream them billions of times, earning at least $10 million.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
TechCrunch
an hour ago
- TechCrunch
Week in Review: Meta reveals its Oakley smart glasses
Welcome back to Week in Review! Lots in store for you today, including Wix's latest acquisition, Meta's new smart glasses, a look at the new Digg, and much more. Have a great weekend! Smart specs: Meta and Oakley have teamed up on a new pair of smart glasses that can record 3K video, play music, handle calls, and respond to Meta AI prompts. They start at $399 and have double the battery life of Meta's Ray-Bans. A $499 limited-edition Oakley Meta HSTN model will be available starting July 11. Unicorn watch: Wix bought 6-month-old solo startup Base44 for $80 million in cash after it quickly gained traction as a no-code AI tool for building web apps. Created by a single founder and already profitable, Base44's rapid rise made scooping it up irresistible. Sand to the rescue: Finland just turned on the world's largest sand battery — yes, actual sand — which stores heat to help power the small town of Pornainen's heating system and cut its carbon emissions. The low-tech, low-cost system is built from discarded fireplace soapstone, is housed in a giant silo, and can store heat for weeks, proving you don't need fancy lithium to fight climate change. You just need a pile of hot rocks. This is TechCrunch's Week in Review, where we recap the week's biggest news. Want this delivered as a newsletter to your inbox every Saturday? Sign up here. News Image Credits:Rebecca Bellan We're back, baby: VanMoof is back from the brink with the S6, its first e-bike since bankruptcy — and it's sticking to its signature custom design, despite that being what nearly killed the company. Backed by McLaren tech and a beefed-up repair network, the new VanMoof promises smoother rides, smarter features, and (hopefully) fewer stranded cyclists. Space lasers: Baiju Bhatt, best known for co-founding Robinhood, is now building lasers in space. His new startup, Aetherflux, has raised $60 million to prove that beaming solar power from orbit isn't a fantasy, with a demo satellite set to launch next year and early backing from the Department of Defense. Techcrunch event Save $200+ on your TechCrunch All Stage pass Build smarter. Scale faster. Connect deeper. Join visionaries from Precursor Ventures, NEA, Index Ventures, Underscore VC, and beyond for a day packed with strategies, workshops, and meaningful connections. Save $200+ on your TechCrunch All Stage pass Build smarter. Scale faster. Connect deeper. Join visionaries from Precursor Ventures, NEA, Index Ventures, Underscore VC, and beyond for a day packed with strategies, workshops, and meaningful connections. Boston, MA | REGISTER NOW Oh no: One of SpaceX's Starship rockets exploded during a test in Texas, likely pushing back the vehicle's next launch, which had been tentatively set for June 29. SpaceX says the blast, caused by a pressurized tank failure, didn't injure anyone, but it's yet another setback in a rocky year for the company's ambitious mega-rocket program. That lossless feeling: Spotify's long-awaited lossless audio tier still hasn't launched, but fresh hints buried in the latest app code suggest that it's under active development and could be closer than ever. But with years of delays and no official timeline, fans might want to temper their excitement until Spotify confirms the rollout. I can Digg it: Digg's reboot has entered alpha testing with a fresh iOS app aimed at becoming an AI-era Reddit alternative. The app offers a clean, simple design with curated communities, AI-powered article summaries, and gamified features like 'Gems' and daily leaderboards. We want you: The U.S. Navy is speeding up how it works with startups, cutting red tape and zeroing in on real wins like saved time and better morale. Department of the Navy CTO Justin Fanelli says it's leading with problems, hunting for game-changing tech in AI, GPS, and system upgrades. And with Silicon Valley finally paying attention, the Navy's becoming a go-to partner for innovators ready to shake things up. Cash ain't king: Mark Zuckerberg is throwing out massive cash — up to $100 million — to lure top AI talent from OpenAI and DeepMind. But OpenAI's Sam Altman says none of his key people have bitten, praising his team's mission over money. Meanwhile, OpenAI keeps pushing ahead with new AI models and even hints at launching an AI-powered social app that could outpace Meta's own shaky attempts. Before you go Image Credits:Cluely San Francisco's latest startup saga? Cluely's after-party for YC's AI Startup School blew up on Twitter, drawing 2,000 party crashers, but it became the 'most legendary party that never happened' after getting shut down by cops before a single drink was spilled. Founder Roy Lee's viral marketing may have promised chaos, but the real party's waiting. Maybe once the weather warms up?
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
The key attribute that explains why Liverpool signed Florian Wirtz – and why he'll succeed
There was a time when Liverpool looked to a German prodigy at Bayer Leverkusen as they sought to add another dimension to their attack but didn't get him. That time was 2017, the Bundesliga wunderkind was Julian Brandt and the reason was that Jurgen Klopp, initially an advocate of his compatriot, was persuaded to switch his attentions to Mohamed Salah by Michael Edwards and the recruitment team assembled by Fenway Sports Group. Fast forward eight years, when Brandt has had a fine career but Salah an exceptional one, and Liverpool have brought in the next generation of German playmaker. Florian Wirtz has cost an initial £100m; it could rise to a British record £116m if add-ons are triggered. It is already a club high: it could be a third overall record set in the FSG era after the most expensive prices then ever paid for a goalkeeper (Alisson, £65m) and defender (Virgil van Dijk, £75m). FSG can make the statement signing and balance the books. When they go big, it tends to be for a player they feel will be transformative. Advertisement Before his departure, Klopp admitted there were times he wished Liverpool had spent more. But he bought into the general policy. His relative frugality helped finance the Wirtz deal. So did the summer of his departure when Arne Slot arrived and Liverpool pocketed a transfer-market profit. Arne Slot has seen his Premier League-winning squad improved already this summer (AP) But if Wirtz's fee can seem off the scale – only Alisson, Van Dijk and Darwin Nunez have otherwise cost more than £60m – both the broader strategy and his profile render him a classic FSG buy. A couple of years ago, Klopp offered some insight into the criteria. 'The owners really want 200 games at 20 years old,' he said. 'That is pretty difficult.'' The best way to read it, however, is to say FSG want 23-year-olds with 200 games to their name. Go through many of their bigger and better signings over the last decade and it is roughly accurate. Wirtz will not turn 23 for a year but has 197 club appearances to his name, plus 31 Germany caps. Jeremie Frimpong, a teammate for both Leverkusen and Liverpool, joins at 24 with 245 club games, and 13 appearances for the Netherlands. Milos Kerkez, the left-back set to become their third major summer signing, has 158 matches to his name; 181 if his caps are included. Advertisement Dominik Szoboszlai came at 22 with the experience of 216 club games, Alexis Mac Allister at 24 with 213, Cody Gakpo at 23 with 195, Sadio Mane at 24 with 197, Salah at 25 with 252, Andy Robertson at 22 with 202, Roberto Firmino at 23 with 191, Diogo Jota at 23 with 213, Ryan Gravenberch with 181 at just 21. Giorgi Mamardashvili, bought last summer at 23, was loaned back to Valencia and has now played 201 matches of club football. Average it out and Klopp's theory stands up. FSG's recruitment policy seems underpinned by several elements. They are signing players whose best days should be ahead of them. Indeed, Liverpool looks a step up for virtually all. Their wages, while they can be substantial – and Wirtz certainly will not come cheap – are likely to be less than those of players a few years older with a stack of major medals to their name. Florian Wirtz signs on the dotted line for Liverpool (Liverpool FC via Getty) And yet those 200 games, those five or six years of first-team football, offer sufficient evidence for Liverpool to form a meaningful judgement. Some of their arrivals, like Robertson, Jota, Mac Allister, Mane and the target Kerkez, have a grounding in the Premier League. Advertisement The others tend to have played in the Champions League and one of six major European leagues: in Germany, Italy, Spain, France, Portugal or the Netherlands. They let them learn, improve and make their mistakes elsewhere and then pounce. Their previous club serves as a well-recompensed finishing school. It is notable, though, that for many Liverpool is not their second club, but the third, fourth or fifth. Florian Wirtz was a crucial part of Bayer Leverkusen's Bundesliga title win in 2024 (EPA) Their formula can have a pertinence. Over the last decade, Liverpool have a high strike rate. That so few of their major buys have failed reflects on the quality of their analysis and decision-making – and Edwards and the off-field transfer specialists can note that the erratic Nunez was more of a Klopp choice – and has enabled them to compete with clubs with bigger budgets. It also stands in contrast to clubs with lower success rates: under Clearlake Capital and Todd Boehly, Chelsea have signed younger, prioritising potential but bringing in players without that body of evidence. Manchester United went through a phase of signing old, on bigger wages, with a lesser resale value. That policy produced Cristiano Ronaldo, Edinson Cavani, Alexis Sanchez, Raphael Varane and Casemiro – what might generously be called mixed returns and an ever-present possibility of decline. Advertisement Liverpool have rarely deviated from their strategy. Van Dijk was older than most, but has displayed longevity. So was Federico Chiesa, but he was more of an opportunistic punt at a low price. Klopp had to persuade his employers to bring in Wataru Endo at 31. Yet a curiosity of Liverpool's buying is that while their statistics gurus can recruit on attributes; their successful signings do not always appear in the positions they did for previous clubs. To varying degrees, Firmino, Mane, Gini Wijnaldum and Gravenberch have been reinvented. Now there are questions surrounding where Wirtz will play, even if the price tag suggests Liverpool have a plan. They usually do. Every other buy in Liverpool's history has been cheaper. Many in the last 10 years have been successes. And if that owes much to the two managers, to the player identification and planning, it also reflects on what can look a low-risk approach to recruitment. You can sign up to DAZN to watch every Club World Cup game for free
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Liverpool target Marc Guéhi prepared to see out final year of Crystal Palace contract
Marc Guéhi will not be rushed into a decision on his future and is prepared to see out the final year of his contract at Crystal Palace if the right move does not materialise this summer. Palace are looking to cash in on the England defender, who is a target for Liverpool, Newcastle and Tottenham, but there is a possibility of the club losing one of their biggest assets on a free transfer next year. Guéhi, who has no intention of signing an extension, remains open-minded about his next destination and a big consideration for the 24-year-old is making sure he has plenty of playing time next season. Advertisement Related: Men's transfer window summer 2025: all deals from Europe's top five leagues The former Chelsea centre-back, who played an integral role in Palace winning the FA Cup, needs to safeguard his place in the England squad before the 2026 World Cup. That means there is an obvious benefit in joining a club who can offer Guéhi a quick route into their starting XI. Liverpool have emerged as strong contenders to sign Guéhi and could bid for him once they sell Jarell Quansah to Bayer Leverkusen for £30m. A potential stumbling block, however, is that Liverpool still have the outstanding duo of Virgil van Dijk and Ibrahima Konaté as their first-choice pairing in central defence. Van Dijk, 33, has extended his contract with the Premier League champions and is showing no sign of slowing down. The sale of Quansah will leave Liverpool short of defensive cover. The 22-year-old centre-back made 25 appearances for Arne Slot's last season and can also play at right-back. Konaté is entering the final year of his deal and has struggled with injuries at times. Joe Gomez, another of Liverpool's defensive options, has been out since February with a hamstring injury. Advertisement Guéhi will face a big decision if Liverpool follow up their interest in him by offering enough for Palace to sell. A chance to join the best team in England and work with Slot would be hard to turn down. At the same time there are indications that clubs who can immediately guarantee him regular football retain a good chance of signing him. Newcastle tried to buy Guéhi last summer, only to be put off by Palace's asking price of around £70m, and they remain in the mix after qualifying for the Champions League. Their current options at centre-back include three players in their 30s – Dan Burn, Fabian Schär and Jamaal Lascelles – and the 25-year-old Sven Botman, who missed much of last season through injury. Spurs will also be in the market for a new defensive partner for Micky van de Ven if they sell Cristian Romero, who has been targeted by Atlético Madrid. Spurs, who have qualified for the Champions League, had an offer of £55m plus £15m in add-ons rejected in January. There seems little prospect of Chelsea following up preliminary interest in Guéhi. Guéhi staying at Palace for another year before leaving for nothing has not been ruled out. He can speak to foreign clubs about signing a pre-contract from January. For Palace, there is a question of making sure their demands remain realistic this summer. Interested clubs are unlikely to want to overpay for a player who is entering the final year of his contract.
