Government Wants Fiordland Wapiti A Special Herd - Forest And Bird Is Appalled
Hunting and Fishing Minister James Meager will consider formally designating Fiordland National Park's wapiti herd as a 'herd of special interest'.
However Forest and Bird is appalled.
The organisation's chief executive officer Nicola Toki accused the concept as letting 'a North American deer species use the national park as a glorified veggie patch - eating away at the very natural heritage that these sanctuaries have been legally designed to protect.'
But Forest and Bird's strong opposition to the wapiti being managed as game animal received a similar backlash.
Laurie Collins convenor of the Sporting Hunters Outdoor Trust said Forest ands Bird's opposition 'bordered on the ideologically idiotic.'
'The strident rhetoric shows Forest and Bird is out of touch with reality,' he said.
Laurie Collins has visited the Fiordland wilderness on numerous occasions since the 1970s with his last visit just a year ago.
He described Fiordland's vegetation as particularly aggressive under the warm, very wet environment which has seen the highest recorded annual rainfall in Fiordland, specifically in Milford Sound, is around 9 metres (29.5 feet), making it one of the wettest places on Earth. Normally the rainfall is about seven metres.
'Even Forest and Bird's founder amateur botanist Leonard Cockayne acknowledged New Zealand's vegetation is aggressive in growth and regeneration,' he said. 'Management of a special wapiti herd embraces management of numbers and quality.'
Hunting and Fishing Minister James Meager said a managed special wapiti herd represent an opportunity for economic growth in regional New Zealand.
'Better, healthier deer herds provide opportunities for domestic and international visitors to hunt the only free-range wapiti herd outside of North America,' said James Meager.
But Forest and Bird were adamant.
'Undermining the incredible landscapes and habitats of Fiordland National Park so that a few hunters can shoot a small number of deer each year, is catering to a handful of vested interests at the expense of all New Zealanders,' said Nicola Toki. 'We are equally clear that putting precious time and taxpayer money into a Herd of Special Interest is not a priority.'
Laurie Collins said Forest and Bird's opposition ignored that New Zealand's vegetation had evolved under intense browsing over 50 million years by large moa numbers and other vegetarian birds such as kokako, takahe, kakapo and wood pigeon (kereru).
'One eminent New Zealand ecologist Dr Graeme Caughley estimated the several moa subspecies totalled several million, meaning high browsing pressure,' he said.
Council of Outdoor Recreation Associations spokesman Tony Orman said Forest and Bird was simply basing its opposition on it's long-held ideology of 'anti-introduced phobia.'
There was ample scientific evidence that Forest and Bird did not acknowledge or selectively chose to ignore and he cited the 1949 New Zealand-American Fiordland Expedition which out researched the relationship of red deer/ wapiti and to the environment.
'The scientists pointed to a change from the natural vegetation (as after moa and before deer) towards a new vegetation still composed of native species but more stable in the face of animal browsing and grazing, was in progress,' said Tony Orman. 'What they said in essence is that vegetation species palatable to the browsers become less but are replaced by non-palatable species. It would've happened with moa, now it's happened with wapiti and deer.'
The 1949 Fiordland scientific research concluded that although the composition of the forest is somewhat altered, 'no changes of economic consequence (through the continued presence of wapiti and deer) can result. Large areas of forest will remain in their pristine condition through inaccessibility despite the continued presence of deer and the number of animals present cannot increase too any extent since the numerical strength of herds is vigorously controlled by the limited area of good browsing range available.'
Tony Orman said the late 1940s when the scientific expedition carried out their extensive research was significantly acknowledged as the peak population years of deer.
Research in the late 1950s by eminent biologist Thane Riney examined an 'unhunted' red deer population in Fiordland and found animal numbers naturally low and had attained balance with the habitat's carry capacity.
'Nature achieved ecological equilibrium on her own. There's no reason for Forest and Bird's hysteria over deer management and in this case of wapiti as a managed herd,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
32 minutes ago
- RNZ News
NZDF Hercules heading to Middle East to help evacuate Kiwis
A defence force hercules is on route to an undisclosed location in the Middle East, to help evacuate New Zealanders from the conflict zone if its able to. Some air space has been closed since the bombing started between Israel and Iran. The plane will remain on standby in the region to assist if and when possible. President Trump claims US stealth bombers have "totally obliterated" key iranian nuclear facilities. Iran has warned of dangerous consequences. International law expert Associate Professor Anna Hood from the University of Auckland spoke to Lisa Owen. Tags: To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
Otago Daily Times
an hour ago
- Otago Daily Times
Destiny Church march 'not Kiwi, nor Christian'
The Minister for Ethnic Communities says he was "appalled" by a Destiny Church march on Saturday which was neither "Kiwi, nor Christian". Church followers marched down Auckland's Queen Street on Saturday against "foreign religions", with leader Brian Tamaki saying the church was building a "Commonwealth crusade" to "reclaim Christian nations". A number of flags were also set on fire but were put out before firefighters arrived. In a post to Facebook, Minister Mark Mitchell said everyone had a right to freedom of speech and protest. "That does mean, however, that New Zealanders are free to condemn behaviour that is not in keeping with our values as a country and as a wider community. "I am proud to be the Minister of Ethnic Communities in a multicultural and diverse New Zealand, which has had a proud history of welcoming people from all walks of life." Destiny Church said the march was to take "a bold public stand for Christian values, Kiwi identity and the future of this nation". Mitchell said behaviour that incited discrimination or violence was "damaging" and condemned the "vile rhetoric and behaviour" of the Church and its associates. "The behaviour I saw was not Kiwi, nor Christian. "The use of taiaha, which is a culturally sacred weapon, to overtly stab at flags representing minority groups in our country, while being torn to pieces and burnt is not acceptable." Mitchell said the government had a strong focus in public safety. "Anything that threatens or disturbs the public's right to go about their lives free from threat of violence is something I take very seriously. "New Zealand welcomes all people, of all backgrounds and ethnicities, who are willing to behave in a way that is tolerant and reflective of our values. The actions I saw from Destiny Church this weekend in my view are not welcome in New Zealand." On Saturday, Acting Prime Minister David Seymour denounced the marching, saying it was "un-Kiwi". "What it means to be Kiwi is people come from all over the world, and so long as they come peacefully to build a better world, then they're welcome," Seymour said. "Brian Tamaki's various attitudes have all sorts of problems, but at their heart they're un-Kiwi attitudes because they're intolerant and uninclusive. "What I take issue with is his attacks on other New Zealander's right to practice their faith just as he has a right to practice his." 'Despicable event' - faith and ethnic communities It comes as faith and ethnic communities urge the government get moving on hate speech legislation in response to a Destiny Church march on the weekend. The Federation of Islamic Associations of New Zealand, the Combined Sikh Association of NZ, and the New Zealand Buddhist Council say the event was "despicable" and New Zealand needs a strategy for social cohesion. In a letter to the government, all MPs and public sector agencies, the groups said there were "elements" in New Zealand who exploit the lack of effective hate speech legislation to gain notoriety for through "racist stunts". "With the rapid rise of hate incidents reported to the NZ Police, we now have similar conditions which gave rise to the terror attacks of 15 March. In an increasing diverse multi-faith and multi-ethnic Aotearoa New Zealand, there needs to be in place a sustained strategy for social cohesion." "This was clearly outlined and specified in detail in the Royal Commission, which have now been mostly abandoned." In the letter the groups requested: • A consensus approach by all political parties on ensuring social cohesion is a national priority. • Expediting the work of the Law Commission on hate crime and include recommendations on the way forward for effective hate speech legislation. • Funding and curriculum resources for schools so tamariki can be exposed to multiculturalism and respect for all communities. • Completion of the recommendations of the Royal Commission. • Funding community-led social cohesion education programmes which emphasise community connections and living with diversity.
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Minister for Ethnic Communities Mark Mitchell condemns Destiny Church march: 'Not Kiwi, nor Christian'
Minister for Ethnic Communities Mark Mitchell. Photo: RNZ / Marika Khabazi The Minister for Ethnic Communities says he was "appalled" by a Destiny Church march on Saturday which was neither "Kiwi, nor Christian". Church followers marched down Auckland's Queen Street on Saturday against "foreign religions", with leader Brian Tamaki saying the church was building a "Commonwealth crusade" to "reclaim Christian nations". A number of flags were also set on fire but were put out before firefighters arrived. Protesters at the Destiny Church rally in Auckland. Photo: RNZ In a post to Facebook, Minister Mark Mitchell said everyone had a right to freedom of speech and protest. "That does mean, however, that New Zealanders are free to condemn behaviour that is not in keeping with our values as a country and as a wider community. "I am proud to be the Minister of Ethnic Communities in a multicultural and diverse New Zealand, which has had a proud history of welcoming people from all walks of life." Destiny Church said the march was to take "a bold public stand for Christian values, Kiwi identity and the future of this nation". Mitchell said behaviour that incited discrimination or violence was "damaging" and condemned the "vile rhetoric and behaviour" of the Church and its associates. "The behaviour I saw was not Kiwi, nor Christian. "The use of taiaha, which is a culturally sacred weapon, to overtly stab at flags representing minority groups in our country, while being torn to pieces and burnt is not acceptable." Mitchell said the government had a strong focus in public safety. "Anything that threatens or disturbs the public's right to go about their lives free from threat of violence is something I take very seriously. "New Zealand welcomes all people, of all backgrounds and ethnicities, who are willing to behave in a way that is tolerant and reflective of our values. The actions I saw from Destiny Church this weekend in my view are not welcome in New Zealand." Protesters and counter-protesters at the Destiny Church rally. Photo: RNZ On Saturday, Acting Prime Minister David Seymour denounced the marching, saying it was "un-Kiwi". "What it means to be Kiwi is people come from all over the world, and so long as they come peacefully to build a better world, then they're welcome," Seymour said. "Brian Tamaki's various attitudes have all sorts of problems, but at their heart they're un-Kiwi attitudes because they're intolerant and uninclusive. "What I take issue with is his attacks on other New Zealander's right to practice their faith just as he has a right to practice his." It comes as faith and ethnic communities urge the government get moving on hate speech legislation in response to a Destiny Church march on the weekend. The Federation of Islamic Associations of New Zealand, the Combined Sikh Association of NZ, and the New Zealand Buddhist Council say the event was "despicable" and New Zealand needs a strategy for social cohesion. In a letter to the government, all MPs and public sector agencies, the groups said there were "elements" in New Zealand who exploit the lack of effective hate speech legislation to gain notoriety for through "racist stunts". "With the rapid rise of hate incidents reported to the NZ Police, we now have similar conditions which gave rise to the terror attacks of 15 March. In an increasing diverse multi-faith and multi-ethnic Aotearoa New Zealand, there needs to be in place a sustained strategy for social cohesion." "This was clearly outlined and specified in detail in the Royal Commission, which have now been mostly abandoned." In the letter the groups requested: Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
