Lessons from DRC private partnership at state-owned ports
After the concession for the Durban Container Terminal Pier 2 was awarded, ICTSI's bid was subject to a further independent review.
By Hans-Ole Madsen
The ability of International Container Terminal Services, Inc. (ICTSI) to successfully meet its R12 billion tender commitment to the Durban port has been underscored by its recently announced financial results for the quarter ending 31 March.
The company posted revenue from operations of $745 million (R1.3 billion) – a 17% increase year on year. The results highlight its financial muscle and ability to operate South Africa's largest container port in partnership with Transnet and to help unlock South Africa's economic potential.
In an affidavit filed at the Durban High court, Transnet CEO Michelle Phillips also admitted 'ICTSI plainly had and continues to have the necessary financial capacity.'
Yet the partnership between ICTSI and Transnet has been delayed by losing bidder Maersk who have stalled the process by pursuing a spurious legal action. Maersk's legal case hinges on their own narrow interpretation of a non-material single accounting measure, despite the tender process being thorough, fair and transparent.
Independent auditors oversaw the process. After the concession for the Durban Container Terminal Pier 2 was awarded, ICTSI's bid was subject to a further independent review.
ICTSI's financial clout to deliver on its commitment to Durban is further revealed when it estimates its capital expenditure for 2025 would be approximately $580m, a significant part of which will be channelled into expansions to port projects in the Philippines, Mexico, Brazil and the Democratic Republic of Congo.
In addition to serious financial flows, ICTSI has experience in upgrading and managing ports in a range of economies and developing nations. ICTSI currently runs 32 ports in 19 countries.
The Port of Matadi in the DRC is one such a success story that should be noted by those concerned about South Africa's struggling export and import economies. When ICTSI partnered with the government of the DRC to develop the port, it had been beset by years of congestion, inefficiencies, and ageing infrastructure.
Matadi is located on the Congo River and serves as the country's primary gateway for containerised and general cargo. Within two years of the public-private partnership with ICTSI, Matadi had undergone a remarkable transformation: a new terminal was built, vessel turnaround times were slashed, and trade flows into Kinshasa and the interior dramatically improved.
What had once been a chokepoint in the country's logistics chain became a symbol of what well-executed public-private partnerships can achieve, even in challenging environments.
This turnaround in the DRC is not an isolated success. It reflects the broader value that private sector participation can bring to state-owned assets - particularly in sectors like transport and logistics, where operational efficiency, technical expertise, and capital investment are crucial.
Across the globe, and especially in developing economies, public-private partnerships have proven to be a catalyst for infrastructure renewal, service improvement, and long-term competitiveness. In South Africa, where state-owned enterprises face mounting pressure to deliver under tight fiscal conditions, now is the time to lean into these partnerships.
ICTSI sees immense potential for South Africa's trade economy – and the Durban Container Terminal Pier 2 is the economy's beating heart. It handles 46% of all SA's port traffic and handles over 70% of the container throughput at the Durban harbour. And, as has been noted by many observers, the infrastructure of DCT2 has basically remained the same since 1963.
That is why ICTSI jumped at the opportunity to become the private partner of Transnet when the concession was first announced.
However, after almost two years, South African exporters and importers are still frustrated with the lack of progress at the Durban port. ICTSI has not been able to implement its agreement with Transnet, due to Maersk's court action.
Bottlenecks and backlogs are still causing costly delays in loading and unloading ships, as well as in processing cargo for onward transportation. Despite efforts to improve operations, inefficiencies persist.
Such delays come at a financial cost. Ships stuck at anchorage or slow-moving cargo means higher port and transport fees, increased fuel costs, and lost productivity for trucking companies waiting at terminals. These inefficiencies also create ripple effects throughout the economy, as this burden is passed onto on consumers. Essential commodities, from electronics to food and medical supplies, become more expensive, reducing affordability and hampering economic growth.
Addressing these challenges is critical, and a partnership with an experienced private operator will provide the expertise, investment, and efficiency needed to modernise port operations and drive economic recovery.
ICTSI is more than able to deliver on its R12bn commitment to partner with Transnet. It is also noteworthy that Maersk's bid for the Durban tender came in at R2bn below ICTSI's.
All parties involved now await the court's judgement.
It is a sobering thought that, were it not for Maersk's spurious case, DCT2 would by now have been well on its way to offer efficient services to shipping lines and South Africa's importers and exporters, contributing substantially to the country's economy.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
a day ago
- The Citizen
Toyota's Japanese insurer files R6.5b lawsuit against KZN government
TOYOTA South Africa Motors' (TSAM) Japan-based insurer, Tokio Marine and Nichido Fire Insurance Co. Ltd, is suing the KZN Department of Transport (DoT), Transnet and the eThekwini Municipality for R6.5b for the unprecedented damages faced by Toyota's Prospecton branch following the devastating April 2022 floods. Also read: Floods hit Prospecton industries hard The insurer filed a summons in the Durban High Court against the three defendants, with the plaintiff's court papers stating the defendants had failed in their duties of maintaining the key infrastructure meant to safeguard the Prospecton Industrial Area from flooding. It is stated within court papers that Transnet owned the Umlaas Canal and was therefore responsible for its maintenance, management, and responsible handling of the flood risk associated with it. The canal, which is lined with concrete, channels and diverts the Umlazi river around the Prospecton Industrial Area. Together with the diversion berm, which falls on the Department of Transport to maintain and manage, it forms a vital part of the flood control and prevention for the area. In addition, it states responsibility for the stormwater management system falls on the eThekwini Municipality. 'As a result of these failures, Toyota was compelled to engage various contractors to repair the damage caused by the flooding and hired specialist engineers to repair the structural damage to the premises, as well as damage to electrical installations, plumbing, air-conditioning and assembly systems,' it said. The damages, which amounted to over R6.5b, included almost R4.5b for the costs incurred during the repair and reinstatement of the premises and property, and over R2b for the losses incurred during business interruption. Also read: KZN floods listed in top 10 costliest climate disasters of 2022 MEC of the KZN DoT, Siboniso Duma, engaged with president and CEO of TSAM, Andrew Kirby on June 20. He said, 'We have agreed to sustain our relationship. We will do that in the interest of the people of KZN and the whole country. Over the years, we have worked well with Kirby and executive vice president of TSAM, Nigel Ward, manufacturing, and Toyota. We agreed that nothing should come between us and this enduring relationship. The current litigation is not being facilitated or funded by TSAM, and it does not benefit in any way from the subrogated recovery action against us. We have no doubt that Toyota will continue to be the most preferred brand in the country. One cannot over emphasise the contribution the motor car industry had made to our economy.' eThekwini Municipality spokesperson Gugu Sisilana said the municipality was aware of the court action and had filed a notice to defend. Transnet's media desk issued a brief response, saying it is aware of the litigation initiated by Toyota insurers and has filed a notice to defend. It further stated that given the early stages of the case, it would be premature to offer further substantiation. The April 2022 floods Following the trail of carnage left by the April 2022 floods, heavy rainfall and landslides in KZN, President Cyril Ramaphosa declared a national state of disaster. Toyota's Prospecton plant was ravaged by the floods, and the business was left with around 4300 flood-damaged vehicles, nearly 90% of the cars on site. The automotive giant reported that over 100 000 new equipment parts needed replacing. Astonishingly, after three months of intense repairs and support from the company's Japanese head office, production resumed in August 2022. Following this, TSAM invested over R200m to prevent disasters of similar magnitude going forward, and over R100m was dedicated to establishing monitoring and maintenance systems to proactively guard against water ingress. These included an early-warning weather monitoring system, construction of perimeter canals, and significant upgrades to the site's stormwater network. An additional R128m was spent on internal interventions to protect the facility even if external systems failed. These included bund walls around critical infrastructure and raised doorways to reduce vulnerability to flooding. For more South Coast Sun news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. You can also check out our videos on our YouTube channel or follow us on TikTok. Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter and get news delivered straight to your inbox. Do you have more information pertaining to this story? Feel free to let us know by commenting on our Facebook page or you can contact our newsroom on 031 903 2341 and speak to a journalist. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
IOL News
3 days ago
- IOL News
Moody's warns of threat to Transnet ratings as government steps in with guarantees
This comes after the government announced on Thursday last week that it had entered a process to allocate additional guarantees to Transnet to allow the company to cover at least all debt redemptions over the next five years and enable it to fund its capital expenditure program. Image: File Moody's Ratings has warned that Transnet's ratings will remain under review for downgrade until the South African government completes the process to allocate additional guarantees by the end of July. This comes after the government announced on Thursday last week that it had entered a process to allocate additional guarantees to allow the State-owned freight and logistics company to cover at least all debt redemptions over the next five years and enable it to fund its capital expenditure program. The Minister of Transport, with the concurrence of the Minister of Finance, approved a R51 billion guarantee facility for Transnet's capital investment programme and debt obligations. The facility will enable Transnet to refinance maturing debt and ensure the organisation's continued access to adequate resources and facilities to be able to continue its operations as well as fund the capital investment programme for the foreseeable future, while also enabling Transnet to focus on operational improvements and strategic reforms. The formalized R51bn guarantee facility has been structured to cover R41bn in funding needs that Transnet expects through the end of financial year 2027, along with R10bn in guarantees for liquidity facilities. Moody's on Thursday said it viewed the significant support measures as strengthening the financial stability of Transnet. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad Loading Moody's senior credit analyst Lisa Jaeger said they viewed the announcements as materially credit positive for Transnet and will monitor the outcome of the process as part of the ratings review on Transnet. 'Until the conclusion of our review, Transnet's ratings, including its long-term corporate family rating (CFR) of Ba3, and its Baseline Credit Assessment (BCA) of b3 remain under review for downgrade,' Jaeger said. 'Based on the government's most recent statement, we understand that it is working on providing at least an additional R48.6bn in guarantees, available until March 2030. This would bring the total guarantees announced in 2025 to R99.6bn, the amount needed to cover Transnet's debt maturities over the next five years.' The new guarantee facilities would be following a previous R47bn guarantee facility provided in December 2023, which has been exhausted. The R51bn guarantee facility that has already been formalized is easing Transnet's immediate liquidity pressure and will enable it to meet a R9.9bn local bond maturity in August 2025,. Jaeger said this was a payment they did not expect Transnet would be able to reliably meet without additional government support. 'While this facility does not provide a permanent solution to Transnet's ongoing liquidity challenges, we believe the announced additional guarantees would support a sustainable improvement in the company's liquidity position,' Jaeger said. 'If the government provides an additional R48.6bn in guarantees as implied by the latest announcement, the total guarantees to Transnet would increase to R150.1bn, which exceeds Transnet's total debt balance of R136bn as of September 2024. 'We expect Transnet's total debt will continue to slightly increase over the next two years, nevertheless, the company would then be able to refinance nearly its entire debt with government guarantees. We believe this will substantially reduce the company's refinancing risk and ensure it maintains an adequate liquidity profile while Transnet continues to progress with its operational turnaround plan.' Transnet falls under Moody's Government-Related Issuers (GRI) methodology given its 100% government ownership. Moody's GRI assumptions are comprised of 'Very High' default dependence with the government of South Africa and 'High' probability of extraordinary support from the government, resulting in three notches of uplift of the company's Ba3 CFR from its b3 BCA. Jaeger said Moody's rating review will focus on the sufficiency of government support measures to bring the company's capital structure and liquidity position on a sustainable footing.
The South African
3 days ago
- The South African
South African economy failing behinds its counterparts
The South Africa economy would be R5-trillion better off if we'd simply kept pace with other emerging countries over the last 15 years. In the last decade and a half, the South African economy has grown at an average of 1% annually. However, other emerging counterparts have grown at 1.4% or higher. This damning data was revealed by Investec's Osagyefo Mazwai. 15 years of lost growth coincides with the South African economy plowing money in State-Owned Entities (SOEs) like Eskom, Transnet and the Post Office. 'It is our proposition that the South African economy is falling behind. Had it followed a more pragmatic approach, focusing on the structural enablers of the economy, the outcomes could be much better for society,' Mazwai said in a Daily Investor report. Likewise, the South African economy displays a stark dislocation in GDP per capita. Proving that, essentially, residents are worse off than they were in 2010. The government has been ineffectual in addressing poverty, unemployment and inequality. And, per capita, the rest of the world is 50% richer than the average South African. With more money to play with, many of the country's crippling debt issues could've been avoided. Image: File As such, Investec compared the South African economy to other emerging markets over the same period. Many emerging nations have been growing at upwards of 4.5% per year. 'Had we grown at 4.5%, our nominal GDP would have been just below R12 trillion. Compared this with the actual number, R7.5 trillion, which is 35% less,' explained Mazwai. This lack of economic growth cost government revenue R800 billion in 2024 alone. And remember that the 2025 Budget impasse squabbled over a mere R75 billion from proposed VAT increases. This is an insignificant amount when one considers how much more growth our emerging-market peers have to play with. In practical terms, Mazwai explains that the missing R5 trillion would have been enough to clear nearly all of the country's national debt. Should SASSA grants be given a re-think in light of this damning data? Image: File As such, finance experts point out that Eskom and Transnet's lacklustre performance is arguably the most significant factor impeding the South African economy. Eskom is R400 billion in debt. Transnet is R140 billion in debt. Likewise, South African Social Security Agency (SASSA) grants cost the fiscus around R265 billion annually. SASSA grants, while well-intentioned, breed an unhealthy dependency on the social welfare system, reducing employment. SASSA grant beneficiaries now number 45% of all residents, and five out of nine provinces have more SASSA recipients than salaried employees. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
