Ireland is running out of priests. There is an obvious solution
Pope Leo XIV
is by all accounts an excellent organiser. But, at least in Ireland, an obvious question arises: if he sticks to his stated
opposition to what he calls 'clericalising women'
, what is there left to organise? Here,
the pope is a general
with lots of grandly arrayed officers, but no foot soldiers.
If you're my age, the slow vanishing of the clergy is one of those phenomena that happens so inexorably that you can lose sight of their profundity. Even in the 1980s,
Bob Geldof
could, without too much anachronism, wail on the Boomtown Rats' Banana Republic: 'Everywhere I go/ Everywhere I see/ The black and blue uniforms/ Police and priests.' Now that it is almost as hard to spot a priest on the street as it is to see a cop, even us heathens are at a loss: how can one be anti-clerical when there are no clerics?
In the year of my birth, 1958, the
Catholic
sociologist Jeremiah Newman (later bishop of Limerick) wrote in The Furrow that the sheer number of men in black in Ireland 'has meant that some priests have not enough work to do'. According to statistics he compiled, the country had 5,489 priests – one for every 593 Catholics.
And the production line was still working overtime: Maynooth, Clonliffe and the other seminaries were turning out nearly 350 newly minted clerics every year. Italy had 20 seminarians per 100,000 Catholics; France had 22; the US 26. Ireland had an astonishing 75.
READ MORE
This glut meant that Ireland operated a religious trade surplus on a scale that would have enraged
Donald Trump
. Newman reckoned there were an additional 5,000 Irish priests serving abroad. If you factor them in, there would thus have been one Irish priest for roughly every 300 Irish Catholics.
Newman expressed the fear that this superabundance might create resentment: 'It should also be remembered that it is possible for a brand of anti-clericalism to appear, based on nothing more than the fact that the clergy appear too numerous.'
He need not have worried. In 1972 and 1973, the Jesuit sociologist Mícheál Mac Gréil conducted a pioneering survey of the social attitudes of adults in Dublin. They were asked, among other things, to rank how happy they would be to have a member of a particular occupation as a close friend.
At the lowest end of this scale were drug pushers. At the highest were priests. Second were 'members of religious orders'. Similarly, 91 per cent of Dubliners said they would be happy to have a priest as a member of the family, compared with just 81 per cent who said the same for a member of
Fine Gael
. Dubs in general felt more comfortable with men in black than in blue shirts.
This prestige drew on spiritual power, but also on social omnipresence. Priests were not just everywhere – they were in every part of people's lives. In his memoir, the then bishop of Derry Edward Daly, best known for ministering to the dying on the streets of the Bogside on Bloody Sunday, described his job when he was a working priest as encompassing the roles of 'social worker, marriage counsellor, bereavement counsellor and youth counsellor, as well as attempting to deliver a dozen other services that were not strictly related to priesthood'. He was not exaggerating.
There are still priests who do all these jobs and who are held in very high regard by their communities.
But theirs is a dying trade.
In 2022, a study for the Association of Catholic Priests found that of the total of 2,116 diocesan priests in Ireland, 299 (almost 15 per cent) were over 75 and still working, while 547 (over 25 per cent) were between 60 and 75. Conversely, just 52 priests (2.5 per cent) were under 40. There will be almost no one left to replace those who are going. Last November, the Dublin Catholic diocese noted that 'no priest was ordained for the archdiocese this year and only two priests have been ordained for the archdiocese since 2020'.
You don't have to be a devout
Catholic to sense the pathos of this decline
. In 2014, the American priest and writer Donald Cozzens, addressing those who had gathered in the once-mighty seminary at Maynooth to celebrate the jubilee of their ordinations, was brutally frank: 'The respect and trust of past years has been mostly shattered. Good people look at us with a wary eye. We want to say, 'You can trust me. I won't hurt you, nor will I hurt your children.' But trust has been broken.' He posed the existential question: 'Could you men gathered here at the seminary that formed you possibly be the last priests in Ireland?'
[
Author Niamh Ní Mhaoileoin: 'I'll always be angry about the history of the church in Ireland'
Opens in new window
]
They will not literally be so. There will always be at least some priests. But there has been a profound cultural shift.
Colm Tóibín
's exquisitely poignant story A Priest in the Family turns that phrase, once regarded as a blessing by 91 per cent of Dubliners, into a sorrow that haunts an old woman as she learns that her son has been charged with the sexual abuse of some of his pupils. It is hard to see the old meaning ever being restored.
Except, of course, that it is in another sense not hard at all. Looked at objectively, there are few great problems that have such obvious solutions. The church is like a farmer who complains of a diminished crop while ploughing only one depleted field and leaving the rest of the land fallow. It creates its own dearth by refusing to admit married men or any women to the priesthood.
[
Mary McAleese is right to call out Catholic Church over its exclusion of women from ordination
Opens in new window
]
It may be that the sorrow of 'the last priests in Ireland' has no real resonance for the new pope.
Perhaps Ireland
itself has been mentally ditched from Catholic history as a lost cause that is best forgotten. But if lost causes are so easily discarded, why not do the same for the biggest lost cause of them all: the unique sanctity of the celibate male?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
On Sanctuary Sunday, we share a responsibility to oppose hostility towards migrants and asylum seekers
Today many churches will be marking Sanctuary Sunday with prayer and action as part of their contribution to Refugee Week. The positive theme 'community as a superpower' stands in stark contrast to the examples of violence and hostility towards migrants and people seeking asylum we have witnessed across the island of Ireland in recent times. Violence and division harm communities, shattering the sense of safety and undermining efforts to address shared social and economic challenges. We all have a responsibility to speak out against these outrages, in particular our political leaders, who have been elected to serve the whole community. This year, we are encouraged to share the positive experiences of encounter and relationship-building with people who have come to our community from other backgrounds and cultures, particularly those who have come in search of safety. READ MORE Contributing to an informed and respectful public discourse about issues of migration and asylum is vital. No country should hesitate to answer the question of whether it will offer protection and safety to refugees. [ Ukrainians in Ireland succeeding in asylum applications at twice rate of other nationalities Opens in new window ] The UN Refugee Convention of 1951 is a universal obligation and affirms the need to work globally to protect refugees from violence and danger. The number of people seeking asylum in Ireland has been rising in recent years, as in other countries around the world, but is not disproportionate in European terms. As the UN High Commissioner for Refugees says, the vast majority of refugees displaced by the destruction and danger of war take shelter in neighbouring countries, and so what we are seeing in Ireland and the rest of the EU falls far behind the contribution that some Middle Eastern and African nations are making to the global response to the needs of displaced people. Ireland has the resources to respond with compassion to the desperate needs of people seeking asylum. This does not have to be at the expense of the wellbeing of local communities. The theme of 'community as a superpower' reminds us of the vital role of local communities as partners with the Government in this work, and of the importance of respect, consultation and engagement in that relationship. In my experience, local church congregations offer incredible strength in building community. We are neighbourhood based, we work at the street level and we know how to build partnerships. And we live where we work - we don't parachute in. We work with partners across all faiths and beliefs for community development and cohesion. [ Jim O'Callaghan's public theatrics mask the truth about asylum seeker deportations Opens in new window ] We know we are in for a long haul. We contribute to building better relationships and driving change. My current passion, working with Churches Together in Britain and Ireland, is the development of the idea of church of sanctuary. A church of sanctuary goes beyond welcome and stands with and supports vulnerable people such as those who are seeking asylum. It becomes part of the growing city of sanctuary and places of sanctuary networks in Ireland, a community-led movement committed to building cultures of welcome and hospitality with refugees. In a church of sanctuary all members of the congregation intentionally work together to learn about real-life stories of refugees and people seeking sanctuary, and engage with others to work from facts, not fiction and misinformation. They embed the values and cultures of welcome, hospitality and safety as part of being the congregation and use these to support refugees and people seeking sanctuary. They also share their vision, commitment and achievements, and let others know about the positive contributions of refugees to society and the benefits of welcoming others. At a time when vulnerable migrants and refugees are under attack, the church of sanctuary initiative is a constructive response that flows from the values of the Irish church as a Christian community. This Sanctuary Sunday, we pray for a renewed commitment to challenge hostility with hospitality, inspired by a strong local community vision and working together with people of all faiths and no particular religious belief. Inderjit Bhogal is founder of the City of Sanctuary and Church of Sanctuary initiatives
Irish Times
10 hours ago
- Irish Times
Rathmines locals protest over An Post move to sell ‘cultural icon' later this year
Protesters gathered outside Rathmines post office on Saturday morning in a demonstration against its relocation and planned sale of the building. The protest came after An Post this week confirmed its plans to move the Rathmines branch by September, paving the way for the sale of one of the most prominent buildings in the south Dublin suburb. Labour leader and local TD Ivana Bacik organised Saturday's demonstration, alongside local councillors Fiona Connelly and Dermot Lacey. Speaking at the protest, she said the building should be kept 'in community usage', adding that 'our priority is to keep the postal service in the retail hall'. Labour leader Ivana Bacik at the protest in Rathmines on Saturday. Photograph: Ella Sloane The imposing 1934 art deco building will be sold with two other Dublin post offices – Phibsborough and Tallaght – as well as a further three across the State, as part of the 'transformation of the national post office network,' An Post said previously. READ MORE At present, 95 per cent of the country's post offices are already contracted out to independent business owners, who often run post office services as part of a local shop. It is understood the Rathmines post office will move to a Centra store in the locality. Ms Bacik described the demonstration as 'a last-ditch appeal' to Minister for Communications Patrick O'Donovan and Minister for Expenditure Jack Chambers to not sign off on the property's divestment. 'The post office is a very well loved, much-used building. This is very much from the heart.' Ms Connelly stressed the importance of public buildings such as the post office 'as a community asset and a community resource'. Cllr Fiona Connelly at the protest. Photograph: Ella Sloane 'It's really sad to see a resource like the post office, that's in such demand and so heavily used, closing.' Enid O'Dowd, a local and regular user of the postal service, said the decision to sell the building was 'just ridiculous', expressing concern at the pressure the branch's relocation would place on the post office in Ranelagh. Speaking of the branch's speculated move to a nearby Centra, she said the shop 'is going to be a very crushed place with queues spilling out on to the pavement'. 'What's going to happen is people are going to start using the one in Ranelagh but that isn't big enough for the demand. They've only two cashiers there.' Enid O'Dowd at the protest. Photograph: Ella Sloane Cliona Buckley, who grew up on Leinster Road said: 'The last thing they [An Post] should be doing is shutting down memorable, protected, built for purpose buildings. What they should be doing is spending money cleaning up the front of it or they could have lovely potted plants or flower baskets and make it a feature.' She said the post office's planned closure and sale showed a failure by An Post 'to serve the Irish citizens'. Andrew Folan, Mary Freehill and Cliona Buckley at the protest. Photograph: Ella Sloane Another local demonstrator, Andrew Folan, said he felt 'absolutely outraged' by An Post's decision, adding that it was indicative of 'the digitalisation of our culture'. 'The analogue thing of writing letters, posting letters, distributing parcels and meeting the community while you do it is an essential part of our life. I think that the gradual shutting down of post offices is a very negative thing.' Mr Folan pointed to the need for 'a spacious building' due to demand for the service. 'This is a fantastic cultural icon, beautiful design and art deco, well built and a landmark for Rathmines. I think we should celebrate what we've got and show a bit more regard for our culture and our heritage,' he said. Former Labour councillor Mary Freehill, from Rathmines, said the recent loss of the suburb's citizen's information centre in 2022 had already taken a toll on the community. 'There isn't a place for people to come together.' 'Rathmines has very few publicly owned buildings,' said Ms Freehill, adding 'this is the only thing built by the Irish State in Rathmines. All of our other public buildings were built by the British.'
Irish Times
18 hours ago
- Irish Times
Palestine GAA club's planned tour of Ireland ‘under serious threat' due to visa delays
A West Bank GAA club's planned trip to Ireland 'is now under serious threat due to visa delays', representatives have said. At least 33 young Palestinian players are to arrive in Ireland in July to play a series of competitive matches against GAA clubs around the country and to take part in a cultural exchange. GAA Palestine, the organisation behind the tour, said it faced 'new requirements introduced during the [application] process', such as English-language birth certificates for Palestinian players and for coaches born in the West Bank. It further said the Irish embassy in Tel Aviv had closed its public office since Iranian missiles hit the Israeli capital and it was 'not prioritising visa applications ... halting all progress'. READ MORE A total of 46 people, including players, coaches, officials and one doctor, were due to arrive in Dublin on July 18th as part of planned trip by Ramallah-based Moataz Sarsour GAA club. GAA Palestine chairman Stephen Redmond said the new requirements in the visa application process had increased the expected processing time from four weeks to eight after, he said, it was given a 10 week pre-departure time frame to submit all necessary paperwork. It had officially submitted the visa applications on May 19th. Co-founder of GAA Palestine Claire Liddy said 'the embassy responded three weeks later, on Monday, June 9th, with a list of additional required documents'. She said the Irish Representative Office in Ramallah 'refused to accept the original documents' on June 13th. She said as local team members were Palestinian, they were 'banned from travelling to Tel Aviv', so club officials outside the region 'had to scan and send the original documents digitally on Monday, June 16th'. A spokesperson for the Department of Foreign Affairs said: 'The department cannot comment on individual visa applications, but all visa applications are processed in line with established procedures for consideration by the Department of Justice.' The spokesperson said the Irish embassy's public office in Tel Aviv and representative office in Ramallah 'are presently closed due to the security situation and staff are working remotely. The public offices will reopen when circumstances permit'. Mr Redmond criticised what he labelled 'bureaucratic nonsense' and he called 'for common sense to prevail so these young people can step on to a GAA pitch'. He said the group had requested an expedited processing of their application, but that this had not taken place. 'With co-operation from the Department of Foreign Affairs, there is still a chance to issue these visas in time,' he said.
