Bates urges Horizon victims to take Government to court over redress delays
Sir Alan Bates has urged victims of the Horizon scandal to take the Government to court over delays to financial redress.
In an email sent to members of campaign group Justice For Subpostmasters Alliance (JFSA), seen by the PA news agency, Sir Alan said a judicial review would 'probably be the quickest way to ensure fairness for all'.
He told the group it would likely take until November 2027 for all claims to be completed.
More than 900 subpostmasters were prosecuted between 1999 and 2015 after faulty Horizon accounting software made it look as though money was missing from their accounts.
Many are still awaiting compensation despite the previous government announcing that those who have had convictions quashed are eligible for £600,000 payouts.
Sir Alan told JFSA members it was 'time for others to step up', adding: 'Hopefully you'll all agree I've done my bit.'
Christopher Head, who became the Britain's youngest subpostmaster in 2006 at the age of 18, offered his assistance in taking the Department for Business and Trade (DBT) to court because he had already aired his case 'out in public on purpose to be transparent'.
In his 'JFSA Circular', Sir Alan described the group litigation order (GLO) scheme, which was set up to achieve redress for the 555 claimants who took the Post Office to the High Court between 2017 and 2019, as a 'mess'.
In his email, Sir Alan said: 'There may be other options but the one which is repeatedly mentioned is a judicial review, not just for the GLO scheme but to include all of the schemes to ensure there is parity in the way victims have, and are, being treated.
'Returning to the courts may seem to be a long haul, but it will probably be (the) quickest way to ensure fairness for all.'
His email added: 'I do know many of you who have already settled have done so out of desperation or despair or because you have been backed into a corner to accept an offer.
'Well a new legal action may well be a way of having your claim reassessed once more, this time by the courts.'
Referring to the GLO scheme, Sir Alan said: 'Quite simply the scheme is a mess, and has been almost since the time of its inception.
' Advice on how to streamline and speed up the scheme which has been offered to the DBT by ourselves, your lawyers and even the DBT select committee is ignored out of hand with the feeblest of excuses.
'And unfortunately it does seem that the GLO scheme is not the only scheme in dire straits, it seems all the financial redress schemes are being similarly affected by common failures with their administration and application.'
His email also said a national fundraising campaign may be needed to cover any potential legal costs.
A Government spokesman said: 'We pay tribute to all the postmasters who have suffered due to the Horizon software over the past 25 years and are continuing to work at pace to ensure all postmasters receive the financial redress and justice they deserve.
'However, we do not accept this forecast.
'The facts show we are making almost 90% of initial GLO offers within 40 working days of receiving completed claims. As of 31 March, 76% of the group had received full and final redress, or 80% of their offer.
'So long as claimants respond reasonably promptly, we would expect to settle all claims by the end of this year.
'We have trebled the number of payments under this Government and are settling claims at a faster rate than ever before to provide full and fair redress.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
25 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Starmer slashes net zero charges to save Britain's factories
Net zero taxes will be slashed for thousands of manufacturers as Sir Keir Starmer scrambles to save British industry from crippling electricity costs. As part of the Government's long-awaited Industrial Strategy, the Prime Minister is to cut power bills by up to 25pc for some 7,000 'electricity intensive' manufacturers, including car makers, aircraft factories and chemical plants. From 2027, they will no longer have to pay the net zero levies that are normally added to their power bills, such as the renewables obligation, the feed-in-tariff and capacity market charges. This will be paid for by financial reforms to the energy market and a raid on companies that burn natural gas, through higher carbon taxes, the Government said. However, the support was at risk of being diluted on Sunday as Iran's threat to cut off a vital oil and gas supply route in the Middle East risked sending energy prices around the globe soaring. It comes after repeated warnings that British manufacturers are labouring under the highest industrial electricity prices of any developed country, with output down by a third since 2021. Sir Keir's announcement was welcomed by manufacturers, including Derby-based Rolls Royce, as a 'giant and much needed step forward'. The Prime Minister said: 'This Industrial Strategy marks a turning point for Britain's economy and a clear break from the short-termism and sticking plasters of the past. 'In an era of global economic instability, it delivers the long term certainty and direction British businesses need to invest, innovate and create good jobs that put more money in people's pockets as part of the plan for change. 'Our message is clear – Britain is back and open for business.' The Government said its new support scheme is expected to save qualifying firms about £40 per megawatt hour (MWh). That would bring their costs closer to EU competitors. According to data from the International Energy Agency, UK businesses paid an average of £258 per MWh for power in 2023 compared to £218 in Italy, £178 in France and £177 in Germany. Companies in the US paid just £65 on average. At the same time, support for traditional heavy industry businesses – such as steel makers, glass blowers and chemical producers – will also be beefed up further, meaning their savings will likely be even greater. These firms already benefited from the so-called 'British Industrial Supercharger', which exempted them from various charges on their power bills. But from next year, their discount on network charges will be increased from 60pc to 90pc. The Government said the changes would cost an estimated £2bn over four years, or about £500m a year. But a spokesman insisted that it would not be paid for via extra charges on households, either through bills or taxes. Instead it will be raised via energy market reforms such as changes to contracts for difference – subsidies used to support wind and solar farms – and higher carbon prices, which are levied on businesses for their carbon emissions. However, with the support targeted at electricity prices, companies that use gas are likely to foot at least some of the bill through the higher carbon pricing that ministers have announced. A spokesman for the business department added that 'energy market reforms' will also pay for the changes, including longer subsidy agreements with wind farms – aimed at bringing the overall cost for power down. The changes would not mean lower funding for renewable energy schemes, the spokesman added. Under the long-awaited Industrial Strategy, a centrepiece of Labour's economic plans, Sir Keir has also announced billions of pounds of extra support for key industries, investment in skills training, reduced red tape, higher research and development spending, and changes to migration and visa rules to attract 'elite global talent'. This will see the British Business Bank's war chest for investment increase to £25.6bn, the Government said, with billions more ploughed into 'sector plans' for advanced manufacturing, clean power, creative industries, digital industries, and professional and business services such as law firms and consultants. Mike Hawes, chief executive of the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, said: 'The publication of an Industrial Strategy – one with automotive at its heart – is the policy framework the sector has long-sought and the Government has now addressed. 'The number one priority must be addressing the UK's high cost of energy, enabling the sector to invest in the technologies, the products and the people that will give the UK its competitive edge.' Tufan Erginbilgic, chief executive of Rolls-Royce, one of Britain's biggest manufacturers, said: 'The UK Government's Industrial Strategy commitment to support our world-leading aerospace and nuclear industries shows long-term strategic foresight.'
Rhyl Journal
2 hours ago
- Rhyl Journal
Swinney urged to increase powers for authorities in bid to tackle knife crime
On Sunday, a march against knife violence took place throughout the streets of Glasgow. The Parents Against Knives were joined on the march, which started at 1pm, by the family of Kory McCrimmon, who died after an attack involving a bladed weapon on May 31 2024. His family previously said the 16-year-old's life 'will not be in vain' as they urged others to join the march. The 16-year-old died after he was found seriously injured in Greenfield Park in the east end of Glasgow. A 14-year-old was last month sentenced to five years' detention after admitting culpable homicide. Speaking from Barrowfield Community Centre in Glasgow, Kory's father, Neil McCrimmon, told the PA news agency that knife crime has always been a problem in Scotland, but said it has changed in recent years, and that the Scottish Government must act to address the problem. He said: 'Knife crime has always been here, there's no getting away from that. If you go back to the 60s, 70s, 80s, and 90s, but it's different today. 'This is our children we're talking about, and this is where Mr Swinney needs to make changes. 'They say we should protect children, and by all means we have. 'We've got to safeguard them in every manner, but my point to Mr Swinney is, who is saving the children from the children?' He added: 'And this is the thing, we've not got any deterrent, and the courts, they're no deterrent.' He said the Scottish judicial system's 'hands are tied' with current sentencing guidelines for minors who have committed serious offences, and that the penalty served his son's killer is 'not justice'. He added: 'In my day, you did the crime, you did the time, and that's all we ask for: justice, and justice hasn't been served in our case. 'The other matter is the police. Mr Swinney will tell you the police have got their powers, but the police will tell you they haven't. They've not got the powers when it comes to children. 'So Mr Swinney, give the police their powers, make a difference, that is all we ask.' The march was organised by Kory's aunt, Jackie McTaggart, who says she wants to set up a meeting with the First Minister as a starting point to tackling knife crime, particularly among youths. She said: 'We want to speak to the First Minister and the Justice Secretary, so we're hoping we'll get that soon, and now we've said it publicly in the media. 'We're hoping that's the next step, so we can sit and speak to them and get everybody involved, like the police, the social work department, the youth workers, the school teachers, everybody. 'If we get them all working with our youth, then hopefully we can make a change and make a difference.' The march came in the wake of the deaths of teenagers Amen Teklay and Kayden Moy in separate incidents in recent weeks. Two boys aged 14 and 16 have appeared in court charged with murder following the death of 15-year-old Amen in the Maryhill area of Glasgow on March 5. Kayden, 16, was found seriously injured on Irvine beach in North Ayrshire after police were called to the area at about 6.45pm on May 17. A 14-year-old boy and two 17-year-old boys have appeared in court charged with murder following his death. The Parents Against Knives march set off from Rangers' Ibrox stadium and those taking part were walking to Celtic Park in the east end of the city. Kate Wallace, chief executive of Victim Support Scotland, said: 'Too many lives are being devastated by knife crime in Scotland. 'Behind every statistic, hundreds of lives are irreversibly impacted with tragic consequences for everyone involved: family, friends, siblings, school mates and the wider communities in which we all live. 'We support the Parents Against Knives walk, organised entirely by the McCrimmon family in memory of their son Kory, which will undoubtedly help draw attention to this growing crisis. 'These are complex and sensitive situations which require a multi-agency response from the Scottish Government, victim support organisations, police, social work, youth work and others to work together to tackle knife crime and the devastation it causes. People across Scotland deserve to feel safe in their own communities.' Mr Swinney said: 'We stand in solidarity with all those who took part in the Parents Against Knives march in Glasgow and my heartfelt condolences go to Kory McCrimmon's family and every family who has suffered unimaginable loss due to knife crime. 'As a father, I find the thought of any parent having to endure the grief and trauma of losing a child to knife crime utterly heartbreaking. Glasgow is united and Scotland is united in wanting these horrific incidents to stop. 'We owe it to every family affected to take meaningful action. That's why we have increased investment in prevention, support and enforcement; from record funding for Police Scotland to vital work by Medics Against Violence and the Scottish Violence Reduction Unit. We stand with the families marching and we are committed to driving the change that keeps our young people safe.'
Leader Live
2 hours ago
- Leader Live
Swinney urged to increase powers for authorities in bid to tackle knife crime
On Sunday, a march against knife violence took place throughout the streets of Glasgow. The Parents Against Knives were joined on the march, which started at 1pm, by the family of Kory McCrimmon, who died after an attack involving a bladed weapon on May 31 2024. His family previously said the 16-year-old's life 'will not be in vain' as they urged others to join the march. The 16-year-old died after he was found seriously injured in Greenfield Park in the east end of Glasgow. A 14-year-old was last month sentenced to five years' detention after admitting culpable homicide. Speaking from Barrowfield Community Centre in Glasgow, Kory's father, Neil McCrimmon, told the PA news agency that knife crime has always been a problem in Scotland, but said it has changed in recent years, and that the Scottish Government must act to address the problem. He said: 'Knife crime has always been here, there's no getting away from that. If you go back to the 60s, 70s, 80s, and 90s, but it's different today. 'This is our children we're talking about, and this is where Mr Swinney needs to make changes. 'They say we should protect children, and by all means we have. 'We've got to safeguard them in every manner, but my point to Mr Swinney is, who is saving the children from the children?' He added: 'And this is the thing, we've not got any deterrent, and the courts, they're no deterrent.' He said the Scottish judicial system's 'hands are tied' with current sentencing guidelines for minors who have committed serious offences, and that the penalty served his son's killer is 'not justice'. He added: 'In my day, you did the crime, you did the time, and that's all we ask for: justice, and justice hasn't been served in our case. 'The other matter is the police. Mr Swinney will tell you the police have got their powers, but the police will tell you they haven't. They've not got the powers when it comes to children. 'So Mr Swinney, give the police their powers, make a difference, that is all we ask.' The march was organised by Kory's aunt, Jackie McTaggart, who says she wants to set up a meeting with the First Minister as a starting point to tackling knife crime, particularly among youths. She said: 'We want to speak to the First Minister and the Justice Secretary, so we're hoping we'll get that soon, and now we've said it publicly in the media. 'We're hoping that's the next step, so we can sit and speak to them and get everybody involved, like the police, the social work department, the youth workers, the school teachers, everybody. 'If we get them all working with our youth, then hopefully we can make a change and make a difference.' The march came in the wake of the deaths of teenagers Amen Teklay and Kayden Moy in separate incidents in recent weeks. Two boys aged 14 and 16 have appeared in court charged with murder following the death of 15-year-old Amen in the Maryhill area of Glasgow on March 5. Kayden, 16, was found seriously injured on Irvine beach in North Ayrshire after police were called to the area at about 6.45pm on May 17. A 14-year-old boy and two 17-year-old boys have appeared in court charged with murder following his death. The Parents Against Knives march set off from Rangers' Ibrox stadium and those taking part were walking to Celtic Park in the east end of the city. Kate Wallace, chief executive of Victim Support Scotland, said: 'Too many lives are being devastated by knife crime in Scotland. 'Behind every statistic, hundreds of lives are irreversibly impacted with tragic consequences for everyone involved: family, friends, siblings, school mates and the wider communities in which we all live. 'We support the Parents Against Knives walk, organised entirely by the McCrimmon family in memory of their son Kory, which will undoubtedly help draw attention to this growing crisis. 'These are complex and sensitive situations which require a multi-agency response from the Scottish Government, victim support organisations, police, social work, youth work and others to work together to tackle knife crime and the devastation it causes. People across Scotland deserve to feel safe in their own communities.' Mr Swinney said: 'We stand in solidarity with all those who took part in the Parents Against Knives march in Glasgow and my heartfelt condolences go to Kory McCrimmon's family and every family who has suffered unimaginable loss due to knife crime. 'As a father, I find the thought of any parent having to endure the grief and trauma of losing a child to knife crime utterly heartbreaking. Glasgow is united and Scotland is united in wanting these horrific incidents to stop. 'We owe it to every family affected to take meaningful action. That's why we have increased investment in prevention, support and enforcement; from record funding for Police Scotland to vital work by Medics Against Violence and the Scottish Violence Reduction Unit. We stand with the families marching and we are committed to driving the change that keeps our young people safe.'
