Indonesian coal industry risking a tough transition as demand declines, report says
HANOI, Vietnam (AP) — Indonesia's coal industry is facing mounting pressure and should diversify as China and India, its biggest customers, cut back on imports of the heavily polluting fossil fuel, according to a report from a Jakarta-based energy thinktank, Energy Shift.
The report released Tuesday says that the industry, which accounts for about 3.6% of Indonesia's economic activity and employs tens of thousands of people, needs to shift toward cleaner energy now or risk being forced into a costly transition later.
Indonesia is the world's biggest exporter of coal, which is central to its economy, generating tax revenues and jobs. So the expected long-term decline in demand presents a unique challenge for the country of some 280 million. Indonesia's coal production is still rising, hitting a record 836 million tons in 2024, nearly 8% more than the year before.
The industry also relies heavily on just a few buyers, with China and India buying nearly two-thirds of Indonesia's coal exports in 2023.
China still relies on coal for more than half its electricity generation. It accounted for 41% of global coal imports in 2024, or nearly 543 million tons. But more than 75% of the growth in demand last year was met by clean energy.
India's coal imports fell 8.4% to 183.42 million metric tons from April to December 2024, down from 200.19 million metric tons in the same period a year earlier, government data shows. The drop is part of India's push to reduce import dependence by ramping up domestic coal production. Imports for industries like cement, steel and aluminum that buy coal at market rates declined 12% while imports for thermal power plants fell even more sharply, down 29.8%.
Indonesia's coal exports fell to a three-year low in January-April of this year, a shift that may signal a longer term decline, experts say.
'These are signs that Indonesian coal miners have to start taking seriously as well,' said Hazel Ilango of the Energy Shift Institute.
There are other risks too. Most Indonesian coal companies are tightly controlled by insiders — owners, executives, and board members — who hold about 75% of company shares on average, according to the report. Regulations such as domestic supply rules and high royalties also limit profits, while access to global financing remains restricted.
The private sector and investors are generally uninterested in long-term transition plans and are more focused on immediate profits, while government policies remain inconsistent, said Putra Adhiguna of the Energy Shift Institute.
Experts say that the country's coal policy is riddled with contradictions. It has pledged to cut emissions and transition to clean energy, but it continues to expand coal production and approve new plants. Domestic subsidies keep coal cheap, but abrupt export bans have disrupted global markets. Meanwhile, the state utility plans to retire coal plants early under a $20 billion transition deal — even as new ones tied to the industry are still being built.
As major coal importers like China and India cut imports to boost their energy security, Indonesia's coal sector needs to plan ahead, said Jordan Lee, an energy transition expert at the Tony Blair Institute for Global Change in Jakarta.
'The reason I say that is basically if you look at what happened with some big oil companies that have tried something similar, we have seen the market not respond too positively,' he said.
The Associated Press' climate and environmental coverage receives financial support from multiple private foundations. AP is solely responsible for all content. Find AP's standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at AP.org.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
ED may chargesheet Robert Vadra soon
New Delhi: The Enforcement Directorate (ED) is likely to file its final prosecution complaint (equivalent to chargesheet) in three money laundering cases allegedly involving businessman Robert Vadra within the next three months. Following these filings, the federal agency will push for court cognisance to kickstart trials against Vadra and co-accused, people in the know told ET. The ED's investigation under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) will also lead to the confiscation of properties allegedly acquired with illicit funds in these cases. Vadra, also husband of Congress MP Priyanka Gandhi, in April this year was questioned in connection with a money laundering probe related to a land deal in Shikohpur, Haryana. Agency sources confirm his questioning in the Haryana land deal is complete. He has been summoned for questioning in a money laundering case linked to UK-based arms consultant Sanjay Bhandari and will soon face a final round of questioning in the Bikaner land deal case as well, people in the know told ET. Vadra has consistently denied the accusations, labelling them a political witch hunt and accusing the BJP of political vendetta. Live Events Haryana Land Deal The Haryana land deal case dates back to a 2018 FIR against then-Haryana CM Bhupinder Singh Hooda, Vadra, and real estate firms DLF and Onkareshwar Properties. It's alleged that in February 2008, Vadra's Skylight Hospitality, launched with ₹1 lakh capital, purchased 3.5 acres in Manesar-Shikohpur for ₹7.5 crore. The land's title was reportedly transferred to Vadra within 24 hours. A month later, the Hooda-led Haryana government allegedly permitted Skylight Hospitality to develop a housing project, significantly increasing the land's value. In June 2008, DLF reportedly agreed to buy the plot for ₹58 crore, allegedly resulting in substantial gains for Vadra. Bikaner Land Deal In the Bikaner land deal, Vadra is accused of making a 615% profit by purchasing 275 bighas for ₹72 lakh and selling it for a significantly higher amount. The ED questioned Vadra and his mother about this probe in 2019. An ET report from January 2020 indicated that the ED concluded Vadra and his company, M/s Skylight Hospitality, did not conduct proper due diligence in purchasing two land parcels in Bikaner, and cheques were issued to 'land owners' solely at the 'behest of' a company's representative. Sanjay Bhandari Link The third case is linked to alleged arms dealer Sanjay Bhandari. The ED's 2023 chargesheet claims Bhandari acquired a London property at 12 Bryanston Square in 2009 and renovated it "as per the directions of Robert Vadra, who provided the funds for the renovation." Vadra has denied any direct or indirect ownership of London property.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Pachuara coal mines dharna ends after talks with dist admin
Dumka: The indefinite dharna launched by the Pachuara coal mines Visthapit Ewam Prabhavit Sangh which had also disrupted the transportation of coal to Dumka and Kurwa-based coal rake points since June 15, has been called off following a a tripartite dialogue with the Dumka district administration, the management of the BGR Mining Private limited and the agitators. The BGR management which operates the Amrapara-based North Pachuara coal mines in Pakur district been allotted to the West Bengal Power Development Corporation Limited (WBPDCL), and transports mineral to both the coal rake points, agreed to fulfil most of the demands including payment of Rs 10 lakh to the dependants of the deceased of road accidents caused by coal transporting vehicles and other ones.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Cheated investor of 3.66 cr, scamster's Dubai run ends in extradition
Surat: A Surat-based property broker, Upvan Jain alias Bunty Jain, who fled to Dubai after allegedly cheating a 62-year-old private sector employee of Rs 3.66 crore in a property scam, was deported by the United Arab Emirates (UAE) authorities following an extradition request by the Indian govt. Jain was taken into custody by the Surat Police Economic Offences Cell at Ahmedabad airport on Saturday and was produced in court the following day. He was remanded to three days of police custody. The case against Jain and his eight accomplices was registered at Adajan police station and later transferred to the Economic Offences (Eco) Cell for further investigation. According to the police, Jain operated as a broker in Surat and allegedly duped Gyanchand Jain between 2019 and 2020 by promising high returns on real estate investments. He sold him four properties — an office in VIP Plaza and flats in River Palace, The Legend and Castle Brown residential complexes — and collected Rs 3.66 crore in the process. Investigations revealed that Jain and his associates created forged sale deeds, used stolen govt stamp papers and opened fake bank accounts to receive and divert the funds. These accounts were registered with Sutex Co-operative Bank, IndusInd Bank and Surat People's Co-operative Bank. The money was subsequently routed through multiple accounts to avoid detection. On learning about the fraud, Gyanchand filed a police complaint against nine people: Upvan Jain, Ashwin Langadiya, Arif Pathan, Naresh Vadhel, Rasik Ambaliya, Bansi Kalsariya, Sangita Kalsariya, Chetan Magroliya, and Vijay Langadiya. While the Eco Cell has already arrested the other eight accused, Jain had fled India. After the complaint was lodged, Upvan initially took shelter in his hometown Udaipur, Rajasthan, before flying to Dubai. A Lookout Circular (LOC) was issued against him, but with no return in sight, the Indian govt pursued extradition under its bilateral treaty with the UAE. Based on India's formal request, Interpol detained Jain in Dubai. He was deported to India after the legal process was completed and handed over to Surat police at Ahmedabad airport.
