This time Hizbullah isn't helping Iran
When Naim Qassem, the greying former chemistry teacher who succeeded Hassan Nasrallah as the head of Hizbullah, sat down for a television interview on June 12th, the symbolism displayed marked a subtle but significant shift. Gone were the portraits of Ayatollah Khomeini and the ever-present Iranian flags. Instead, behind him was the yellow standard of Hizbullah and the Lebanese cedar.
Last summer, as Israel killed many of Hizbullah's senior leaders, including Nasrallah, there was simmering discontent within the Shia militia and political party. Iran, its long-time patron, did not intervene to help it. For some in the group, that was a betrayal. But Tehran was never going to trade its own skin for that of its proxy. 'Iran sponsored Hizbullah because it wanted Hizbullah to fight the Israelis,' says Meir Javedanfar, an Iran expert, rather than Iran having to. 'That would have been completely reversing and putting the whole subcontracting model on its head.'
At the time one Shia critic of the group likened the relationship to a president and his bodyguards. 'It is the bodyguard's duty to defend the president. It is never the president's duty to defend his bodyguards.'
More on the war between Israel and Iran:
That logic never troubled Hizbullah's senior ideologues, particularly Nasrallah, who were content with their role as Iran's loyal enforcers. They were fighting for the Islamic Revolution. But for the movement's domestic base, it was an unpleasant feeling. 'The rank and file, the average Shiites who sustained heavy casualties and who endured Israel…were frustrated,' says Hilal Khashan, a political-science professor at the American University of Beirut. 'They really expected Iran to come to the rescue.'
Thoughts and prayers
Those frustrations returned with force on June 13th, when Israel launched a blistering aerial campaign against the Islamic Republic. The strikes bore a chilling resemblance to previous offensives against Hizbullah: precision intelligence, the elimination of commanders and a swift degradation of air defences. From Beirut, there was little more than a formal message of condolence.
Once, Hizbullah was seen as Iran's ultimate deterrent—a force capable of preventing an Israeli attack on Iran's nuclear programme. Nasrallah had boasted of 100,000 fighters and an arsenal of rockets. Now, as the members of the high command of Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) are being killed, its Lebanese protectors are silent.
Hizbullah may have little choice but to sit this out. Israel's intelligence agencies had deeply penetrated the group since the two last fought a major war in 2006. In just over a year of fighting that started after Hamas's attack on Israel on October 7th 2023, Israel wiped out Hizbullah's military capabilities. The fall of Bashar al-Assad's regime in Syria in December has paralysed its efforts to rebuild. Today Hizbullah's missile stockpiles are depleted, and thousands of its fighters remain marooned and unarmed in Iraq, having fled there after a ceasefire with Israel in November 2024. 'Hizbullah as a fighting force is a thing of the past,' says Mr Khashan. 'They have become a lame duck. They can't even defend themselves.'
Constraints are not just military. Domestic politics, too, have clipped the group's wings. After two years of paralysis and caretaker governments, a new Lebanese president, Joseph Aoun, the former head of the army, was appointed in January. He is determined to reassert the authority of the state over the country, at the expense of militias including Hizbullah.
What remains of Hizbullah's leadership knows full well that dragging Lebanon into another war could tip the country into internal strife. Though Hizbullah swept recent municipal elections, there are even embers of resentment among its base too. Many remain angry that the group dragged Lebanon into Hamas's war after the October 7th attacks, while offering little aid to Shia communities whose homes were reduced to rubble.
Hizbullah's influence over state institutions is waning: its men have been ousted from sensitive airport jobs, and the army is reclaiming control over points it once controlled in the south. The airport road, which only months ago was flanked by portraits of Nasrallah and Qassem Suleimani, head of the IRGC's foreign operations, now boasts adverts promising 'A New Era' for the country. Provoking another conflict, whether internal or external, could weaken the group even more.
More broadly, the network of proxies and militias once known as the 'axis of resistance'—Iran's regional umbrella—has come apart. Hizbullah, long the crown jewel in that axis, is not interested in fighting. As one observer notes, without Hizbullah the axis of resistance no longer really exists.
Many trace the unravelling to the assassination of Suleimani in an American drone strike in Baghdad in 2020. 'He was the institutional memory…he created the axis of resistance,' says Saeid Golkar, an Iran expert at the University of Tennessee at Chattanooga. Israel's bloody campaign in Gaza has massively weakened Hamas's offensive capabilities, while some of the axis's more powerful Iraqi chapters are more interested in playing the country's elections scheduled for later this year.
Without Suleimani, the glue that held Iran's shadow network together has dissolved. The success is 'not just building these networks, but also running the networks was a pair of shoes his successor, Ismail Qaani, was simply never able to fill,' says Mr Javedanfar.
And Hizbullah, once the fiercest of Iran's proxies, is increasingly behaving like just another Lebanese political party—wounded, wary and watching from the sidelines.
Sign up to the Middle East Dispatch, a weekly newsletter that keeps you in the loop on a fascinating, complex and consequential part of the world.
Get 360° coverage—from daily headlines to 100 year archives.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
19 minutes ago
- Time of India
Houthis threaten to resume attacks on US vessels in Red Sea if US joins Israel's war with Iran
Tel Aviv: The Iranian-backed Houthi rebels in Yemen have threatened to resume attacks on US vessels and warships in the Red Sea if the Trump administration joins Israel's military campaign against Iran. Saturday's threat came in a prerecorded video statement by Houthi military spokesman Brig Gen Yahya Saree. "In the event of the American involvement in the attack and aggression against Iran with the Israeli enemy, the armed forces will target its ships and warships in the Red Sea," Saree said. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Villa For Sale in Dubai Might Surprise You Villas in Dubai | Search ads Learn More Undo US President Donald Trump is weighing active US military involvement in the war .
Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
Spying charges: Iran confirms arrest of German cyclist; foreign ministry yet to confirm
Iran on Saturday acknowledged for the first time that it had detained a German cyclist on allegations of spying, in what is likely an effort by Tehran to pressure Germany amid its war with Israel. The semiofficial Mehr news agency published footage of the unnamed man's arrest, though it did not specify when it took place. It said he was detained in Markazi province, where Iran's Arak heavy water reactor is located. German news agency dpa reported that the arrest happened last year, and that the man is currently being held in Tehran's Evin prison, known for housing Western nationals and political prisoners. The German foreign ministry declined to comment on Saturday. Meanwhile, Israel has intensified its offensive on Iranian nuclear infrastructure. Military officials confirmed a second wave of strikes on key facilities in Isfahan and western Iran, following an earlier round of airstrikes on 13 June. The Israeli army said it is now targeting Iranian military infrastructure in the southwest of the country. It was not immediately clear which sites were hit. Shortly after, Iranian state media reported loud blasts in two cities in the oil-rich province of Khuzestan. Air defences were activated in both areas. Fars news agency said a large column of smoke was seen rising above the port city of Mahshahr, while 'frightening explosions' were heard in the provincial capital, Ahvaz.
NDTV
an hour ago
- NDTV
Days After Her "Papa, Save Me" SOS, Indian Student In Iran Returns Home
New Delhi: "Papa, save me," an Indian student who was stuck in conflict-hit Iran wrote to her father on June 13. Today, she met her father after landing in Delhi in an evacuation flight arranged by India under 'Operation Sindhu'. Zoya Rizvi, from Noida, was studying medicine in Iran. On June 13, she messaged her father that a military base that was close to her place in Iran was struck by Israel. "They have attacked a military base. If I have ever said anything wrong to you, please forgive me... Papa, save me," read her message. She ended her message on an ominous note, "I am going to sleep now. You will know tomorrow if I am alive or not." "I got really scared," Ms Rizvi said today while standing next to her visibly emotional father at Delhi's Indira Gandhi International Airport. She told NDTV that she saw interceptions and bombings. "There was an attack close to the place I was staying," she said. Ms Rizvi also thanked the governments of India and Iran for the evacuation of the students. "The Indian embassy helped a lot, they relocated us, first to Qom, then Mashhad... Then the airspace was opened, so we came here from Mashhad, she said. Another student, from Jammu and Kashmir, said she saw drone attacks while she was in Iran. Syeda Farwa, however, insisted that she wanted to go back when the situation is better. Iran lifted its airspace restrictions on Friday for India's ' Operation Sindhu' to evacuate its nationals from Iran. The country opened its airspace for three flights to evacuate Indians. More than 800 Indian nationals have so far returned home from Iran under Operation Sindhu, the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) said on Saturday. Thousands of Indian students, most of them from Jammu and Kashmir, are stranded in Iran. Mohammad Javad Hosseini, the deputy chief of mission at the Iranian embassy, said more evacuation flights could be operated in the coming days to bring back Indians if required. He said about 10,000 Indians are living in Iran, and those wishing to return home are being evacuated. The Israeli military said today that it struck Iran's nuclear research facility in Isfahan, for the second time in the latest round of conflict between the longtime enemies. Isfahan was hit in the first 24 hours of the crisis as part of Israel's goal to destroy the Iranian nuclear program. The Israeli military is also preparing for a "prolonged campaign" to destroy its targets, including nuclear sites, enrichment facilities and missile infrastructure. The latest round of conflict started on June 13 when Israeli airstrikes targeting nuclear and military sites, top generals and scientists in Iran.
