Rihanna's ex-bodyguard slams ‘ridiculous' justice system after appeal victory
Images of chalk depictions revealed
Images of the symbols, three large depictions of the letters 'xe' can be published by this newspaper for the first time today.
Last month, Mr. Keating successfully had his conviction for criminal damage, arising from the incident on Mellows Road on May 9th, 2022, overturned in the District Court Appeals Court.
'The whole thing was ridiculous,' Mr. Keating, who survived a shooting attempt on his life last year, told the Sunday World.
'I drew the symbols to protest the treatment of juveniles.
'These were Nordic symbols and for that, for drawing chalk symbols on the grounds, I was arrested, charged and convicted of criminal damage
'At one stage, the piece of chalk was handed in to the judge as an exhibit.
'But the actual CCTV of the incident had disappeared and couldn't be found.'
Asked why he had drawn the symbols, Mr. Keating said it was to protest the alleged ill treatment of minors.
'There's been a few cases involving minors and the gardai and I mentioned these in court,' he said.
'It was also claimed I had said the symbols were to remove evil spirits.
'But the garda's own statement shows I never said any such thing.' Read more
A copy of Gda Roger's statement seen by the Sunday World mentions only that when he questioned Mr. Keating, the latter explained that 'these symbols were for Gardai protection and he stated: 'I will go to any lengths to protect children.'
He said after he arrested Mr. Keating under section 12 of the Criminal Damage Act, Mr. Keating did not make any reply after caution.
Mr. Keating told the Sunday World that said he had explained the meaning of the symbols and had actually taken a cup of water from the garda station with him on his release to wash them away.
However, it had rained while he was in the station and they were mostly gone by the time he was released.
Geoff Keating, pictured with Rihanna
Mr. Keating was convicted criminal damage in Blanchardstown District Court on May 27th, 2022 where he was given a fine of €200.
Appearing on Mr. Keating's behalf at the District Court Appeals Court last week, barrister Paddy Flynn successfully argued that the appeal was based on issues of proportionality.
He said Mr. Keating should not have received a conviction in the first place.
Constitutional rights as well as ECHR (European Court of Human Rights) rights protect the rights to protest and freely express oneself and it appeared on any proportionality assessment of the facts that what occurred was not such to be treated as criminal.
He said Mr Keating had given strong evidence that he had acted in the most peaceful and non-violent manner in achieving his act of protest.
Judge Catherine White said she agreed with the defence in this case that the conviction was disproportionate and allowed Mr Keating's appeal against his conviction.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
3 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Heartbreaking tributes pour for ‘always chatty' biker, 53, killed in horror motorcycle crash as gardai probe timeline
TRIBUTES are being paid to a "lovely" motorcyclist who was killed in a crash in Co Cork over the weekend. Patrick Joseph Crotty Junior died in a The tragic biker was discovered unresponsive on Sunday morning and was sadly pronounced deceased by emergency services at the scene. The 53-year-old from Smith's Road in Charleville has been remembered as the "beloved son" of Pat and Kathleen, "dear brother" of Kieran, Eugene, Caroline, Tomás and the late baby Barbara. Advertisement And devastated mourners have told how Pat was a "lovely man" who was "always chatty". One simply said: "Such a nice young man may he RIP." READ MORE IRISH NEWS A second local said: "Our sympathy to Pat and Kathleen and family at this sad time. Pat was a lovely man and was always chatty when I met him. May he rest in peace". Another wrote: "Lord rest you Pat. A gentleman you were". Advertisement A work colleague wrote: "Our thoughts and prayers are with Pat's family and friends at this very sad time with his sudden passing. "Pat was a very popular work colleague with many friends who will miss him''. MOST READ ON THE IRISH SUN In a statement, Mr Crotty's family said they would "like to thank all of the First Responders, Garda Siochana, Charleville Fire service and the Paramedics who attended for their professionalism and kindness". Gardai and RSA measures aimed at driving crash deaths on Irish roads His funeral arrangements will be announced tomorrow afternoon. Advertisement The family has asked that the house remains private at this time. Gardai are appealing for witnesses from the area to come forward, and have asked road users with dash-cam footage from between 1pm and 6pm on Saturday to make it available to investigating officers. A Garda spokesperson said: "Anyone with any information is asked to contact Mallow Garda Station on 022 31450, the Garda Confidential Line on 1800 666 111, or any Garda Station." To date there have been 79 fatalities on Irish roads which is one less than the same period last year. Fourteen of these fatalities have been on motorcycles. Advertisement TRACTOR TRAGEDY Separately, tributes have poured in for Brendan Roche, aged in his 60s, who was killed after being struck by a tractor in Sixmilebridge, Co last Saturday. The incident occurred on the L7006 at Kilmurry around 10.15am on June 21. Devastated mourners have left their condolences with the heartbroken One person said: "As a long-time colleague, I will always remember his kindness, dedication, and the positive spirit." Another mourner added: "I have very fond memories of playing golf with Brendan and meeting him out for a stroll on a fine summers evening in Rossroe. Advertisement "Brendan always greeted you with a smile and you felt the better for meeting him." 1 Patrick Joseph Crotty Jnr was sadly pronounced dead at the scene of the incident Credit:
Irish Daily Mirror
4 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Digging machinery brought into Annie McCarrick search site
Demolition experts have brought new digging machinery into the search for Annie McCarrick this morning. A demolition company, which is assisting the Garda search on a West Dublin property, were seen driving the small vehicle into the grounds earlier today. It is understood Gardai have excavated a large hole under an extension of the property - between the front and back garden - where they are searching for any evidence of Ms McCarrick, who vanished from Sandymount in March 1993. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week A uniformed Garda kept watch as workers brought the machinery onto the site this morning - as the search of the property now enters its third week. Sources say Gardai are taking their time in a methodical and thorough search of what used to be a garden but now part of the property. The current occupants of the home have no connection to the investigation and have been re housed for the duration of this ongoing search. It comes as we today revealed our extensive interview with one of the suspects in the case - who was recently interviewed by Gardai in another country. The man's brother was arrested on suspicion of the murder of Annie McCarrick earlier this month - and has since been released without charge. In our exclusive interview the man's brother said he believed he too had been treated as a suspect - and insisted that they are both innocent. 'My brother and I have nothing to do with Annie's disappearance,' he told us. He insisted to us that he has a 'watertight alibi' regarding himself - and that his brother also has nothing to do with Annie's disappearance. 'No (I was not surprised gardai came to interview me), because I've been involved in this from day one,' the man told us. "It was I that reported her missing. I was the first person who made the statement in respect of her disappearance in order that the guards might not spend time worrying or spend time investigating me. 'I said this is my alibi, this is who I was with and it was airtight - watertight. Every other tight. So I would have been one of the first to be ruled out of the investigation and I would have imagined that was the same as my brother.' Speaking to us as gardai continue to search a house in West Dublin, the man said he did not see his brother often -during the time that Annie disappeared. 'God no I wasn't seeing him on a regular basis then. Sorry I beg your pardon, that doesn't mean that I wouldn't have seen him on a regular basis, but it would not be - I could go months without seeing him. His life and my life did not cross over,' he said. He then went on to deny that anything he recently told gardai gave them anything new that led to the arrest of his brother - and the massive invasive search in West Dublin. "The police are feeding you lies. The police are feeding twists. They did indeed interview me but there was nothing about my interview with them that gave them fresh evidence to go after my brother,' he said. "Bear in mind he's been a suspect for 32 years - which is fine. Why didn't he do anything in the past 32 years guard? 32 years. They can't pin anything on him. There is nothing to pin. 'They looked at some rubbish. OK that's fine, I don't have a problem with that but they looked and they looked and they looked and they couldn't come up with anything and then a new push on to make cold cases into murder cases. 'So there's a new push and all the boys want a result and by God will they get a result no matter what they do. It doesn't matter whether they get the guilty person. That's not in their brief. They want a result,' he said. Asked about the search of the home in West Dublin, the man said gardai were wasting their time and the taxpayers money too. Well it's outlandish to believe such a thing. I can't figure out how they could have found justification for spending the guts of E100,000 of the States money on such a fool's errand,' he said. 'It was a surprise to me and I just thought, my God , they're wasting their time. We've nothing to do with, my brother and I have nothing to do with Annie's disappearance.' He went on to speak about his belief that he was being treated as a suspect in this case - and insisted there was 'nothing erroneous" about either of his statements to gardai 32 years ago and in recent months. 'Do you not think I'm a suspect? Did the cops not state to you that I'm a suspect as well?' he said. 'Yeah they didn't arrest me, yeah that's fine. I'm not in Ireland at the moment. It's fine they can leave me for as long as they want,' he added. He also claimed that gardai have 'nothing' on his brother - who declined to speak to us when contacted on Friday. 'Bearing in mind they did arrest him for 24 hours and they did release him without charge. They have nothing,' he said. 'There's nothing in this case. It's just totally baseless. Look at it now what have they done with their helicopters and their diggers. What have they got? Nada. Zilch. 'I know nothing about Annie's disappearance and I know nothing about her murder. Nobody can (say I do) because I'm not. Nor are you, nor is the pope in Rome, nor is President O'Higgins,' he said. 'They wasted their time,' he added, telling us that 'I've been on this case for 32 years in my head.' Last week the man's brother, who was arrested in this case, hung up on this paper when contacted by phone - after we identified ourselves when he asked 'who's this?' It comes as we have also learned how tragic Annie, from Long Island in New York, had told pals 'I've made a terrible mistake' shortly before she vanished. Sources say a guilt ridden Annie wanted to confess to the girlfriend of the suspect that she had had a romantic encounter with him. We've also learned that pals have claimed the suspect was at the time known to be 'angered' that Annie had returned to Ireland from the United States - after deciding to permanently move here in January 1993. 'He was upset that she had decided to come back. He was known to be very unhappy about it,' a source said. This week the suspect also did not respond to a text from us asking if he denied involvement in the disappearance of Ms McCarrick - who he is believed to have had a romantic entanglement with shortly before she vanished in March 1993. The now wealthy man, who was arrested on suspicion of murder and released without charge last week, has been laying low ever since - as a massive garda search takes place on a Clondalkin home once connected to him some 32 years ago. As revealed by us last week, the suspect is a wealthy man who had been renting out a plush country house as a holiday home - charging members of the public close to €400 a night. We called to that address and another connected to the man this week - but no one answered the door.
Irish Examiner
4 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Man charged with vandalising Taoiseach's office in Cork released on bail
A 34-year-old man gave an undertaking to stay away from the constituency office of An Taoiseach Micheál Martin in Cork after he was arrested and charged with causing criminal damage by daubing it with slogans. Sergeant Chris Cahil arrested Thomas Heising of Frankfield Terrace, Summerhill South, Cork, on the night Saturday, June 21, and charged him on the following day with causing criminal damage. On Monday the defendant was brought before Judge Mary Dorgan at Cork District Court. There was no objection to bail being granted to the accused. Judge Dorgan adjourned the case until July 28, on the application of Sergeant Aisling Murphy, to allow time for directions from the Director of Public Prosecutions. Bail Bail conditions require him to sign on twice weekly at Anglesea Street garda station between the hours of 9am and 9pm, reside at the Summerhill South address and stay away from the environs of the constituency office of An Taoiseach, Micheál Martin at 137 Evergreen Road, Turner's Cross, Cork. He is also required to have no contact, direct or indirect, including on social medial platforms, with An Taoiseach, Micheál Martin TD, or any staff members of the constituency office and engage in no commentary, including on social media platforms, in respect of matters before the court. These were the conditions required by the prosecution. Shane Collins-Daly, solicitor, said the accused man agreed to all of these conditions. Charge The charge states that: 'On May 27 at 137 Evergreen Road, Turner's Cross, Cork, he did without lawful excuse damage property, to wit, the walls, door and windowsill of 137 Evergreen Road, intending to damage such property or being reckless as to whether such property would be damaged, contrary to Section 2(1) of the Criminal Damage Act, 1991.' It was previously reported that the office was vandalised with the words related to Israel and Palestine including the words, 'Zionist pawn', written on a window, as well as red paint daubed on the walls.
