Apple must pay Optis $502 million lump sum in UK patent dispute, court rules
LONDON:
Apple
must pay a U.S. patent holder $502 million for the use of
4G patents
in devices including iPhones and iPads, London's Court of Appeal ruled on Thursday, in the latest stage of a long-running legal battle.
Texas-based Optis Cellular Technology LLC sued Apple in London in 2019 over its use of patents which Optis says are essential to certain technological standards, such as 4G.
London's High Court ruled in 2023 that Apple should pay Optis a total of $56.43 million plus interest to cover past and future sales over a set period.
But Optis argued that was far too low and challenged the decision at an appeal heard in February and March.
The Court of Appeal said in a partially-redacted written ruling that Apple should pay a lump sum of $502 million, not including interest, for the period from 2013 to 2027.
The lump sum relates to a global licence to use Optis' patents.
An Apple spokesperson said they were "disappointed by this decision and plan to appeal".
"Optis makes no products and their sole business is to sue companies using patents they buy," the spokesperson added. "We will continue to defend against their attempts to extract unreasonable payments."
Optis did not immediately respond to a request for comment outside U.S. office hours.
Thursday's ruling is the latest decision in the legal battle between Apple and Optis over the FRAND (fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory) terms to use Optis' patents.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
I for…? You'll be amazed to know what the ‘i' in iPhone stands for!
I for interesting, I for intriguing, I for invigorating! But what does the 'i' stand for in iPhones? Is it the internet? Or is it the personal pronoun, with a wee bit of narcissism attached to it Nearly two decades after the debut of the first iPhone, Apple enthusiasts continue to ponder a curious question: What does the enigmatic 'i' stand for? Throughout Apple's journey, the letter 'i' has graced a multitude of its iconic products, from the iPod and iPhone to the iMac and iPad. At this point, this branding has become more than just a letter; it has evolved into a powerful symbol of the company's innovative spirit. Over time, fans and users on social media have concocted various theories to decode the meaning behind the 'i.' Many believe it connects to the internet, hinting at the groundbreaking capabilities these devices offered. Others suggest it represents the personal pronoun 'I,' emphasizing the individual user's experience. Speculation also swirls around concepts like intelligence, information, and even a nod to the operating system, 'iOS'. One internet user on X playfully proposed that it stands for 'individual,' as in the unique devices tailored for personal use. When asked about the meaning of 'i' in the Apple products, Grok, the a generative artificial intelligence chatbot developed by xAI, came up with a concise response, saying, 'The "I" in iPhone likely stands for Internet, individual, instruct, inform, and inspire, as Steve Jobs explained during the 1998 iMac launch. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Free P2,000 GCash eGift UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo These meanings reflect Apple's focus on connectivity, personalization, guidance, information, and innovation. However, Apple hasn't officially confirmed a single definition, leading to speculation like intelligence or iOS. The flexibility of the "I" seems intentional, fueling ongoing debate.' However, the internet has different opinions, as some users strongly suggested that the 'i' in the iPhone stood for 'idiot', saying, 'To save you time reading the article, it stands for "idiot." The late Steve Jobs, Apple's visionary founder and the mastermind behind the iPhone, did shed some light on this mystery before his passing in 2011. As reported by Reader's Digest, the 'i' in Apple's pioneering product, the iMac, originally highlighted its cutting-edge internet technology when it launched in 1998. At the time, the idea of a computer with robust internet capabilities was revolutionary, and Apple wanted to celebrate that leap in innovation. However, as Apple flourished, so did the meaning of the 'i.' Jobs later revealed that it could encompass a range of interpretations. In addition to signaling internet connectivity, he suggested that it could personify concepts such as individualism, instruction, information, and inspiration—all qualities central to Apple's mission. He even hinted at the idea of 'I' as representing the personal connection users have with their devices, as well as the educational potential they harness. Now, with the latest enhancements in Apple's AI technology integrated into newer iPhone models, the concept of 'intelligence' becomes an increasingly fitting interpretation of this iconic letter. Ultimately, according to Jobs, the 'i' was never meant to be pinned down to a single definition; rather, it encapsulated the essence of innovation, inspiration, and the visionary nature of the Apple brand. Today, as customers continue to explore the fascinating world of Apple products, the mystery of the 'i' remains a testament to the company's ever-evolving legacy. What Was I Made For?
Time of India
6 hours ago
- Time of India
2 new Aavin dairies to double supply
Chennai: With Gujarat-based Amul slowly firming up its dairy footprint in Tamil Nadu, the state govt-run Aavin has begun ramping up its infrastructure in Chennai after several years. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Two new dairies — one in Madhavaram with a capacity of 10lakh litres a day and another in Acharapakkam of 1 lakh litre capacity — are set to begin operations by March 2026, effectively doubling Aavin's current milk supply potential in Chennai to 22 lakh litres a day, said A Annadurai in response to a grievance letter from the Tamil Nadu Milk Dealers and Workers Welfare Union. The move comes days after Amul managing director Amit Vyas told reporters here that the brand, already selling curd in Chennai, will "slowly and steadily enter into the milk segment" through its plant in Chittoor. Though Chennai, with a population of more than one crore, is a high-potential dairy market, Aavin's current daily sales in the city hover around just 11 lakh litres. Private dairies, despite commanding higher prices, have a stronger presence. Many brands have increased prices by 2 to 3 thrice in the past year, without prior notice or justification. "Aavin's Green Magic, a standardized variant, is in high demand. But it's restricted to monthly cardholders. At retail outlets, agents push the full cream 'premium' or toned 'nice' packs, which don't suit our morning coffee," said T Sadagopan, a resident-activist from Pattabiram. "Aavin should promote what consumers actually prefer, not what offers them higher margins." Beyond sales, Aavin's response letter also addressed environmental concerns raised by the union. The Ambattur dairy, one of its key units, was flagged for polluting the Korattur lake. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Aavin said that its sewage treatment plant, earlier operating at 3.3 lakh litre a day capacity, is being upgraded to 7 lakh litres a day, with the new facility expected to go live by the end of 2025. Indian Institute of Technology Madras has certified the treatment unit's current output at 700 KLD, and formal approvals from the pollution control board for capacity expansion are under process. On the procurement front, Aavin released 342.14 crore in procurement incentives since Dec 2023, directly credited to dairy farmers through cooperative unions. Dealers too have been seeking a revision in commission rates, which currently stand at 1.5 a litre for retail sellers and 2 for wholesale. Aavin has said the revision will be considered when milk prices are restructured.
Time of India
7 hours ago
- Time of India
Less than 100 days to go, Kumartuli readies Durga idols for foreign shores
1 2 Kolkata: The festive fervour of Durga Puja may still be a little over three months away, but the idol makers' enclave in Kumartuli is already abuzz with activity. The artisans are racing against time, giving finishing touches to several idols — not for local pujas, but to meet the international demand. Several batches of idols have already been shipped to United States (US), the United Kingdom (UK), Canada, and Australia, among other countries where the Bengali diaspora organises Durga Puja celebrations. According to the Kumartuli Mritshilpi Sanskritik Samity, more than 200 idols have already been sent abroad this season, and dozens more are at various stages of completion. The first idol was dispatched as early as Jan this year, to Sydney. "This year, I have already dispatched five large idols to various cities in the US and the UK," said Bikash Pal, an idol maker. "It takes time to pack the idols securely and get the necessary customs clearances. The shipping itself can take weeks, so we begin much earlier," he added. Some idols are sent by air, too. Mintu Pal, another artisan, has dispatched several idols to Canada, Germany, France, Poland, and Italy. "The price starts from Rs 1 lakh . by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Florida New Policy For Senior Drivers The Quote General Learn More Undo This is excluding the expenses for packaging and travel," said Pal, who was busy giving finishing touches to an idol. Potters admit that the number of orders has increased over the past decade. "Earlier, we would only get a handful of overseas orders. Now, the international orders come months in advance," said Koushik Ghosh, who dispatched an idol to Sydney in Jan. The increasing number of orders has not only changed the production timeline but also the economic dynamics of Kumartuli. Artisans say that overseas clients are often willing to pay more as the idols have to be customised. The increased income has led to more stable employment for workers and assistants, who previously relied only on seasonal work. However, the international orders also come with specific challenges. "We have to follow strict guidelines for height, weight, and materials due to shipping constraints," explained Bikash Pal, adding that some idols need to be assembled on-site. Preparations for local pandals have also begun. Full-scale activity for Kolkata-based pujas is expected to pick up by first week of July.
