Allahabad HC clears way for Sambhal mosque survey: Here's what court said in its verdict
PRAYAGRAJ:
Allahabad high court
dismissed on Monday the Sambhal Shahi Jama Masjid committee's petition challenging a Nov 19, 2024 trial court order directing an advocate commissioner to survey the structure, the subject of a suit claiming that the mosque was built in 1526 after demolishing a temple, reports Rajesh Kumar Pandey.
While upholding the trial court's survey order, Justice Rohit Ranjan Agarwal vacated the interim stay on the
Hindu plaintiffs
' suit.
The mosque committee had asked for the suit to be dismissed on the ground that the Hindu side's claim to the site was prima facie barred under the Places of Worship Act, 1991. The legislation prohibits conversion of any place of worship and mandates maintaining the religious character of any such site that existed on Aug 15, 1947.
HC: Plaintiffs only seeking right to access to Sambhal site
This is not a case where any conversion of place of worship is taking place or the religious character is being changed.
The plaintiffs have only sought right to access to a protected monument, declared in 1920 under Section 18 of Ancient Monument and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958, the 45-page judgment states. In its petition, the mosque committee contended that the civil judge (junior division) ordered the survey "hastily" and "without issuing notice".
Based on the Nov 19 directive, a survey was conducted that very day and another one on Nov 24.
Later that month, SC stayed proceedings in the trial court until the mosque committee's petition against the survey order was heard by an HC bench.
Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) said in its submission to the bench that the mosque had been designated as a protected monument under the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958.
This effectively means that its status is governed by preservation laws rather than religious classification.
ASI also mentioned that nowhere in official records was the mosque described as a religious place.
The Hindu plaintiffs contend that the disputed Sambhal mosque stands at what used to be site of an ancient Harihar temple dedicated to Kalki, last avatar of Vishnu. The suit claims in 1526, on orders of Mughal emperor Babar, the temple was partially demolished and a mosque built over it.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
32 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Takeaways from Bengal bypoll: TMC wins big in Kaliganj, BJP says its strategy was on point
IN A big boost for the ruling Trinamool Congress months ahead of the state elections, the party retained the Kaliganj Assembly seat with a margin of 50,049 votes. While TMC candidate Alifa Ahmed won with around 55% of the votes, the BJP's Ashish Ghosh got half the votes, at 28%. The Congress's Kabiluddin Sheikh was placed third, with about 15.21% of the votes. The takeaways from the election: Beset by several scams, and facing anger over the scrapped teachers' recruitment exercise, the TMC heaved a sigh of relief at not just retaining the seat but also its votes. A senior TMC leader said: 'There was no question that the party would win. Our challenge was to hold peaceful elections, and maintain our lead and vote share, which we have done.' West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee posted on X: 'People of all religions, castes, races and walks of life have blessed us… The main architects of this victory are ma-mati-manush (mother, soil, and people).' She also paid tribute to Nasiruddin Ahmed, the late TMC MLA whose death led to the bypoll. Ahmed's daughter Alifa, a graduate and employee of a prominent IT company, was fielded by the TMC for the bypoll. 'I have got the blessings of every corner of Kaliganj,' the 38-year-old said after her victory. The BJP, which continues its replacement of the Congress and Left as the main Opposition in Bengal, said it was happy with the results as their voting share had increased. A senior BJP leader said, 'Generally, in a bypoll, the ruling party always has an advantage. Moreover, in Kaliganj, almost 48% of the voters are from the minority community. We were not expecting any exceptional results. We only wanted to see if we could consolidate the Hindu votes. In that, we have been successful to an extent.' Leader of the Opposition Suvendu Adhikari said, 'The CPI(M) and Congress appear to have got some votes in minority areas, but our target was to consolidate the Hindu votes. Hence we concentrated on only 109 booths, where we got a large chunk of votes. We were successful in this strategy.' Once upon a time, Kaliganj was a Congress stronghold, with its current ally Left also winning the seat multiple times. In 2016, the TMC was defeated by the Congress from here. However, in 2021, the TMC won big from Kaliganj, and has now continued that. The small solace, if any, for the Congress-CPI(M) is that its vote share has seen a rise from 11.98% of the votes in 2021 to 15.21% in this bypoll. With the Left extending support to the Congress in the Kaliganj bypoll, CPI(M) state secretary Md Selim said they are taking heart from their performance. 'The TMC and Bengal ran an extremely communal campaign, but the people of Bengal realise that it will not solve their basic problems… We will gain more in the coming days.'
India Today
an hour ago
- India Today
Trinamool Congress's Alifa Ahmed wins Kailganj bypoll, defeats BJP's Ashish Ghosh
Trinamool Congress (TMC) candidate Alifa Ahmed has won the Kaliganj Assembly bypoll in West Bengal's Nadia district by a massive margin of 50,049 votes, defeating her nearest BJP rival, Ashish Ghosh. The by-election was held following the death of her father and former MLA Nasiruddin Ahmed in February this to the Election Commission of India (ECI), Alifa secured 1,02,759 votes, while BJP's Ashish Ghosh received 52,710 votes. The Congress-Left-supported candidate, Kabil Uddin Shaikh, came third with 28,348 Alifa received around 9,000 votes less than her father's 1,11,696 votes in 2021, her winning margin increased. Nasiruddin had won by 46,987 votes in the last election, whereas Alifa surpassed that, seemingly due to a split in votes between BJP and Congress-Left candidates. Outside the counting centre, Alifa thanked voters for their support. She said, "This victory is because of people's love and faith in Mamata Banerjee's development politics."Responding to BJP leader Suvendu Adhikari's claim that Hindus didn't vote for TMC, Alifa said, 'I do not agree. We received significant leads from some Hindu-majority areas.'She added, 'We did not target votes from any particular community. We approached all voters. The results show people don't support communal division in Bengal.'advertisementWith PTI inputs.
India Today
2 hours ago
- India Today
New Zealand radical leader destroys Hindu, Buddhist, Sikh flags, performs haka
Destiny Church leader Brian Tamaki, along with his followers, held a march in central Auckland, claiming that "the spread of non-Christian religions is now out of control" in New Zealand. During the protest, participants reportedly tore and trampled on religious flags and symbols, including those of Hindu, Buddhist, Sikh, and Islamic communities, performing haka after each such march, promoted under the slogan "Faith, Flag, and Family", was organised by Destiny Church against immigration and non-Christian of the march, Tamaki said church leaders had sent an open letter to Prime Minister Christopher Luxon calling for a reversal of the position that the country has no official religion, Radio New Zealand reported. The protesters marched down Queen Street in Auckland carrying a massive banner declaring, "NZ's official religion: Christianity," according to the report in The New Zealand his followers on Saturday, Tamaki said, "We are living in dangerous times, we are living in the last days. This is about standing for our flag." He also added, "Mass immigration has ruined Christian countries around the world," according to a report by The New Zealand Palestinian, Islamic, Buddhist, and Sikh flags were torn and stomped on by men who performed haka after each ritualistic destruction of flags, The New Zealand Herald also group, largely clad in black and carrying New Zealand flags, gathered at Auckland's Aotea Square around noon."Tear it, boys," the self-described bishop told supporters holding a Buddhist flag, as they destroyed it while performing the haka, New Zealand-based news outlet, Newstalk ZB EMPLOY THEIR OWN PEOPLE, NOT KIWIS: PROTESTERSChurch leader Tamaki specifically targeted the Sikh and the Buddhist communities."Sikhs were taking over our country, our businesses and our companies, and they no longer employ Kiwis, they employ their own people," Newstalk ZB quoted Tamaki as about Buddhism, Tamaki claimed it "might be nice on the surface, but it's dangerous underneath."CHURCH LEADER CALLS FOR NO IMMIGRATION WITHOUT ASSIMILATIONTamaki said one of their demands was enforcing a policy of "no immigration without assimilation."Deputy Prime Minister David Seymour criticised the Destiny Church protest, saying the church leader's messaging was "un-Kiwi"."What it means to be a Kiwi is people come from all over the world, and so long as they come peacefully to build a better world, then they're welcome," he Zealand Police Minister Mark Mitchell has also condemned Destiny Church's protest, stating that their "vile rhetoric and behaviour" has no place in the country. He also criticised the misuse of culturally sacred weapons to spread Federation of Islamic Associations of New Zealand, the Combined Sikh Association of New Zealand, and the New Zealand Buddhist Council have come together to urge politicians to take action before hate crimes rise rapidly and lives are lost, The New Zealand Herald reported on Monday.
