Uttarakhand HC orders probe into death of man in Haldwani clashes – ‘eyewitness statement ignored'
The Uttarakhand High Court has ordered a special investigation team to probe the death of a man who was allegedly shot dead during the Banbhoolpura riots in Haldwani in February 2024.
A Division Bench of Chief Justice G Narendar and Justice Alok Mehra has also ordered the transfer of the investigating officer, Neeraj Bhakuni, out of the district. The SIT has been asked to submit a progress report every month, and the court will monitor the probe.
The petition was filed by Parvez, the victim Faheem's brother, seeking a CBI probe into his death.
On June 4, after the final report was submitted by the IO, the court said that the word 'shocking' would be an understatement.
'The IO appears to have gone around recording the statements of all and sundry and comes to a conclusion that all of them have not confirmed witnessing the act and on that basis, he attempts to justify his act of ignoring the statement of the complainant, who claims to have witnessed certain persons using firearms to shoot his brother and the fact remains that the brother of the complainant died due to gunshot injuries. Despite such a statement of an eye-witness, the IO has filed a closure report, probably one and only of its kind in the country, where an eyewitness statement is ignored and a closure report is based on people who appear not to be the eyewitnesses,' the court had remarked.
Following this, the DGP was asked to look into the closure report and file his statement as an affidavit. The court set up an SIT after perusing the affidavit Wednesday.
The petition filed by the victim's brother had alleged that there was no progress in the investigation despite the chief judicial magistrate's court ordering a probe in May last year.
Earlier, on the IO's statement that the pendrive with videos was tampered with, the court had said, 'Whether the pendrive was subjected to a forensic examination by competent authorities is not forthcoming. The IO by stating that the source of WhatsApp videos has not been disclosed appears to have abdicated his duties as an investigator'.
It further said: 'By stating that the videos on the pendrive are tampered, he has assumed the role of a Judge, and by attempting to circumvent the question and the veracity of the statement of the eyewitness, based on the statements of third parties, he has assumed the role of a defence counsel. That apart, the opinion formed on the basis of the fact that the bullet has passed from left to right, and hence, could not have been fired from a small weapon, here, he assumes the role of a ballistic expert.'
Aiswarya Raj is a correspondent with The Indian Express who covers South Haryana. An alumna of Asian College of Journalism and the University of Kerala, she started her career at The Indian Express as a sub-editor in the Delhi city team. In her current position, she reports from Gurgaon and covers the neighbouring districts. She likes to tell stories of people and hopes to find moorings in narrative journalism. ... Read More
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India.com
6 hours ago
- India.com
Dawood Ibrahim's brother used to work in Bollywood films, wrote songs for Salman Khan, Rishi Kapoor, Raveena Tandon, his name is..., songs are...
Dawood Ibrahim's brother used to work in Bollywood films, wrote songs for Salman Khan, Rishi Kapoor, Raveena Tandon, his name is..., songs are... Bollywood had a notorious history with the underworld mafia Dawood Ibrahim. Several movies were made on him, even after he left India and went abroad. It was following his departure that he attempted to make an indirect effect on the industry, via his brothers. One of his criminal brothers, Noor Ul Haq Kaskar, secretly used to work in Hindi films and was an aspiring lyricist. Fondly known as Noora, he wrote songs that starred Bollywood icons like Rishi Kapoor, Salman Khan and Raveena Tandon. Dawood Ibrahim's brother was was an aspiring songwriter and lyricist Noora wrote song Choom Loon Honth Tere Dil Ki Yahi Khwahish Hai, in the Rishi Kapoor-starrer film Shreemaan Aashique . He also penned Tumse Jo Dekhte Hi Pyar Hua for film Patthar Ke Phool , starring Salman Khan and Raveena Tandon. As recounted in The Indian Express, his most memorable contribution was the iconic song Tumse Jo Dekhte Hi. Popular journalist S Hussain Zaid once shared in his YouTube video, 'Noora was a shayarmizaaj aadmi… For Dawood, it was family first. If he ever had any differences with Iqbal or Noora, he wouldn't let anybody know of it. The 'tapori' type songs in films, he'd write those. He could do anything for his brothers. Everybody else came second.' Dawood Ibrahim's brother was a notorious criminal Reports suggest that beyond his creative side, Noora was deeply involved in Mumbai's underworld along with his brother Dawood Ibrahim during the 1980s and 90s. He was a feared gangster who was embedded in hafta vasooli (extortion) rackets. Noora was said to gave been killed in 2009, after it was claimed that he died of a heart attack. His death marked the end of straddling criminal activities and creative production.
Time of India
7 hours ago
- Time of India
83-year-old retiree loses Rs 1.19 crore in fake IPO scam
An 83-year-old retired man from Dadar, Mumbai, has fallen prey to a sophisticated online stock investment scam, losing Rs 1.19 crore after being lured by fraudsters posing as financial advisors. The incident began on March 10, when the senior citizen clicked on a stock investment advertisement on social media. He was subsequently added to a WhatsApp group named G-5 ICICI Stock Exchange Group, which appeared to be managed by two individuals identified as Vinita Patodia and Ashwin Parekh. The group, with over 90 members, frequently posted messages boasting of high returns from stock trades. On April 2, Patodia privately messaged the victim, asking if he was interested in investing. After he agreed, she sent him a registration link. Soon after, a person named Pranay Warma contacted him and, referencing Patodia, persuaded him to invest Rs 7.5 lakh as an initial amount. Over the following weeks—between May 2 and May 23—the victim made multiple transfers to various bank accounts, believing he was investing in IPOs. The scammers sent fake documents and screenshots showing inflated virtual returns to gain his confidence. When he requested a payout, the fraudsters demanded a 10% commission on the supposed profits. His suspicion grew after his messages and calls began going unanswered. He then consulted a friend, who confirmed it was a scam. Live Events The victim filed a complaint via the National Cybercrime Reporting Portal (1930), and the case has since been transferred to the Cyber Police (Central Division). An FIR has been registered under relevant sections of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita and the Information Technology Act. Investigations are ongoing. Also Read: $2.4 trillion worth of gold! India's household hoard is 6x Pakistan's economy
Economic Times
7 hours ago
- Economic Times
83-year-old retiree loses Rs 1.19 crore in fake IPO scam
An 83-year-old retired man from Dadar, Mumbai, has fallen prey to a sophisticated online stock investment scam, losing Rs 1.19 crore after being lured by fraudsters posing as financial advisors. ADVERTISEMENT The incident began on March 10, when the senior citizen clicked on a stock investment advertisement on social media. He was subsequently added to a WhatsApp group named G-5 ICICI Stock Exchange Group, which appeared to be managed by two individuals identified as Vinita Patodia and Ashwin Parekh. The group, with over 90 members, frequently posted messages boasting of high returns from stock trades. On April 2, Patodia privately messaged the victim, asking if he was interested in investing. After he agreed, she sent him a registration link. Soon after, a person named Pranay Warma contacted him and, referencing Patodia, persuaded him to invest Rs 7.5 lakh as an initial amount. Over the following weeks—between May 2 and May 23—the victim made multiple transfers to various bank accounts, believing he was investing in IPOs. The scammers sent fake documents and screenshots showing inflated virtual returns to gain his he requested a payout, the fraudsters demanded a 10% commission on the supposed profits. His suspicion grew after his messages and calls began going unanswered. He then consulted a friend, who confirmed it was a scam. The victim filed a complaint via the National Cybercrime Reporting Portal (1930), and the case has since been transferred to the Cyber Police (Central Division). An FIR has been registered under relevant sections of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita and the Information Technology Act. Investigations are ongoing. ADVERTISEMENT Also Read: $2.4 trillion worth of gold! India's household hoard is 6x Pakistan's economy (Disclaimer: Recommendations, suggestions, views, and opinions given by the experts are their own. These do not represent the views of Economic Times) ADVERTISEMENT (You can now subscribe to our ETMarkets WhatsApp channel)
