Government can kiss goodbye to its plan for lifting the rent cap
The news that
rents
are climbing at their fastest rate in 20 years and have passed €2,000 a month nationally should, in theory, put the kibosh on any plans to lift the cap on rents that applies in pretty much every urban area of the State.
The Government has been trailing the idea since the last election, based on the premise that it will kick-start development, particularly the sort of large apartment schemes considered crucial to making a dent in the
housing shortage
.
Even allowing for the fact that the figure of €2,000 per month contained in the Daft quarterly rental report is asking rents – for properties that are coming to market, including new builds exempt from the rent cap – the lifting of the cap now looks like a non-starter politically.
The construction industry argues, rather counterintuitively, that ever-rising rents simply bolster their argument for doing away with the cap
The true picture may be somewhat different. According to the most recent report from the Residential Tenancy Board, the average rent for new tenancies nationally rose by 5.5 per cent year-on-year to €1,680 in the fourth quarter of 2024. It rose by 4.6 per cent year-on-year for existing tenancies nationally to €1,440.
READ MORE
This is a moderation in the rate of rental inflation, it argues, but the problem for the Government is that the figure that matters is in the Daft figure as that is the one the Opposition will use to beat them up in the Dáil should they lift the cap and expose sitting tenants to significant increases.
The construction industry argues, rather counterintuitively, that ever-rising rents simply bolster their argument for doing away with the cap. They are right up to a point. The reason rents are rising is because there is insufficient supply. The number of new homes commenced so far this year is eight times lower than the comparable period last year and at its lowest since 2016, according to the
Department of Housing
.
'I've entrepreneurial spirit in my veins' – Apprentice star Jordan Dargan
Listen |
44:45
According to the industry a negative feedback loop has set in. Rent caps are discouraging investors and developers from building apartments and houses for rent and this is squeezing supply, which in turn is pushing up rents to record levels. The solution, they argue, is to remove rent caps and allow rents to move until such time as a positive feedback loop sets in.
Leaving aside the possibility that capitalism is broken beyond repair, there is no doubt that the Government is in a very tricky place
Of course, it won't work that way – not in the short term at least – and actively encouraging such an inflationary cycle brings us one step closer to the sort of housing market crash that some think is the only way out of the current mess.
Leaving aside the possibility that capitalism is broken beyond repair, there is no doubt that the Government is in a very tricky place.
The main argument for lifting rent caps – made by everyone from Taoiseach Micheál Martin downwards – is to encourage international investors into the market. Again, the argument is correct up to a point. If you want to get the sort of investment funds that are funding large developments here to invest more in the Republic, you have to offer them a better return than they can get from investing elsewhere in other assets. That means higher rents.
The societal and political costs of lifting the rent cap have to be considered
There does, however, come a point when the returns these funds are looking for are so expensive to the State that other sources of capital become more attractive. And this is where we find ourselves.
The cost of getting money from these funds goes beyond allowing them to make large profits by charging high rents. The societal and political costs of lifting the rent cap have to be considered.
The main one is the possibility of a political upheaval driven by the rise in prices and rent that will occur before the predicted moderation in rents kicks in, assuming it ever does. There is also the possibility of some sort of crash.
The thing to remember about crashes is that most people don't see them coming, or else there would not be crashes.
The Government would argue that it has other tools it can use to bring down the costs of construction, which in turn, should allow investors to get the returns they seek without a jump in prices.
It may look like international investors have a gun to the Government's head. But that is always the wrong time to make a deal, particularly when you have the best part of €15bn in rainy day funds
There are two problems here. The first is that progress in areas such as planning reform is just too slow and there is no real reason to believe that this will change. The second is that the world doesn't work that way. Investors will bank any savings rather than pass them on to tenants.
Lifting the rent cap to encourage international investment is arguably the biggest gamble this Government will take. The potential for it to blow up in their faces is significant.
It may look like international investors have a gun to the Government's head. But that is always the wrong time to make a deal, particularly when you have the best part of €15 billion sitting in rainy day funds.
It's time to look out the window ... the rain is pouring down.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Mayo sends clear message of solidarity with Palestine - ‘You will never have peace until you have justice'
Debbie McCole from Shanaghy Ballina, is the chairperson for the Mayo branch of the Ireland-Palestine Solidarity Campaign (IPSC), which is described as an 'apolitical and movement-focused' group. Speaking to the Irish Independent Ms McCole explained why she is fighting for justice, 'I often think it's a very interesting conversation around justice versus peace. An awful lot of people will advocate for peace but it's very easy to mistake one for the other. You will never really have peace until you have full justice.' Ballina has been holding a weekly vigil on Ham Bridge since the end of May last year. It came to be referred to as a 'Bridgvil'. 'I am very proud to stand on that bridge and represent humanity,' said Debbie, who admitted she was nervous at first as she had not been involved in protests of any form before, 'We are very lucky in Mayo that we have such an active community and everybody is anxious to do something. I think people are finding the courage to stand up and say no this is enough now.' The former teacher continued, 'International law has been decimated. Until there has been some trust restored and people can see that justice has been served for the Palestinian people, then our work is not done.' This distrust towards the international community is a feeling shared by local musician Patrick O'Laoghaire from Louisburg, who said he felt that the 'social contract of trust has been broken.' Mr O'Laoghaire is set to take part in a walk from Achill Sound to Westport on Saturday June 21st in solidarity with the people of Gaza. The route has been chosen as it is roughly the same distance as walking from one end of the Gaza Strip to the other. Inspiration for the 42 km walk came when Patrick, along with his wife, were walking their dog on Silver Strand in Mayo and a plane passed over them. ADVERTISEMENT 'It reminded me of Shannon [airport]. It struck me that I'm living in Mayo, it's sunny here, I have the dog with me and there's a plane passing over and I know that some of them come [via] that route to refuel and fly on.' The route he is referring to is one that is reportedly used by US military aircrafts enroute to the Middle East. Patrick said he felt helpless in that moment and questioned. 'Can I lie with that helplessness or can I go back to being inspired by the people of Gaza and Palestine by walking and thinking of them? With walking there is a movement, a physical movement. There's energy in it.' Mr O'Laoghaire has a personal connection to Gaza through his passion for music which led him to connect with Gaza-based musician Ahmed Abuamsha on social media. 'The musicians I have made contact with in Gaza, they are singing. I'm learning their songs. When they are teaching me their songs they're teaching me that they have a life, a culture, things that are important to them. You can get a lot from a song,' Patrick continued, 'A couple of days ago they took the signal away and I was waiting for Ahmed to get back to me, and it was a feeling of 'Is he alright?' But he did come back online and he was singing with a group of children, all of them singing, 'I'm careful not to become hopeless, I feel that to lose hope does a disservice to the people in Palestine and Gaza who are somehow hanging onto hope and joy. I'm not taking inspiration from my government, I'm taking inspiration from people who are there'. Similar to Patrick, Debbie is shared her concern over reports that Shannon Airport is used as a refuelling spot for the US military. Ms McCole also stated the airport is used to bring weapons 'through and over the country'. She said, 'It's so blatant and they (the government) just pretend it's not happening, it's terrible gaslighting.' Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade Simon Harris spoke in the Dáil in March and denied any claims of US weapons travelling through Shannon Airport, 'It is expressly prohibited for civil aircraft to carry munitions of war in Irish sovereign territory, without being granted an exemption to do so by the Minister for Transport. The system of exemptions is operated under the Air Navigation Orders 1973 and 1989, by the Department of Transport.' He assured the house that 'In 2023, 2024, and to date in 2025, no applications have been received or exemptions granted for the carriage of munitions of war on civil aircraft to a point in Israel.' While in office as Taoiseach, Mr Harris stood alongside Spain and Norway in May 2024 and announced the recognition of the State of Palestine. He has been vocal on Ireland's historical and 'principled position' for the 'equal right to self-determination, peace, security and dignity for Israelis and Palestinians alike' committing to an 'unwavering support for the two-State solution'. Ms McCole elaborated on Ireland's historic stance in previous conflicts saying, 'We as Irish people have a good reputation in regards to human rights and standing on the side of the oppressed traditionally,' She has not been convinced by the Government's words and said they take advantage of Ireland's history 'to be able to say nice things' but 'Palestinians can't eat the words that they're saying. It doesn't translate into material changes on the ground.' According to data published yesterday by the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, the Ministry of Health in Gaza reported at least 55,637 Palestinians have been killed and a further 129,880 have been injured since October 7th 2023.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Nordic group mulls higher offer for Dalata as it buys more shares in Irish hotel chain
A Scandinavian consortium circling Dalata Hotel Group has signalled an interest in potentially making an improved offer for the business, after its €1.3 billion bid was rejected earlier this month. Oslo-based investment firm Eiendomsspar and Swedish hotel company Pandox, in which it owns an almost 25 per cent stake, said on Friday that they have bought 1.69 million shares in Dalata at €6.30 – marking a premium to the €6.05-a-share non-binding offer it had made for the company. 'Consequently, any firm intention to make an offer for Dalata by the consortium in accordance with Rule 2.7 of the Irish Takeover Rules, if made, will be at a price of not less than €6.30 per share,' the Nordic group said. 'There can be no certainty that any offer will be made. A further announcement will be made as appropriate. Any offer, if made, is likely to be solely in cash, although the consortium reserves the right to vary the form of consideration and/or introduce other forms of consideration.' READ MORE Eiendomsspar already owned an 8.8 per cent stake in Dalata before it made the bid approach. This latest share buying brings its stake in the Irish hotel group to 9.6 per cent. [ Dalata rejects surprise €1.3bn bid from Scandinavian consortium Opens in new window ] The property firm, which has a history of large investments in hotels, first emerged with a disclosable stake above 3 per cent in Dalata at the end of October. The company added to its stake the following month. But its chief executive, Sigurd Stray, sought to contain speculation at the time that it could amount to a strategic stake-build, telling The Irish Times he saw it as a 'financial investment' that would 'hopefully provide a fair return over time'. The early-June bid came as a surprise as the Pandox-Eiendomsspar consortium had not been involved in a formal sale process, managed by investment bank Rothschild, that has been going on in recent months. Dalata, which is led by chief executive Dermot Crowley, rejected that offer, saying it 'materially undervalues the group and its prospects'. [ Bidding war for Dalata Hotel Group hots up Opens in new window ] The board of Dalata, which floated on the stock market in 2014, hired investment bank Rothschild to carry out a strategic review of the business in March, following a sustained period of underperformance by the stock. Shares in Dalata jumped as much as 5.3 per cent to €6.53 on Friday afternoon, after the Pandox-Eiendomsspar consortium revealed its latest share purchase. The spike suggest that investors are holding out for a bid above the new floor that the consortium has set for a potential second tilt at the company.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Dublin airport operator warned over passenger cap breach
Dublin Airport operator DAA has been issued with an enforcement order by Fingal County Council for breaching the 32 million annual passenger limit, despite a High Court suspension of the cap. An Bord Pleanála imposed the limit on airport's capacity in 2007 as a condition of allowing it add a second terminal. The move was meant to allay fears over traffic jams on roads to and from the airport, which have since been upgraded. State company DAA applied to the council for permission to increase the cap to 36 million and 40 million in separate applications, but has yet to receive a decision from the planning authority. However, in April the High Court effectively suspended the passenger cap pending the outcome of a legal challenge relating to the limit taken last year by Irish airlines Ryanair and Aer Lingus, and Airlines for America, which represents US and Canadian carriers. READ MORE The cap was breached last year when 33.3 million passengers came through the airport. The council has now issued DAA with an enforcement notice which allows a two-year period to comply with the passenger capacity conditions. [ Aviation regulator drops measure from winter travel plan Opens in new window ] 'The two-year period provides an opportunity for DAA to progress their planning applications to increase passenger capacity at Dublin Airport or take such other steps as they consider appropriate to achieve compliance,' the council said. In response to complaints received that the conditions were breached in 2023 and 2024, the council's enforcement unit initiated a formal investigation to assess compliance. 'A warning letter was issued to DAA, providing them with an opportunity to respond, which they did,' the council said. 'Fingal County Council acknowledges the operational complexities presented. However, the information submitted by DAA does not constitute sufficient grounds to prevent further action. The investigation has determined that a breach of the relevant planning conditions has occurred and remains ongoing.' A DAA spokesman described the issuing of the enforcement notice as a 'sorry indictment' of the planning system. 'The fact that Fingal County Council is sending us an enforcement notice regarding 32 million passengers when passenger numbers will be north of 36 million this year and heading towards 40 million before the end of the decade is a sorry indictment of the mess that is the Irish planning system, particularly when it comes to the most vital piece of transport infrastructure on this island,' he said. DAA said that until the 'broken' system was overhauled the airport was effectively 'hamstrung' and unable to grow Ireland's connectivity. It has called for a complete scrapping of the passenger limit and for the airport to be classified as strategic infrastructure, placing relevant decisions in the hands of a national planning body and not a local authority. 'When it took up office, the Government committed to acting speedily to identify and implement a legislative solution that would remove the passenger cap from Dublin Airport,' the DAA spokesman said. 'The Minister has since also said he will bring forward legislation to solve the cap issue, dispel uncertainty and maintain connectivity for Ireland – and this can't happen quickly enough.' Minister for Transport Darragh O'Brien last month said he hoped forthcoming legislation could bring an end to the dispute.
