Cook did not want husband dead: Defence
Lawyers acting for alleged mushroom poisoner Erin Patterson have ridiculed an argument put forward by the prosecution that she also wanted to kill her husband, labelling it 'absurd', the jury has heard.
During his closing address to the jury on Wednesday, defence barrister Colin Mandy SC said there was 'no possible prospect' Ms Patterson wanted to kill her husband.
His comment came after Dr Rogers suggested the sixth beef Wellington Ms Patterson had prepared was 'clearly intended' for her husband Simon Patterson.
'The prosecution case is: had Simon Patterson changed his mind and decided to attend the lunch after all, he, too, would have been served that sixth poisoned beef Wellington,' she said on Monday. Erin Patterson has pleaded not guilty to three counts of murder and one count of attempted murder. 9News Credit: Supplied
Previously the jury was told Ms Patterson had prepared six beef Wellingtons – one more than the number of people present at the lunch.
In the witness box the accused woman disputed the sixth was intended for her husband, saying it was just an 'extra one' made because she had the ingredients and the steaks used came in twin packs.
Dr Rogers pointed to the accused woman's evidence that if Simon had attended, she would have given him a beef Wellington too, and Ms Patterson's final message to her husband after he told her the night before the lunch he wouldn't come.
'I hope you'll change your mind. Your parents and Heather and Ian are coming at 12.30. I hope to see you there,' the message read. Simon Patterson told the jury the pair remain married. NewsWire / David Geraghty Credit: News Corp Australia
Mr Mandy told the jury it was 'obvious from the tone of the message' his client did want him to come and was trying to guilt him into coming.
'The prosecution says the only reason she wanted him there was because she wanted to kill him as well. And that's, we say, an absurd theory,' he said.
'That would have had the result of removing from the children's lives their father, their grandparents, Simon's aunt and uncle.
'There's no possible prospect that Erin wanted in those circumstances to destroy her whole world, her whole life. Surely it's more likely that her account is true.'
Also on Wednesday, Mr Mandy said he expected to conclude his remarks on Thursday morning.
The update follows trial judge Justice Christopher Beale advising jurors earlier this week he would wait until Monday to begin his summing up of the case and charge, and that he expected this would take a couple of days.
The jury would then be sent out to deliberate. Barrister Colin Mandy SC will continue his closing address on Thursday. NewsWire / Diego Fedele Credit: News Corp Australia
Ms Patterson is facing trial accused of murdering three of her husband's family members, and the attempted murder of a fourth, with a poisoned beef Wellington lunch on July 29, 2023.
Simon Patterson's parents, Don and Gail Patterson, and aunt, Heather Wilkinson, died in the week following the lunch while Heather's husband, Ian Wilkinson, survived.
Prosecutors allege the 50-year-old deliberately sourced the deadly fungi and included it in the lunch intending to kill or at least seriously injure the four guests.
She has pleaded not guilty, with her defence arguing she did not intentionally poison the meal, labelling the case a tragic accident.
The trial, now in its eighth week, continues.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
9 News
an hour ago
- 9 News
'Beloved' father becomes second pedestrian in less than a year to die on Melbourne road
Your web browser is no longer supported. To improve your experience update it here A father-of-two who was hit by a car in Melbourne has been remembered as a much-loved father, husband, and uncle. Anisul Karim, 51, was walking on Heatherton Road, near Matthew Flinders Avenue, in Endeavor Hills about 7.45pm yesterday when he was fatally struck. Despite the efforts of emergency services, Karim died at the scene. A father-of-two who was hit by a car in Melbourne has been remembered as a much-loved father, husband, and uncle. (Nine) His grieving loved ones want urgent action to be taken, so no other pedestrians lose their lives crossing the busy road. "Everybody loves him in the community," Karim's friend, Milon Islam told 9News. "The whole community, the Muslim community is in shock, shattered. He was a very honest and close friend of mine. "He's leaving behind his wife, and two young children and they are shattered. They simply cannot process it." His grieving loved ones want urgent action to be taken, so no other pedestrians lose their lives crossing the busy road. (Nine) The female driver stopped to help, with police treating the crash as a tragic accident. It comes less than a year after another life was lost just up the road. "It's really shocking to know that an incident has happened at the same place and the government or the authority has not taken any action," Islam said. With two pedestrians killed here in the past eight months, locals say urgent action needs to be taken. They're calling for safety upgrades on the 80km/h stretch of road, and want the speed limit reduced. "No one should go through what we are going through, or what the other family went through," Islam said. Melbourne national crashes Victoria CONTACT US
Perth Now
5 hours ago
- Perth Now
New law to close horror ‘loophole'
The NSW government is set to introduce groundbreaking reforms aimed at bolstering support for victims of sexual violence across the state and closing a loophole that left a shocking crime unpunished in some cases. The Minns Labor Government is set to introduce a suite of reforms to parliament next week, bringing NSW into line with relevant Commonwealth offences and increasing protections from sexual exploitation. A new provision to the Crimes Act 1900 will ensure sexual offenders who either sexually assault someone or indecently interfere with their body after death are unable to escape prosecution when the time of death is unknown, making which specific crime occurred unclear. The new provision means when it is clear 'beyond a reasonable doubt 'that one of these two crimes occurred, but it is uncertain due to the timing of death which one, the accused will be sentenced with whichever offence has the lesser maximum penalty. Previously they would have been unpunished. Groundbreaking reforms aimed at bolstering support for victims of sexual violence across the state will be introduced to parliament next week. NewsWire / Simon Bullard. Credit: News Corp Australia The government says the reform is in 'direct response' to issues that arose in the inquest of Mona Lisa and Jacinta Rose 'Cindy' Smith in 2024, and the tireless advocacy of their families for reform. The penalty for indecently assaulting a deceased person will also be increased and criminalising female genital mutilation will also be strengthened. Other amendments to the act will redefine the age threshold for child abuse material offences, raising it from 16 to 18 years, aligning with Commonwealth standards. These reforms are designed to close existing legislative gaps and ensure the safety and wellbeing of children. The Crimes Act will also be amended to 'make it easier to prosecute people who commit sexual acts in the presence of children', the Minns government said in a statement. Changes to the act will also be made to ensure female genital mutilation is considered a crime regardless of the reason or motivation or age of the victim, while ensuring medically necessary practices are protected. The legislation, to be introduced in Parliament the day after the Minns Labor Government hands down the 2025-2026 NSW budget, comes after changes around domestic violence offences. These changes included making it harder for alleged domestic violence offenders to get bail, and introducing electronic monitoring for alleged serious domestic violence offenders. It also strengthened laws to protect against repeated breaches of ADVOs, and made changes to bail courts across NSW to ensure bail decisions are made by magistrates and judges – not registrars. The NSW government is set to introduce new reforms aimed at bolstering support for victims of sexual violence across the state. Photo: NewsWire/ Gaye Gerard Credit: News Corp Australia Attorney-General Michael Daley said the Minns Labor Government stands with victim-survivors. 'We are ensuring that women and children are better protected from sexual abuse and exploitation,' he said. 'Our Government is closing loopholes and strengthening the law to make it easier to prosecute those who commit acts of sexual violence. 'I thank the families of Mona Lisa and Jacinta Rose 'Cindy' Smith for their bravery and advocacy in the face of tragedy to strengthen New South Wales laws to better protect victims.' Minister for the Prevention of Domestic Violence and Sexual Assault, Jodie Harrison said the government is 'working to build a safer New South Wales for women and children'. 'Sexual and abuse and exploitation is unacceptable, at the same time as we are investing in support services for victim survivors, we are ensuring that perpetrators are held to account,' she said. 'We will continue to work with experts, advocates and victim survivors to address the impact of domestic and sexual violence across our state.'
Perth Now
5 hours ago
- Perth Now
Baby hit in fire extinguisher attack: cops
Two teenage boys have been charged after allegedly spraying a fire extinguisher into a car injuring a father and his five-month-old baby. Police allege two boys riding an e-bike discharged a fire extinguisher into the open rear window of a Silver Suzuki Vitara at a set of traffic lights in Sippy Downs, Queensland on the evening of June 15. The car was being driven by a 29-year-old father Leon, with his baby girl Pixie sitting in the back seat. Both were taken to hospital where they were treated for minor injuries. Leon's partner, Tiffani Teasdale, told 9News the car filled with smoke leaving Leon unable to see or breathe. 'He yelled out to them 'I've got a baby in the car, I've got a baby in the car',' she said. Tiffani Teasdale said her five-month old daughter Pixie was doing well after e-bike riders sprayed a fire extinguisher into their car. Tiktok Credit: Supplied After the incident, Pixie was rushed to hospital, where nurses flushed the chemicals from her eyes. Ms Teasdale said she heard her daughter scream and saw her with bloodshot eyes and covered with red rashes. Police allege the fire extinguisher used in the incident was stolen earlier that evening from a car park on Courage Street, Sippy Downs. A 15-year-old Buderim boy has been charged with 13 offences including three counts of wilful damage and two counts of assault occasioning bodily harm. A 14-year-old Buderim boy has been charged with six offences including two counts of wilful damage and two counts of assault occasioning bodily harm. Both teenagers will be dealt with under the provisions of the Youth Justice Act. The incident prompted a public appeal, and police have thanked the Sunshine Coast community for their assistance.
