Purchaser of €6m Ballsbridge penthouse sues over heating system
A businesswoman who bought a penthouse apartment in Ballsbridge, Dublin, for more than €6 million – marketed as 'thought to be the most expensive in Ireland' – has claimed in the High Court she has had to endure 'unbearable' temperatures of up to 33C degrees due to an alleged failure to maintain or repair the district heating system.
Aideen O'Byrne is seeking injunctions preventing the developer of the property from transferring its beneficial interest in the Lansdowne Place apartment buildings and common areas to an owners management company until problems are resolved.
She has brought the proceedings against the developer, Copper Bridge C 2015 ICAV, and O'Connor Sutton Cronin and Associates Ltd.
On Thursday, Mr Justice Brian Cregan granted her an interim order until next week preventing Copper Bridge transferring its interest pending determination of the proceedings. The application was made by Fiona Forde BL, on a one side only represented basis.
READ MORE
In an affidavit, Ms O'Byrne said that in 2017 she agreed to pay some €6.5 million off the plans for the penthouse with a construction period of two years. The price was ultimately reduced by €335,000 and she moved in 2021 and lives there with her husband.
She said the developer maintained the apartments were of the highest standard and her property was publicised by agents as 'thought to be the most expensive apartment sold in Ireland' at the time.
However, she said she did not receive full value for the price paid due to issues including the internal temperature frequently making occupation uncomfortable and 'occasionally unbearable'.
An expert report found that during last year's summer of moderate/below average temperatures there was a threshold internal temperature of the apartment of 33.4 degrees centigrade which is well above acceptable temperatures including those recommended by the World Health Organisation.
She said the owners management company was aware of the problem and a report was provided in 2021 showing lobby areas were consistently showing temperatures of 29 degrees.
The report recommended door-hold open devices, the opening of high level stair ventilators and the operating temperatures of the district heating system were also reduced.
Ms O'Byrne said the opening of the automatic vents on her roof garden was both a security risk, visual eyesore and noise nuisance. Certain other recommendations were made to deal with the problem including a shut down of the district heating system between midnight and 5am and insulation improvements to the pipework.
The management company said last February, through its solicitor, that a report had been sent to the developer with certain recommendations in relation to heating in the lobby areas and was 'in hand'. She has not been furnished with it, despite repeated requests, she said.
She had brought proceedings in 2022 against the defendants alleging breach of contract, negligence and breach of duty including by failing to repair/maintain the heating system and common areas. She now seeks that the management company be also joined as a defendant.
She said last April a note was circulated to all residents by the management company rejecting any liability for alleged defects.
It said it had been notified of the proposal to join it as a co-defendant but said 'if the member persists, the owners management company will incur significant costs for the High Court representation including senior and junior counsel, engineers and architects etc'.
Ms O'Byrne said this appeared to 'comprise an effort to intimidate and isolate me from my fellow residents' and put pressure on her to abandon her requests for an indemnity from the developer in relation to issues with the apartment.
In April the developer confirmed the transfer of the legal interest in the common areas to the management company and therefore the only interest remaining was the beneficial interest, she said.
There was now an urgency to prevent the transfer of that remaining interest as the developer had not given an undertaking not to do so, she said. She said the developer is a special purpose investment vehicle (ICAV) which meant the owners would not have any recourse under company law against it.
She has no assurance the developer will exist or have the means to meet her claim once the transfer of the common areas is completed, she said. She also seeks that an indemnity be sought from the developer which she said the management company had said it will not seek.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Aircraft leasing executive Paul Barton left €17.5m estate
Aircraft leasing executive Paul Barton left an estate valued at €17.5 million when he died last September, according to documents published by the Probate Office this week. Mr Barton, of Waltham Terrace, Blackrock, Co Dublin, was managing director of GE Capital Aviation Services , the world's largest commercial leasing and financing company by number of aircraft, before a €25 billion deal with rival AerCap saw the world's two biggest aviation leasing companies join forces in 2021. Mr Barton, who was a founding director of Avolon , another major aircraft leasing company, began his career with Tony Ryan's Guinness Peat Aviation in 1985. In other grants of probate published last week, Josephine Buckley, of Annakisha, Mallow, Co Cork, who died on March 17th, 2022, left an estate valued at €5.9 million. READ MORE Jeremiah Anthony Roynane, of Lavally, Mallow, Co Cork, left an estate valued at €4,281,419 when he died in November 2023. Julian Deale, of Monkstown Road, Dublin, left an estate valued at €2.212 million when he died on May 16th, 2024. [ Wills and spouses: Why you cannot just cut a wife out of your will Opens in new window ] Bridie Brady, of Mount Prospect Avenue, Clontarf, Dublin, left an estate valued at €2.185 million when she died on May 20th, 2024. Paul Kennedy, of Cartown House, Kildimo, Co Limerick, who died on November 2nd last, left an estate valued at €1.89 million. The figures mentioned here include all assets, which would typically include a home or farm and are not intended to represent cash in the bank.
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Some local authorities inspecting ‘just 10%' of new builds for compliance with safety regulations
Enforcement of building safety regulations in Ireland is a 'key weakness', with inspections of new developments varying among local authorities, some of whom inspect 'virtually none', a construction conference has heard. The Construction Bar Association annual conference heard on Friday that local authorities require greater resources to ensure compliance with building safety regulations. Deirdre Ní Fhloinn, a barrister specialising in construction law, said statistics of historical building defects in Ireland do not suggest there were a 'few bad eggs in the industry' but instead, there was a 'systemic problem'. She cited a 2022 report that found that up to 100,000 of the 125,000 apartments built between 1991 and 2013 had defects concerning fire safety, water ingress issues or structural safety issues. READ MORE The total cost of repairing the homes is estimated to be in the billions, with Ms Ní Fhloinn saying the taxpayer has become the 'insurer of last resort for building defects'. Noting that rules and regulations were adequate at the time of their construction, Ms Ní Fhloinn said enforcement was a 'huge part' of the problem. Speaking on the value of 'robust regulation', she welcomed the fact that Government approval has been received to draft a general scheme to establish a Building Standards Regulatory Authority. She said about a quarter of new buildings are being inspected by local authorities, adding that this figure itself is inflated by larger authorities that inspect upwards of 70 to 80 per cent of new buildings. On the other hand, some authorities are inspecting 'virtually none', she said. Property developer Michael O'Flynn, meanwhile, said building control regulations in Ireland have 'great standards' but agreed enforcement of the regulations was a 'key weakness'. Inspection levels vary significantly among local authorities, he said, with some inspecting just 10 per cent of new buildings. 'There is no huge shortage of existing regulation, the question is, is it happening? Are people doing what they're supposed to be doing?' 'Local authorities are inspecting, unfortunately, a very low percentage. There has to be a consistent standard,' he said, adding that resourcing and upskilling is a must to ensure adequate enforcement. Mr O'Flynn added that there is currently no balance between regulation and planning, saying the Irish planning system was suffering from an 'existing enormous backlog'. He cited 2023 figures in which 22,000 housing planning applications were caught in a backlog in An Bord Pleanála , which had an average waiting time of 79 weeks. He described waiting times generally as 'quite frightening' and a 'really serious issue'. 'Our planning system is in a very bad place,' he said. 'We can't ignore these things, because if we do, we will continue to fail a generation of people who are unable to buy homes,' he said.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
Oil prices expected to jump after US attacks on Iran
US president Donald Trump 's decision to intervene on Israel's behalf in its war with Iran is likely to see crude oil prices spike when commodities markets open on Sunday night, experts have warned, with potential consequences for the Irish and world economies. Oil prices have increased by 11 per cent since Israel's June 13th attack on Iran, but moved sharply up and down last week as investors weighed the potential for the conflict to impact global oil supply. Mr Trump's decision to bomb Iranian nuclear sites overnight on Saturday is likely to result in spot crude prices surging in early trading when the market reopens at 11pm on Sunday. Brent crude, the global benchmark for oil prices, closed at $77 (€67) a barrel on Friday evening. READ MORE While it could take several weeks for higher crude oil prices to feed into petrol and diesel costs in Ireland, prices at the pump have been ticking upwards in recent days as tension ratcheted up in the Middle East. Saul Kavonic, an energy analyst at MST Marquee, told Bloomberg on Sunday the market's reaction will largely depend on Iran's response. 'But this could set us on a path toward $100 oil, if Iran responds as they have previously threatened to. 'This US attack could see a conflagration of the conflict to include Iran responding by targeting regional American interests that include Gulf oil infrastructure in places such as Iraq, or harassing passage through the Strait of Hormuz.' The maritime chokepoint at the mouth of the Gulf is a vital conduit for not just Iranian shipments, but also for those from Saudi Arabia, Iraq, Kuwait and other members of the Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries. Washington's intervention in the war and the White House's messaging have injected fresh uncertainty into an already anxious macroeconomic environment. Even before Israel's strikes on June 13th that killed several senior Iranian military commanders, economists warned that the global economy had entered into a period of heightened volatility with clear risks for Ireland. In its financial stability review earlier this month, the Central Bank of Ireland warned that the structure of the Republic's economy and its high level of integration with global capital means the effects of 'geopolitical and macroeconomic shifts abroad' can be amplified domestically. 'The potential for further fragmentation in global supply chains or tightening in international financial conditions could have material implications for Irish firms and households,' the regulator said. – Additional reporting: Bloomberg
