India's growth and urban planning: On different planets
Metro stations in Athens are like archaeological museums, featuring pottery shards and other artefacts discovered during excavations. Moscow's subway stops are like art galleries, grandiose and distinctive, adorned with ornate chandeliers and striking murals. Mumbai's recently inaugurated mid-town metro station, in contrast, turned into a water-world on 26 May, with the season's first downpour flooding its concourse and platforms.
This embarrassing incident symbolizes problems with India's haphazard urbanization and its official approach to infrastructure build-up. More critically, it highlights laxity in recognizing the effects of climate change.
Also Read: Seven reform pathways to bridge India's urban investment gaps
What made the incident doubly disconcerting were proclamations by Niti Aayog CEO B.V.R. Subrahmanyam that the Indian economy had become the world's fourth-largest. The incongruity between that statement and the lived experience of Mumbai commuters and Indians coping with sub-par infrastructure elsewhere was striking.
Yet, there was a common link between that statement and the flooding episode: Subrahmanyam seemed to have jumped the gun (we'll know if the Indian economy has overtaken Japan's only once the current year is over), a precipitate action like the metro station being pressed into service before it was made rain-proof. The episode also underscored the death of irony: officials attributed the flood to untimely monsoon downpours despite common knowledge that a coastal city like Mumbai witnesses heavy rainfall for four months every year.
But it is not just Mumbai. The previous day saw Delhi reeling under the season's first cloudburst, with streets and underpasses flooded. A few days earlier, unseasonal May rainfall flooded large parts of Bengaluru's extended city, damaging property and causing large-scale economic losses. City after city in India suffers from the same problems every year, and yet the political or administrative classes seem either helpless in solving such well-known problems or incapable of preventing their recurrence.
Also Read: Urban renewal: Indian cities need a governance overhaul
It is also a fact that climate change has altered weather patterns, but authorities do not seem to have taken this into their calculations. Mumbai's monsoons, for example, are getting increasingly erratic in terms of both timing and precipitation. Yet, infrastructure projects—whether it is roads or metro station walls—routinely fail to take this into account.
This anomaly sits uneasily with India's growing urbanization: about 40% of the population lives in urban areas, with many experts claiming that the number may be closer to 50% or even higher.
This data uncertainty has arisen because a large section of the urban population resides in informal shelters, invisible to the formal gaze but most vulnerable to urban failures. Every city depends on this section for the delivery of multiple services, but is typically blind to their income, education, housing or health needs.
Worse, they are not covered by any labour laws and usually do not have any rights. In the triangulation between various interest groups in an urban settlement—the entrepreneurial class and those employed in the formal sector, the political class, bureaucrats, municipal authorities and real estate developers—this section usually gets the short end of the stick. With little or no access to water, waste collection mechanisms, modern sanitation systems or health facilities, this cohort suffers the harshest impact of climate change and extreme weather events. Yet, the country's big-budget urban build-up seems to ignore their needs.
Also Read: Urban renewal: Indian cities need a governance overhaul
A Niti Aayog report titled Urban Planning Capacity in India ascribes the continuing urbanization crisis to a lack of urban planning. 'For this reason, as the state and city governments continue to solve urban issues in a firefighting mode, urban areas struggle to achieve 'basic services for all'… India's urban story may be lauded globally or suffer irreversible damages in the next 10-15 years depending on corrective policy measures and actions taken at the beginning of this decade." Written in September 2021, the lack of any remedial action since then is already manifesting itself across multiple malfunctions, collapses and avoidable disasters.
The report also points to a lack of qualified urban planners in the state planning machinery: against 12,000 town planners required at all levels then, there were less than 4,000 sanctioned posts, with half of those lying vacant. What the report fails to mention, though, is that state governments have largely outsourced urban planning to real-estate developers and infrastructure contractors.
Projects are designed, finalized and executed based on interests divergent from user interests. This was amply evident in Mumbai over the past 36 months after the city's municipal corporation, under guidance from the state government instead of formal urban governance structures, unleashed multiple construction projects that choked city traffic and worsened air quality.
The Smart Cities mission was conceived about 10 years ago, though there is still little clarity about what makes cities 'smart' and whether any city has actually become any smarter. Problems of urbanization in India have also been well documented along with solutions. The smart thing would be to implement some of those suggestions immediately, especially those that will make cities not only more empathetic, but also more resilient to economic downturns and extreme weather events.
The author is a senior journalist and author of 'Slip, Stitch and Stumble: The Untold Story of India's Financial Sector Reforms' @rajrishisinghal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
30 minutes ago
- India Today
The new Indian beauty standard: What you should know
For years, professional makeup products carried the baggage of being inaccessible—either too complicated, too expensive, or too foreign. But that myth is now being dismantled. According to Bonish Jain, the focus has shifted to developing products that combine high performance with they're a college student, a working professional, or a beginner, users today want tools that are easy to use, effective, and trustworthy, without needing a beauty degree to figure them out. India Today spoke with Bonish Jain, Director and Founder, and Vaishnavi Jain, Head of Product Development at PAC Cosmetics, to understand how makeup that was once seen as 'too pro' is now becoming intuitive, inclusive, and proudly shift toward accessibility is reflective of a broader beauty movement in India: one that values ease, familiarity, and high-impact results at 'MADE FOR INDIA' REALLY LOOKS LIKEThe phrase "Made for India" is often used in branding, but truly applying it requires an understanding of nuance. For a makeup brand, that means taking into account not just undertones and skin shades, but also how the product wears in heat, humidity, or long workdays. Every aspect—from pigment payoff to texture to longevity—is informed by how Indians live and look. It also means challenging Eurocentric beauty standards and creating solutions grounded in local realities and consumers are incredibly value-conscious. But that doesn't necessarily mean they only shop by price. As Bonish points out, performance builds loyalty. Customers returned not because something was cheaper, but because it worked mindset has helped homegrown brands build genuine credibility. With rising competition in the beauty space, trust—earned through honest formulation and results—has become the most valuable INCLUSIVITY, NOT JUST CLAIMING ITInclusivity in Indian beauty is not a buzzword anymore—it's an expectation. And that means rigorous testing. Vaishnavi Jain shares that their approach involves multiple rounds of trials with both professional artists and real users from across idea is to ensure that a product doesn't just 'look good in theory,' but performs on a wide variety of skin tones and textures in daily life. It's this kind of feedback-driven development that allows products to feel authentic, relatable, and usable across geographies and RISE OF INGREDIENT-CONSCIOUS CONSUMERSToday's buyers want more than just a flawless finish—they want to know how that finish is achieved. What's in the formula? Is it safe? Does it offer skincare benefits too?This growing ingredient-consciousness signals a deeper shift in consumer behaviour: from trend-driven buying to science-backed decisions. Vaishnavi highlights that Indian consumers are now asking informed questions and seeking transparency around formulation, testing, and efficacy, especially in the makeup space, where skincare integration is becoming more FROM NICHE TO NECESSITYWhile sustainable packaging is still emerging in the Indian beauty market, it is no longer a distant goal—it's on the radar. As Vaishnavi notes, there's a steady rise in awareness about waste, material usage, and environmental footprint. Even if not mainstream yet, sustainability is expected to become an integral part of brand strategies going shift also mirrors changes in global beauty ecosystems, where brands are now judged as much on their values as on their is not a monolith—it's a mosaic of skin tones, traditions, and beauty practices. To build a brand that resonates nationally, understanding these regional nuances is Bonish puts it, beauty in India is diverse in its expression. From dewy minimalist looks in the metros to vibrant bridal palettes in smaller towns, cultural relevance drives emotional connection. And this is what allows a product to feel personal, not Indian beauty consumer is evolving—curious, confident, and clear about what they want. And the most successful brands are the ones listening closely. Whether it's inclusivity in shades, transparency in formulation, or relevance in design, what's emerging is a makeup movement that feels intuitive, inclusive, and unapologetically more Indian-led innovations enter the mainstream, the message is clear: professional makeup no longer belongs only to backstage artists or influencers. It belongs to everyone—one brushstroke at a time. advertisement
Business Standard
32 minutes ago
- Business Standard
Interarch Building bags Rs 80-cr order from Ather Energy
Interarch Building Solutions announced that it has secured an order worth Rs 80 crore from Ather Energy for the design, engineering, manufacturing, supply, and erection of pre-engineered steel building systems. The project, valued at Rs 80 crore, is scheduled for completion within nine months, with a 10% advance to be paid along with the order. Interarch Building Solutions provides turnkey pre-engineered steel construction solutions in India. Ather Energy is an Indian electric two-wheeler (E2W) company engaged in the design, development, and in-house assembly of electric scooters, battery packs, charging infrastructure, and supporting software systems. On Friday, shares of Interarch Building Solutions added 1.43% to close at Rs 2,061, while shares of Ather Energy rose 0.53% to end at Rs 320.75 on the BSE.
NDTV
36 minutes ago
- NDTV
Indian Workers In Israel Being Forced To Return? What Government Said
New Delhi: The government, putting an end to rumours, said that no Indian workers in Israel would be forced to return to their home country. "A message circulating on social media claiming Indian workers in Israel would be forced to return to India or face jail/fine if they register with the Embassy of India is fake," the Indian Embassy in Tel Aviv said today. It asked citizens not to "believe or forward such misinformation". "Always rely on official updates from @Indemtel (Embassy of India, Tel Aviv) for accurate info," a post on X said. The embassy said that the "registration of Indian nationals in Israel is to enable the Embassy to reach out to them not only in times of crisis but also to help them avail of the various facilities and welfare schemes of the Government of India". This comes amid a heightened tension between Israel and Iran, who have been launching fresh attacks on each other, killing scores of people on both sides. The latest crisis between the longtime foes started more than a week ago when Israel, under its 'Operation Rising Lion', conducted multiple strikes on the territory of Iran, with Tehran also returning fire after warning Israel. Last week, the embassy asked all Indians in Israel to stay vigilant and avoid any unnecessary movement while adhering to the safety protocols issued by the Israeli authorities. Indians have been employed in Israel for decades, thousands as caregivers looking after elderly Israelis, while others work as diamond traders and IT professionals. But since the war in Gaza escalated in 2023, recruiters have launched a drive to bring Indians in for Israel's construction sector also. The drive was a part of the Israeli government's effort to fill a void left by tens of thousands of Palestinian construction workers barred from entering Israel since Hamas' October 7, 2023, attack. Meanwhile, Israeli Ambassador to India, Reuven Azar, has said that his country is in "constant contact" with the Ministry of External Affairs on the subject of the evacuation of Indian nationals from there amid the escalation of conflict with Iran. On Wednesday, India announced the launch of 'Operation Sindhu' to evacuate its nationals from Iran.
