No action on High Court assessment of needs disability as last government ‘couldn't agree'
The last
government
did not act on a
High Court
decision three years ago on assessments of need for children with
disabilities
because 'there wasn't agreement' on it, Taoiseach
Micheál Martin
has said.
In 2022 the High Court ruled that assessments of need should take more than 30 hours, which resulted in the HSE changing its model of assessment.
More than 15,000 children have been waiting longer than six months for assessment and 25,000 are expected to be in this situation by the end of the year.
Social Democrats acting leader Cian O'Callaghan said the accelerated procedure 'was struck down for a good reason. It consisted of one hour of observed play time and a 30-minute discussion with a parent.
READ MORE
'Children were then diagnosed as having a disability but not told which disability they had. It was a completely inadequate box-ticking exercise. Are you telling us that this is a system that you're going to return to, or is your plan to get rid of assessment and need altogether?' he asked Taoiseach Micheál Martin.
[
Government 'all talk but no action' on disability assessment backlog, says activist
Opens in new window
]
Mr Martin said, 'I have no intention of going back on the standing operating procedures' that applied before the High Court ruling.
But he said, 'I believe when the High Court makes a decision it is clinicians that should ultimately decide in terms of the nature and type of provision on therapy, medicine or anything.
'The last government did not follow through for different reason. There wasn't agreement in respect of it after the High Court decision.'
The Taoiseach said, 'an assessment of evaluation is not a static thing, nor should it be. As a child develops, the child needs ongoing review' and the Government had decided to have a national 'in-school therapy service', a 'red-line' issue for this Government.
Mr O'Callaghan said 'that is an astonishing answer'.
'When 15,000 children are waiting for needs assessments 'you haven't got your act together in this because the previous government couldn't agree on what to do'.
Mr O'Callaghan said: 'You've been talking around changing the law, hiring more people. But when are you actually going to stop breaking the law?'
[
Government to change law in bid to speed up autism and disability assessments
Opens in new window
]
Accusing Mr O'Callaghan of 'deliberate distortion', the Taoiseach said this Government will deal with the court decision but the previous government had dealt with a lot of other related issues, including a 30 per cent increase in assessments in 2023 and a 65 per cent increase in the first three months of this year compared to last.
Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald said the Taoiseach had met Cara Darmody on Wednesday morning and 'you gave no commitments'.
Mr Martin confirmed he met the teenager on Wednesday morning and 'we discussed all the issues involved and I outlined what the Government is going to do'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
15 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
State pays over €1.9 million to cover costs at Wicklow IPAS centre
The Department of Children, Equality, Disability, Integration and Youth which handles international protection accommodation service (IPAS) centres, has released figures detailing the amount of money the state has paid out so far this year to run these facilities in County Wicklow. The data for Q1 2025 shows Vesta Hotels Limited received the biggest allocation in February with two payments of €680,680, and a third worth €607,750 to provide accommodation for international protection applicants. A Hiqa report carried out at the south Wicklow facility in 2024 recorded capacity of 111 people. At the time of inspection, it was accommodating 104 residents, and nine of these were children. Meanwhile Arturo Ventures Unlimited received a payment of over €320,000 in January to provide accommodation for Ukrainians in west Wicklow. However, with a reduction in demand for accommodation for Ukrainians, elected members of the Baltinglass Municipal District have been told the operator of the Avon Hotel in Blessington has instead been offered to provide accommodation for international protection applicants. At their meeting in May councillors were informed this would be offered under a lease agreement of up to two years which is currently being examined by the Department. The 95 Ukrainian residents currently being accommodated at The Avon are all due to be relocated by August 8. The proposal to turn the hotel into an IPAS centre has sparked opposition from residents in recent weeks, with protests taking place in the town. They claim department officials have failed to consult them about their plans and fear the move could have a negative impact on local services. ADVERTISEMENT The figures also show Powertique Limited received two separate payments from the state in January totalling more than €1 million to house Ukrainians at the Royal Hotel in Bray. Meanwhile Woodstone Property Ak Limited which oversees operations at the Wilton Hotel in Bray received over €203,000 in January to accommodate Ukrainians seeking international protection. A breakdown of the figures also shows E and B Hotel Limited which owns Rathmore Country House in Ashford was allocated over €65,000 in January for the associated costs in providing accommodation. As of May 2025, there are currently 1,395 international protection applicants residing in County Wicklow. This figure far exceeds that of its neighbouring counties, including Wexford (605), Carlow (436) and Kildare (564) but naturally the numbers in Dublin are much higher. There are currently 3,403 applicants for international protection based in centres in Dublin city, with 1,190 in Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown.
Irish Times
17 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Live updates: Trump hints at Iran regime change after US attacks on nuclear sites
50 minutes ago US president Donald Trump has brought up the possibility of regime change in Iran following US military strikes against key Iran military sites over the weekend, even as top members of his administration insisted the US was not seeking to topple the Iranian leadership. In a social media post he said: 'If the current Iranian regime is unable to make Iran great again, why wouldn't there be regime change?' The world is braced for Iran's response after to the US attacks, which saw it joining Israel in the biggest western military action against the Islamic Republic since its 1979 revolution. The Irish Government called on all parties to 'de-escalate' the Iran conflict, but did not criticise or condemn the bombing of Iranian nuclear facilities by the US. Neither Taoiseach Micheál Martin nor Tánaiste Simon Harris condemned the bombing of Iran by the US in their respective comments on Sunday. Mr Martin did not refer to the bombing in his statement, but called on all parties to work to 'de-escalate the conflict' between Iran and Israel. 'Diplomacy and dialogue are ultimately the only ways to resolve the issues and bring peace and security to the region,' he said. Key Reads Taoiseach calls for 'de-escalation' but does not criticise US bombing Middle East on edge as US enters war with Iran Unclear what comes next after Donald Trump's riskiest foreign policy action as president How effective were the US strikes on Iran's nuclear sites? 29 minutes ago Flight cancellations show aviation industry's concerns Commercial airlines around the world on Monday were weighing how long to suspend Middle East flights as a conflict which has already cut off major flight routes entered a new phase after the US attacked key Iranian nuclear sites and Tehran vowed to defend itself. The usually busy airspace stretching from Iran and Iraq to the Mediterranean has been largely empty of commercial air traffic for 10 days since Israel began strikes on Iran on June 13th, as airlines divert, cancel and delay flights through the region due to airspace closures and safety concerns. New cancellations of some flights by international carriers in recent days to usually resilient aviation hubs like Dubai, the world's busiest international airport, and Qatar's Doha, show how aviation industry concerns about the region have escalated. However, some international airlines were resuming services on Monday. Leading Asian carrier Singapore Airlines, which described the situation as 'fluid', was set to resume flying to Dubai on Monday after cancelling its Sunday flight from Singapore. Similarly, Flightradar24 departure boards show British Airways, owned by IAG, was set to resume Dubai and Doha flights on Monday after cancelling routes to and from those airports on Sunday. Air France KLM cancelled flights to and from Dubai and Riyadh on Sunday and Monday. – Reuters 33 minutes ago Taoiseach calls for 'de-escalation' but does not criticise US bombing The Government has called on all parties to 'de-escalate' the Iran conflict, but did not criticise or condemn the bombing of Iranian nuclear facilities by the US. Neither Taoiseach Micheál Martin nor Tánaiste Simon Harris condemned the bombing of Iran by the US in their respective comments on Sunday. Mr Martin did not refer to the bombing in his statement, but called on all parties to work to 'de-escalate the conflict' between Iran and Israel. Read the full article here . 36 minutes ago Israel claims it is very close in meeting goals in Iran Israeli prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu said Israel is very close to meeting its goals in Iran of removing the threats of ballistic missiles and the nuclear programme. Speaking to Israeli reporters, he said: 'We won't pursue our actions beyond what is needed to achieve them, but we also won't finish too soon. When the objectives are achieved, then the operation is complete and the fighting will stop.' The UK, France and Germany have released a joint statement following American strikes on Iran's nuclear facilities, saying that they call upon Iran to engage in negotiations leading to agreement that addresses all concerns associated with its nuclear programme. The three countries also urged Iran 'not to take any further action that could destabilize the region', adding: 'We have consistently been clear that Iran can never have a nuclear weapon and can no longer pose a threat to regional security.' – Guardian Israel-Iran map
Irish Independent
30 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Taoiseach to raise Meath bus fare increases with Minister following intervention
Deputy Dempsey secured a commitment from Taoiseach Micheál Martin to address the fare hikes, which have hit towns like Navan and Athboy despite the absence of rail alternatives. Speaking in the Dáil chamber, Deputy Dempsey said: 'Commuters across Meath West welcomed the announcement of new commuter fare zones, but were left disappointed in April when it applied only to rail fares. That disappointment deepened in recent weeks with the bus fare changes.' 'In my hometown of Trim, the fare reduction was minimal, while towns like Navan and Athboy actually saw increases. The rationale offered was that fares now cover both bus and rail, but as we know, these towns have no rail service. It's only fair that areas without rail access, like Navan and Athboy, be given an exception and see their bus fares reduced.' The new fares structure came into effect on Monday. Among the most affected routes are the single Leap fare from Navan to Dublin, which will rise from €5.60 to €6.30, and the fare from Athboy to Dublin that will increase from €7.70 to €8.10. The Meath West TD added: 'Meath has some of the longest commutes in the country, with most people relying on cars. We need meaningful incentives to shift towards public transport. With our population and regional importance growing, it's vital that national infrastructure plans reflect this reality.' In response, the Taoiseach acknowledged her concerns and the region's importance. He said: 'Your point is well made, especially in the context of our climate targets. While implementing changes may be challenging, Navan doesn't yet have a rail line, though we are committed to delivering it, and work is underway. I will raise this issue with the Minister for Transport. I understand the motivation behind your proposal, and I agree Meath plays a major role as a commuter county.' Deputy Dempsey welcomed the Taoiseach's pledge, saying she looks forward to working toward 'a fair, effective solution for Meath commuters' and ensuring that 'no community is left behind.' Funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme.
