logo
ENع
10 Underrated Bourbon Brands You Should Be Drinking

10 Underrated Bourbon Brands You Should Be Drinking

Forbes08-05-2025

Scotch whiskey glass and old wooden barrel. With copy space
Bourbon has never been more popular, and with that popularity comes a lot of hype. Bottles sell out in minutes, secondary market prices skyrocket, and suddenly, it feels like you need a treasure map (or a really good liquor store connection) just to get your hands on the so-called 'best' bourbons. But here's the thing—some of the best bottles aren't the ones people are camping out for. They're the ones quietly waiting on the shelf, overlooked by the masses but beloved by those in the know.
While brands like Pappy Van Winkle, Weller, and Blanton's get all the attention, there's a whole world of underrated bourbons that offer incredible flavor without the impossible hunt or inflated price tag. These are the bottles you can actually find, actually afford, and—most importantly—actually enjoy without feeling guilty for opening them.
From high-proof powerhouses to smooth, easy sippers, this list highlights ten bourbons that deserve more love. Some are longtime staples that have been overshadowed by new trends, while others are up-and-coming distilleries proving they can compete with the big names. But they all have one thing in common: they're absolutely worth drinking.
So, if you're looking to expand your bourbon horizons and add a few new favorites to your rotation, here are ten underrated bourbons that should be on your radar.
Old Grand Dad 114
If you think Old Grand-Dad is just a bottom-shelf relic, think again. The 114-proof version is a hidden gem that delivers serious flavor at a wallet-friendly price. Don't let the old-school name fool you—this bourbon punches well above its weight class.
Why It's Underrated: The name might not scream sophistication, but this high-proof bourbon is a fantastic bang for your buck. It's got history, character, and enough kick to make you double-check the label.
Tasting Notes: Rich caramel and vanilla up front, followed by baking spices, toasted oak, and a warming cinnamon finish. Strong but surprisingly smooth.
Henry McKenna 10-Year Bottled-in-Bond
Despite winning top whiskey honors, Henry McKenna 10-Year still manages to fly under the radar. Aged for a full decade and bottled-in-bond, this bourbon is rich, complex, and proof that sometimes, the best things come to those who wait.
Why It's Underrated: It won Best in Show at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition, but it still flies under the radar compared to other premium-aged bourbons.
Tasting Notes: Deep vanilla, toasted oak, and honey, with a touch of black pepper and dried fruit on the finish. A solid balance of sweet and spice.
Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style
Old Forester might not always get the same fanfare as some of its Brown-Forman siblings, but the 1920 Prohibition Style expression is an absolute powerhouse. If you like high-proof, full-bodied bourbons with a bit of history, this one's for you.
Why It's Underrated: Old Forester is often overshadowed by its fancier cousins in the Brown-Forman family (hello, Woodford Reserve), but this Prohibition-era tribute is a powerhouse.
Tasting Notes: Dark cherry, caramelized sugar, cocoa, and a hint of leather. A warm, long finish with plenty of oak and spice.
Wilderness Trail Bottled-in-Bond
Wilderness Trail is a small but mighty Kentucky distillery that's making waves with its commitment to traditional bourbon-making. This bottled-in-bond expression showcases their dedication to quality, with rich flavors and a perfectly balanced profile.
Why It's Underrated: A small Kentucky distillery making a name for itself with traditional methods and a focus on grain-to-glass transparency.
Tasting Notes: Butterscotch, honey, and citrus zest up front, balanced with rich oak and nutmeg. Creamy mouthfeel with a long, dry finish.
New Riff Bottled-in-Bond
New Riff may be a newcomer in the bourbon world, but they're already proving they can hang with the best. Their bottled-in-bond release is a fantastic example of what careful craftsmanship and patience can produce.
Why It's Underrated: New Riff is one of the newer kids on the block, but they're doing things the right way—100% Kentucky-made with no shortcuts.
Tasting Notes: Toasted marshmallow, vanilla bean, and a little herbal spice. The rye in the mash bill gives it a peppery kick on the finish.
1792 Full Proof
If you're after a high-proof bourbon that delivers bold flavors without the insane secondary market prices, 1792 Full Proof is a winner. It's a well-balanced, rich, and deeply satisfying pour that deserves more attention.
Why It's Underrated: This high-proof bourbon delivers a big, bold flavor without the collector's price tag. It's not as flashy as some barrel-proof offerings, but it holds its own.
Tasting Notes: Dark chocolate, caramelized banana, cinnamon, and oak. The heat is there, but it mellows out nicely.
Elijah Craig Small Batch
Elijah Craig Barrel Proof gets all the glory, but don't sleep on the Small Batch. It's an excellent everyday bourbon with a depth of flavor that makes it a go-to for both sipping and cocktails.
Why It's Underrated: It's often overlooked in favor of its barrel-proof sibling, but this is a solid everyday bourbon with plenty of depth.
Tasting Notes: Brown sugar, vanilla, and toasted oak, with a hint of orange peel. Classic bourbon flavors, well-balanced and easy to sip.
Four Roses Single Barrel
Four Roses is well-known, but its Single Barrel offering is often overshadowed by more hyped bourbons. With a unique high-rye mash bill and hand-selected barrels, this is a beautifully balanced and flavorful bourbon.
Why It's Underrated: Four Roses gets respect, but it's still not as widely adored as some other Kentucky classics. The Single Barrel expression is one of the best values in bourbon.
Tasting Notes: Ripe red fruit, caramel, spice, and a floral undertone. The finish is long with just enough heat to keep things interesting.
Barrel Craft Spirits Bourbon
Barrell Craft Spirits is known for sourcing and blending exceptional whiskeys, but they don't always get the love they deserve. Their bourbon releases are bold, complex, and a fantastic option for those who love cask-strength pours.
Why It's Underrated: It's a non-distilling producer (NDP), which means they source their whiskey—but they do it exceptionally well, blending barrels from multiple states for unique flavor profiles.
Tasting Notes: Maple syrup, dark chocolate, dried cherries, and a touch of espresso. Bold, complex, and worth every penny.
Chattanooga Whiskey 111
Tennessee bourbon often gets overlooked, but Chattanooga Whiskey is changing the game. Their 111-proof expression is a bold, flavorful sip that proves great whiskey exists outside of Kentucky.
Why It's Underrated: Tennessee bourbon gets overshadowed by Kentucky, but Chattanooga Whiskey is proof that great whiskey doesn't stop at the state line.
Tasting Notes: Molasses, toasted coconut, dark fruit, and warm baking spices. A rich, full-bodied pour with a long, satisfying finish.
Bourbon lovers tend to chase the bottles that everyone's talking about, but there's plenty of great whiskey outside the spotlight. Next time you're looking to try something new, skip the long lines and secondary market prices—one of these bourbons might just become your new favorite.
Have your own favorite underrated bourbon? Tell us why you like it in the comments!

Hashtags

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

15 Risky Decisions That Will Haunt You When You're Older
15 Risky Decisions That Will Haunt You When You're Older

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

15 Risky Decisions That Will Haunt You When You're Older

Aging is a funny thing. It's like a time machine that whisks you forward and forces you to reckon with the choices you've made. Some decisions you can laugh about over wine, others may gnaw at you in the quiet of the night. Here are 15 risky decisions that might just come back to haunt you, the ones that demand introspection and perhaps a touch of regret. Education doesn't stop after formal schooling, yet many of us neglect ongoing learning in favor of more immediate pursuits. The world is ever-changing, and continuous learning could be the key to staying relevant and fulfilled. As you grow older, the opportunities missed for personal and professional development might start to weigh on you. The haunting realization is that knowledge could have opened doors you didn't even know existed. The regret is compounded by the awareness that it's never too late to learn, but now the climb seems steeper. Watching others thrive because they invested in their growth can serve as a constant reminder of what you didn't do. You might find yourself yearning for the insights and skills that could have been yours. And you'll wish you'd recognized the power of lifelong learning when it mattered. How often do we linger in toxic relationships because we're too afraid of the void they might leave behind? The idea of ripping off the Band-Aid seems daunting, so you stick around, hoping things will magically improve. But here's the harsh truth: allowing toxic people to sap your energy is a decision you'll kick yourself for later. Ask anyone who's survived it—they'll tell you that time spent on people who don't uplift you is time wasted. The years will pass, and what you'll remember isn't the comfort of the familiar, but the stagnation it brought. It's like being stuck in quicksand where every attempt to reach for better is stifled by their negativity. As the years roll by, you'll yearn for the courage to have cut ties sooner. And realize that peace was always just a decision away. There's something almost invincible about feeling young, like your body's a temple that you can graffiti all over without consequences. But the truth often hits you later—hard—when you realize those skipped dentist appointments and ignored aches are catching up. According to a study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association, untreated minor health issues in your 20s and 30s can evolve into major problems by the time you're 50. So those cavalier days of skipping check-ups might morph into a regretful reflection in the mirror, as you count the cost of negligence. The real kicker is that routine self-care often sounds unbearably mundane in your youthful years. Who wants to swap late-night adventures for early morning jogs or trade pizza for kale? The reality check comes later when you're left with a body that feels older than its years. And you'll find yourself shaking your head, longing for a chance to whisper some wisdom into your younger self's ear. The allure of climbing the career ladder is undeniable, and there's a certain prestige that comes with those late nights at the office. But here's a sobering thought: no one on their deathbed ever wishes they'd spent more time at work. Research from Harvard Business School highlights a staggering number of professionals experiencing significant regret over imbalanced work-life priorities. The hard truth is, while promotions and paychecks are enticing, they're a poor substitute for memories and meaningful connections. Years down the line, when you're flipping through old photo albums, it's the family gatherings and spontaneous road trips that'll tug at your heartstrings—not the spreadsheets or client meetings. The risk here is that you might wake up one day and realize you've built a career but not much of a life. What seemed like ambition in your youth might echo as regret in your later years, leaving you to wonder if the trade-offs were truly worth it. There's a certain thrill in living for today, in cashing in your paycheck for instant gratification. But fast forward a few decades, and you'll be cursing your past self for not stashing away those dollars. Retirement may seem like an eternity away when you're young, but the future has a sneaky way of arriving sooner than expected. And suddenly, those splurges on non-essentials start to haunt you. The regret deepens when you see peers enjoying the fruits of their financial wisdom. They've got peace of mind, while you're scrambling to catch up, feeling the pressure of financial insecurity. This decision, once so trivial, becomes a looming ghost. It serves as a reminder that sometimes the most freeing choice is the one that feels like a sacrifice at the time. The world is a vast playground, but how often do we put off exploring it, thinking we'll have time later? According to travel expert Rick Steves, there's an undeniable enrichment that comes from seeing the world, something you can't replicate in textbooks or documentaries. Yet, many of us hesitate, citing work, finances, or responsibilities as barriers. Years later, the regret sinks in as you realize that the opportunity was there, ripe for the taking, and you let it pass by. Sure, traveling can feel like an extravagant indulgence, especially when you're young and funds are tight. But those who've done it will tell you it's an investment in your soul, one that pays dividends in perspective and joy. The places you didn't see, the cultures you didn't experience become a haunting reminder of a world half-lived. And that's a ghost that whispers softly, "You should have come." Comfort zones have a sneaky way of morphing into ruts without you even realizing it. We crave stability and safety, but too much of it can lead to a stagnant life. According to psychologist Dr. Carol Dweck, stepping out of your comfort zone is crucial for growth and fulfillment. Yet, too often, the fear of change keeps us tethered to what's familiar, and we wake up one day feeling unfulfilled and trapped. The rut becomes a prison of our own making, and the longer we stay, the harder it is to leave. You'll look back and see the missed opportunities for growth and the dreams that quietly faded into the background. The risk of staying put can leave you with a life unlived, haunting you with the possibilities you didn't pursue. And the regret is not just about what you did, but what you never dared to do. There's a seductive pull to short-term pleasures that often blinds us to the long-term goals we set for ourselves. The thrill of an impulsive purchase or the fleeting high of a night out can feel euphoric. But when those moments accumulate into a pattern, they can derail the bigger aspirations you once held dear. Years later, as you sit amidst the clutter of temporary satisfactions, you might wonder where all that time and money went. The haunting realization is that each small indulgence took you a step further from the dreams you shelved. While not all pleasures are detrimental, consistently choosing the short-term can leave you with a life that feels scattered and unanchored. The echoes of those choices will remind you of the sacrifices you made and the goals you compromised. And you'll find yourself yearning for a second chance to balance desire with discipline. We often let the fear of others' opinions shape our decisions, silencing our true desires. This fear becomes a shadow that follows you, influencing every choice, no matter how minor. Over time, you might realize that many of your life's decisions weren't truly yours, but rather a reflection of what you thought others wanted. It's a realization that comes with a sting—a life lived for others is rarely fulfilling. As you age, the weight of this becomes heavier, and the regret more palpable. The sad irony is that people are usually too caught up in their own lives to scrutinize ours as closely as we imagine. By allowing fear to dictate your path, you end up with a life that feels like an ill-fitting costume. And the haunting thought will be how different things could have been if you'd only listened to yourself. Pride and fear of vulnerability often keep us from reaching out when we need help the most. We assume independence is synonymous with strength, but this mindset can be isolating. In hindsight, you might see the times when a little support could have made all the difference. The reality is that everyone needs a helping hand now and then, and refusing it only prolongs struggle. The haunting regret here is rooted in the unnecessary suffering, the challenges that became harder because they were faced alone. Years down the line, you'll see the missed opportunities for connection and growth that come from asking for help. The courage to be vulnerable might have led to richer relationships and easier resolutions. And you'll wish you'd embraced the strength in admitting you couldn't do it all alone. Love's a tricky business, and the fear of being alone can lead us to settle for relationships that don't truly fulfill us. You might think you're being practical, but settling is a compromise that chips away at your soul bit by bit. Fast forward a few decades, and the decision to stay in a lukewarm relationship will feel like a weight around your heart. It's a decision that haunts you in the quiet moments, a constant reminder of what could have been. The regret is often not just about the love that didn't feel right, but about the love you never opened yourself up to. The realization that you could have held out for something more authentic, more passionate, can be a bitter pill to swallow. Settling in love leaves you contemplating a life half-lived, yearning for what you believe love should have been. And you'll find yourself longing for a chance to do it over, to choose differently, to choose better. We all have that inner voice, that gut feeling that guides us, yet how often do we ignore it? It's easy to be swayed by logic, by what seems rational and sensible on the surface. But as time goes on, you might find that ignoring your instincts leads you away from paths that were meant for you. That haunting, nagging feeling in the pit of your stomach becomes a testament to the choices you didn't make. The regret lingers because deep down, your inner voice often knows best—even when logic doesn't agree. You'll look back and see the opportunities missed, the roads not taken, all because you silenced that whisper of intuition. It becomes an echo of lost potential and dreams deferred. And you'll wish you'd trusted yourself more when it mattered. Friendships often take a backseat when life gets busy, overshadowed by work, family, and responsibilities. Yet these relationships are the threads that weave the tapestry of a fulfilling life. In the end, it's the friends you've nurtured who will stand by you, who'll be the keepers of your shared stories and laughter. The regret comes when you realize you didn't invest enough in these connections. Years later, you might find yourself feeling isolated, missing the camaraderie and support you took for granted. Those friendships you let drift away can become ghosts that haunt you, reminders of the support system you could have had. The realization that you didn't prioritize those bonds only hits harder with age. And you'll wish you'd known the true value of those friendships when you had the chance to nurture them. Perfectionism is a seductive trap, promising success and acceptance, yet delivering stress and anxiety. In the pursuit of perfect, you often miss the beauty of progress and the joy of the journey. As the years pass, you might find yourself with a list of accomplishments that feel hollow, tainted by the constant pressure you placed on yourself. The haunting realization is that perfection is unattainable, and in chasing it, you overlooked the growth and learning along the way. The regret is not just about what you didn't achieve, but how you achieved what you did. Those moments lost to stress and self-doubt can add up, leaving you wondering why you weren't kinder to yourself. With age, you begin to see that progress, no matter how imperfect, is where the real achievement lies. And you'll wish you'd celebrated the small wins instead of fixating on flawlessness. Fear is a cunning beast that masquerades as wisdom, whispering caution when what you need is boldness. The irony is that failure isn't life's greatest tragedy—it's the missed opportunities that could've led to success. In your later years, you'll look back at the risks you didn't take and realize that the safety net you clung to was more of a cage. It's a bitter pill to swallow, knowing your potential was stifled by nothing more than your own doubt. There's a stark difference between calculated risks and reckless abandon, and oftentimes, we err on the side of excessive caution. This hesitation can rob you of the breakthroughs that come from stepping into the unknown. As the years tally up, so too will the what-ifs, each a testament to chances not taken. And you'll wish you'd been a little braver, a little more daring, when the stakes were lower.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store