Vaughan says first-innings injury substitutes should be allowed to bat and bowl
NOTTINGHAM, England, May 23 (Reuters) - Former England captain Michael Vaughan said substitutes who replace injured players in the first innings of a test match should be able to bat and bowl for the remainder of the contest instead of being restricted to fielding duties.
Under the current laws of the game, injured players can be replaced during a match but the substitute is only allowed to field, with the lone exception being a concussion substitute.
The restriction leaves teams shorthanded with only 10 eligible batters and puts added strain on a bowling corps if the injury was to a bowler.
Zimbabwe's frontline seamer Richard Ngarava could bowl only nine overs before being helped off the field due to a back injury on the opening day of their one-off test against England on Thursday.
England's top three batters then feasted on Zimbabwe's pedestrian attack, with each of them smashing a hundred as the hosts racked up 498-3.
"Injury replacements should be permitted in test cricket in the first innings of the game," Vaughan told BBC Sport.
"If there's a genuine injury in the first innings, it affects the game and the entertainment, which fans pay money to watch. The first innings is a good cut-off to make it fair."
Former Zimbabwe seamer Henry Olonga said substitutes should be allowed to bat or bowl regardless of when they enter a match.
"I'm open to the idea of substitutes, perhaps with a limited number, but not necessarily like-for-like and not only restricted to injuries," the 48-year-old said.
"If you want to grow the game globally, then make it more like other sports where subs are allowed.
"Think of football, tactically if a game is going in a certain way, substitutes can be used to tweak the direction."
The Marylebone Cricket Club (MCC), the custodian of cricket's laws, did not immediately respond to a Reuters request for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
15 minutes ago
- BBC News
Zaib leads Northants' recovery against Middlesex
Rothesay County Championship Division Two, County Ground, Northampton (day two)Middlesex 413: Cracknell 112, Du Plooy 66, Hollman 51; Guthrie 7-94Northamptonshire 308-5: Zaib 83*, Procter 62, McManus 55*; Gohar 4-83Northants (5 pts) trail Middlesex (5 pts) by 105 runsMatch scorecard Saif Zaib resumed his rich vein of County Championship form by passing 50 for the fourth time in as many red-ball innings to spearhead Northamptonshire's recovery against Middlesex at Wantage Luke Procter's knock of 62, the home side were under pressure at 132-4 when Zaib arrived at the crease, but the left-hander struck an unbeaten 83 to guide them to 308-5 at Zafar Gohar prised out four of Northamptonshire's top five before Zaib and Lewis McManus, who finished 55 not out, guided their side towards a position of parity with an unbroken partnership of had earlier posted 413, with overnight centurion Joe Cracknell dismissed for 112 as left-arm seamer Liam Guthrie registered career-best figures of 7-94. Beginning the day just three runs short of a fourth batting bonus point, Middlesex quickly secured that when Toby Roland-Jones hooked Procter to the boundary – and a fifth even looked within the realm of hopes were dashed when Calvin Harrison pouched an outstanding one-handed catch at point, leaping to his right to cut off Cracknell's robust drive and Lloyd Pope's maiden Championship wicket in the next over castled Tom Helm to end the visitors' started well in reply, with Procter dispatching both Roland-Jones and Helm to the fence as he and Ricardo Vasconcelos – who looked scratchy at the outset – built an opening stand of visitors tried a range of tactics without success, including the deployment of a heavily leg-side field for Ryan Higgins that included four men clustered around midwicket at one was Gohar who eventually stifled Northamptonshire's progress, switching ends prior to lunch and immediately tempting Vasconcelos to sweep him straight into the hands of deep square to three in the batting order, Harrison looked lively as he thumped Helm over midwicket for six, but Middlesex's spinners soon established control and captured three further wickets during the was caught behind off an inside edge playing back to Gohar, while Luke Hollman struck with his fourth delivery, deceiving James Sales with flight and hitting him on the toe to secure a leg before who completed his fifth half-century of the campaign, proved harder to dislodge but the captain was neatly snapped up at short leg off Gohar to leave Northamptonshire in some a tendency to play the spinners late, Tim Robinson began their fightback in tandem with Zaib, though a dreadful mix-up between the pair should have seen the New Zealander run out but for Leus du Plooy's fumble in the signed on a short-term deal at Wantage Road, looked on course to mark his debut with a half-century, advancing to 43 before he was harshly given out leg before attempting to sweep Zaib maintained his side's momentum, striking the ball cleanly on both sides of the wicket and passing 5,000 runs across all formats for Northamptonshire en route to his half-century from 87 weighed in with a string of attacking strokes, cutting Gohar for two to post his fourth 50 of the season and take the partnership beyond three figures shortly before the close. ECB Reporters' Network supported by Rothesay.
The Independent
15 minutes ago
- The Independent
Josh Tongue mops up India's tail again as England fight back in first Test
Josh Tongue lived up to his new nickname by blowing away India's tail for the second time in three days and reviving England's hopes of an unlikely win in the first Test at Headingley. India were streets ahead for most of the fourth day, KL Rahul's 137 and Rishabh Pant's 118 taking their team to a remarkable five centuries in the match, but England came back fighting late on. Tongue conjured a triple-wicket maiden as India lost their last six batters for just 31 to finish 364 all out, reprising his first-innings role as tail-end destroyer. Nottinghamshire team-mate Ben Duckett dubbed him 'the mop' after he forced a similar collapse on day two and he was at it again here, wiping out Shardul Thakur, Mohammed Siraj and Jasprit Bumrah in the space of four balls. That left England needing 371 for a remarkable win – just seven short of the record chase they managed against the same opposition at Edgbaston in 2022. Zak Crawley and Duckett scored 21 of those in six overs before the close, leaving 350 still to make on what could be a blockbuster final day. England drew first blood just seven balls into the day's play, Brydon Carse cutting down Shubman Gill's stumps via a big inside edge. With a slim overnight lead of 96 and one of their eight remaining wickets snapped up quickly, the heat was on the batting side. But in Rahul and Pant, England encountered two men unwilling to go quietly. Rahul was a study in diligence, with Pant a more unpredictable counterpart. He hacked his second ball a few inches over slip, came down the track to Chris Woakes and knelt to slog-sweep an 87mph delivery from Carse. Pant even tried a tumbling ramp off the rapid Carse and survived the folly. That was the nudge he needed to put the theatrics to one side. India ended the morning with just 63 runs on their ledger. Rahul, who made one error on 58 and was shelled by Harry Brook at gully, was responsible for just 25 of them from 82 balls. But they cashed in impressively after lunch, dialling up the intensity to heap 145 runs in the middle session. Pant rode his luck at times, nicking Tongue through an unoccupied first slip on 31. When England filled that gap, he edged through the gap at second. But there was some wonderful ball-striking too. He lined up Tongue for some heavy treatment, launched Bashir for two sixes in three balls and punched the loosener of a new Carse spell hard through midwicket. Such was Pant's whirlwind of activity, it took the confirmation of Rahul's 202-ball hundred to briefly take a share of the spotlight. Despite tip-toeing carefully through the 90s, Pant was quicker to his hundred by 72 deliveries and became just the second wicketkeeper after former England coach Andy Flower to score twin centuries in the same Test. England enjoyed a much-needed reprieve when Pant picked out Zak Crawley at long-on eyeing another big blow off Bashir. The relief was palpable after a fourth-wicket stand of 195 that ate up 47 dispiriting overs. It took another 13 to to prise out the rock solid Rahul, whose occupation of the crease had become a visible drain on English morale. It was Carse who found a chink in the armour, pounding the pitch hard enough to conjure a hint of extra bounce to undo Rahul's impeccable defence. When Woakes had Karun Nair caught and bowled it was over to Tongue to work some magic with the second new ball. He made light work of Thakur, who sprayed straight to slip, roughed up Siraj as the next ball thumped his glove and produced a testing hat-trick ball that Bumrah gamely defended. That was the extent of his resistance, though, with the next one flattening middle stump. Having lost seven for 41 on Saturday, India's lower order had flopped again from 333 for four to 364 all out. The tone of the day had shifted quickly but there was still time for another late twist. With six overs left – and three from the fearsome right arm of Bumrah – it was a nervy time for Crawley and Duckett. But they held up their part of the bargain, getting the pursuit safely under way without offering a chance.
The Sun
22 minutes ago
- The Sun
Premier League refereeing errors fall to all-time LOW as worst-hit team revealed – and it's not Arsenal
REFEREEING errors fell to an all-time low in the Premier League last season - despite a series of controversies. According to the Prem 's 'Key Match Incident Panel' - made up of former players, managers and refs - there were just 18 VAR errors over the 380 matches of the 2024-25 campaign. 6 6 6 That was a 42 per cent drop on the 31 errors in 2023-24 and further down on the 35 mistakes assessed in the previous campaign. The panel looks at every major decision on goals, penalties and red cards, determining if the call by the onfield officials or the VAR was correct or flawed. SunSport understands the reduction was largely down to fewer missed VAR interventions on subjective decisions, although there were occasions in which Stockley Park wrongly recommended a change of call. Missed interventions included the red cards for Manchester United skipper Bruno Fernandes against Spurs, Arsenal left-back Myles Lewis-Skelly's dismissal at Wolves and the last minute penalty winner for West Ham that spelled the end for Old Trafford boss Erik ten Hag. The KMI ruled that the VAR should have stepped in to recommend red cards for Brighton's Joao Pedro against Brentford and Everton 's James Tarkowski in the final Goodison Merseyside derby. Brentford were the biggest sufferers, with three mistakes which should have been changed in their favour, with Everton the beneficiaries of three errors. There were a number of occasions in which the KMI Panel agreed that the on-field decision was wrong but did not meet the threshold for a VAR intervention. The numbers will doubtless be met with disbelief from Arsenal fans who remain insistent that PGMOL have an agenda against them. JOIN SUN VEGAS: GET £50 BONUS But the costly second yellow cards for Declan Rice and Leandro Trossard against Brighton and Manchester City respectively did not come under the scrutiny of the Panel. Changes to time-keeping last season saw an average of nine minutes and 45 seconds of stoppage time per game, down 108 seconds from the previous season. The campaign saw 105 added time goals across the 380 matches, 40 fewer than in 2023-24. But VAR checks were significantly speeded up, with the average delay per match due to VAR down to 39 seconds from 64 seconds in the previous season. 6 6 6
