As sports embrace gender tests, Coventry and IOC may follow
As the gender furore that engulfed boxing at the 2024 Paris Olympics rumbles on, the International Olympic Committee (IOC) is weighing reintroducing testing, while several sports have already embraced testing for male chromosomes.
Such testing has its critics and the Olympics have already tried it once only to abandon it in 1996.
Incoming president Kirsty Coventry, who will become the first woman to lead the Olympic movement when she starts her term on Monday, signalled a change of direction on this politically inflammatory and scientifically complex issue when she was elected in March.
'We will protect the female category and female athletes,' said Coventry, a Zimbabwean swimmer who won seven Olympic medals.
At recent Games, the IOC has left responsibility for setting and enforcing gender rules to the international federations who run their sports.
'I want the IOC to take a little bit more of a leading role,' Coventry said, adding that she planned to create 'a task force'.
Even before Coventry begins her consultations, World Athletics and World Boxing have adopted chromosomal testing—generally a cheek swab. World Aquatics in 2023 adopted a policy that foresees such testing.
Their rules make participation in women's competition conditional on the absence of Y chromosome genetic material—known as the SRY gene, an indicator of masculinity.
'Non-invasive'
Only 'XX athletes', as World Athletics calls them, can compete. Both transgender women and those who have always been considered female but have XY chromosomes—a form of 'differences in sex development' (DSD)—are excluded.
On the surface, chromosomal screening simplifies access to women's competition, which has long been the subject of varied regulations and scientific and ethical debates.
Last October, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Violence against Women and Girls, Reem Alsalem, told the UN General Assembly that such tests were 'reliable and non-invasive'.
The gender debate reignited in June around Paris Olympic boxing champion Imane Khelif.
The Algerian was at the centre of a violent controversy over her gender last summer stoked by Donald Trump, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, and Harry Potter author J.K. Rowling.
World Boxing, which is taking over running Olympic boxing in Los Angeles in 2028, ordered Khelif to undergo testing before a competition in the Netherlands in early June. She skipped the event.
During the Paris Games, the International Boxing Association, which was booted out of the Olympics by the IOC in 2019, accused Khelif, raised as a girl, of carrying XY chromosomes.
Chromosomal screening attracts criticism, notably from the World Medical Association and human rights organisations.
'Highly invasive'
'It is far from being scientifically accurate as a performance indicator, while being very harmful to the athletes affected,' Madeleine Pape, a sociologist of gender in sport at the University of Lausanne, told AFP.
While World Athletics and World Aquatics both say transgender women have a muscular advantage, Pape, who ran the 800m for Australia at the 2008 Beijing Olympics, disagrees.
She said there is a lack of research proving that transgender athletes or those with or one of the many forms of DSD gain a 'disproportionate advantage' over XX competitors.
Explaining performance is so complex that this uncertainty applies to 'all athletes,' said Pape.
She also said it was possible to have an XY chromosome while being 'totally or partially insensitive to testosterone,' as was the case with Spanish hurdler Maria Jose Martinez-Patino, who after missing out on the 1988 Olympics was the first woman to successfully challenge the femininity tests in court.
Aware of these limitations, World Boxing and World Athletics are proposing additional steps after SRY screening which could include anatomical examination.
'Chromosomal tests seem very simple, very clean, but there is a lot of complexity behind them: potentially a highly invasive and non-standardised gynaecological examination, or expensive genetic sequencing that is inaccessible in many countries,' said Pape.
Ultimately, the future of such tests could be decided in the courts.
The European Court of Human Rights is expected to rule on July 10, for a second time, on the case of DSD athlete Caster Semenya, the double Olympic 800m champion.
The South African was barred from competing under an earlier version of the World Athletics rules. In 2023, the court ruled that her rights had been infringed but that decision did not force WA to reinstate her.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Vaishnavi's dominance, Harshvardhan and Dinesh rally light up day 1 for Maharashtra
1 2 3 4 Nagpur: Vaishnavi Torve, Dinesh Malpote, and Harshvardhan Mali registered victories in contrasting fashion to start Maharashtra's campaign in the chief minister's cup U-15 national wrestling championship on a high note. While Vaishnavi, a small-town girl from Loni Deulkar in Indapur Taluka of Pune district, delivered a dominant display in the first final of the day, played in front of CM Devendra Fadnavis, Dinesh and Harshvardhan rallied from two points down to surprise the experienced grapplers from Haryana in close contests to emerge as champions. In the 46kg women's freestyle final, Vaishnavi thrashed Anshika Yadav of Delhi 10-0 to open Maharashtra's gold medal account. In a dominant display, Vaishnavi took just 1 minute and 45 seconds to clinch the yellow metal. Trained by Prakash Kodekar at a small town near Pandharpur, Vaishnavi won the national gold medal on debut. "I got my grip in the initial stage, and that was enough for me to win the bout. Though this is my first national medal, I am optimistic about doing well in the Asian Championship and look forward to making my parents and country proud," Vaishnavi told TOI. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Villa For Sale in Dubai Might Surprise You Villas in Dubai | Search ads Learn More Undo Dinesh Malpote, a farmer's son from Mulashi Taluka of Pune, followed Vaishnavi's feat with a gold medal in the 57kg freestyle boys' final. In a thrilling summit clash, Dinesh defeated Jatin Singh of Haryana 3-2. Trained under Olympian Ravinder Khatri at the Hindkesari Amol Buchade Academy in Pune, Dinesh aims to become one of India's Olympic medallists. "My coach is working very rigorously with me, and our aim is to first win a medal in the Asian Championship. Thereafter, my target is to become one of the youngest medallists in the 2028 LA Olympics," Dinesh told TOI. Later, Harshvardhan Mali added the third gold medal for Maharashtra when he outclassed Haryana's Sawan Singh 7-5 to emerge as champion in the 48kg freestyle boys' final. In an exciting 52kg boys' final, Maharashtra's Shrikant Sawant suffered a heartbreaking defeat when he was tied with Prathamesh Patil from Services 5-5. With Prathamesh scoring the last point, he was declared the winner. Overall, Maharashtra finished the opening day with three gold medals, three silver, and five bronze medals. Haryana wrestlers, however, took the opening day's honours by winning as many as five gold medals.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
New tool finds vast online abuse of tennis players
Tennis players last year received abuse so threatening that 15 cases were escalated to law enforcement agencies, according to a joint report released Tuesday by the Women's Tennis Association and the International Tennis Federation . The report, which covers the 2024 season, lays bare the scale of abuse directed at players on social media. It also offers a reminder that the detected abuse only scratches the surface. From January to December in 2024, an artificial intelligence threat analysis system analyzed 1.6 million posts and comments. It verified around 8,000 posts and comments sent from 4,200 accounts as abusive, violent or threatening. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like How a $49 Japanese Palm Gadget Gave Her Grip in Weeks Yukon Rewards Undo The report identified 458 players as targeted with direct abuse or threats, with five players receiving 26% of the posts classified as abusive. Ninety-seven social media accounts were responsible for 23% of all detected abuse. According to the data analysis, angry gamblers sent 40% of all detected abuse last year. Of the 10 most prolific accounts, responsible for 12% of all abuse detected, nine have either been suspended or have deleted their posts or had them removed by the relevant platform . One account sent 263 abusive messages in 2024, but has not posted any abusive content in 2025 to date. Live Events Of the 15 incidents reported to law enforcement agencies, four took place at the Grand Slam events and one at the Olympics . The other 10 were from tour events. Three were submitted to the FBI , with 12 investigated by other national law enforcement bodies. They led to individuals being barred from venues and having tickets rescinded. Signify Group's Threat Matrix service, which went live in January 2024, is designed to help protect players by detecting and filtering out abusive messages through a combination of artificial intelligence and human analysts. All players competing in WTA Tour and ITF World Tennis Tour events (and WTA and ITF players competing in the four Grand Slam events) are automatically covered by the service. A Signify Group representative said in an email that: "targeted abuse is defined by a player's handle being referenced in the content of a message or posted on their profile on platforms where accounts are not referenced directly. "Our system proactively gathers every mention of handles or comment on profiles and then analyzes the rest of the content of the message for abusive, threatening or discriminatory content. If there is problematic content sat alongside that account in a comment or post, our system flags it for review then passes to our human analyst team, who carefully review every AI-flagged message. They are then able to confirm if the flag is accurate or not." But targeted abuse is just the start. During last month's French Open, Jessica Pegula, the world No. 3, said that abuse always finds a way to enter her timeline, even if not directed at her. "These bettors are insane and delusional," Pegula wrote in the wake of her fourth-round defeat to French qualifier Loïs Boisson. "I don't allow DMs, and try to remember when to shut my comments off during tournament weeks." She added: "This stuff has never really bothered me much, but does any other sport deal with this to our level? I'd love to know because it seems to be predominantly tennis? It's so disturbing. "Every person on tour deals with it. It's so bad. Those are just really small snippets. I get told my family should get cancer and die from people on here on a regular basis. Absolutely crazy." Bettors and angry fans will name players in abusive comments after a loss, even if they do not message or tag them on social media when doing so. The normalization of this kind of abuse has become a major issue for the sport, and is the natural next step for people who have been blocked or cannot message the targets of their abuse directly. The International Tennis Federation and the WTA and ATP Tours share match data with providers linked to sports betting. Income from those deals goes toward the funding of the tours. Pegula, who sits on the WTA Players' Council, said on Tuesday: " Online abuse is unacceptable, and something that no player should have to endure. I welcome the work that the WTA and ITF are doing with Threat Matrix to identify and take action against the abusers, whose behavior is so often linked to gambling. "But it's not enough on its own. It's time for the gambling industry and social media companies to tackle the problem at its source and act to protect everyone facing these threats." Caroline Garcia, the French former world No. 4 who will retire later this year, opened up about the damaging effects of social media abuse at the U.S. Open last August. She wrote on Instagram that unhealthy betting accounted for most of the abuse, and emphasized how damaging it was to players who were already emotionally destroyed after a defeat. "If someone decided to say these things to me in public, he could have legal issues," Garcia wrote. "So why online we are free to do anything? Shouldn't we reconsider anonymity online?" A Betting and Gaming Council representative told BBC Sport that the organization does "not tolerate abuse on social media, which has no place in betting or sport." In a statement, the organization said: "It is vital social media companies take swift action against users, remove offensive content and work more closely with BGC members on measures to further strengthen safer gambling. Each month, around 22.5 million people in Britain enjoy a bet, on the lottery, in bookmakers, casinos, bingo halls and online, and the overwhelming majority do so safely and responsibly." Meta, which owns social media platforms like Facebook and Instagram, did not immediately respond to a request to comment. Jonathan Hirshler, the CEO of Signify Group, which developed the Threat Matrix service, said that the fact that a lot of the abuse came from a small number of accounts "means that we are able to be even more focused working with the platforms to ensure successful take down, support the tennis bodies to drive law enforcement intervention for the most egregious accounts and work with event security teams to ensure prolific abusers are unable to attend tournaments." The threat of online abuse can also tip into real-world threats. At the French Open, Clara Tauson of Denmark and Jakub Mensik of the Czech Republic confronted bettors who abused them from the stands. And in March, at a practice session during the Miami Open, Iga Swiatek was confronted by someone who has regularly abused her online. The tournament gave Swiatek additional security after the incident, which a representative for the five-time Grand Slam champion described as "a direct transition from verbal aggression online to harassment in the real world."
New Indian Express
2 hours ago
- New Indian Express
Bindra's world: Olympic spirit & social change
CHENNAI: There is nothing that unifies more than sport and brings joy to people's faces — Abhinav Bindra. These words encapsulate the power of sport quite succinctly. Just a couple of days before the Olympic Day (June 23), Bindra spoke about Olympism, Olympic Value Education Programme and the Let's Move campaign and how collaborative initiatives in schools have led to social change. Some of the children have taken flights for the first time in their lives. A few even went to Lausanne. A small initiative can usher in miracles. The true power of sport lies in its innate quality to bring in social upliftment and change. It can stir emotions that are unparalleled, can appeal to the senses and render justice to the highest form of being — life. The gold medal at the Beijing Olympics changed Bindra's life forever. Sport has, like he acknowledges, been his life and has given him everything. And this is a small way to give back to society, and in the larger context, India and the world. It has given him a new meaning. The OVEP is one such vehicle that's created a new ecosystem across government schools in Odisha and Assam. Bindra is passionate while describing the nuances of the programme that was launched four years ago in Odisha. OVEP started as a programme to spread Olympism and spirit of sport, but Bindra says it has brought about not just social but behavioral changes in the students and even the parents. For the uninitiated, OVEP is the International Olympic Committee's (IOC) initiative that "communicates the long-term benefits of sport and physical activity through an understanding of Olympism and its impact on individual health, enjoyment, and social interaction." Bindra usually comes across as a man who has his emotions under control. Even his celebrations after winning countless medals were muted. Yet, during an online conversation with this daily, he sounded emotional. At times, he was excited while speaking about OVEP and how it has impacted lives. He says the attendance in schools have increased and more interestingly, girls have started participating in sport. "We have had many positive stories coming out," Bindra explains. "There are many important things that have helped kids become active, but also have had a byproduct. There is better attendance in schools. There are behavioural changes in kids, a positive environment in schools and sport does that." It is fascinating to converse with Bindra. He narrates anecdotes with such clarity that it keeps one engaged. "I have always been inspired by the role sport can play to shape society," he says. "As an athlete, maybe when I was competing, I saw sport from a very small lens. And that was trying to be on top of the podium. But after retirement, I realised that the true power of sport lies on what sport can really do to people, to normal people. How it can really play a positive role in shaping society, in our context in India." Bindra believes that the essential need in India is to try and increase the playing population: "the need to embrace sport as a tool for nation building, the need for people to just play sport for the sheer joy of playing sport, because that is the only way you will build a culture for sport." He feels through these activities "you will have more kids and more young people getting involved in elite sport. And then performances at the elite level will become a byproduct of a larger movement where communities and society on its own embrace sport." Bindra has seen how the top countries win the majority of the medals at the Olympics and he has realized that more than money, it's the sport culture that helped the citizens pursue sports not just as a profession alone. "Sport is played by a normal person, not to become some champion, but just to embrace, make sport as a way of life. That is what we need to develop in India. And that is where I was very inspired by the OVEP," he says. Bindra, who is a member of IOC's athletes' commission, has been doing his bit to spread Olympism in the country and through play and games they are able to imbibe Olympic values and values of sport into character development of kids. "There is no better way than sport to put our youth on the right track and the world to imbibe values that are so unique to sport. That is how we started with a small pilot four years back and that grew and we are now in about 60,000 schools with state curriculum integration in the states of Odisha, Assam, as well as the Union Territory of Chandigarh," he says. "We signed off and started Chandigarh earlier this year. We have had many positive stories coming out." Last year, the IOC came up with their Let's Move campaign in India. He feels it is to get the global population to get moving. "Because of the IOC's partnership with the WHO, we know the numbers are at an all time high on lack of physical inactivity. That is going to have severe health related issues to the population in years to come. And there the role sport and Olympianism can play to make the world a better place." Bindra's foundation has been involved in implementing the Let's Move campaign in the territories that they are working so deeply in these states for the last couple of years.
