Security guard jailed for sexual assault of woman travelling to concert on Luas
A SECURITY GUARD has been jailed for eight months for the broad daylight sexual assault of a woman aboard a crowded Luas last year.
Abdiweli Ali, 24, was handed the sentence in Dublin District Court today.
The court heard that the assault happened as the woman and her friend travelled in broad daylight to the 3Arena for a Smashing Pumpkins concert on 10 June 2024.
Describing it as an 'appalling offence', Judge Gráinne Malone stated she had to ensure women could travel safely on public transport without being violated in this way, and there had to be a deterrent.
Ali, from Somalia, came to Ireland in 2020, claiming he fled from terrorist groups.
He denied the allegation for a year and changed his plea shortly before his trial was due to start.
Garda Colm Maguire played CCTV footage of the assault in court, and described how Ali and the victim, in her late twenties, boarded the tram at the Bus Aras Luas stop at 7.20pm.
It was busy, and Ali stood behind her for the eight-minute trip.
'At one point during the journey, the injured party felt something wet on the back of her leg but didn't have enough room to check what it actually was while on the Luas,' Maguire said.
'On arrival at The Point Luas stop with her friend, she check her skirt and found what she suspected to be semen on her skirt.'
Ali also got off the luas, and ran to a taxi to take him to work.
She reported it to gardaí in the area, and her skirt was later sent for forensic examination, confirming her suspicion.
A large amount of CCTV was gathered during the investigation, and the accused was the only male identified as a suspect.
Maguire spotted Ali on 27 June at O'Connell Street and recognised him from the video footage, wearing the same clothes.
He was arrested and questioned but made no admissions, insisting it was not him on the CCTV of the Luas.
However, a DNA sample from Ali matched the sample from the skirt.
Maguire said it was 'a thousand million times more likely that it came from the accused than any other person'.
Pictures of the stained skirt were handed into court.
The garda agreed with defence counsel Rory Mulvaney that it was an isolated incident.
The court heard Ali had no prior convictions, but had been given a strike-out for obstruction of a garda after donating money to charity last year.
Advertisement
Prosecutor Derek Mangan outlined how the State had been ready to bring 10 witnesses to testify after Ali maintained his denials for a year.
He also said the victim wished to address the court.
In a powerful impact statement, she said, 'My life has changed completely since that day. I feel disgusted and utterly violated.'
She recalled how he was heading to the concert with her friend.
'We were not talking to men or wearing anything provocative. I was just going on the Luas with my friend, as I have on many different occasions.
'I thought I had no reason to doubt my safety as I was in a public space on a busy Luas in broad daylight. Now, I can't make any plans without having to consider the safety of every part of the plan.'
'Any sense of safety I had has been taken away,' she said, adding that she has been attending counselling costing €80 per session.
She opened up about how preparing for the trial and the possibility of giving evidence left her 're-traumatised again and again over the last year, replaying the assault and preparing to be questioned.'
'As a woman, I have always been wary of drunk men, rowdy men and creepy men. Now I am wary of every man and even every person. Any sense of safety I had has been taken away. Every part of my life is different now.'
All her decisions are now influenced by her encounter on the Luas, which led her to change her habits.
'I can't stand at a traffic light with someone waiting behind me without having to move because it makes me feel so anxious.'
'When I'm in a crowded room, I need to have my back to the wall if I'm standing, and if I'm sitting down, I feel the need to have my chair facing the room so that no one can pass behind me.'
It also significantly affected her professional and personal life. The court heard she had taken numerous weeks off work due to anxiety and stress.
She avoids public transport, does not walk to work anymore, relies on taxis or lifts, and often questions her clothing choices, terrified she might attract 'unwanted attention.'
'I have been forever changed by this assault,' she stated, but concluded her statement by expressing hope that someday she could go about her daily life without overwhelming anxiety.
Mulvany told the judge that his client, who did not address the court and could not explain his actions, was ashamed and recognised the distress caused.
Ali offered an 'unreserved apology' through the barrister.
The court heard Ali claimed he came to Ireland five years ago to avoid 'various terrorist gangs trying to recruit young people into their organisations.'
He was allowed to stay, trained and obtained a security guard's license. Ali worked in that role for two years and was posted at an IPAS centre until this allegation came to light.
Sentencing, Judge Malone said jurisdiction had been accepted earlier by another judge for the case to remain in the District Court, which could impose a maximum of one year's imprisonment.
Taking into account the guilty plea, she suspended the final two months on condition Ali did not reoffend for two years.
She praised the victim for coming forward, which will protect others from Ali, and she commended the garda investigation.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
7 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
I battled addiction for 14 years but drug treatment court saved my life – it let me be mum to kids and kept me from jail
A MOTHER who battled addiction for 14 years has told how Ireland's only full-time Drug Treatment Court 'saved my life'. Anne Marie Sweeney — who previously served time in the Dochas women's 5 Anne Marie Sweeney wants to see full-time drug treatment courts all across Ireland Credit: Gary Ashe 5 Judge Paul Kelly detailed how the system works to our Crime Editor Stephen Breen Credit: Gary Ashe The After completing her course last year, the mum of seven, 43, from Swords, north Dublin, wants to see full-time drug treatment courts (DTC) in cities and towns across Ireland. Anne Marie, who now works as an outreach worker for the Traveller community, said: 'This court is such a positive aspect of our 'Once I had completed the process, it then gave me a foundation to build on, and now I am in the community helping others. 'It allowed me to be a mother to my 'I can't recommend this court process to people enough — especially those who are struggling with their mental health and addictions.' Anne Marie added: 'I firmly believe that this type of court should be operating on a full-time basis all across Ireland. 'I often travel around the country to talk about my experience and I have also been to the prisons to speak about such a positive experience.' During the court process, which normally takes around two years to complete, participants have to prove they are no longer on drugs, must undertake education courses and prepare a plan for their future. The programme is based on different 'bronze', 'silver' and 'gold' phases. HELPING CHANGE LIVES Those participating in the programme range from the ages of 18 to people in their 60s. Once each phase has been completed, participants receive a cash voucher with a graduation ceremony held at the end of the 'gold' phase. Following the end of the gold phase, participants are drug-free, have completed an education course, and have identified a 'pathway' to employment. In operation since 2001, the DTC has helped change the lives of more than 700 people. In March this year, ten people were in the bronze and silver phases, with one in gold. Eight people are also being assessed for the programme. Other figures show that, since its formation, 105 people have graduated from the gold phase. 'THEY'RE HUMAN BEINGS' Judge Paul Kelly, who is President of the District Court, told The Irish Sun how the aim of the court was to help improve the lives of offenders. The senior judge said: 'Every person before the court is an individual whose own case is personal and individual to them. 'They are human beings and they are citizens — they are entitled to get the best out of our system, including our judicial system. 'The people who participate in the programme often have chaotic backgrounds, but if they successfully complete the programme, they will reconnect with their community and contribute to society.' Former gang member Ger Redmond, 43, who now teaches kids in Oberstown Detention Centre, described the DTC as a 'unique opportunity' for the participants. 'This court is such a positive aspect of our criminal justice system — it saved my life." Anne Marie Sweeney Ger, from Darndale in north Dublin, said: 'Anyone who participates in this programme has nothing to lose but everything to gain. 'This is a great alternative to a prison sentence, courses like this don't just keep people out of prisons. 'It gives people an opportunity to be redeemed and live a life they could never have imagined.' OFFERING AN ALTERNATIVE Judge Kelly added: 'Prison doesn't address their underlying problems. It's the underlying conditions of addiction that drive the criminality, particularly for shorter sentences. 'This is an alternative to the traditional court process and it allows offenders who have addictions to illegal drugs to divert from the normal criminal court system and embark on a programme of treatment which is supervised by the court and in the control of the court. 'The programme allows them to avail of a 'Rolls Royce' service in terms of support with education, housing, personal support, probation support and Garda support. 'I have often said that there really is a need for a drug treatment court in every city and large town in Ireland, at the very least.' The judge also said: 'Anybody who gets through the gold standard is somebody who has got back to a sustainable, productive and fulfilling life. 'BACK IN THE COMMUNITY' 'They are back in the community and contributing to society — great positive benefits for society, less stealing and drug dealing. 'The multi-agency approach to this process is crucial and it wouldn't work without that.' When we visited the court last week, we also spoke to Mary, 50, one of two women who were appearing at the court last Wednesday. The Dublin woman, who is in the 'silver' phase of the process, has vowed to turn her life around after struggling with addiction to sleeping tablets and other prescription pills. 'This is a great alternative to a prison sentence, courses like this don't just keep people out of prisons." Ger Redmond She joined the programme two years ago after she was charged with theft. Once she completes the course, her charge will be struck out. She said: 'I'd rather do this programme than go to prison. 'I love life now and I can hold my head high, because, in the past, I was always out of it.' Other participants have included a mother who now gives talks at justice conferences, a former addict who is now participating in Hyrox fitness competitions in Another includes a former participant who now works at the DTC, providing support to others undergoing the programme. Louise Dwyer, who has had 27 years working in the courts and is the registrar at the DTC, paid tribute to those people who are working hard to turn their lives around. REAL POSITIVE CHANGE She added: 'I have been at the DTC for nine years and it has been fantastic to see the real positive changes that people have made to their lives.' Garda Jamie Cruise, who is the full-time Garda at DTC, also praised those who had changed their lives. Gda Cruise added: 'The participants on the programme get great encouragement and it provides them with the opportunity to get their lives back on track.' Sgt Colin Sullivan, who is based at the Criminal Courts of Justice, also spoke about the benefits of the drug treatment court. He said: 'The court offers a positive engagement with the clients who participate in the programme. 'GREAT SUPPORT' 'We have had great support from Supt Jonathan O'Brien at the Bridewell Garda Station and we can see the benefits once individuals have graduated from their courses.' The agencies involved in the DTC are the Participants are also given points by the DTC after completing different phases of their courses and, once they earn 70, they receive a voucher. Those who fail to reach the required standard could have their bail revoked or be discharged from the programme. Although the only full-time court is in Dublin, similar courts have been held in 5 Former gang member Ger Redmond now teaches kids in Oberstown Detention Centre Credit: Instagram / gerredmond5 5 Anne Marie Sweeney previously served time in the Dochas women's prison Credit: Gary Ashe 5 Garda Sgt Colin O Sullivan, Noel Mooney, Judge Paul Kelly, Louise Dwyer, Garda Jamie Cruise and Lorraine Fagan are all part of the team helping Credit: Gary Ashe
Irish Independent
9 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Norma Foley begins talks with Attorney General on forcing religious orders to pay redress schemes
Ms Foley said her officials have now liaised with the Office of the Attorney General 'and will be engaging on the identification and legal analysis of potential mechanisms which may be available to the State'. The minister said the issue of forced financial contributions was 'complex work' and would take some time to complete. The broader impacts and implications of any 'potential mechanisms' identified would also have to be considered. The move raises at least the possibility of the sequestration of assets or the seizing or freezing of bank accounts. A recent RTÉ Investigates programme revealed how the Christian Brothers in Ireland had been rerouting their financial and asset holdings offshore – with the work carried out, in some cases, by persons against whom serious allegations have been made. The news comes days after the first excavation work was begun at the Tuam mother and baby home site, where it is claimed up to 796 babies' remains were buried. In April, Taoiseach Micheál Martin said the Government would consider options it can take against religious orders that are 'within the law'. He was answering the Social Democrats party, which said the orders had been operating as 'criminal networks'. Only one religious order made a serious offer of restitution to government negotiator Sheila Nunan, who was asked to extract a cash commitment after the State paid compensation to victims in the first instance. Another made a tiny offer. Why are these orders not being raided by the gardaí? 'When is the State finally going to flex some legal muscle when it comes to these religious orders?' Social Democrats stand-in leader Cian O'Callaghan asked in the Dáil. 'Why are these orders not being raided by the gardaí? Why are their assets not being seized?' ADVERTISEMENT He said it was unbelievable that the approach of successive governments to these orders, 'which operated as criminal networks', was to 'roll over'. Religious orders made millions on the backs of 'enslaving' women and children and were now 'walking away without paying a penny', he said. This was because 'the Government is allowing them to run rings around you'. After receipt and publication of the report from Ms Nunan, Ms Foley made contact with each of the relevant religious organisations. Of eight organisations mentioned in the report, only two made offers of a voluntary contribution 'Of eight organisations mentioned in the report, only two made offers of a voluntary contribution to the Mother and Baby Homes Payment Scheme,' she said. 'My officials have initiated contact with representatives of those organisations to ensure that this matter moves forward without delay. 'With regard to the offer of a voluntary financial contribution, I can confirm that my officials have been in contact with representatives of this organisation and that this matter is progressing. 'Similarly, with regard to the offer from an organisation to transfer legal ownership of a property to the State, officials have commenced contact with relevant parties. 'With regard to those organisations who have not chosen to make a contribution to the payment scheme, I can confirm that I have written to them to express my disappointment at their approach and to express my belief that more could and should be done by them in terms of offering contributions. 'The purpose of my contact was also to invite each of them to reflect on the content of the Nunan Report and take that opportunity to make a meaningful contribution. 'My departmental officials have been, and remain, at all times available to engage with these organisations in the event that they are willing to take up this invitation and make a meaningful contribution.' In the meantime, the minister has consulted the Attorney General to examine ways in which the cash can be obtained without their consent, she indicated. Mr Martin in April said current law meant that 'we simply can't just go in and raid people'. There had to be legality for whatever Government does, he added. Former children's minister Roderic O'Gorman first wrote to the orders early in the last government 'saying they may wish to consider making a financial contribution to redress costs'. In May 2023, the government appointed former trade union official Ms Nunan to negotiate with the orders. She was told to come back with their best and final offers within six months. Nearly two years later, Ms Nunan filed her final report stating just one order had made a serious offer of cash to pay redress. These are religious orders that own assets worth hundreds of millions Mr O'Callaghan said: 'We know these orders would much prefer to pay their armies of lawyers than the women and children that they tortured and abused. These are religious orders that own assets worth hundreds of millions.'
Sunday World
a day ago
- Sunday World
Dad twice caught driving at over four times legal limit dodges prison
'VERY LUCKY' | Defence barrister Sarah Brennan said the 'very traumatic' murder of his sister in the US had provided the catalyst for the onset of an 'extensive drink problem'. Peter McKenna Judge Raymond Finnegan warned Peter McKenna (56) of the potential consequences that awaited him following both episodes which occurred in Castleblayney, Co Monaghan in April and December last year. McKenna, with addresses at Castle Lodge Guesthouse, Market Square, Monaghan and Cois Locha, Doohamlet, Castleblayney, Monaghan pleaded guilty to two counts of drink driving, alongside those of no insurance and dangerous driving in the south Monaghan town on April 21 and December 16, 2024. Sgt Lisa McEntee relayed the State's evidence in connection to the first incident which took place shortly after 1am. She explained how gardaí, who had been on patrol in the area, came across McKenna behind the wheel of a red Vauxhall van which had been travelling along a stretch of the old Monaghan road and in the direction of Castleblayney town. Sgt McEntee said the vehicle was spotted 'swerving over and back and from side to side', resulting in gardaí turning around their patrol car and going off in pursuit of the offending vehicle. Having carried out that manoeuvre on the town's York Street area, Sgt McEntee said pursuing gardaí proceeded to activate the patrol car's blue lights as the vehicle in question continued onwards with its full beam headlights on while also 'swerving over and back and from side to side'. When McKenna pulled in and was tested for drink driving, Sgt McEntee said his reading returned a result of 223mg of alcohol per 100ml of blood. That reading put McKenna at almost four and a half times over the legal limit to drive owing to the fact the State's present day legal limit stands at 50mg of alcohol per 100ml of blood. Less than eight months later, the court was told how McKenna was caught for a second time with an almost identical blood alcohol level, this time as he drove a silver coloured Renault Kangoo van through the town. Sgt McEntee said McKenna was identified by gardaí as they observed him driving at speed along the town's Main Street shortly after midnight on December 16 last year. Like the earlier incident, gardaí took off in pursuit of McKenna before noticing the accused make a left hand turn at a roundabout while proceeding out of town and along the Monaghan Road. Moments later, the van was sighted turning onto the Ballybay Road where McKenna signalled to turn right before turning off his indicator to instead indicate left. Judge Finnegan was told how once McKenna pulled in, gardaí once again took a sample from the accused in a move which returned a reading of 224mg of alcohol per 100ml of blood. The court heard McKenna had one previous conviction for drink driving to his name, which dated back to 2004. Defence barrister Sarah Brennan, BL, said there was no denying the 'very high' nature of both readings, as she told of McKenna had been cooperative throughout both incidents by providing samples and ultimately tendering guilty pleas before the court. She said McKenna was a separated man who had been labouring under poor health for some time, challenges which had been brought to bear by a diagnosis of Chron's disease some 10 years earlier. Ms Brennan said McKenna had undergone extensive surgery as a result and was now on anti-depressants and reliant on a €240 weekly income from disability allowance. She said the upshot from that diagnosis and the 'very traumatic' murder of his sister in the US had, by his own admission, provided the catalyst for the onset of an 'extensive drink problem'. Peter McKenna News in 90 Seconds - June 22nd In appealing for leniency, Ms Brennan also implored the court to consider the antiquity which was linked to her client's sole previous conviction over two decades earlier. Judge Finnegan disqualified McKenna for two and three years respectively for dangerous and drink driving for the April 21 incident, fining him €250 in the process. A five month jail term, suspended for two years, was similarly imposed for the drink driving summons despite Judge Finnegan's own concession of how he had been 'very tempted' not to suspend any of its duration. A further €500 fine was handed down for no insurance in the latter incident with a six year ban and five month consecutive suspended prison sentence being recorded for what Judge Finnegan said was an 'extraordinary' alcohol intake reading. In handing down those penalties and advising McKenna of his good fortune in avoiding a custodial spell, Judge Finnegan told him: 'You are getting a chance Mr McKenna. It's up to you whether you take it, if you don't you will serve the full sentence.'
