Op Sindoor mix: Surprise, optics, audacity & some patience
The first, of course is, how does one secure surprise when the other side has been in a most heightened state of alert for 14 days, fully mobilised, assets airborne, missiles locked and loaded.
Many analytical takeaways and lessons will emerge from Operation Sindoor in the course of time. Who knows, if there are more episodes left in this story, and what the next might be.
The second, the optics, packaging and headline-management for India's riskiest moment in a generation.
And third, the audacity it needed to take risks of this magnitude, to game the escalation ladder and tolerance/acceptance levels.
The most remarkable is the surprise. With Uri and Pulwama, the Modi government had set a template. Everybody in Pakistan—and indeed in India—knew the strikes were not a matter of whether, but when. There were many who said these retaliations must take place within 24 hours, if not immediately after the killings. Or the Overton Window keeps shrinking. Why wait out for a full 14 days then?
You can be sure that the armed forces would've war-gamed this response. There has been an inevitability to major terror attacks in India since 13 December, 2001 (Parliament attack). There is one always around the corner. The forces did not need these 14 days to make fresh plans, or to acquire a new weapons system. Why the long wait then?
Conjecture is that this was needed to take away that predictability. The other side also saw the Overton Window shrinking and that contributed to that window of a few seconds, no more than 30 seconds of surprise becoming available. You can be sure that the Pakistanis knew when the IAF aircraft took off, which type these were and what their likely targets were. You can also be sure that the PAF flew their best-equipped aircraft parallel to these on their side.
The question was, how would they determine that IAF wanted to fire, and when to bounce them. It was in that situation, when fully visible to the other side, your general intention pre-announced, that those seconds of surprise needed to be found. Just enough to line up the target, shoot, and start the journey home. The fact is, the weapons were launched right under the eye of the PAF.
Also Read: Operation Sindoor strikes aren't the 'end'. It's the first salvo of a long-drawn-out battle
The Modi government utilised these 14 days to build an impression that there was no hurry, that it might even follow the advice of many of its social media supporters to strangle Pakistan with a long rope, blocking them at IMF, reopening FATF and keep squeezing them on the Indus rivers. We can now see that even the 'action' on the waters was part of this grand deception. That India would prefer the safer and slower approach of starving Pakistani farmers of water rather than risk an armed conflict.
The PM had big meetings on a daily basis, the Cabinet Committees, including CCS. There was one with the service chiefs, NSA and Raksha Mantri, and then with individual chiefs, NSA and defence secretary. All on camera. One evening, the government let the word drop that a big announcement was coming. It was the caste census. An impression was created that the government was letting public anger dissipate. The India-UK FTA was announced and celebrated, Modi went to the ABP News summit and delivered his usual Viksit Bharat speech with just a mention of the Indus waters. That again was a distraction, we can now see.
For the next day, a large air power exercise was scheduled in the Rajasthan sector. A couple of other exercises had been held already, so this also seemed like buying time. For the day after this, nationwide civil defence drills were called. Again, as if to drag things along. Even on the night/early hours of 6/7 May as fighters took off, Pakistanis must have tracked them in parallel. It is probably the repetitiveness of such activities with no outcome that created those few seconds of surprise. Whatever the Pakistani claims, those weapons hit their targets.
The optics and messaging, with the codename addressed to Indian women who were made to watch the men in their family killed by terrorists in Pahalgam, two women officers underlining the jointmanship of our forces and multiple diversities of our people. The briefing was measured, minus the grandstanding or jingoism. Please note also how the social media handles on the BJP's Right 'rectified' their position on Himanshi Narwal and her secular liberalism. There were words of regret and even advice to the comrades not to fall into the divisive trap. In the briefing today, Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri said the objective of the massacre was to trigger communal riots across India.
The third, the audacity. This was a risky move and at the very least, entailed possible casualties. After Pulwama the PAF knew for sure there would be an attack. The risk was failure, and finally, of an uncontrollable escalation particularly if the bombing succeeded. This is by far the riskiest action by Modi in more than a decade. Especially now with many ongoing wars, distractions, Russia war-weary. The Trump administration makes it more uncertain.
To sum up, while all of this is so far, so good and the ball is now in Pakistan's court. How they want to play, what they can do with it, and how prepared we are to counter them, will script the next episode of this story.
Also Read: Away from LoC, General Munir is losing a far more fateful war within Pakistan
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
11 minutes ago
- India Today
Won't get Nobel for halting India-Pak war: Trump at it again after PM fact-check
US President Donald Trump rued that he won't get a Nobel Peace Prize for "stopping" the war between India and Pakistan, repeating the claim despite being fact-checked by Prime Minister Narendra Modi over the issue days ago. Trump's rant on Truth Social came as Pakistan formally nominated him for the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize."I won't get a Nobel Peace Prize for stopping the War between India and Pakistan... I won't get a Nobel Peace Prize, no matter what I do," Trump said while listing a series of key diplomatic peace outcomes that he claimed to have brokered. advertisementThe US President stuck to his version of events days after PM Modi set the record straight by telling him that at no point during the hostilities with Pakistan last month, was trade or mediation on the issue discussed with the US administration. India has made it clear on several occassions that the ceasefire was directly negotiated between the two nations upon Pakistan's insistence. It came as India struck vital military sites and airbases inside Pakistan as part of its Operation Sindoor.'WON'T GET NOBEL PRIZE NO MATTER WHAT I DO'The eccentric US President began his lengthy post by announcing that he and Secretary of State Marco Rubio had secured a "wonderful" treaty between Rwanda and Congo that would halt the war characterised by "violent bloodshed and death"."Representatives from Rwanda and the Congo will be in Washington on Monday to sign documents. This is a Great Day for Africa and, quite frankly, a Great Day for the World!" Trump by the US and Qatar, Rwanda and Congo agreed to a truce to end decades of conflict that killed thousands of people in the region and displaced hundreds of thousands of InMust Watch
NDTV
22 minutes ago
- NDTV
On International Yoga Day, Rajnath Singh Shares "Op Sindoor" Message
Udhampur: Defence Minister Rajnath Singh led the 11th International Yoga Day celebrations in Udhampur of Jammu and Kashmir. Mr Singh met the army personnel here in Udhampur, praised their efforts in Operation Sindoor. "Your bravery is widely admired across the nation. I salute the valour and courage of the Indian Army," Rajnath Singh said during his address. He gave a clear message that Operation Sindoor was not just a reaction, and it is not over yet. "The recent terrorist attack in Pahalgam was not merely an isolated incident from across the border, but a direct attempt to target India's social and communal harmony. We not only foiled their nefarious plans but also delivered such a powerful response that Pakistan was forced to kneel down, leading us to announce a temporary halt to Operation Sindoor. As we have stated earlier, Operation Sindoor is not yet over," said the Union minister. He added, "This operation was not just a reaction to the Pahalgam terror attack. Through Operation Sindoor, we have sent a clear message to Pakistan that sponsoring terrorism against India will have increasingly severe consequences. Operation Sindoor is the natural progression of the 2016 Surgical Strike and the 2019 Air Strike." "With this operation, we have conveyed to Pakistan that its long-standing campaign of inflicting wounds on India through terrorism will no longer succeed. Any terror attack on Indian soil will now come at a very high cost to Pakistan. India is fully prepared to take every necessary step in its fight against terrorism," he said. "Pakistan aims to weaken India from within. But it must never forget that for India's unity and integrity, Major Somnath Sharma sacrificed his life, and so did brave soldiers like Brigadier Usman, who gave the ultimate sacrifice for the nation. Today, I am in Udhampur, just a few hours from Naushera--the very place where Brigadier Usman laid down his life for Bharat Mata," said Mr Singh. Expressing the importance of Yoga in our lives, the minister said, "As our nation observes International Yoga Day, it is important to reflect on the true meaning of Yoga. Yoga means union. Uniting every section of society with India's culture and spirit is the essence of yoga. If even one section of society is left behind in this effort, the circle of India's unity and security will break. Therefore, today, let us practice not just physical yoga, but strive for unity in thought and society as well. This must be done with patience and deep resolve." "Today, the entire country is observing Yoga Day with enthusiasm--and not just India, but the whole world is embracing our cultural legacy. Yoga, an ancient tradition over a thousand years old, was once practised only by sages. Today, people across the globe are performing yoga. This is a reflection of India's growing global influence," he added. He further added, "In today's world, where stress, anxiety, and unrest are widespread, yoga has emerged as a powerful solution. Yoga is not merely about sitting quietly with eyes closed--it's about mindfulness and inner control." The theme of this years yoga Day celebrations is "Yoga for one Earth, one health," aligning it with sustainability and global well being. Speaking about the theme of this year's Yoga day celebrations, the Defence Minister said, "Every year, we celebrate Yoga Day with a unique theme. This year's theme, "One Earth, One Health", reflects India's belief in Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam--that the whole world is one family." The Minister arrived in Udhampur on June 20 and took part in cultural celebrations and Bada khana with army personnel.
NDTV
22 minutes ago
- NDTV
"Won't Get Nobel Prize For Stopping India-Pak War": Trump Claims Credit Again
US President Donald Trump on Friday reiterated his claim of brokering peace between India and Pakistan and lamented that he won't be honoured with a Nobel Peace prize for "stopping" a possible war between the two countries last month. India, including Prime Minister Narendra Modi at a recent meeting, has repeatedly asserted that a ceasefire between New Delhi and Washington was a result of direct military talks and Washington was never roped in for mediation. "I won't get a Nobel Prize for stopping the war between India and Pakistan. I won't get a Nobel Prize for stopping the war between Serbia and Kosovo, I won't get a Nobel Peace Prize for keeping peace between Egypt and Ethiopia, and I won't get a Nobel Peace Prize for doing the Abraham Accords in the Middle East...," Mr Trump posted on his social media platform, Truth Social. "No, I won't get a Nobel Peace Prize no matter what I do, including Russia/Ukraine, and Israel/Iran, whatever those outcomes may be, but the people know, and that's all that matters to me!" he added. The US President made the remarks as he took credit for a peace deal negotiated in Washington between the Democratic Republic of Congo and Rwanda. "This is a Great Day for Africa and quite Frankly, a Great Day for the World. I won't get a Nobel Peace Prize for this..," he said. India has continuously denied the US' role in curbing tensions between New Delhi and Islamabad, which were triggered by Operation Sindoor that was launched in response to the Pahalgam terror attack on April 22. New Delhi has, on several occasions, emphasised that neither Washington nor any third party had a role in its decision to cease military hostilities with Islamabad. India has maintained that the Pakistani Director General of Military Operations sought to speak to his Indian counterpart on May 10 after India struck several airbases in the country, including the important Nur Khan airbase, under Operation Sindoor. India and Pakistan reached an understanding on May 10 to end the conflict after four days of intense cross-border drone and missile strikes. On Wednesday, Mr Modi held a 35-minute telephonic conversation with Mr Trump, mainly on the operation, and made it clear that at no time were issues such as the India-US trade deal or mediation by the US to broker peace between India and Pakistan were discussed. The US President, however, continued to claim credit for the ceasefire. "Well, I stopped the war between Pakistan - I love Pakistan - I think Modi is a fantastic man, I spoke to him last night. We are going to make a trade deal with Modi of India... And I stopped the war between Pakistan and India. This man (possibly referring to Asim Munir) was extremely influential in stopping it from the Pakistani side, Modi from the India side, and others. And they were going at it, they are both nuclear countries. I got it stopped," he said earlier this week. Complaining that the press had failed to take note of this, he said: "I don't think I had one story written, did I have one story written? I stopped a war between two major nations, major nuclear nations. I did not have a story written about it, but that's okay. You know why, the people know." Meanwhile, the Pakistan government has decided to "formally recommend" Mr Trump for the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize, in "recognition of his decisive diplomatic intervention and pivotal leadership during the recent India-Pakistan crisis". On Wednesday, Mr Trump hosted Pakistan Chief of Army Staff Asim Munir for lunch at the White House. The Peace Prize has principally been awarded to honour efforts in four main areas - arms control and disarmament, peace negotiation, democracy and human rights, and work aimed at creating a better organised and more peaceful work, according to its official website.
