Govt's handling of housing czar appointment 'a shambles'
Sinn Féin's housing spokesperson Eoin O'Broin has described the Government's handling of the appointment of a housing czar as a "shambles" and said "no one" believes a potential €430,000 a year salary was never discussed.
The opposition TD was speaking on RTÉ's Today with Aine Kerr during which Fine Gael Minister of State Jerry Buttimer rejected reports of a "row" in Government over the controversy.
Asked about the decision on Thursday by NAMA chief executive Brendan McDonagh to say he no longer wants to be considered for the role, Deputy O'Broin said "it's a shambles".
He said given "only one candidate was being considered by Fianna Fáil", and that this was Mr McDonagh, he said he believes Fine Gael's Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe "would have been in the loop" as he is NAMA's line minister.
Deputy O'Broin said "I don't believe for a second, and I don't believe anyone who's followed this story credibly believes" that when Mr McDonagh's name was brought up that his existing salary of €430,000 was not discussed.
While the Government has insisted no conversations involving a salary for the potential new role took place, Deputy O'Broin said asking people to believe that position "insults the public", before adding: "If you ever wanted confirmation of the absolute shambles [of housing policy], it's not just the past week it's the past six weeks."
Responding to the claims on the same programme, Minister Buttimer said that while "it's great for the media to see it [the new unit and potential appointment] revved up to a row" at Cabinet, he insisted "it's not".
Minister Buttimer said while "personally I thought it [the reported potential salary] was a big high", in his view the Housing Activation Office is "the important thing" and that it is "imperative and important to increase supply, build more homes and give people what they want - a home of their own".
Asked if trust has been "broken" between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael after several sources in both parties appeared to brief against each other on the issue, Minister Buttimer said: "I know the media love to dramatise and have a row between people, but it's about delivery [of houses].
"We can debate all we want, and it's very sexy and gets the headlines, but for the people who want to get their own home it doesn't help."
Speaking on the same programme, Green Party leader Roderic O Gorman said: "I think the Government has been in absolute panic mode on housing" since a previous row over projected housing completion figures for this year.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
More than 130 properties offered for IP accommodation as Government looks to buy, not rent
More than 100 properties have been offered to the State following the latest push by Government to purchase large properties for asylum seeker accommodation. A spokeswoman for Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan said 131 submissions were made in response to a call for properties for international protection accommodation to 'sell or lease'. The preference was to purchase, she said. 'That is the direction we are going.' Offers were being 'worked through and assessed', meaning it was not possible to say how many of the 131 had been offered for sale rather than lease. The spokeswoman could also not say if they were spread across every county or concentrated in a smaller number. READ MORE Not all would be suitable, the spokeswoman said, adding that they were being examined for building compliance, fire and other regulatory issues. Last Tuesday, Mr O'Callaghan confirmed plans to purchase Citywest Hotel in Dublin for more than €148 million to make it a permanent processing centre for international protection applicants. This would contribute to his plan to provide 14,000 State-owned beds for asylum seekers by 2028 rather than relying on private providers and would 'deliver significant long-term savings to the State as its moves from licensing to ownership,' a department spokesman said. The 764-bed hotel and conference centre, which has been leased by the State since 2020, had capacity to accommodate 'approximately 2,300 people between the hotel and the convention centre', the spokesman said. The latest invitation for submissions, published on the Government's E-tender website, seeks 'expressions of interest from property owners, private developers and building contractors who are interested in selling or leasing existing properties or buildings in turnkey condition [and] existing properties that require upgrading/refurbishment/renovation'. 'All properties acquired through this expression of interest process will be to provide accommodation for international protection (IP) applicants and must be on the terms of vacant possession,' the notice says. According to tender documents, properties that will not be considered are buildings set aside for social housing; accommodation planned for use by other arms of Government; student accommodation; and nursing homes which are currently operating. State-owned properties will be directly managed by the International Protection Accommodation Service (IPAS) . As of early 2025, IPAS was providing accommodation for more than 33,000 people across 325 accommodation centres. Mr O'Callaghan said purchasing Citywest was 'a hugely significant step' towards reforming the international protection system – part of which was a 'stable and sustainable accommodation network'. This was necessary to bring Ireland's system into compliance with the EU Asylum and Migration Pact which comes into force next year, he said. It will require international protection applications to be processed within three to six months, fingerprinting and photographing of adult and child applicants and the establishment of designated accommodation centres. 'State-owned centres are part of the Government's long-term plan to reduce the reliance on private accommodation providers in communities resulting in better value for money of public funds and a more efficient international protection system,' Mr O'Callaghan said. News of the Citywest purchase sparked protests by some local residents . Protesters claimed to have gathered more than 8,000 signatures of people against the move by going door-to-door in Saggart, Rathcoole and Citywest. 'Ninety per cent of the doors we called to signed that petition. It shows that 90 per cent of people in the areas around here do not want this,' said Amanda Higgins at a demonstration outside Leinster House on Wednesday.
Irish Independent
5 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Eoin O'Malley: CityWest deal shows the State is in the asylum business for the long haul, but the opposite approach is working for Denmark
The Danes are pursuing a 'zero refugee' policy and is sending out a strong message about how tough its rules are Today at 21:30 If we were to choose a monument to Irish policy failure, we could do worse than to pick the Citywest Hotel. The Government last week authorised the purchase of the hotel in Saggart, Co Dublin, to become a state-owned International Protection Accommodation Service (IPAS) centre for asylum-seekers. Citywest was built by businessman Jim Mansfield, who borrowed heavily to expand it to become one of the largest hotels in Europe. It became host to some large events. All-Ireland champions partied there after victory. It was where the Fianna Fáil faithful gathered when the party was in its heyday. The faux-Georgian hotel seemed to symbolise Celtic Tiger excess and hubris.
Irish Independent
5 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Eilis O'Hanlon: Now he has all the answers, does Leo Varadkar plan to go from pub bore to president?
Weighing in on Irish unity, calling for action on Gaza, writing a memoir and appearing on Ray Goggins' TV show – it doesn't look like the former taoiseach has had enough of public life Today at 21:30 Stepping down as taoiseach last year, Leo Varadkar said he had no 'definite personal or political plans', but was 'looking forward to having the time to think about them'. Having since considered all his options, the former Fine Gael leader seems to have decided that the best use of his talents as a communicator is to become a full-time pub bore on the issue of Irish unity, like Christy Moore without the guitar, or Colm Meaney without the Starship Enterprise uniform.
