‘The danger gap is so big': woman who witnessed Sydney light rail death calls for safety upgrades
A woman who says she witnessed a pedestrian fatally struck by a Sydney tram earlier this month is calling for safety upgrades to the city's light rail network.
Annalise Gasparre, 27, said she was standing on the opposite platform at a light rail stop on Devonshire Street in Surry Hills to the man in the moments before he died on 5 June.
Police said last week their initial inquiries, including reviewing CCTV footage, showed the man was attempting to cross the light rail track between two carriages when the tram began moving and trapped him.
The man was the second pedestrian to die after being struck by a tram on Sydney's light rail in two years, after the 2023 death of a teenage girl who became trapped underneath a tram while attempting to cross a street in the CBD.
The Sydney Light Rail network includes the L1 Dulwich Hill, L2 Randwick and L3 Kingsford lines, all of which run into the CBD. A new line opened in December, connecting Parramatta with Carlingford.
The L2 and L3 routes use the Citadis X05 Light Rail Vehicles, built by the French manufacturer Alstom. While they are 33m in length, these trams are coupled together on the L2 and L3 routes to form a 66m-long vehicle.
The fatal incident in Surry Hills prompted debate about whether it was safe to operate coupled trams.
Gasparre, who said she saw the pedestrian die, suggested sensors or cameras be added to trams to alert drivers if a person was trapped underneath before they started moving away from a light rail stop.
She also suggested that the yellow line at the edge of the platform at light rail stops should be moved further back.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
She said 'you could fit two people' in between the platform and the joinery between the trams.
'To be honest, I think the light rail design needs to be changed,' she said. 'The danger gap is so big.'
Gasparre said she did not believe the man was trying to cross the tracks, and thinks instead that he had tripped forward and fallen off the platform.
'I hope something in terms of safety will come out of this,' she said.
NSW police on Thursday said the man's death was now a matter for the coroner, who would be reviewing statements from all witnesses.
Dr Liam Davies, a lecturer in sustainability and urban planning at RMIT University, said the two light rail deaths were 'terrible accidents' but the network was 'overwhelmingly' safe.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
However, he said additional safety measures could include installing something to block the gap between the tram carriages, or putting a barrier in the middle of a light rail stop to discourage people from trying to cross the road.
'It would have to be a lower cost, lower tech intervention, like fitting something to the existing trams,' he said.
'The other option is simply to not run them as coupled trams, but that would require a large amount of reorganisation to get more drivers and to redevelop all the timetables to be able to run more trams during peak hour.'
Davies said Sydney's light rail network was much smaller and less complex than Melbourne's, where trams only run in a single fashion rather than being coupled together to form a longer vehicle.
'There's no right or wrong answer,' he said. 'It's got to be really context specific, and usually the context that these types of couple trams get run in are very busy corridors that have a lot of passengers.'
Transport for NSW (TfNSW) said in a statement that the Surry Hills death was 'extremely distressing'
'This incident is now under investigation by NSW Police and Transport for NSW and the operator Transdev are giving their full support,' the statement said.
'The investigation will review what controls were in place, and we can not speculate further on any controls or conditions at this time.
'While the matter is investigated, we are unable to comment further.'
Guardian Australia sought comment from the light rail's private operator, Transdev, on Thursday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
25 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Jack thought he was meeting up with someone he had matched with on a dating app... the truth was much more sinister
An Australian man says he was 'too ashamed' to tell loved ones that he was lured to a date with another man when he was attacked by a group of at least eight teens. Jack Jacobs had made plans on February 9, 2020, to meet someone he met on Grindr, a popular dating application for gay men. When the then-24-year-old arrived at the dinner venue in East Melbourne, he said 'something was off'. 'A group of about eight or nine teenagers ran at me. I tried to run, but they caught up quickly,' he told Daily Mail Australia on Saturday. 'They threw me to the ground and started kicking me repeatedly, including in the head.' He called Triple-0 and a young woman, who saw him distressed, stayed with Mr Jacobs until police and ambulance services arrived. For years, he kept the full details of the incident to himself, explaining: 'I was too ashamed.' 'I lied to my friends and family because I didn't know how to explain what had happened.' Mr Jacobs told most people he had been randomly attacked while walking home, omitting any mention of the date. 'I didn't want anyone to judge me. I was just looking for food, not a hookup. But I knew how people could view it.' On Wednesday, Mr Jacobs shared the full details of the experience during an interview with Network Ten's The Project. 'That was the first time my friends and family knew everything,' he said days later, adding that he had received messages of support from many loved ones. But not everyone was kind, he said: 'One former colleague said, "Knowing Jack, he probably deserved what he got".' Mr Jacobs said he has chosen to come forward now to raise awareness about the dangers of online dating and the responsibility of dating apps. 'What scares me is how common this violence is becoming,' he said. 'After the attack, the person's profile was deleted immediately. They must have blocked me right after. I lost all the evidence, the chats, the photos, everything.' Following the attack, Mr Jacobs was taken to the Alfred Hospital where he was treated for head, wrist and knee injuries. 'They thought my knee was bruised, but later, I learned I'd torn two ligaments. That injury still hurts me today.' In the days following the attack, Jack contacted the police to file a Victims of Crime report but it had never been processed. 'I found out that my statement was never filed. There was no record of it,' he said. Daily Mail Australia has contacted Victoria Police about the alleged incident but has not received specific comment. A police spokesperson did condemn the incident in a statement, saying there is 'no place for this type of concerning behaviour in our society'. 'We treat incidents of this nature with the utmost seriousness and urge anyone who has experienced this behaviour to come forward and make a report to police so we can investigate and track down the offenders responsible,' they said. They also said more than 30 arrests had been made since October 2024, 'in relation to attacks on men linked to the use of dating apps'. On the same day Mr Jacobs spoke to The Project, five Perth boys were jailed for a similar incident. The group of five boys, aged 16 and 17 at the time of the alleged incidents, are believed to have used Grindr to lure men to secluded areas, the ABC reported. Perth Children's Court heard that the boys, who cannot be named as they are underage, then attacked victims with weapons including a knife, machete, a metal bar, pepper spray and a taser. Daily Mail Australia does not suggest the incidents were related in any way, only that Mr Jacobs' account is indicative of an issue experienced by others in the country. Judge Wendy Hughes condemned the teenagers' actions as cruel and calculated, telling the court the behaviour was inexcusable. 'It's really difficult to believe that given your young ages that you would be so cruel to a human being,' she said. All five boys pleaded guilty to multiple charges, including unlawful wounding, assault causing bodily harm, aggravated armed robbery, threats with intent, distribution of an intimate image, and criminal damage. Half a decade on from the incident, Mr Jacobs has said he now thinks twice about using online platforms and struggles to trust the other party. 'I rarely use Grindr anymore. I don't meet people online without thoroughly vetting them,' he said. 'I've become much more cautious and less trusting, and I struggle to be as social as I once was. I've had to move forward the best I can. 'I'm sharing this now because I want people to understand that these things do happen, and no one should feel alone or ashamed if it happens to them. 'There is support out there, and there are people who understand what you're going through. Reaching out for help really does make a difference.'
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
Queensland MP calls for return of vagrancy laws to allow police to prosecute homeless people
A Gold Coast Liberal National party MP has called for the return of vagrancy laws to allow police to prosecute homeless people amid an ongoing crackdown on tent cities in Queensland. Ray Stevens, the member for Mermaid Beach, made the call in a speech to parliament last week. He spoke about the rise of 'presumably homeless people' setting up in tents in 'some of the most sought after locations anyone could wish for – absolute beachfront' in his electorate. 'There are many local voices contacting my office to ask what I am doing to protect their residential amenity. My first call of course is to my local police station,' he said. 'The police reluctantly tell me they have no legislative power to move these people on, which I find incredibly disappointing. The vagrancy act is no longer applicable and unless there is demonstrable public disturbance the police, I am told, cannot move them on. This is unacceptable.' 'It is imperative a solution be found that includes giving law enforcement officers the legislative power to enforce the removal of these illegal camp sites,' he said. The 1931 Vagrants, Gaming, and Other Offences Act made 'having no visible lawful means of support or insufficient lawful means' an offence subject to six months' prison. It also banned begging, public drunkenness, fortune telling, using bad language and more. It was repealed in 2005. South-east Queensland is facing its worst housing crisis in generations, with hundreds living in tent cities or sleeping bags. Councils in the Gold Coast, Moreton Bay and Brisbane have carried out a campaign of clearing the camps in recent months. Council rangers don't have the same powers of detention as arrest, though they can levy a fine and can remove property such as tents from public land. Police typically accompany them during homeless camp clearances but only as a supporting element. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email A University of Queensland law professor, Tamara Walsh – who has long studied laws criminalising homelessness – said police can still charge people with public nuisance offences. But they tend not to because doing so is extremely expensive to the taxpayer, due to the cost of putting an offender through court and jail. 'If people are living in poverty and unhoused, then that is a housing issue. It's a social welfare issue, it's not a criminal law issue,' she said. Walsh said homelessness is typically not a choice, so punishing people for being homeless can't make them stop. 'I wonder how many people would swap their very comfortable, warm home for a beachfront squat at the moment, I certainly wouldn't. Yeah, the view is spectacular, but at night you can't see a thing and all you are is in the freezing cold,' she said. North West Community Group president, Paul Slater, said bringing back the act would be a step in the wrong direction. 'Making homelessness illegal would be a disgrace and would be shameful for our country,' he said. The attorney general, Deb Frecklington, was contacted for comment. The state government is also considering bringing back laws against public drunkenness, contrary to the recommendations of the 1991 royal commission into Aboriginal deaths in custody. Stevens said that he understood 'that there must be solutions to where the homeless people can be moved to' but that he had heard several reports of bad behaviour on the part of the homeless, including one father who saw two of them 'fornicating in the public toilets'. Council rangers moved on a tent city in Rebel Wilson park in the Gold Coast on Tuesday. A few kilometres away, the National Homelessness Conference was being held at the same time.
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
From a rectal kit to a Berlin Wall-era transmitter: the artefacts of Australia's spy museum which doesn't exist
Every morning Mike Pritchard eats breakfast next to a Stasi surveillance rack. The machine, sitting on a couple of milk crates near his dining room table, is composed of colour-coded buttons, switches and dials. It contains a surveillance receiver, a controller for up to 10 receivers, a reel-to-reel tape recorder, and a numbers-station broadcast box. 'The equipment in this rack can be seen in the German film The Lives of Others,' the Sydney man says. 'It's absolutely been used. They used this stuff every day. Remember, this was a police state – they are using this stuff to listen to everybody. This is not a once-a-month thing, it's your day job.' The artefact is not the only piece of espionage history in his home. He has spy cameras once favoured by intelligences services such as the CIA and KGB and a field radio used in the second world war by US women parachuted in behind enemy lines. The really interesting things he keeps off-site in a facility that is packed to the brim – like cipher devices used by the French intelligence services during the Algerian civil war and in Indochina that were once uncrackable; several working enigma machines; a briefcase built to conceal a compact automatic firearm; a bra built to conceal a hidden camera; a rubber stamp from a Berlin Wall checkpoint; and a nameless device built to detect invisible writing. 'The truth is, I think I am a complete nerd,' he says. Sign up for a weekly email featuring our best reads Every so often he extracts these items to photograph them for the Australian Spy Museum's social media feed – an institution which doesn't yet exist but which the 59-year-old is working to make real. Currently, Washington DC and Berlin host the biggest public spy museums in the world, with smaller collections on display in Spain, Latvia and Finland; a private collection of mainly KGB equipment in France that occasionally tours; and some good cryptography museums including in Bletchley Park in the UK and in Moscow. No such institution exists in Australia – something Pritchard wants to change. Australia's intelligence agencies maintain their own in-house 'captive' collections, and a spy camera museum exists outside Cairns. Pritchard is thinking bigger. His museum would span the history of espionage from the Renaissance to recent times, with exhibitions organised around the pillars of spy-craft: cryptography, mass surveillance, covert communications, tradecraft equipment and modern threats. Within each one of those, a collection would track the development of events and technologies over time, from old clockwork devices through to the digital age. Pritchard's collection, which started in 2011 and is now 'well north of 1,500 artefacts' is enough to get started, he says. He won't say what it's worth – 'its value is: 'I don't want my wife to see that in print'' – but it includes artefacts from the intelligence services of the UK, US, France, Russia, Soviet Union, Poland, Romania, Finland, Peru, Kazakhstan, Ukraine, Czech Republic and more, all across different eras. He has also sourced like-models for equipment issued by Australian intelligence services but says agencies such as Asis and Asio have been 'notably scrupulous' at policing their kit and destroying it at end of life. 'We've also never had a big dramatic event like a government collapse or a civil war in our contemporary history that would have allowed some of this stuff to get out,' he says. James Bond may have glamorised espionage, but Pritchard says the franchise is a fantasy that is a 'powerful marketing vehicle for watches and cars', a world away from the reality – which can be less glamorous. Within his collection is a rectal conceal kit, a capsule about the size of a thumb, that contains diamond wire that could be used to cut metal as part of an escape. Another example is a Tochka – a spy camera about the size of a finger – built to be hidden behind a necktie. The Romanian man who sold it to him, he says, was among those who raided the Securitate building, headquarters of a brutal secret police, at the fall of the regime. Sign up to Five Great Reads Each week our editors select five of the most interesting, entertaining and thoughtful reads published by Guardian Australia and our international colleagues. Sign up to receive it in your inbox every Saturday morning after newsletter promotion His favourite artefacts, however, demonstrate an extraordinary blend of prowess and deviousness – like a device used by the Stasi to speak to its operatives across the Berlin Wall using infrared. Unless you were standing inside the beam of light, there was no way to know a conversation was being had – and no way to eavesdrop. 'I can hold in the palm of my hand this tiny object, and it's built with this craftsmanship, this jeweller-like precision that goes into this tiny camera,' Pritchard says. 'And to think about the effort and the work that went into it is extraordinary. And it has its own life as just this beautiful little example of precision engineering, which is then overlaid with its story, its place in history, of these monumental changes in our world.' Any future spy museum, Pritchard says, could also serve as something of a Trojan horse to educate people about modern threats – such as climate change. Among his most prized items are rare, first-edition books and publications charting the development of the theory behind the greenhouse effect. The materials begin with Joseph Fourier, who in 1827 first used the term 'greenhouse effect', and Eunice Foote, who in 1856 performed experiments that demonstrated the greenhouse effect. There are also artefacts once belonging to Guy Callendar, who confirmed the Earth's temperature was rising in 1938, and Roger Revelle, who warned of 'radical climate changes' way back in 1958. 'It's about rebuilding that story on a timeline that ordinary people can walk into and can see, and then go, 'Oh my God, this is what we knew at this point. This is what we knew at this time.'' Governments and intelligence agencies tend to have a particular view about how the past gets told, so Pritchard's preference is a privately owned open museum in Sydney, with its vibrant tourism market. Think of it as 'educational espionage', he says. 'A museum where the Get Smart gadgets are on the surface and everyone goes, 'Wow, a telephone hiding in a shoe!' but then, as they walk through the galleries, they learn about cryptography, or they learn about the security aspects of climate change and they go, 'OK, I never really thought about that before.' 'It's learning by stealth.'
