‘The physics community has never split like this': row erupts over plans for new Large Hadron Collider
Scientists are refining plans to build the world's biggest machine at a site beneath the Swiss-French border. More than $30bn (£23bn) would be spent drilling a 91km circular tunnel in which subatomic particles would be accelerated to near light speeds and smashed into each other. From the resulting nuclear debris, scientists hope they will then find clues that would help them understand the detailed makeup of the universe.
It is an extraordinarily ambitious project. However, it is also a controversial one – for many scientists fear the machine, the Future Circular Collider (FCC), could soak up funding for subatomic physics for decades and leave promising new research avenues starved of resources.
Others argue that the mega-collider is being imposed on physicists by senior officials at Cern, the European Organization for Nuclear Research, without properly consulting researchers.
'I'm amazed to see how they are lining up this concept,' particle physicist Halina Abramowicz of Tel Aviv University told the Observer. 'This is not how things are supposed to work. The physics community is supposed to tell Cern what should be the next step, not the other way round.'
These arguments have led the journal Nature to warn this month that 'a battle is under way for the future of particle physics'. Its analysis of the views of dozens of leading physicists revealed that many were critical of the proposed collider and warned it could trigger dangerous divisions between groups. As Prof Ruben Saakyan of University College London told the journal: 'The [physics] community was never split like this before.'
For its part, Cern says that the FCC offers scientists a chance to undertake 'a unique exploration of space, time and matter'. Since its formation in 1954, the organisation – which is based in Geneva – has become a much-lauded example of the effectiveness of international scientific cooperation and has earned itself a reputation for generating world-leading research over the decades.
Its Large Hadron Collider (LHC) – currently the world's biggest machine – revealed the existence, in 2012, of the Higgs particle. This was the first direct evidence that a field – known as the Higgs field – permeates the universe and is responsible for giving different fundamental particles their various masses.
However, the LHC is scheduled for closure by 2040 and many puzzles about the structure of the universe remain unsolved, despite hopes it would provide more major insights. Persisting mysteries include the nature of dark matter, whose existence is inferred from its gravitational influences on galaxies but whose exact makeup is unknown. Similarly, the fact that our universe is made up of matter – while antimatter is virtually nonexistence – cannot be explained from current observations.
To get round these problems, Cern has proposed building its new mega-collider, which would be a much more powerful and much bigger version of the LHC. It would be built in two stages. The first would generate Higgs particles in vast numbers in order to understand their critical role in influencing other fundamental forces and would come online around 2040. Then it would be repurposed after a couple of decades so that it could collide protons at vast energies and provide new data about the universe. This version would begin operations around 2070.
However, the technology to accelerate protons at the unsurpassed energies proposed for the FCC does not exist yet. It is merely assumed that, in 40 years' time, it will have been developed. Such an assumption worries some scientists, as well as the fact that the FCC will cost so much that it will lock scientists into a device that would monopolise funds for particle physics for decades.
'What worries me most is that, by investing all this money, we will be stopping the development of other technologies because there will be no money for them. The FCC could soak up funds for years and years,' said Abramowicz ,who dismissed the idea of the mega-collider as 'a toy' that could certainly not be guaranteed to fix the holes that exist in current theories.
Instead, researchers have suggested that linear accelerators – which would fire particles in straight lines – might prove to be cheaper, more flexible and more likely to achieve results than a circular collider. This point was backed by Jenny List, a researcher based at the German accelerator centre Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron (DESY) in Hamburg.
'There are other technologies on the horizon that could be used to accelerate particles like the proton without needing huge magnets or tunnels,' she said. 'Plasma wave technology is one of these. Current devices are small, but within 20 years or so we could find they are ready to use to run a big collider.'
However, if the FCC were given the go-ahead, it could lock up funds for decades and end up dictating the direction that particle physics will have to take for much of the century, List added.
'We will be telling future generations exactly what to do scientifically, and so we need to ask ourselves today: who are we to decide what our grandchildren should research and not research?'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economist
4 days ago
- Economist
Are China's universities really the best in the world?
A decade ago Nature, a scientific publisher, began tallying the contributions made by researchers at different institutions to papers published across a set of 145 respected journals. When the first such Nature Index was published in 2016, the Chinese Academy of Science (CAS) ranked first, but American and European institutions dominated the top ten. Harvard placed second, with Stanford and MIT fifth and sixth; the French National Centre for Scientific Research (CNRS) and the German Max Planck Society were third and fourth; Oxford and Cambridge took ninth and tenth (seventh and eighth place went, respectively, to the Helmholtz Association of German Research Centres and the University of Tokyo).
Scotsman
13-06-2025
- Scotsman
Biofilm prevention leader Remora announces groundbreaking partnership with global textile chemical innovator
Award-winning Scottish biotechnology company Remora has announced a major milestone in its commercial journey after signing a new long-term licensing agreement with Swiss-based Beyond Surface Technologies (BST) to bring its revolutionary biofilm prevention technology to the global textile market. Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Award-winning Scottish biotechnology company Remora has announced a major milestone in its commercial journey after signing a new long-term licensing agreement with Swiss-based Beyond Surface Technologies (BST) to bring its revolutionary biofilm prevention technology to the global textile market. The partnership will see BST – a specialist in sustainable textile chemistry – integrate the patented Remora® technology into its green chemical formulations for use across performance apparel, outdoor garments and technical fabrics. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Biofilms – invisible layers of microorganisms that adhere to fabrics – are a widespread issue in the textile sector. On performance garments in particular, they cause persistent odours, staining, and material degradation, even after repeated washing. They also pose risks of skin irritation and contamination. Matthias Foessel, Co-founder and CEO of Beyond Surface Technologies Remora® technology offers a breakthrough solution. Developed using a scientifically engineered molecule inspired by red seaweed's natural defense mechanisms, it prevents biofilm formation at source, without relying on toxic antimicrobial agents. Remora's collaboration with BST will support the sustainable creation of cleaner, fresher and longer-lasting textiles. The technology can be used at multiple stages of the supply chain. Dr Yvonne Davies, Chief Commercial Officer at Remora, said: 'This partnership with BST is a transformational step for Remora and a breakthrough moment for the textile industry. Our Remora® technology offers a sustainable, scientifically proven alternative to toxic biocidal treatments and will help brands tackle persistent odour, staining and material degradation caused by biofilms. 'Through BST's extensive global supply chain relationships and deep expertise in green chemistry, we now have a clear route to market with some of the biggest names in fashion, performance wear and technical textiles. This collaboration doesn't just scale our technology, it unlocks its full potential to support a cleaner, safer and more sustainable future for textiles.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Matthias Foessel, Co-founder and CEO of Beyond Surface Technologies, said: 'We are excited to bring this remarkable marine-inspired technology for biofilm prevention to the textile industry. It offers a unique way to keep fabrics and garments cleaner and fresher for longer. 'We're very pleased to have signed this collaboration with Remora, based on a Unilever patent portfolio. This partnership marks another important milestone in our mission to advance chemistry with reduced environmental impact - without compromising on performance.' Originally developed through a decade-long R&D collaboration with Unilever and leading UK universities, Remora's technology now has a direct route into commercial textile markets via BST's formulation expertise and global customer network – which includes many of the world's best-known fashion and sportswear brands.
The Herald Scotland
13-06-2025
- The Herald Scotland
New Forest cicada being reintroduced in UK after extinction
The New Forest cicada (Cicadetta montana) was once found across the New Forest, but the last confirmed sightings were back in the 1990s. Conservationists believe the insects became extinct in the UK because of changes to the way land was managed. Native wild animals in the UK New Forest cicada reintroduced to the UK as scientists say "it's like bringing them back from the dead" Species Recovery Trust project officer, Charlotte Carne, said: 'This has been a really challenging project so it's amazing to see New Forest cicadas in England after all this time. 'It's like bringing them back from the dead.' The Trust recruited a French entomologist this week who captured the 11 female cicadas in northern France and had them shipped to the UK on Wednesday (June 11). It is understood that some of the insects are already pregnant and have been laying eggs in their specially created habitat, which is full of their favourite plants such as raspberry canes and hazel tree saplings. Because cicadas spend at least four years underground as nymphs, the trust will not know until 2029 at the earliest whether this phase of the project has been successful. If they survive, the conservationists can release the adults at secret locations in the New Forest. Species Recovery Trust has said reintroducing the New Forest cicada to the UK is like "bringing them back from the dead". (Image: Pete Hughes/PA) In the meantime, Species Recovery Trust said it hopes to import more cicadas from France to continue the breeding programme at Paultons Park. They are also studying populations of the same species in Slovenia to learn more about their behaviour. Species Recovery Trust director, Dominic Price, said: 'We believe the New Forest cicada probably went extinct because of changes to the way land was managed, but we have worked with Forestry England to put the right kind of management in place. 'What's more, we think that our warming climate could also favour their survival, so we are very hopeful that one day soon, cicadas will sing in the New Forest again.' This project is the first of its kind and has been funded by Natural England, the Swire Charitable Trust and the Valentine Charitable Trust. Acting deputy director for the Thames Solent Area Team at Natural England, Graham Horton, added: 'This project represents a remarkable achievement, showcasing the dedication, innovation and teamwork that made it possible. 'After years of absence, we finally have New Forest cicada on English shores again and we look forward to the next phase of the project to explore re-establishing this species in the New Forest.' What is a New Forest cicada? New Forest cicadas are described as "musical" insects and are known for their singing. Buglife explains: "New forest cicada males are known for their characteristic high pitched singing which they perform to woo females for mating. "The pitch of the Cicadas song is so high that it is at the limits of human hearing, and a struggle for most adults to hear." RECOMMENDED READING: The adult insects are black with distinct golden rings and transparent wings, with females growing to about 5cm while males are slightly smaller. Once New forest cicadas hatch, they are often found high up in trees out of sight, Buglife reports, making them "extremely difficult to find". "Singing is therefore one of the most effective methods of finding these elusive insects," the experts added.
