‘A chronicle of disaster foretold': French Polynesia leader warns against deep-sea mining, urges ocean conservation
NICE (France), June 13 — French Polynesia pledged this week to create the world's largest marine protected area to safeguard its seas — and it hopes to encourage others to lift their game.
The archipelago in the far South Pacific Ocean, an overseas territory of France, is led by Moetai Brotherson, who believes oceans should be valued, not plundered.
President Brotherson spoke with AFP about deep-sea mining, ecological stewardship, and his dream of a day where environment summits are no longer needed.
Q: How big is this new protected area?
A: 'It covers our entire exclusive economic zone, approximately 5 million square kilometres. From north to south, that's equivalent to the distance between Stockholm and Sicily, and from east to west, it's Romania to Portugal.
'All seabed exploitation, trawling and seine fishing (use of a large circular weighted net) is prohibited in our waters. And within this area, there are just over 1 million square kilometres that are high protection zones.
Q: Are these zones totally off-limits?
A: 'Yes, absolutely. Even our longliners (which use baited hooks on a long line) will be prohibited in these high protection zones.'
Q: What motivated the decision?
A: 'We are doing it because there are other ways to exploit the ocean than plundering it, and we hope that our example will inspire other countries.
'We are not just a people of the ocean, we are the ocean. For us, it is unthinkable to destroy this space, this place that is part of our origins, our legends, our founding myths. We talk about marine protected areas, but here we call it rahui (leaving fallow), and it has existed for 3,000 years.
'There are 280,000 of us, and we are here to show the rest of the world that with a population the size of Montpellier, we can achieve great things.'
French Polynesia's President Moetai Brotherson poses during a photo session at his hotel on the sidelines of the third United Nations Ocean Conference (UNOC3), which gathers leaders, researchers and activists to discuss how to protect marine life in the French riviera city of Nice, on June 11, 2025.
Q: Do you think France should do more to protect its oceans?
A: 'I am not the President of the French Republic. But yes, in absolute terms, of course France should do more.
'Today — if we look at France's actions in relation to ocean protection — it mainly comes from overseas territories.'
Q: Deep-sea mining has been a hot topic at the UN Ocean Conference. What's your position?
A: 'It's a subject that worries me. Our closest neighbour, the Cook Islands, is planning to mine polymetallic nodules in its exclusive economic zone. The machines used are a kind of combine harvester that settle on the ocean floor and destroy everything in their path.
'Underwater pollution, like the Chernobyl cloud, will not stop at the border. The plume of dust that will be released will block out the light and prevent the development of phytoplankton, which is necessary to feed the entire food chain. It is a chronicle of a disaster foretold.'
Q: What needs to be done to prevent this disaster?
A: 'The message to the big countries is: don't come and lecture us, because you have been destroying the planet for centuries without caring about the environment. It's rather inappropriate to come and lecture us today.
'Some of us today see no other solutions for our economic development. The responsibility of the world's major countries is to help us, the small island countries, to develop other socio-economic models based on green tourism, blue tourism and renewable energies, which do not involve exploiting sub-oceanic minerals.
'We need adequate funding and development aid.'
In this file photo taken on December 8, 2022, in Vaasa, a plastic bottle floats below a layer of ice. — AFP pic
Q: Beyond the speeches, do you think the UN Ocean Conference achieved anything?
A: 'These gatherings can of course be criticised. But they are still necessary to meet decision-makers and people who have the financial means to participate in environmental preservation efforts.
'I dream of the day when it will be announced that there is no longer any need for climate or ocean summits.' — AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Free Malaysia Today
2 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
NZ diplomats say China downplayed nuclear-capable missile test
Beijing's missile launch in September was its first over international waters in more than 40 years. (Chinese People's Liberation Army/AFP pic) SYDNEY : China tried to mislead foreign governments in 2024 by playing down the importance of a nuclear-capable missile test over the Pacific Ocean, New Zealand diplomats privately warned in documents obtained by AFP. Beijing sent shivers through the South Pacific in September 2024, when its elite Rocket Force fired a dummy warhead into the high seas near French Polynesia. A tranche of classified government briefing notes obtained by AFP shows deep concern within the New Zealand government in the wake of the surprise launch, which China shrugged off as 'routine'. It was China's first long-range missile launch over international waters in more than 40 years, the papers confirmed, serving as a blunt reminder of Beijing's potent nuclear-strike capabilities. 'We are concerned that China is characterising this as a 'routine test',' senior diplomats wrote in a memo to New Zealand's foreign affairs minister. 'It is not routine: China has not conducted this type of long-range missile test in over 40 years. 'We do not want to see this test repeated.' China's military played down the test as a 'legitimate and routine arrangement for military training'. Behind the scenes, New Zealand diplomats privately decried China's 'mischaracterisation'. 'As this is the first time that China has undertaken such an action in the Pacific in several decades, it is a significant and concerning development,' they wrote in one of the briefing documents. AFP applied to access the heavily redacted documents – written between September and October last year – under New Zealand's Official Information Act. They were classified as 'Restricted', which protects government information with diplomatic or national security implications. Nuclear scars China has been seeking to cement its presence in the strategically important South Pacific. (AP pic) China has been seeking to cement its presence in the strategically important South Pacific, showering developing island nations with new hospitals, freshly paved roads, and gleaming sports stadiums. But rarely has it so obviously flexed its military might in the region, where the US, Australia and New Zealand have long been the security partners of choice. 'We have again asked China why it conducted the test at this time, and why it chose to terminate the missile test in the South Pacific,' New Zealand diplomats wrote. China's Rocket Force launched the intercontinental ballistic missile with little warning on Sept 25, 2024. Photos released by China showed a projectile streaking into the sky from a secret location atop a billowing plume of smoke. It appeared to be one of China's advanced Dong Feng-31 missiles, analysts said, a weapon capable of delivering a thermonuclear warhead. The long-range missile splashed into a patch of ocean long designated a nuclear-free zone under an international treaty. Pacific island nations remain deeply scarred by the nuclear tests that shook the region in the decades following World War II. 'This is the first time that we are aware of a test of a nuclear-capable missile terminating within the zone since its establishment in 1986,' the New Zealand diplomats wrote. Forceful reminder China alerted the US, the UK, France, Australia and New Zealand before the test. But there was only a vague indication of what it would do, according to a separate batch of Australian government documents obtained by AFP. 'Beijing advised us of a planned activity the evening prior to the launch, but specific details were not forthcoming,' Australian defence officials wrote in November last year. Pacific island nations, however, were not provided with advance notice of the launch, New Zealand diplomats noted. Following the launch, Japan publicly voiced 'serious concern', Australia said the test risked 'destabilising' the South Pacific, and Fiji urged 'respect for our region'. Pacific nation Kiribati, one of China's warmest friends in the region, said the South Pacific Ocean should not be a proving ground for jostling big powers. 'The high seas in the Pacific are not isolated pockets of oceans… we appeal to all countries involved in weapon testing to stop these acts to maintain world peace and stability,' read a government statement at the time. China foreign policy expert Nicholas Khoo said the intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM) test was particularly significant because it took place in the South Pacific. 'Since 1980, China's ICBM tests have taken place within Chinese territory,' he told AFP. 'The test is a reminder to regional states that China is a 'full spectrum' power that has economic and military power. It is a peer with the US.' Harvard University researcher Hui Zhang said it was a forceful reminder of China's nuclear strength. 'The test shows that the Rocket Force has an operational and credible nuclear force that can help ensure China's ability to maintain a strong nuclear deterrent,' he wrote last year for the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists. 'The rare public ICBM test seems to have been specifically aimed at dissuading Washington from using nuclear weapons in a potential conflict across the Taiwan Strait.' China's ministry of foreign affairs said that the 'facts are clear and no one has been misled'. 'The missile test is a routine part of annual military training, in compliance with international law and international norms,' it said in a statement.
Malay Mail
7 hours ago
- Malay Mail
France's Macron urges diplomacy, warns of ‘uncontrolled escalation' after US strikes on Iran
PARIS, June 23 — French President Emmanuel Macron on Sunday warned against an 'uncontrolled escalation' in the Middle East after the United States joined Israel's campaign against Tehran's atomic programme by bombing Iranian nuclear sites. 'No strictly military response can produce the desired effects,' Macron told a defence council meeting in Paris. 'The resumption of diplomatic and technical discussions is the only way to achieve the goal we all seek, which is to prevent Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons,' he added. The French leader however did not directly condemn the unprecedented US intervention. After a scheduled visit to Norway on Monday, Macron is on Tuesday due to go the Netherlands for a Nato summit which US President Donald Trump is also set to attend. In a joint statement with his German and British counterparts, Macron called on Iran 'not to take any further action that could destabilise the region' in response to the strikes. Earlier the French leader had urged Tehran to de-escalate and 'exercise the utmost restraint' after the strikes in a call with his Iranian counterpart Masoud Pezeshkian. He said he also told Iran to 'renounce nuclear weapons', warning of 'the risk of the worst for the entire region'. On Sunday, Macron also spoke with the leaders of Saudi Arabia, Oman, the United Arab Emirates and Qatar. — AFP
Malay Mail
2 days ago
- Malay Mail
How Juan Antonio Samaranch saved the Olympics — and nearly lost his legacy
PARIS, June 21 — Incoming and outgoing International Olympic Committee presidents Kirsty Coventry and Thomas Bach will salute each other in the handover ceremony on Monday but the person they will thank for the movement's continued existence is Juan Antonio Samaranch Senior. Samaranch Senior — whose son of the same name finished runner-up to Coventry in the IOC presidential election in March — did, like Coventry, serve in a controversial regime prior to being elected in 1980. While Coventry has been sports and arts minister in a Zimbabwean government whose election in 2023 was declared unfair and undemocratic by international observers, Samaranch served at a high level in the fascist Spanish regime of General Francisco Franco. His IOC presidency, which ran from 1980-2001, will for some be forever overshadowed by the 'votes for favours' scandal surrounding the 2002 Salt Lake City Winter Olympics. However, to other more measured voices he is the saviour of the Games who transformed it from a movement at risk of extinction into a vibrant and financially healthy behemoth. 'His legacy is that we have an Olympic Games to talk about,' former IOC marketing executive Terrence Burns told AFP. 'He saved it from financial and political ruin.' Samaranch Senior's earlier career exercised many people when he was IOC chief. After Franco's death and the restoration of the monarchy, Samaranch Senior went on to be ambassador to the Soviet Union. 'I recognised that my political career in Spain was over,' said Samaranch Senior, who always insisted he was not a fascist. It was in Moscow at the 1980 Games, overshadowed by a boycott because of the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, that he was elected president of the IOC. The IOC members' faith in him was more than repaid. 'Within the IOC I think the Samaranch legacy is fully understood: that he saved the Olympic Movement,' former IOC marketing chief Michael Payne told AFP. His success was developing 'the business model', which included a TV strategy and 'the creation of the TOP programme, the most successful (sports) marketing programme ever,' he added. Payne worked closely with him and said he was a different personality to his son in that he was 'more a listener' than Samaranch Junior, who is a 'great communicator.' 'He was very introverted, a great listener, didn't do a lot of talking, and a great strategic thinker,' said Payne. 'But because he wasn't at the forefront, communicating and explaining, he was often misunderstood. 'He only learned English as his third or fourth language when he was 60.' Participants of the Paris 2024 Olympics and Paralympics game walk in front of the cafeteria of the Olympic Village, in Saint-Denis, northern Paris, on July 22, 2024. — AFP pic 'I cannot regret' Payne said Samaranch's leadership shone through during the Salt Lake City scandal. Six members were to be expelled and Samaranch also oversaw a series of reforms to prevent a repeat of the situation. 'He was calm under unbelievable pressure and stress,' said the 66-year-old Irishman. 'Honestly, you went to the office every day and you didn't know if the organisation would survive... And that was for three months. 'It was brutal. And yet, Samaranch Senior displayed absolute calm, focus.' Nevertheless Samaranch, in a rare moment of letting the mask slip, revealed the effect of what Payne described as 'personal attacks'. 'Retiring myself after the Barcelona Games (in 1992), I could have been a hero, no?' he told the Los Angeles Times in 2000. 'I cannot regret. I have to write my history again.' Payne said despite his diplomatic background Samaranch could play hardball. One incident occurred when Greece refused to allow the Olympic torch to be lit ahead of the 1984 Games in Los Angeles, as they objected to the commercialisation of the event. 'Samaranch sent one of his relatives to Olympia to privately film the lighting of the flame, put it in a miner's lamp, and brought it back to Lausanne,' said Payne. 'Then Samaranch called the Greeks and said, 'just for you to understand, I now have the Olympic flame on my desk. ''Either you will agree to let the Americans come and properly light it or there will never be another torch lighting in Olympia. Because it will be lit at the Olympic Museum in Lausanne.' 'So he wasn't shy of being very tough.' — AFP
