High interest rates, volatile stock markets could prime private credit to outshine private equity again
[SINGAPORE] Funds that invest in private credit globally may be poised to beat those for private equity (PE) again this year. That is especially if interest rates remain high while exit opportunities in stock markets are stymied by volatility.
An Apr 29 report by index provider MSCI shows that private credit funds generated 6.9 per cent last year, exceeding the PE funds' return of 5.6 per cent. 2024 marked the third straight year of outperformance.
A relatively new asset class, private credit began as a source of liquidity when the global financial crisis of 2008 caused high-yield and syndicated loan markets to seize up. Demand for private credit has been growing, as tighter regulations make it more onerous for banks to lend to companies.
Interest rates on private debt are usually charged at a premium to the benchmark rates, so the asset tends to perform better when borrowing costs are rising, or not falling as quickly as anticipated.
On May 7, the Federal Reserve held interest rates steady for the third time this year. While noting that the US economy has 'continued to expand at a solid pace', the central bank highlighted that the risks of higher unemployment and inflation have risen.
This indicated the Fed has dropped 'its implicit easing bias', Ray Sharma-Ong, head of multi-asset investment solutions, Southeast Asia, at Aberdeen Investments, said in a May 8 report. The uncertainty surrounding US economic outlook due to the impact of tariffs and trade policy 'makes it harder for the Fed to cut rates pre-emptively to support economic growth'.
BT in your inbox
Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.
Sign Up
Sign Up
'Private credit, predominantly consisting of floating rate instruments, has benefited from the higher interest-rate environment. The increased interest income has more than offset any write-downs and default events,' Keith Crouch, executive director at MSCI Research, told The Business Times. 'Given these factors, while private credit funds have shown resilience, the overall trend will depend on how these dynamics evolve.'
Keith Crouch of MSCI Research says that higher borrowing costs have benefited private credit, and the dynamics in the interest-rate climate will influence the asset's outlook. PHOTO: MSCI
Another reason for the more sanguine outlook for private credit compared to PE is the squeeze on exit opportunities amid continued volatility in public stock markets.
PE fund managers rely on deal flow to exit and generate returns for their investors, which typically include pension funds, sovereign wealth funds and insurers. The exits occur when the portfolio companies raise capital via avenues such as initial public offerings, or through mergers and acquisition activity. But these are drying up in the aftermath of the turmoil unleashed on global financial markets by US President Donald Trump's 'Liberation Day' tariffs, and the ongoing trade negotiations.
'The current market environment with the heightened volatility and long-term economic uncertainty simply creates greater exit challenges for PE,' said Michael Jones, managing director at PGIM Private Capital, which manages a US$109.7 billion portfolio of private placements, mezzanine and direct lending investments.
'It is fundamentally easier to exit private credit funds because private credit funds become self-liquidating over time, given the underlying investments have stated maturity dates and private credit can ultimately force an exit if needed (either via a refinancing or a sale) or negotiate an outcome as the borrower needs to address the debt at maturity,' he told BT.
Michael Jones of PGIM Private Capital says private credit funds are 'fundamentally easier' for investors to exit. PHOTO: PGIM PRIVATE CAPITAL
Fewer PE exit opportunities could aggravate the current low rate of distributions, the returns or profits that fund managers disburse to investors.
In the fourth quarter of 2024, the distribution rate of buyout and venture capital funds – two types of PE funds – remained well below their five-year averages before the Covid-19 pandemic, according to the MSCI report. This 'remains a concern' for investors in PE funds as capital they would otherwise redeploy to new investments remains stuck.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
3 hours ago
- Business Times
Gold rises as investors seek safe havens amid Middle East conflict fears
[BENGALURU] Gold prices inched higher on Monday (Jun 23) as investors turned to safe-haven assets amid growing fears of a broader Middle East conflict, with markets closely watching for Iran's response to US attacks on its nuclear sites. Spot gold was up 0.1 per cent at US$3,371.30 an ounce, as at 0020 GMT. US gold futures were steady at US$3,387.20. The world braced on Sunday for Iran's response after the US attacked key Iranian nuclear sites, joining Israel in the biggest Western military action against the Islamic Republic since its 1979 revolution. In a televised address, US President Donald Trump warned Iran against retaliating, stating that any response would trigger further attacks unless Iran agreed to pursue peace. Tehran vowed retaliation, with missile exchanges between Iran and Israel continuing over the weekend. Israeli fighter jets struck military sites in western Iran, according to officials, while Iranian missiles wounded scores of people and flattened buildings in Tel Aviv. Meanwhile, the close split at the US Federal Reserve over whether to keep hedging against inflation risks or move forward faster with rate cuts came through on Friday in the first public comments from policymakers following a decision this week to hold borrowing costs steady for now. The Fed's latest Monetary Policy Report to Congress, released on Friday, said that US inflation remains somewhat elevated and the labour market is solid. However, it suggested that the full impact of Trump's tariffs is likely yet to be felt, reiterating the Fed's stance that it can wait for greater clarity before making policy moves. On Friday, Trump once again floated the idea of firing Fed chair Jerome Powell, whom he has long criticised for not lowering interest rates as much as he wants. Elsewhere, spot silver was up 0.1 per cent at US$36.03 per ounce, platinum fell 0.3 per cent to US$1,260.78, while palladium edged down 0.1 per cent to US$1,043. REUTERS
Business Times
6 hours ago
- Business Times
US Federal Reserve's Daly says employment, inflation risks roughly in balance
[NEW YORK] US Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco president Mary Daly said she sees the central bank's monetary policy stance as 'in a good place' currently, with risks to its US employment and price stability mandates as roughly equal. 'We have to navigate policy not only depending on how the environment evolves, but also with keeping those two objectives in mind,' Daly said on Sunday (Jun 22) while answering questions after a speech prepared for the Western Economic Association International's 100th Annual Conference in San Francisco. Last week, the Fed held interest rates steady at 4.25 to 4.5 per cent and signalled uncertainty remains elevated about the effects of US President Donald Trump's tariffs on the economy. Officials see slower economic growth, higher inflation and rising unemployment, and hold divided views on the outlook for interest rates, according to their latest projections. Fed governor Christopher Waller said on Friday the central bank could begin cutting rates as soon as July. Daly, speaking on Friday, said she sees a move as more likely in the fall. In her speech on Sunday on central bank communications, the San Francisco Fed chief did not comment on the outlook for the economy or policy. She said public guidance on interest rates sometimes 'comes with a price'. Officials should give 'guidance about what we know, humility about what we don't, and a commitment to respond to the world we get, even if it is different from the one we expect', Daly said. BLOOMBERG
International Business Times
2 days ago
- International Business Times
Wall Street Shows Mixed Signals as S&P 500 Down 0.21%, Dow Gains 38 Points as Middle East Tensions Escalate
U.S. stock markets finished Friday with mixed results as traders continued to grapple with new geopolitical uncertainty in the Middle East and further cycles in oil and currency markets. The Dow Jones Industrial Average added 38.47 points, or 0.1%, to end at 42,210.13. The S&P 500, on the other hand, slipped 0.21%, while the Nasdaq Composite sank more deeply by 0.49%. Investor sentiment took on a cautious tone as President Donald Trump postponed taking military action in the wake of recent flare-ups in the Israel-Iran conflict. Markets began the day on a positive note, but worries about what could unfold over the weekend contributed to choppy trades and late-session declines. Energy prices also signaled the market's unease. Brent crude dropped 2.3 percent to $77.01 a barrel, but it was still up 3.6 percent for the week. U.S. crude futures settled at $74.93, down 0.28%, but still up 2.7% for the week, despite a holiday-thinned session on Thursday. "People are holding back from major moves ahead of the weekend. There's still a lot of risk tied to how the situation unfolds," said Rick Meckler of Cherry Lane Investments. Diplomatic Moves and Geopolitical Risks: The United States forged ahead with targeted sanctions on enterprises tied to Iran's defense industry, a diplomatic strategy from the White House. But analysts warn that with Israel and Iran continuing to trade hostilities, any miscalculation would see the crisis ratchet higher and put vital oil infrastructure at risk. "There's always a chance of an unintended spark in these kinds of conflicts," said John Evans, an analyst at PVM Oil Associates. European officials called on Tehran to resume negotiations over its nuclear ambitions after a high-level meeting in Geneva ended without progress. European stock markets closed slightly higher, buoyed by optimism from earlier Asian trading sessions. The MSCI World Index was down slightly by 0.01%, while gains in Hong Kong and Seoul helped balance out losses in the other Asian markets. Fed Talk Spotlights Policy The Gap: Federal Reserve officials spoke publicly for the first time since comments by the Fed's chair, Jerome H. Powell, on Wednesday, indicating that the central bank is likely to cut interest rates this year. But he cautioned that inflation, particularly from Trump's trade tariffs, is a risk. A divide among policymakers is also now visible. Governor Christopher Waller insisted to open the door to a rate cut as soon as the next meeting, and Richmond Fed President Tom Barkin countered that there's no rush to move. Powell, for his part, warned against putting too much stock in forecasts in such a dynamic environment. Waller's dovish take sent bond markets into motion. The yield on the benchmark 10-year Treasuries fell 2 basis points to 4.375%. Strong safe-haven demand, which has been soaring in recent weeks because of global tensions, was another factor contributing to the fall. Currency and Commodity Price Movements The dollar was stronger, reaching a three-week high against the yen. A gauge of the dollar against major currencies inched 0.03% higher on the day and 0.6% for the week. The euro was 0.3% firmer at $1.1528. Gold prices were down 0.13% at $3,365.91, set for a weekly decline despite some strength earlier in the week as a safe haven asset.
