Performative politics of many on the left is pushing people away
Take, for instance, a comment posted by Ruby Davies in response to your article 'Jimmy Carr shows 'should be cancelled' over secret pro-Israel party'. Here we had a comedian doing a paid gig, likely booked through an agent and probably unaware of the crowd dynamics that night. Ruby, in a fervour, likens him to individuals who entertained some of history's most heinous figures, such as Hitler or Pol Pot. This comparison isn't just excessive; it borders on delusional. It's not a quest for justice; it becomes a performative act devoid of real substance.
READ MORE: First aid trucks enter Gaza after Israeli blockade lifted
On the other side of the spectrum, we had politicians like Maria Eagle in the same venue boasting shamelessly about British military involvement in Israel's assault on Gaza. Did Ruby direct her outrage towards them? No, and that's telling. Confronting those in real positions of power takes courage, while chastising a comedian is a safer bet that garners attention and clicks.
Regrettably, this tendency to misplace focus is emblematic of a wider issue. Take Stonewall's recent response to the UK's drop in the European Rainbow Index, which evaluates the legal and policy conditions for LGBT+ people across Europe. In their announcement, they unequivocally lumped the UK in with countries like Hungary and Georgia. This comparison is fundamentally flawed. In those nations, LGBT+ individuals face violent mobs, bans on education, and systemic silence enforced by the government. Here in the UK, while challenges remain, we are not at that level of crisis – and when individuals exaggerate these situations, they do not come off as courageous; they appear disconnected from reality.
READ MORE: Israel 'will take control of all of Gaza', Benjamin Netanyahu says
A striking example is Deborah Frances-White's appearance on the show Triggernometry. She faced a direct and polite question, yet her demeanour shifted dramatically. Rather than engaging in a constructive dialogue, she appeared as though she was under attack. Watching That interaction was painfully awkward; it encapsulated a troubling trend within too much of the left today – a fragility, defensiveness, and an inclination to interpret even neutral inquiries as hostile. This 'Fragile Left' mentality, where every critique is treated as an assault, is pushing people away. It's no wonder many are growing frustrated and tuning out entirely.
The truth is that Most working-class individuals don't engage with this discourse. They are not active participants in the Twitter battlegrounds or immersed in endless online threads debating who is associated with whom. Instead, they live in the real world, juggling a myriad of responsibilities – bills to pay, children to raise, lengthy shifts, and the overarching stress of daily life. When everyday people observe those on the left melting down over a comedian's offhand joke at a dinner event, they don't interpret that as activism; they think, 'This crowd has completely lost the plot.'
READ MORE: Labour 'breaking promise to reset devolution', John Swinney says
If the working class feel marginalised, they are inclined to support anyone who doesn't talk down to them – even if that means rallying behind individuals like Farage. They don't see themselves reflected in the current leftist narrative, not out of love for right-wing populism, but rather because there is a desperate need for the left to reassess and recalibrate its approach.
While Ruby may believe she is championing a righteous cause, her actions, and those like hers, are not drawing people in – they're alienating them. It is essential that we initiate genuine conversations about these dynamics. If we fail to unite and understand the real challenges facing our communities, the individuals and groups opposing our values will continue to thrive by default, leaving us further estranged from the very people we seek to uplift.
James Murphy
Bute
SCOTLAND needs to concentrate on some canny voting next year. As much as we might disagree with the SNP government, inespecial where independence is concerned, we need to make sure it – or a combination of independence parties – gets the majority necessary to continue governing Scotland.
We cannot afford to let Farage and his business team get anywhere near to entering Holyrood, regardless of what we might think about his only concern where immigration is concerned.
READ MORE: Kenny MacAskill: Scotland can't survive Keir Starmer's migration crackdown
Immigration is a fact of life for Scotland, as the country needs and welcomes immigrants to contribute to our public and NHS services. This has always been the situation before Johnson and his ridiculous Brexit plan, which has almost ruined the the UK economy.
Voting for Reform UK on the single premise of immigration will not help a Scottish Government if it results in Farage becoming the leading opposition in Holyrood. Better it is/was with the Tories in that position.
In North East Fife we do not have an SNP candidate as yet, although I understand one is being considered by the SNP election people. However, it is a strong LibDem constituency, so I will have to give it a well-considered 1 and 2 selection. Certainly not a Farage vote if his party is on the list.
Please consider the next five years of government in Scotland, how we vote for what we can and will achieve as a sovereign nation responsible for effecting our independence. There is a way forward already in motion, via Salvo, that will help us achieve that without any unnecessary contacts or input with the UK/English parliament.
Alan Magnus-Bennett
Fife
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Western Telegraph
20 minutes ago
- Western Telegraph
PM urges Britons to contact Foreign Office for Israel evacuation flights
It comes after the US attacked three nuclear sites in Iran overnight and Tehran then launched a ballistic missile barrage against Israel. Speaking to Sky News, Sir Keir Starmer said: 'I urge all citizens to make contact with the Foreign Office so that we can facilitate whatever support is needed.' He added that the Government will help evacuate British citizens on charter flights 'as soon as we can'. Sir Keir said: 'Well for British citizens, we've been saying for some time to register their presence. 'And so far as Israel is concerned, just as soon as we can get charter flights off, we will do so.' The UK is preparing a flight to transport vulnerable British nationals and their dependants out of Israel and the OPTs early next week. British nationals in Israel and the OPTs should register their presence to receive the latest updates and register their interest in the… — Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office (@FCDOGovUK) June 22, 2025 The Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO) has continued to urge British nationals to register their details and interest in evacuation flights, the first of which it said will take off early next week. It said further flights 'will be considered depending on demand and the latest security situation'. According to the Israeli Government, some 22,000 tourists are seeking to board evacuation flights. It is unclear how many of these are UK citizens. British nationals who have already registered will automatically be contacted and provided with a link to the booking portal, the FCDO said. Those eligible for the flight will be expected to pay for their seat – and payment will be taken on registration on the flight booking form. The FCDO added that those with 'greatest need' will be prioritised, and British nationals plus their non-British immediate family members travelling with them are eligible. All passengers must hold a valid travel document, and those non-British immediate family members will require valid visas/permission to enter or remain that was granted for more than six months, the FCDO said. The UK has been working on charter flights for Britons in Israel but none have so far taken off as the country's airspace has been closed. Jonathan Reynolds said the Government is 'in active conversation' about chartering aircraft to get people out of Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories (Jordan Pettitt/PA) Business Secretary Jonathon Reynolds told Sky News on Sunday morning: 'We are in active conversations about chartering aircraft to get people out.' Asked if that will happen imminently, Mr Reynolds said: 'I believe our intention would be to do that as soon as possible… hours, not days.' Meanwhile, shadow foreign secretary Dame Priti Patel told Times Radio the UK 'must not be behind the curve' in evacuating its nationals. 'The Government's got to start moving fast now in terms of British nationals in Israel,' Dame Priti said. 'They've been talking about this for days… Israeli airspace is shut down. 'The Americans are ready to evacuate 25,000 US nationals — we must not be behind the curve.' The FCDO has warned British nationals not to make their way to the airport unless they are contacted. Register your presence: — Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office (@FCDOGovUK) June 22, 2025 A spokesperson said: 'This is a perilous and volatile moment for the Middle East. 'The safety of British nationals in Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories continues to be our utmost priority – that's why the UK Government is preparing flights to help those wanting to leave. 'Working closely with the Israeli authorities, our staff are continuing to work at pace to assist British nationals on the ground and ensure they receive the support they need.' Commercial flights remain in operation from Egypt and Jordan to the UK, and international land border crossings to these countries remain open. The FCDO said the situation 'remains volatile' and the Government's ability to run flights out of Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories 'could change at short notice'. The portal to register presence in Israel as a Briton is available at:
Sky News
21 minutes ago
- Sky News
Israeli forces recover remains of three hostages from Gaza
Israeli forces have recovered the remains of three hostages from the Gaza Strip. The military identified the remains as those of Yonatan Samerano, 21; Ofra Keidar, 70; and Shay Levinson, 19. All three were killed when Hamas militants stormed across the border into Israel on 7 October 2023, an act which ignited the ongoing war. The militant group still holds 50 hostages, of whom only 20 are believed to be alive. "The campaign to return the hostages continues consistently and is happening alongside the campaign against Iran," Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said. Israel's military did not provide any details about the recovery operation. Mr Samerano's father Kobi said in a Facebook post that his son's remains were returned on what would have been his 23rd birthday. The Hostages Families Forum, which is the main organisation representing the families of the hostages, has repeatedly called for a deal to release the remaining captives. "Particularly against the backdrop of current military developments and the significant achievements in Iran, we want to emphasise that bringing back the remaining 50 hostages is the key to achieving any sort of victory," it said. Hamas has said it will only release the remaining hostages in return for more Palestinian prisoners, a lasting ceasefire and an Israeli withdrawal from Gaza. Mr Netayahu has rejected the group's terms, saying Israel will continue the war until all hostages are returned and Hamas is defeated or disarmed. Hamas-led militants killed some 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and abducted 251 people during the 7 October 2023 attack. More than half of the hostages have been returned in ceasefire agreements or other deals, eight have been rescued alive and Israeli forces have recovered dozens of bodies. 1:25 Israel's war in Gaza has killed more than 55,000 Palestinians, according to the Hamas-run health ministry, which has said women and children make up more than half of the dead. The ministry does not distinguish between civilians and combatants in its count.
Daily Mail
22 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Incredible satellite images show the precision of the US attack on Iran's nuclear machine in full
A new series of satellite images has revealed the precision of the US attacks on Iran 's primary nuclear facility. President Donald Trump last night ordered six B-2 stealth bombers to drop a dozen 30,000-pound 'bunker buster' bombs on the base hidden deep inside a mountain in Fordo, 80 miles south of Tehran. 'The strikes were a spectacular military success,' Trump said in a late-night address from the White House, before warning that he wants peace now or that there will be dire consequences. In the aftermath, Iran's foreign minister has branded Trump a 'lawless bully' who 'betrayed' diplomacy as he warned the world has been thrown into an 'unprecedented level of danger'. The newly-released images show the exactitude of military attacks, which Trump claimed flattened the facility. The satellite imagery shows the exact 'strike area' on the Fordow Nuclear Facility, which the B-2 stealth bombers hit as well as possible bomb 'entry points'. Annotated to show the areas clearly, the images also suggest 'possible subsidence' of land which has been caved inwards after the strikes. In response, Iran this morning targeted Israel which has left at least 16 people injured, including a young man with shrapnel wounds to his upper body, according to emergency services. The attacks on Israel are understood to have started at around 6.30am GMT (8.30am IST) this morning - just hours after the US's strikes on Iran. Addressing Trump's attack at a press conference today, Iran's foreign minister Abbas Araghchi said: 'Humanity has come too far as a species to allow a lawless bully to take us back to the law of the jungle.' He ordered 'urgent and decisive action' must now be taken by the United Nations and other International bodies, adding that 'silence' will 'plunge the world into an unprecedented level of danger'. Sir Keir Starmer said the US took action to 'alleviate' the 'grave threat' of Iran's nuclear programme - but urged Iran to return to the 'negotiating table' to end the conflict. The UK Prime Minister said in a statement: 'Iran's nuclear programme is a grave threat to international security. 'Iran can never be allowed to develop a nuclear weapon and the US has taken action to alleviate that threat. 'The situation in the Middle East remains volatile and stability in the region is a priority. 'We call on Iran to return to the negotiating table and reach a diplomatic solution to end this crisis.' obliterated '.
