In the Trump era, where have all the protest songs gone?
Some of the most prominent and popular 21st-century songs with sharp political critiques are from the Black community, including Beyonce's 'Freedom,' Kendrick Lamar's 'Alright,' and Childish Gambino's 'This Is America.' They're all at least seven years old.
No recent music has captured the current political climate, at least not in the way that civil rights anthems of the 1960s, rap hits of the '80s, or even the anti-Bush wave of the '90s and 2000s were able to. Some of those songs dominated the charts and set the cultural tone of social movements. Bob Dylan's 'Blowin' in the Wind,' the Temptations's 'War,' and Marvin Gaye's 'What's Going On' were explicit in their purpose, and all were in the US Billboard Hot 100 Hits. But protest music has been on an inexorable decline since the highs of the '60s and '70s.
Advertisement
President Trump has taken office amid silence, centralizing power and influence while blaring 'YMCA' by Village People. There's plenty to protest: the detainment, without due process, of immigrants nationwide; the blatant self-enriching crypto schemes launched by the Trump family; the struggles of everyday Americans with inflation; even the COVID-19 pandemic (remember the disastrous
'The explanation is simple. You can't make much money off these songs,' Ted Gioia, a prominent music historian,
Protest songs are now often met with indifference from a cautious music industry, while social media have opened up new opportunities to scrutinize even mildly controversial viewpoints. As mainstream audiences have become generally less receptive to musicians promoting causes, many listeners now shrug off entertainers who dabble in activism as performative, or, even worse, preachy.
'It is not just that people have lost faith in any performer to help bring about change, it is that they resent anyone who attempts to do so,' Dorian Lynskey
But as Gioia points out, protest music hasn't totally disappeared — it's just flourishing outside the United States. Beyond the confines of American music charts, movements filled with music are still alive and continue championing global causes.
Today, Palestinian rappers like
Advertisement
In Hong Kong, 'Glory to Hong Kong' became the soundtrack of the 2019 pro-democracy protests and was later
This is the kind of music America needs, especially now that the Trump administration has actively targeted musicians. On May 19, Trump called for a
Some protest music is still being made, such as Nemahsis's 2023 album 'Verbathim' and Macklemore's 2024 single 'Hind's Hall,' both independently released pro-Palestinian projects. But their impact and reach is limited. As Lynskey writes, 'The right question is not, 'Where have all the protest songs gone?' but 'Is anybody listening?''
In the age of filtered algorithms and tailor-made playlists, the only stars with enough cultural cachet to break through audiences' information siloes are juggernauts like Taylor Swift, Lamar, Beyoncé, Post Malone, Charli XCX, and Ariana Grande. They have little financial incentive to protest.
Advertisement
Now Swift and Grande stick to writing about their love lives. Post Malone is playing low-stakes pop country on tour with Jelly Roll. And despite a link with the Harris campaign, Charli XCX's 'Brat' is made for clubbing, not marching.
In this era, if artists are globally popular, they're not singing protest songs. And if they're singing them, they don't reach the mass audiences they might have commanded in previous decades. The levers of mass media influence for political music don't seem to exist anymore, and if listeners want to tune out politics, they can.
'I began this book intending to write a history of a still vital form of music,' Lynskey concludes in an epilogue. 'I finished it wondering if I had instead composed a eulogy.'
Rebecca Spiess can be reached at
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
Beyoncé lights up Paris again on Night 2: New dazzling looks, more special guests
PARIS — Beyoncé Knowles-Carter launched her second show in Paris, and she delivered another high-energy spectacle with new fashion and more special guests. The Grammy-winning singer kicked off her June 21 show at Stade de France in Paris around 8:36 p.m local time. The show marked the second show at the stadium on her Cowboy Carter and the Rodeo Chitlin' Circuit Tour. She is set to hit the stage for the third and final time June 22. 'Y'all are absolutely stunning. Thank you guys for having us tonight. Thank y'all for being here tonight," Beyoncé said as she opened the show. "I'm so thankful for your loyalty for almost 30 years." Beyoncé first launched her tour in Paris on Juneteenth, when fans planned a powerful display at her concert to commemorate the holiday, which celebrates the end of slavery in the United States. View this post on Instagram A post shared by Beyoncé (@beyonce) The night was made especially special when Beyoncé brought out Miley Cryus and the two women sang their beloved duet "II Most Wanted." Dressed in all gold, the Grammy-winning singers held hands and the crowd went wild as Cryus approached the stage. Christian Louboutin spotted at Cowboy Carter Tour! 🤠 — Beyoncé Press. (@beyoncepress) June 21, 2025 Saturday's show proved to be another groundbreaking spectacle filled with new fashion looks and a few changes. And special attendees such as French designer Christian Louboutin were there to witness it. Beyoncé's stunning new opening outfit in Paris night 2. — NotBeyoncebutViolence (@ourhermitage) June 21, 2025 Beyoncé first debuted a new look during the opening number of the show, donning a white ensemble and a matching cowboy hat. OH THIS NEW ALLIGATOR TEARS LOOK CHEWS😭😭😭 — 𝗱𝗮𝗻𝗻𝘆🫧💚 (@beyoncegarden) June 21, 2025 And the new fashion looks continued throughout the entire night. THIS LOOK IS JUST STUNNING😭😭😭 — 𝗱𝗮𝗻𝗻𝘆🫧💚 (@beyoncegarden) June 21, 2025 One fan wrote "New outfit for 'Alligator Tears,' 'Just for Fun,' 'Protector,' and 'Flamenco' — Beyoncé looks incredible!" ANOTHER NEW LOOK JESUS😭😭😭 — 𝗱𝗮𝗻𝗻𝘆🫧💚 (@beyoncegarden) June 21, 2025 And fans noted her outfits weren't the only change. During the show, Beyoncé debuted another special guest: The Mayyas, an alternative dance crew founded by Nadim Cherfan. They performed behind her during 'Protector,' stepping in for her usual dancers. 'We have a special guest tonight. Please give it up for The Mayyas,' Beyoncé told the crowd, and she made sure to shout them out again before the show ended. View this post on Instagram A post shared by The Mayyas مَيّاس 🇱🇧 (@mayyasofficial) Cherfan and the Mayyas have collaborated with Beyoncé before, and many fans were thrilled to see them on stage once again. As fans know, Beyoncé first debuted her "Cowboy Carter" tour at SoFi Stadium in Los Angeles on April 28 with 39 songs on the set list. Her shows have been filled with family, fashion, different music genres, and most notably country music and cultural commentary. "I love you so much Paris. Thank y'all so much," she said toward the end of the concert. "Thank you so much for your energy." The nine-city tour will span the U.S. and Europe with the grand finale taking place in Las Vegas on July 26. Follow Caché McClay, the USA TODAY Network's Beyoncé Knowles-Carter reporter, on Instagram, TikTok and X as @cachemcclay. This article originally appeared on Nashville Tennessean: Beyoncé stuns again Night 2 in Paris: More new looks, special guests
USA Today
7 hours ago
- USA Today
Lynn Hamilton, 'Sanford and Son\
Lynn Hamilton, an actress known for her roles on "Sanford and Son" and "The Waltons," has died. She was 95. Hamilton's death was confirmed in a statement on Facebook and Instagram from her former manager and publicist, Rev. Calvin Carson, who said that the actress died on June 19 "surrounded by her grandchildren, loved ones and caregivers." "With profound gratitude and admiration, we celebrate the extraordinary life of iconic actress Alzenia 'Lynn' Hamilton-Jenkins, whose remarkable legacy continues to uplift and inspire," Carson said. "Her illustrious career, spanning over five decades, has left an indelible mark on the world of entertainment, motivating audiences across the globe through her work as a model, stage, film, and television actress." Hamilton starred as nurse Donna Harris, girlfriend of Fred Sanford (Redd Foxx), on the classic sitcom "Sanford and Son" beginning in 1972. The influential show, which aired on NBC, also starred Demond Wilson and LaWanda Page. Hamilton also portrayed Verdie on the CBS drama "The Waltons," beginning in 1973. She reprised the role in the television movies "A Walton Thanksgiving Reunion" and "A Walton Easter." 'Sanford and Son': Looking back at the 'double-edged' Black sitcom pioneer 50 years later The actress made her on-screen debut in the 1958 John Cassavetes film "Shadows," and throughout her career, she appeared on shows like "Dangerous Women," "Room 222," "Mannix," "Gunsmoke," "Hawaii Five-O," "Good Times," "Starsky and Hutch," "The Rockford Files" and "Roots: The Next Generation." She also starred on the NBC soap opera "Generations." On the film side, Hamilton had roles in movies like "Lady Sings the Blues," starring Diana Ross and Billy Dee Williams, and "Buck and the Preacher," starring Sidney Poitier. Hamilton continued to act into the 2000s with roles on "NYPD Blue," "The Practice" and "Curb Your Enthusiasm." Nathaniel Taylor, best known as Rollo on 'Sanford and Son,' dies at 80 Hamilton was married to writer Frank Jenkins until his death in 2014. They worked together on theater productions such as "Nobody" and "The Bert Williams Story," according to Carson, who said that their "partnership was a shining example of creativity, love, and dedication."
Yahoo
14 hours ago
- Yahoo
R. Kelly's Rep Unfazed By Denial Of Latest Freedom Move
R. Kelly is tunnel-visioned on regaining his freedom despite the latest denial. The R&B singer and his legal team are taking his recent loss in court on the chin with a resolve to bounce back harder and apply more pressure to secure his release. R. Kelly has made several moves towards his freedom lately, including a plea to Donald Trump for clemency due to increasing threats on his life behind bars. The singer's lawyer, Beau B. Brindley, declared that he is not sitting around moping about their loss in court. Instead, he will swing into immediate action by filing a new motion to ensure Kelly's release from prison. The presiding judge, Martha Pacold, threw out Kelly's emergency motion for temporary furlough due to lack of jurisdiction. The motion was reportedly filed in the Northern District of Illinois, where Kelly was sentenced. However, in Kelly's filing, the incidents he cited occurred in Arizona and North Carolina, where he is currently held in custody at the federal prison in Butner. Brindley noted that they had seen the loss coming on technical grounds, but swift recourse would be taken due to the delicate nature of the matter, which, according to him, had Kelly's life hanging by a thread. As reported by PEOPLE, the lawyer commented on the disturbing state of Kelly's health when he visited him on June 18, saying: "Mr. Kelly remains in prison with blood clots in his lungs — this threatens his life every minute that he is denied the surgical intervention (pulmonary embolectomy) that Duke University hospital doctors sought to perform, but were prevented from executing," Brindley claims. The danger could not be more imminent." Brindley had established in his emergency motion that Kelly was placed in solitary confinement after he spoke up as punishment. It was there that Brindley claimed a prison official fed him a toxic mix of substances under the guise of administering him his medication. Assistant U.S. Attorney Jason Julien, however, set the record straight on Brindley's narrative. According to Julien, solitary confinement was activated for Kelly to ensure his protection in prison. Julien reiterated that Kelly is a child molester with records of criminal and sexual abuse against children, which date back to President Bill Clinton's first term in office. The attorney noted that Kelly's crimes had occurred years before he was brought to book, and he has never taken responsibility for his actions or shown remorse. Brindley and his team painted a vivid picture of Kelly struggling for his life after the effects of the dangerous cocktail kicked in. Describing solitary confinement as forcefully imposed on his client, he explained that three prison officials were in on the plan. The Blast shared that the attorney accused the prison officials of hatching a plan to eliminate Kelly with the help of another inmate who had access to him. Kelly reportedly woke up feeling weak and dizzy on June 13 after ingesting the substance the day before. His vision also became blurry, and his knees gave way when he attempted to stand up, causing him to fall. He put in the final push when he crawled up to the door of the cell in a bid to get help, but he lost consciousness while at it. The singer was eventually transported to the Duke University Hospital after prison medical personnel failed to help him. Kelly spent two days in admission before the prison authorities allegedly forcefully extracted him back to prison against the doctor's advice. This is not Kelly's first time pointing accusing fingers at prison officials for their misconduct regarding his case. In 2023, he claimed they collaborated with Tasha K, a famous blogger, to spill sensitive information about his case to the public on the premise that they would get a financial settlement. As a result of this move, Kelly noted that the leaking started in 2019 after they taped his phone calls, visitor logs, email correspondence, and other private information. He added that Tasha K and her team also fabricated stories against him with the access they gained to his records. These false stories and weaponized narratives reportedly caused him psychological stress and emotional discomfort. Kelly and his attorney blamed the United States government for failing to take necessary security precautions and instead granted unbridled access to his details. The "The Storm Is Over" singer's call for clemency unearthed a significant episode in his story, which revolves around his former partner and her current standing with her family. As reported by The Blast, Joycelyn Savage, who was once engaged to the disgraced singer, has been cut off from contact with her family for approximately six years. Her family connected her behavior to the trauma of her experience with Kelly during their time together. The family's attorney, Gerald Griggs, explained that Savage is still under Kelly's mental control and has not found a way to get out of that cycle. The last time she was in direct contact with her family was a brief phone conversation in 2019. Now, her loved ones can only communicate with her representatives, who have also not clarified their connection to her. For the Savage family, 31 years is not even enough for him to face the consequences of his crimes against children and others around him. What will be R. Kelly's next move?
