Annie McCarrick: 'Significant excavation' continues in search of suspect's former home
The innocent owners of the Dublin house where gardaí are searching for the remains of American student Annie McCarrick will be compensated for damage to their beautifully renovated family home.
The search of the property, which was the chief suspect's family home at the time Ms McCarrick disappeared, has been ongoing and is expected to continue into next week.
Sources said the current owners of the property, who purchased the house within the past 15 years and have since moved out for the duration of the search, have transformed it into a large, modern family home. Annie McCarrick. Pic: An Garda Síochána/PA Wire
But with gardaí determined to rule it out as a possible burial site, 'significant excavation' work is being carried out.
A response to parliamentary queries from former Social Democrats co-leader Catherine Murphy confirmed a total of €217,790 was paid to property owners who had been subject to Garda raids between 2015 and September 2021.
The bulk of this, €158,685, was paid out by the SCA. Garda Headquarters handled more minor claims amounting to €59,005. The innocent owners of the Dublin house where gardaí are searching for the remains of American student Annie McCarrick will be compensated for damage to their beautifully renovated family home. Pic: Sam Boal/Collins Photos
Last week, Extra.ie revealed gardaí moved to arrest the chief suspect in the McCarrick murder after going to another jurisdiction to speak with a close associate of the man. It is understood this associate provided information to gardaí, which discredited the suspect's alibi for the day Ms McCarrick vanished.
The arrest came as detectives worked on the theory that she was murdered by a 'jealous' man who was known to her.
In March 2023, Extra.ie revealed a person of 'significant interest' to detectives was identified and that this was why the case was upgraded to a murder investigation at the time. Annie McCarrick. Pic: An Garda Síochána
The development came more than 30 years after Ms McCarrick's friends told gardaí they were concerned about the man, who was well known to her.
Ms McCarrick's friend, Linda Ringhouse, and her aunt, Maureen Covell, this weekend expressed concern at how gardaí handled the original investigation.
'They botched it,' Ms Covell told the Irish Times. The innocent owners of the Dublin house where gardaí are searching for the remains of American student Annie McCarrick will be compensated for damage to their beautifully renovated family home. Pic: Colin Keegan, Collins Dublin.
'They admitted it. They didn't listen to the family and did not investigate who we thought was guilty in the very beginning.
'They pooh-poohed a lot and didn't follow up on things they should have. That's no secret. It is all documented.
'And no matter how many times we said there is something wrong, it was: 'Oh, she is off on an adventure and she will turn up'.'
Newspaper reports this week quoted Annie McCarrick's mother, Nancy, as saying she had 'no interest' in justice, but her friend and aunt are adamant that the family do want justice.
In a social media post in 2022, Ms Ringhouse described Ms McCarrick as her 'first and oldest best friend'.
'She was a force of freedom and adventure so much that she took off to Ireland to live her ultimate dream,' she wrote at the time.
'I remember being jealous of Ireland, in a way, because it was taking her away from us.
'She was a true romantic with a big loving heart. An eloquent, soft-spoken, natural beauty as well as a hilarious, foul-mouthed stunner. She could make you spit your drink out from crazy laughter.'
Ms Ringhouse told how she visited Ms McCarrick the month before she went missing.
'I was able to see how happy she was to be there and starting a new life chapter. It's hard to describe losing someone this way. It's a different type of loss and grief. It brings a type of anger and rage that does subside, but can come right back at any moment.
'She is never forgotten among those of us that were lucky to call her a friend.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
2 hours ago
- Sunday World
Mike Lynch's sunken superyacht taken to Sicilian town for full probe
Irish tech tycoon Mike Lynch and his 18-year-old daughter were among those killed when the superyacht sank off Sicily on August 19 Tech tycoon Mike Lynch's superyacht the Bayesian is moved after being lifted to the surface near the fishing town of Porticello, Sicily. Peter Byrne/PA Wire Tech tycoon Mike Lynch's superyacht the Bayesian is moved after being lifted to the surface near the fishing town of Porticello, Sicily. Peter Byrne/PA Wire Tech tycoon Mike Lynch's superyacht the Bayesian is moved after being lifted to the surface near the fishing town of Porticello, Sicily. Peter Byrne/PA Wire Tech tycoon Mike Lynch's superyacht the Bayesian is moved after being lifted to the surface near the fishing town of Porticello, Sicily. Peter Byrne/PA Wire Tech tycoon Mike Lynch's superyacht has been taken to the town where British and Italian investigators will carry out a full probe into the sinking. Seven people died when the Bayesian sank off Sicily on August 19 including billionaire Mr Lynch, 59, and his daughter Hannah, 18. The vessel was held above the water by one of Europe's most powerful floating sea cranes, which set off from the fishing village Porticello at around 1.10pm local time. It was held in front of the crane as it moved. People navigate on a boat past the wreckage of "Bayesian" yacht. Photo: REUTERS/Igor Petyx The vessel arrived in Termini Imerese, a town around 12 milies away at just after 3pm on Sunday. It will then be moved into a specially manufactured steel cradle, which has a tarpaulin underneath for pollution prevention. Salvage workers on site, not accompanying the vessel to port, are conducting a 'full sweep' of the seabed near Porticello for any potential debris, a project insider said. Tech tycoon Mike Lynch's superyacht the Bayesian is moved after being lifted to the surface near the fishing town of Porticello, Sicily. Peter Byrne/PA Wire Italian prosecutors previously said raising and examining the yacht for evidence would provide key information for its investigation into the sinking. It will also aid the Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) report on what happened. Tech tycoon Mike Lynch's superyacht. Photo: Peter Byrne/PA Wire News in 90 Seconds - June 22nd Simon Graves, an MAIB investigator, previously told the PA news agency: 'When the wreck is brought ashore, we'll be completing a full examination of the wreck and we'll be finding out all of the elements that might have contributed to the safety of the vessel.' Further details such as 'escape routes' will be included in its final report on the sinking, according to Mr Graves, who added: 'Once we get access to the vessel we'll be able to tell a fuller picture of activities on board and the sequence of events.' The wreckage of "Bayesian" yacht. Photo: REUTERS/Igor Petyx The vessel was originally expected to be raised last month but salvage efforts were delayed after a diver died during underwater work on May 9, prompting greater use of remote-controlled equipment. About 70 specialist personnel had been mobilised to Porticello from across Europe to work on the recovery operation. Inquest proceedings in the UK are looking at the deaths of Mr Lynch and his daughter, as well as Morgan Stanley International bank chairman Jonathan Bloomer, 70, and his wife, Judy Bloomer, 71, who were all British nationals. Tech tycoon Mike Lynch's superyacht the Bayesian is moved after being lifted to the surface near the fishing town of Porticello, Sicily. Peter Byrne/PA Wire Fifteen people, including Mr Lynch's wife, Angela Bacares, were rescued. Mr Lynch and his daughter were said to have lived in the vicinity of London and the Bloomers lived in Sevenoaks, Kent.
Extra.ie
8 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Crime teen's boast: 'You can't keep me in custody because Oberstown is full'
Teenage criminals are using WhatsApp groups to keep track of capacity levels at the country's main detention centre for young offenders, has learned. And when they become aware that Oberstown Children's Detention Centre is full, they then embark on 'crime sprees', safe in the knowledge they won't be detained. Gardaí became aware of the WhatsApp groups after teen criminals taken in for questioning bragged about them during Garda interviews. Oberstown Detention Centre. Pic: The revelation comes after Oberstown hit the headlines this week, following a court hearing that revealed there was no space for two juveniles at the centre last weekend. The 17-year-olds were accused, along with two adults, of being armed with a machine gun during a burglary in Shankill in Co. Dublin last week. Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan has acknowledged that the number of places for young offenders in detention centres needs to be increased. The overcrowding problems are now being exploited by teenage criminals who are actively monitoring capacity levels at the Oberstown facility in north Co. Dublin. Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan. Pic: Gareth Chaney/Collins Photos One senior security source told 'They know when Oberstown is at capacity and, as a result of that, they won't be going into custody. It is then they go on a right spree.' One teenage criminal arrested recently after a vehicle was hijacked told gardaí about the WhatsApp group during an interview. The source said: 'He was bragging that he would be going home because he knew Oberstown was full. 'The situation came to the fore this week with the juveniles, the machine gun and no bed at the inn, so they couldn't be remanded in custody.' The overcrowding crisis is also believed to be a factor in a spate of recent violent incidents at the juvenile detention centre. One Wednesday, nine staff members were assaulted at the facility, four of whom required hospital treatment. Teenagers are becoming aware that Oberstown Detention Centre is full. Pic: Getty Images Trade union Fòrsa has expressed 'grave concern' for the safety of members working at Oberstown. One Oberstown staff member was left with 'life-changing injuries' after their face was slashed in a 'very serious incident' on June 11, according to Fòrsa. The trade union said the incident occurred when a residential care worker attempted to move a young person. It also said ten staff have sustained injuries in three violent incidents since June 8. Mr O'Callaghan, this week, said he was 'very concerned' to hear there was no space for the two 17-year-olds who were involved in the armed burglary in Shankill. They were refused bail after the judge heard a 60-year-old man was 'savagely' beaten in front of his family during the burglary. When it emerged that Oberstown did not have any room, the teenagers were released on bail under 'house arrest' until their appearance at the Children's Court on Monday. But one of the boys who was released on Saturday night failed to attend his court hearing, and a warrant was issued for his arrest. Mr O'Callaghan said: 'We need to ensure that if people under 18 years of age are charged with very serious offences, that there's accommodation and places available for them to be remanded in custody, and it's a failure that that wasn't available at the weekend. We need to increase the number of accommodation units available.' Irish Penal Reform Trust executive director Saoirse Brady has called for the introduction of a bail supervision scheme for young offenders, as well as the creation of more secure beds. Speaking on RTÉ's News At One this week, Ms Brady said: 'Judges have been calling this issue out for quite a long time now around the lack of availability of bed spaces in Oberstown for those who may pose a risk to public safety'. She said recent figures show that on any average day in May at the Oberstown facility, one in three young people were held on remand, meaning they had not been convicted of any offence.
Extra.ie
8 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Family of slain Detective Garda Colm Horkan meet with whistleblower
The family of murdered Detective Garda Colm Horkan has met the Garda whistleblower who has revealed shocking information about the defective gun holster he was wearing on the day he was killed, can reveal. The meeting was facilitated by Labour TD Alan Kelly, who has brought revelations made by this newspaper about the defective nature of Garda-issued leather holsters, one of which was used by Det Gda Horkan on the day he was murdered, to the floor of Dáil Éireann. This meeting piles pressure on Garda Commissioner Drew Harris to fully disclose what the force knew about the faulty standard issue holsters and what exactly they did when warned by officers within the force of their danger. Garda Commissioner Drew Harris. Pic: Leah Farrell/ In October 2023, revealed that another, more junior Garda whistleblower – a former member of the Defence Forces – had warned management and the Garda watchdog that leather gun holsters used by officers were 'not fit for purpose' before tragedies that led to the death of Det Gda Horkan and left another officer with life-changing injuries. In 2019, nine months before Detective Horkan's murder, this first whistleblower raised safety concerns about Garda HQ-issued holsters with automatic pistols used by armed detectives. Holsters specifically designed for the 9mm Sig Sauer P226 and Walther P99c guns make it very unlikely that an assailant can take the weapons or that they will fire accidentally. Garda Colm Horkan. Pic: File also published the content of Protected Disclosures from this person that revealed the presence of a huge unregistered, recklessly handled cache of firearms at Garda HQ. This whistleblower subsequently claimed he had been targeted by superiors and left An Garda Síochána. However, earlier this year, began publishing the content of protected disclosures, revealing another more senior serving Garda officer who has been in a leadership role in some of the force's most elite units. Pic: File This whistleblower revealed the details of gross mismanagement of biometric data in the form of fingerprints and DNA, but also was in a position to corroborate and widen our knowledge of the information provided by his more junior colleague. The detailed Protected Disclosures in the area of An Garda Siochána's management, storage and treatment of firearms and gun equipment were wider and more disturbing. This second, more senior Garda, who is still serving, was present in the incident room in Castlerea Garda Station on the night Det Gda Horkan was gunned down with his own firearm on June 17, 2020. The family of Garda Colm Horkan. Pic: Collins Courts It is this second Garda whistleblower who met with the Horkan family, can reveal. Those present did not want to disclose the interactions at the meeting, but it is believed internal Garda knowledge of the holsters and the failure to act were discussed. This whistleblower – who headed up the Garda National Technical Bureau (GNTB) – says in a Protected Disclosure published by in May, that senior officers withheld Det Gda Horkan's defective gun holster from the control of GNTB officers charged with forensic investigation of the crime. In May, the whistleblower detailed a first-person account of his attendance at the incident room in the hours after Detective Horkan's murder. In the account, he claims he was told that Det Gda Horkan's murderer, Stephen Silver, initially told investigators he had pulled the slain garda's gun from his holster. Stephen Silver. Pic: Michael McCormack/PA Wire The whistleblower wrote: 'Crucially, it was also stated at one point that Silver had opened up and provided an initial account as to what had occurred after Colm exited his official Garda vehicle and approached him. 'We understood that Silver had stated that during his confrontation with Colm he had managed to get behind Colm, on Colm's back and that as Colm shook from side to side, in an effort to remove Silver from his back, that Colm's jacket had also swayed from side to side in line with his body movements and that as it did so, it presented Stephen Silver with a view of Colm's official firearm, which was housed or contained in his official issue leather holster on his hip. 'Having observed Colm's firearm, Silver stated that he reached down and that he was literally able to pull the weapon straight up and out of the holster, without issue, after which, he started to shoot Colm.' Garda Colm Horkan. Pic: File It means that at the very early stages of the investigation, Garda Horkan's holster was identified as a key piece of evidence. The whistleblower goes on to detail that, despite the holster being bagged and tagged as a ballistic exhibit, it was not returned to the GNTB for forensic examination. Instead, it was taken into the possession of another uniformed Chief Superintendent, at the direction of Garda management, who then had the holster examined by a non-forensically trained officer. This sequence of events was confirmed to Deputy Kelly by Garda Commissioner Harris at a recent meeting of the Oireachtas Justice Committee. Alan Kelly TD. Pic: Dáil Éireann The explosive allegations are among those contained in new protected disclosures made by a senior serving officer to former Labour leader Alan Kelly and Others include that: The whistleblower's 'warning campaign' about the holsters caused 'frustrations at the highest level' of the force. A previous incident where a Garda received life-changing injuries outside the Israeli Ambassador's residence when his gun went off accidentally saw that holster being examined forensically, with a report concluding the holster was significantly defective. Video footage from live-fire training events, prior to the murder of Det Gda Horkan, clearly evidenced the defective nature of the holsters and the dangers they posed. An 'alternative report' into the holster taken from the Israeli Ambassador's residence incident – when a garda received life-changing injuries after his gun accidentally fired – ordered by Commissioner Harris and carried out by the Firearms Stores Section that procured the holsters, was a 'clear conflict of interest' that undermined Garda 'forensic and ballistic experts'. This second report was compiled some months later, while the whistleblower was on annual leave. The senior officer was deliberately targeted for raising the concerns. The senior officer involved in the investigation into Det Gda Horkan's murder claimed that the 'initial account' about the gun provided by Silver in custody was that he was 'able to reach down [from behind] and remove it from Garda Horkan's official issue leather pistol holster'. But, he notes in his disclosure: 'Court reporting later provided by RTÉ showed that the narrative [provided by Silver] had changed. 'It was now being reported that it was actually Det Gda Horkan who moved to draw his official issue firearm and that Stephen Silver placed his hand on top of Det Gda Horkan's hand resulting in both men drawing the pistol together, with Silver somehow managing to take the firearm from Garda Horkan even though his [Silver's] grip would have been significantly weakened as a result of it being widened by the grip that Det Gda Horkan allegedly already had on the pistol grip of the firearm.' At the time, Mr Kelly called for a full investigation by the Department of Justice into the allegations, which include serious claims made against the force and Garda Commissioner Harris.
