Lawsuit challenges FTC authority over 'unsubstantiated' advertising claims
June 18 (Reuters) - Hygiene products maker Xlear sued the U.S. Federal Trade Commission on Wednesday, accusing the agency of overstepping its authority to regulate false and deceptive advertising by requiring advertisers to "substantiate" claims about their products.
Xlear, whose products are sold in major U.S. retailers and pharmacy chains, filed the lawsuit, opens new tab in federal court in Utah after the agency in March dropped a four-year-old lawsuit that had accused Xlear of falsely claiming its saline nasal spray could prevent and treat the COVID-19 virus.
The complaint seeks a court declaration that companies do not violate FTC rules by making statements that are allegedly unsubstantiated.
'This lawsuit argues that the FTC is grossly overreaching in its interpretation of the law,' said Rob Housman, an attorney for Xlear. 'The FTC Act doesn't say anything about requiring companies to have 'substantiation.''
The Federal Trade Commission declined to comment.
Xlear in its lawsuit cited a U.S. Supreme Court ruling in 2024, Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, that overturned a key 1984 precedent requiring judges to give deference to agencies in their interpretation of the laws they administer.
Housman said that under the justices' ruling an agency 'can't just invent new rules not found in the law.'
The FTC's lawsuit in 2021 alleged Xlear had no scientific or factual basis to make its COVID claims, and said the company's alleged deceptive advertising and misinformation 'to sell their product to concerned consumers during a pandemic poses a risk to public health and safety.'
In seeking dismissal of that case, Xlear denied making any deceptive statements.
Xlear said it spent upwards of $3 million defending itself against the FTC in what the company called "vexatious litigation."
The FTC did not provide a reason for dropping the case earlier this year.
The case is Xlear Inc v. Federal Trade Commission, U.S. District Court, District of Utah, No. 2:25-cv-00484.
For plaintiff: Robert Housman of Book Hill Partners, Evan Strassberg of Michael Best & Friedrich and Ronald Price of Price Parkinson & Kerr
For defendant: No appearance yet
Read more:
US agencies face fees over faulty cases, Ford seeks $300 million from lemon law lawyers
US appeals court orders revised penalty in FTC 'Do Not Call' case
US Supreme Court curbs federal agency powers, overturning 1984 precedent
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
42 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
America crowns new favorite restaurant chain as LongHorn Steakhouse dethroned by bitter rival
Texas Roadhouse has been named America's favorite restaurant — beating the likes of Chili's, Olive Garden and its big steakhouse rival. It has beaten longtime rival LongHorn Steakhouse to claim the top spot on the closely watched American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI) for sit-down restaurants. The two steakhouses, which both scored 84 on the 2024 list, are now separated by a single point — with Texas Roadhouse notching 84 and LongHorn falling just behind at 83. Olive Garden was third with 81, and Applebee's and Cracker were fourth with 80. Outback Steakhouse, the third major US steakhouse chain, also cracked the top 10 despite a lower satisfaction score of 79, tied with Red Lobster. Chili's was eighth, along with IHOP and Red Robin, with 78. Both Texas and LongHorn had a bumper 2024 as they benefited from inflation-weary Americans seeking out good value meals. They both offer a steak, potatoes and vegetables for $20 to $25. Despite a rocky start to 2025 — including a sluggish 2.9 percent sales gain and weather-related closures — Texas Roadhouse, actually founded in Indiana, has maintained its value positioning in the face of inflation and tariffs imposed by President Donald Trump. LongHorn experienced a 4.3% increase in customer traffic and operates over 500 restaurants worldwide Texas Roadhouse, which was founded nearly 30 years ago, now operates 655 restaurants across the United States. LongHorn, owned by Darden Restaurants, has grown into a global steakhouse empire with more than 500 locations worldwide since opening its first restaurant 44 years ago. Their success comes as many competitors falter. Both chains have overtaken Outback Steakhouse in sales In terms of sales, both have overtaken Outback Steakhouse — a dramatic shift for a brand that once dominated the casual steakhouse scene, fueled by the late-1980s Australian craze sparked by Crocodile Dundee. Sales have also fallen at Olive Garden, Starbucks, and TGI Friday's. Last year, Olive Garden also lost its position as the top-grossing US restaurant brand — a spot it had held for seven consecutive years — to Texas Roadhouse. The Italian-inspired chain — famous for its bottomless breadsticks and carb-heavy comfort food, also faced internal turmoil, including employee walkouts over new uniform policies. Meanwhile, Applebee's has been in a prolonged period of contraction, shuttering roughly 300 restaurants between 2016 and 2023 amid rebranding efforts and broader financial challenges. Texas Roadhouse is focusing on offering various low-priced entrees Red Lobster, ranking number eight on the list, closed hundreds of restaurants last year after filing for bankruptcy and exited last September after being purchased by asset manager Fortress. Chili's pulled off ' the best comeback of all time,' and landed in a three-way tie with IHOP and the struggling Red Robin chain. Its next entries, The Cheesecake Factory and Buffalo Wild Wings have had slight dips in sales this year, but not big enough to put them at risk of bankruptcy. Denny's concludes the list with a score of 75, which came after shuttering dozens of restaurants and implementing an egg surcharge. The ACSI rankings, considered a key benchmark of consumer sentiment across major industries, are closely monitored by investors and analysts for signs of shifting brand loyalty and operational performance.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Small business owners aren't jumping for joy about the US economy – but they still aren't jumping ship
Small businesses in the US account for approximately half of the country's jobs, so when small businesses are doing well, it's likely that the economy is doing well. Media reports recently indicated that many small businesses are challenged by Trump's tariffs, ongoing inflation, labor shortages and higher financing costs. So how are small businesses doing so far in 2025? Not great. But not that bad either. In just the past two months, there have been no less than seven comprehensive surveys conducted by well-known companies and brands that altogether surveyed or drew from their internal data of tens – even hundreds – of thousands of small businesses. And they give a pretty good idea of how they're doing. Wealth management firm Principal Financial's Well-Being Index from June found that 56% of the companies they surveyed reported business growth and 90% of employers have either maintained or grown their workforce over the past year, with 49% increasing wages in just the past three months. However, optimism remains tempered by a weakening outlook on future economic growth and many have reported 'significant declines' in the financial health of their business, their local economy and the US economy, 'eroding the sense of optimism expressed in years past'. According to a survey by accounting giant EY, 95% of those polled were 'confident in business growth' over the next year. Additionally, 73% of entrepreneurs reported experiencing revenue growth this year compared with last year, with 29% reporting growth of 20% or higher. However, 43% said that current economic conditions are hurting them, but many still plan to pursue funding and strategic transactions, with investment in AI and M&A considerations leading the list. Software provider Intuit's QuickBooks Small Business Index draws on actual information from its customers, derived from anonymized employment and payroll data. The company found that job growth among small businesses – the great majority of their customer base – was stable with employment increasing in seven of the 12 sectors tracked. That's good, but unfortunately the study also found that average real monthly revenue for small businesses with one to nine employees decreased about 0.06% from the month before. Like Intuit, HR services giant Paychex said in its Small Business Employment Watch reports that job growth derived from its 350,000-plus customer database in May 'stayed flat' month over month and hourly earnings growth decreased to a four-year low. 'Caution persists' in both wage and hiring trends. The closely watched Small Business Optimism Index published monthly by the National Federation of Small Businesses reported a tick up in small business optimism in May to a level above its 51-year average. The survey found that the top concerns of the federation's members shifted from inflation to taxation and that although sales expectations and hiring plans are 'improving', uncertainty remains. Finally, in its June Small Business Perspective report, US Bank said that 96% of the small business owners it surveyed reported their business as currently successful and 88% saw growth in the past year. Two-thirds said the country's economy is 'moving in the right direction', with only 18% saying it's going in the wrong direction. Interestingly, this sentiment was even stronger among younger business leaders (gen Z and millennial), with 74% saying it was moving in the right direction, versus 52% of leaders from older generations (gen X and boomer). Although four out of five owners felt at least 'somewhat stressed' about tariffs, those leaders were 'slightly more likely to anticipate a positive rather than negative impact'. My take? Despite all the headwinds and uncertainties such as tariffs, federal and local policies, geopolitical conflicts, inflation, labor shortages and other challenges – small businesses, so far, in 2025 remain optimistic about the future and are maintaining employment levels mostly reporting average financial results. Few are jumping for joy. But it seems that fewer are jumping off the ship.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Cook up your favorites with $70 off the legendary KitchenAid 9-speed hand mixer with multiple attachments: 'This is the best mixer EVER'
Imagine using just one tool to make meal preparation easier. There's a huge reason why thousands of shoppers consider the KitchenAid 9-Speed Digital Hand Mixer their go-to for countless tasks in the kitchen. Whipping? Shredding? Stirring? Kneading? Fluffing? Blending? Let's just say this device does it all — and it won't set you back. Normally $109, it's currently reduced to just $89.98. Enter code WELCOME20 to score an extra $20 off your first order, bringing your total to just $69.98. KitchenAid 9-Speed Digital Hand Mixer Snap up this game-changing small appliance for a huge discount! It comes with Flex Edge Beaters, dough hooks, a Pro Whisk, and a Blending Rod, and is equipped with nine speeds to simplify any task in the kitchen. Available in your choice of three gorgeous colors (red, silver, and white), it's on sale right now — and when you enter WELCOME20 at checkout you can score it for an extra $20 off! $69.98 (was $109) Shop You don't need to be a skilled chef to use this handy small appliance. In fact, it's perfect for novices and experts alike. It comes with everything that you need to perform assorted steps, all while speeding up and streamlining preparation. You'll get a pair of Flex Edge Beaters, ideal for handling everything from batter-blending to swirling ingredients together. Two dough hooks recreate the act of kneading, which can be a game-changer if you find that a tiring task. With these hooks, you'll save time and spare yourself the discomfort, too. Also included is a Pro Whisk, which masterfully whips up everything from cream to egg whites and leaves everything gorgeously fluffy and light. And with the Blending Rod, you can create all of your favorite sauces, creams, broths, dressings, and other liquid dishes with ease. KitchenAid has a lock on small appliances that simplify cooking, and this beautifully designed hand mixer is no exception. The beauty of the device is that it's equipped with a whopping nine speeds, allowing you precise control of every task. That's crucial when you need to mix ingredients lightly or are slowly incorporating dry ingredients into a mixture. The device makes it easier than ever to follow your recipes' directions to the letter. It's even got a handy Soft Start feature, which is absolutely essential for preventing the unnecessary splattering that otherwise leaves your surfaces a mess. That's no longer an issue here! Ready to change the attachment? Just press the oversized ejector to swap the existing one for another. It's quick, easy, and won't slow you down while you're preparing dishes. Unsurprisingly, KitchenAid's 9-Speed Digital Hand Mixer is stylish, too. Like the brand's legendary mixers, this handheld model comes in assorted colors like Empire Red, White, and Contour Silver. All are dazzling shades that fit nicely into any kitchen. Is it any wonder that shoppers love it so much? It boasts over 1,200 five-star reviews, with plenty of people expressing delight for its efficacy, speed options, and design. 'This is the best mixer ever!' exclaimed one user. 'Love the quiet operation. It's the best. I would buy again!' 'I love it,' declared another. 'Works great and looks beautiful. Powerful and quiet! It makes one-hand operation much easier. Cord wrap is a very nice feature, too!' Take this as your sign to upgrade your kitchen. Snap up the KitchenAid 9-Speed Digital Hand Mixer while it's on sale for this super low price — you can't beat it!
