Rating agencies in public brawl over scores for private credit
Unlock the Editor's Digest for free
Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favourite stories in this weekly newsletter.
Two US credit rating agencies have become embroiled in a rare public dispute over the reliability of scores for insurance companies' growing stash of private credit investments.
The dispute involves a study, since withdrawn by its publisher, purporting to find that small credit rating agencies assign more generous scores to private credit investments than the larger and more established ones. Kroll Bond Rating Agency has accused Fitch Ratings of misleading market participants by relying on the study to raise doubts about the quality of its ratings.
Fitch on Monday published a report critical of Kroll and other groups, based on the 2024 study, issued by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners.
A Fitch spokesperson stood by its report, arguing the insurance commissioner's group reached similar conclusions in prior studies. 'If the (association) provides new information, we will update our analysis.'
The unusually overt quarrel highlights the intense competition in the fast-growing and lucrative $1.6tn private credit industry to carve out turf — not just among lenders, but among the groups paid to referee creditworthiness of the market's opaque investment offerings.
'There's a build-up of risk in the insurance industry and also potentially in the collateralised loan sector that is not being properly monitored,' said Ann Rutledge, a former senior Moody's analyst and now chief executive of rating agency CreditSpectrum. 'The opacity and the risk are both attributable to the fact that there are cracks in the foundation of the current SEC-regulated credit rating industry.' Read More Prudential to launch $2bn share buyback
Insurers and other investors use the types of ratings in question, known as private letter ratings, when no public ratings are available. Larger ratings firms historically have eschewed issuing these types of scores for private credit products, leaving the market dominated by smaller agencies.
Private letter investments were 'inherently more risky given the lack of transparency and potential ratings inflation', analysts at JPMorgan said in a recent note, adding 'there is an inherent challenge in assessing credit quality from the outside as no part of the process, analysis, or information is transparent from the outside'.
Kroll, which was among the first to challenge the establishment credit agencies with its launch after the global financial crisis, said it was troubled by its larger rival's boosting of 'statistically unsound' research. It said Fitch's criticism appeared geared towards supporting its own grab for dominance.
'In seeking relevance to increase its market share in private credit, Fitch appears to have undercut two foundational principles for any rating agency — integrity and analytical rigour,' Kroll said in a statement.
The study by the NAIC focused on the rise of private letter ratings for insurers' private credit investments, which totalled about $350bn at the end of 2023.
It found confidentially-issued grades from smaller rating shops were more likely to deviate from scores by the association's own securities valuation office and were notably higher on average. According to the original report, smaller groups such as Kroll tended to offer ratings three notches higher than the association's internal score, while larger agencies such as Fitch offered ratings about two notches higher. Read More The sporting weekend in pictures
Recommended
The study also showed that the number of privately rated securities held by US insurers grew from 2,850 in 2019 to 8,152 in 2023, and that the share of securities rated by small credit rating providers such as Egan-Jones, Kroll and Morningstar had grown to 86 per cent in 2023.
The report also noted that Fitch is the leading provider of private letter ratings among the big three US rating agencies, ahead of S&P Global Ratings and Moody's Ratings.
But earlier this month, the insurance association announced it was removing the report from its website 'to undergo further editorial work to clarify the analysis presented'.
Without naming names, the insurance association said it would 'evaluate how the information we provide to the public could be misconstrued or otherwise utilised in inappropriate ways'.
The NAIC declined a request for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Insider
3 hours ago
- Business Insider
TruGolf to Participate in the '2025 Virtual Tech Conference: Discover the Innovations Reshaping Tomorrow' Conference Presented by Maxim Group LLC on Wednesday, June 4th at 3:00 PM EDT - (Updated)
Salt Lake City, Utah, June 03, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- TruGolf Holdings, Inc. (NASDAQ: TRUG), a leading golf technology company, announced today that Brenner Adams, TruGolf's Chief Growth Officer will present at the '2025 Virtual Tech Conference: Discover the Innovations Reshaping Tomorrow,' presented by Maxim Group LLC, tomorrow, June 4 th at 3:00 PM EDT. The Conference will be live on M-Vest. To attend, follow this link to register for this virtual event. About TruGolf Holdings TruGolf is a golf technology company, committed to making golf, easy. From innovative uses for AI to build content and enhance its image and spatial analysis, to gamified golf improvement plans, TruGolf is an industry leader in the growing technological revolution in the sport of golf. Since its founding, TruGolf has redefined what is possible in golf through technology. TruGolf's suite of Hardware, Software, and Web Products make it easier to Play, Improve, and Enjoy the game of golf. Forward-Looking Statements Some of the statements in this release are forward-looking statements, which involve risks and uncertainties. Forward-looking statements include, without limitation, whether the Company's compliance plan will be accepted by Nasdaq and the Company's expected future cash needs. Although the Company believes that the expectations reflected in such forward-looking statements are reasonable as of the date made, expectations may prove to have been materially different from the results expressed or implied by such forward-looking statements. The Company has attempted to identify forward-looking statements by terminology including ''believes,'' ''estimates,'' ''anticipates,'' ''expects,'' ''plans,'' ''projects,'' ''intends,'' ''potential,'' ''may,'' ''could,'' ''might,'' ''will,'' ''should,'' ''approximately'' or other words that convey uncertainty of future events or outcomes to identify these forward-looking statements. These statements are only predictions and involve known and unknown risks, uncertainties, and other factors. Any forward-looking statements contained in this release speak only as of its date. The Company undertakes no obligation to update any forward-looking statements contained in this release to reflect events or circumstances occurring after its date or to reflect the occurrence of unanticipated events. More detailed information about the risks and uncertainties affecting the Company is contained under the heading "Risk Factors" in the Company's Annual Report on Form 10-K and subsequently filed Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q and Current Reports on Form 8-K filed with the SEC, which are available on the SEC's website,
Business Upturn
5 hours ago
- Business Upturn
The China Fund, Inc. Announces Board Approval of Plan of Liquidation
BOSTON, June 20, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — The China Fund, Inc. (NYSE: CHN) (the 'Fund') announced today that its Board of Directors (the 'Board') has approved a plan of liquidation and dissolution (the 'Plan') for the Fund. The Plan will be submitted to Fund stockholders for approval at a Special Meeting. The date of the Special Meeting and more detailed information about the proposed liquidation and Plan will be set forth in a proxy statement to be mailed to the Fund's stockholders in the near future. The Board recommends that the Fund's stockholders vote for the liquidation of the Fund at the Special Meeting. In determining to liquidate the Fund, the Board considered a variety of factors including, among others, prevailing geopolitical and market conditions, the size of the Fund, the trading volume of the Fund's shares, the Fund's discount to net asset value, and the availability of competing open-end products, such as exchange-traded funds. The Board also considered alternatives, including converting the Fund into an open-end management investment company. On balance, the Board determined that the liquidation of the Fund is in the best interests of the Fund and its stockholders. The Fund intends to file a proxy statement with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (the 'SEC') with respect to the proposal to liquidate the Fund. As noted, copies of the Fund's proxy statement will also be mailed to each stockholder of record of the Fund. Upon receipt, stockholders are advised to read the Fund's proxy statement as it will contain important information. Once filed with the SEC, the proxy statement will be available free of charge on the SEC website, This press release may contain statements regarding plans and expectations for the future that constitute forward-looking statements within the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such forward-looking statements are based on the Fund's current plans and expectations, and are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from those described in the forward-looking statements. Additional information concerning such risks and uncertainties are contained in the Fund's regulatory filings, which are available free of charge on the SEC's website. An investment in the Fund involves risk, including loss of principal. Investment return and the value of shares will fluctuate. Any data and commentary provided in this press release are for informational purposes only. The Fund is a closed-end management investment company. The Fund's investment manager is Matthews International Capital Management, LLC. For further information regarding the Fund, please call (888)-CHN-CALL or visit the Fund's website at The information contained on the Fund's website is not part of this press release. Copies of the Fund's complete audited financial statements are available free of charge upon request. Investments involve risk, including possible loss of principal, and an investment should be made with an understanding of the risks involved with owning a particular security or asset class. Interested parties are strongly encouraged to seek advice from qualified tax and financial experts regarding the best options for your particular circumstances. Contact Julian ReidChairman of the BoardThe China Fund, Inc. +44 7768 068200
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
The China Fund, Inc. Announces Board Approval of Plan of Liquidation
BOSTON, June 20, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- The China Fund, Inc. (NYSE: CHN) (the 'Fund') announced today that its Board of Directors (the 'Board') has approved a plan of liquidation and dissolution (the 'Plan') for the Fund. The Plan will be submitted to Fund stockholders for approval at a Special Meeting. The date of the Special Meeting and more detailed information about the proposed liquidation and Plan will be set forth in a proxy statement to be mailed to the Fund's stockholders in the near future. The Board recommends that the Fund's stockholders vote for the liquidation of the Fund at the Special Meeting. In determining to liquidate the Fund, the Board considered a variety of factors including, among others, prevailing geopolitical and market conditions, the size of the Fund, the trading volume of the Fund's shares, the Fund's discount to net asset value, and the availability of competing open-end products, such as exchange-traded funds. The Board also considered alternatives, including converting the Fund into an open-end management investment company. On balance, the Board determined that the liquidation of the Fund is in the best interests of the Fund and its stockholders. The Fund intends to file a proxy statement with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (the 'SEC') with respect to the proposal to liquidate the Fund. As noted, copies of the Fund's proxy statement will also be mailed to each stockholder of record of the Fund. Upon receipt, stockholders are advised to read the Fund's proxy statement as it will contain important information. Once filed with the SEC, the proxy statement will be available free of charge on the SEC website, This press release may contain statements regarding plans and expectations for the future that constitute forward-looking statements within the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such forward-looking statements are based on the Fund's current plans and expectations, and are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from those described in the forward-looking statements. Additional information concerning such risks and uncertainties are contained in the Fund's regulatory filings, which are available free of charge on the SEC's website. An investment in the Fund involves risk, including loss of principal. Investment return and the value of shares will fluctuate. Any data and commentary provided in this press release are for informational purposes only. The Fund is a closed-end management investment company. The Fund's investment manager is Matthews International Capital Management, LLC. For further information regarding the Fund, please call (888)-CHN-CALL or visit the Fund's website at The information contained on the Fund's website is not part of this press release. Copies of the Fund's complete audited financial statements are available free of charge upon request. Investments involve risk, including possible loss of principal, and an investment should be made with an understanding of the risks involved with owning a particular security or asset class. Interested parties are strongly encouraged to seek advice from qualified tax and financial experts regarding the best options for your particular circumstances. Contact Julian ReidChairman of the BoardThe China Fund, Inc.+44 7768 068200Error while retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data
