Do not discriminate against gender-critical women, Lib Dems told

The Liberal Democrats have been told to stop discriminating against gender-critical women by their chief executive.
Mike Dixon has written to constituency chairs across the country to remind them of equality laws after the party lost a number of legal battles with their members.
He warned that associations cannot 'discriminate on the basis of someone's protected beliefs' even if they 'disagree with them or find their views offensive'.
In response, the Liberal Democrat Christian Forum (LDCF) noted: 'It is a sad indictment of the democratic health of the Liberal Democrats that party HQ has to remind activists to be Liberal.'
Mr Dixon's warning comes after the party was forced to pay £14,000 to Natalie Bird, who was removed as a prospective parliamentary candidate for Wakefield after she wore a T-shirt with the slogan: 'Woman: Adult Human Female'.
Last month, in the face of lengthy legal action they also backed down and agreed to lift a ban which had prevented Liberal Voice for Women, women's rights campaigners who believe in biological sex, from holding events.
'Be constructive, polite, play the ball not the person'
In the email, seen by The Telegraph, Mr Dixon said: 'There have been a number of legal judgements recently in cases involving political parties and other relevant organisations concerning discrimination on the basis of protected beliefs, in particular gender critical beliefs.
'The costs of these for local and national parties can be very significant.'
He said that he wanted to give chairs 'some broad principles that will help you avoid legal action'.
Reminding members of guidance by the equalities watchdog, he added: 'The short version is that you need to treat members with protected gender-critical beliefs in the same way as any other member.'
Mr Dixon said that the 'basic rules of thumb' which should protect the local party and members from legal challenge included 'be constructive, polite, play the ball not the person, and be measured in any criticism'.
He noted that online they 'cannot exclude someone from a party group or remove posts solely because of their protected beliefs' even if they are seen as offensive.
'There is real danger of political parties continuing to be taken to court about these issues unless we get the response right,' he added. 'We would all prefer to spend money on campaigning and winning seats than defending legal cases.'
The party is still facing legal action from David Campanale, a former BBC journalist, who is suing for breaches of the equality act claiming that he was deselected as a prospective MP over his Christian beliefs.
As part of the case the party has been accused of creating a 'hostile environment' for people of faith and failing to investigate serious allegations of discrimination and harassment.
'Braver, more inclusive instincts should have prevailed'
In response to Mr Dixon's warnings, the LCDF called for the party to apologise to Mr Campanale for the delays and the 'apparent tolerance of secular bigotry' and to hold a 'fair and independent investigation' into his complaints of equality breaches.
'Our hope now is that the party would end the run of expensive court cases by admitting it has got this one wrong,' the letter added.
Commenting on behalf of the LDCF executive, Cllr John Pugh, the former Liberal Democrat MP for Southport, added: 'Happily we are not dealing with a widespread problem.
'However, it is neither credible nor consistent for the party to warn associated bodies against breaking the law while weakly adopting a 'head in the sand attitude' in David Campanale's case and adding pointlessly to its own mounting litigation costs. The better, braver, more inclusive instincts of the party should have prevailed.'
A Liberal Democrat spokesman said: 'We are proud to be a liberal party where our members have a range of views on all sorts of issues, but come together to discuss them in a friendly and constructive way.
'Liberal Democrats are committed to respecting and defending the rights of all people, and to combating all forms of prejudice and discrimination. Our party policy is clear on these issues.'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Daily Mail​

17 hours ago

• Daily Mail​

New British Army recruits 'should be paid a £10,000 bonus' to help solve the forces' manpower problems and make UK 'war ready'

Britain should pay new recruits a one-off £10,000 bonus as a way of stopping the British Army haemorrhaging manpower, the Liberal Democrats have suggested. Leader Ed Davey suggested the cash be paid out to new recruits who complete their training and serve for at least two years. Additionally, re-joining bonuses for veterans should be increased to £20,000 to help retain talent, under a scheme that would cost the taxpayer up to £45million. The British Army has struggled to recruit and retain soldiers for years, with the trained personnel strength hitting 70,752 in January this year. Sir Ed, who last week visited British soldiers in Estonia, said the bonuses could be paid to help the force reach 73,000, the level desired in the Government's Strategic Defence Review earlier this week. Sir Ed said that UK troops were doing 'incredible work' amid a growing threat from Russia. But he added: 'It is clear that given the threat of a barbaric Putin and the challenge of an erratic Trump, we need to do more to make Britain war-ready. 'A new bonus scheme is needed to urgently attract new recruits, encourage experienced ex-soldiers back into the Armed Forces and reverse years of short-sighted troop cuts under the Conservatives. 'War readiness also starts at home. That's why I'm calling for a public awareness campaign aimed at every home in Britain – to make sure we're all prepared for the possibility of a conflict or hostile acts such as major cyber attacks. 'We need to also step up cooperation with our European friends, including through the Joint Expeditionary Force, to protect our interests in the Arctic and High North against Putin's imperialism.' Ministers have acknowledged the British Army - and other UK forces - are struggling with numbers. At the start of June Defence Secretary John Healey suggested it might be the 2030s before the 73,000 target was met. Asked when the Army would reach the target he told the BBC: 'We've narrowed the gap, but we've still got more people leaving than joining. 'The first job is to reverse that trend and then I want to see in the next parliament our ability to start to increase the number.'

The Independent

20 hours ago

• The Independent

Almost a quarter of privately rented homes in UK fail to meet basic living standards

New analysis reveals almost a quarter of privately rented Homes in the UK, over a million properties, fail to meet basic living standards. This includes nearly half a million Homes with Category 1 hazards, posing serious and immediate risks to health and safety, alongside issues like poor thermal comfort and disrepair. The findings are highlighted as the UK experiences high temperatures, raising concerns about the safety and liveability of these substandard Homes. The Liberal Democrats, who commissioned the research, are advocating for a new insulation program and an immediate ban on no-fault evictions. The government is addressing the issue through a new Renters' Rights Bill, aiming to end no-fault evictions and enforce the Decent Homes Standard in the private rental sector.

BBC News

a day ago

• BBC News

Surrey MP backs water safety school lessons after drowning deaths

Calls for water safety lessons to be "embedded" in schools have been backed in the House of Liberal Democrat MP Monica Harding supported the move in a debate earlier this week when it was revealed 1,700 people had drowned in the UK since who represents Esher and Walton, said her constituency had seen three such drowning deaths in the past four years."These are tragedies with unimaginable pain for the families and profound effects for schools, emergency services and the wider community," she said. Harding said that a "river-based constituency" like hers owed it "to our residents, visitors and local businesses to prioritise water safety"."The Thames threads through our towns, the River Mole runs through our parks and reservoirs sit at the heart of our communities, so addressing the root causes is so important," she said that those risks had only been heightened by the recent spell of hot weather."We must do more to ensure that water safety is embedded in our children's education, especially in areas such as mine which have rivers and open waters," Harding other matters discussed were whether a new Water Safety Minister should be appointed and if better signage was required at outdoor swimming spots.