Explaining the curious case of ‘Emilia Pérez,' the woebegone Oscar frontrunner
NEW YORK — Jacques Audiard's 'Emilia Pérez' is an Oscar contender unlike any other. It's a musical, a trans parable, and a Mexico-set melodrama, all combined into one unique amalgamation by an international filmmaking team.
And just as singularly, it's a best picture front-runner that, it sometimes seems, no one likes.
On one hand, 'Emilia Pérez' is one of the most celebrated films of the year. It triumphed at the Golden Globes, earned 11 BAFTA nominations and landed 13 Academy Award nominations. Only three movies, ever, have scored more.
On the other hand, 'Emilia Pérez' has been lampooned for its tonal extremes, criticized for its depiction of Mexican culture and engulfed in controversy since it ascended to Oscar-favorite status.
A lot is hinging on how far 'Emilia Pérez' can go. If it manages to steer through the backlash and go home the big winner at the March 2 Oscars, it would hand Netflix its first best picture win. Its star, Karla Sofía Gascón, is the first openly trans actor nominated for best actress. A win would be even more historic.
Those possibilities, though, appear severely threatened after old tweets of Gascón's led her to issue an apology Thursday — the latest setback in an Oscar campaign that's veering close to becoming a train wreck.
But how did we get here in the first place? What has made 'Emilia Pérez' so acclaimed and reviled in equal measures?
It started in Cannes
When 'Emilia Pérez' debuted at the Cannes Film Festival last May, the reception was mixed but generally favorable. Audiard, the French director of 'A Prophet,' 'Dheepan' and 'Rust and Bone,' has made tales of transformation a specialty. But 'Emilia Pérez' is perhaps his boldest foray yet into shape-shifting narratives.
Gascón stars as a Mexican drug lord who, with the help of a lawyer (Zoe Saldaña), undergoes gender-affirming surgery. Later, she emerges to reconnect with the children she had with her ex-wife, played by Selena Gomez.
The narco-musical is unabashedly audacious — a quality that the film's supporters warmly embraced. The film's ensemble shared in the best actress award at Cannes, and the movie won the jury prize. Netflix acquired it for a reported $12 million.
Becoming an Oscars front-runner
While 'Emilia Pérez' seemed to have promising awards chances for its actors, it didn't take on the air of Oscar heavyweight until late fall. By then, Netflix, which aggressively campaigns for awards, had built 'Emilia Pérez' into an unlikely juggernaut.
Working in its favor: This year's awards season has been seen as wide open. Also, the other much-honored musical, 'Wicked,' features songs from the Broadway adaptation, leaving it on the sidelines in the best song category where original tunes are required. Both 'El Mal' and 'Mi Camino' from 'Emilia Pérez' were nominated for best song.
It also, as France's submission, was nominated for best international film. As the film academy has expanded its membership in recent years, many more overseas voters have swayed the Oscars toward international nominees. A Spanish-language, French production featuring Hollywood stars perfectly suits the increasingly global Oscars.
Audiences have their say
As the awards chances of 'Emilia Pérez' expanded, audiences also began to weigh in. If critics were split, viewers have been largely negative, according to some metrics. On Rotten Tomatoes, the movie earned a passing grade from 76% of reviewers, but just 19% from audiences. Netflix doesn't report box office figures, so 'Emilia Pérez' has no quantifiable ticket sales in the U.S. and Canada. The film also hasn't ranked highly on the streaming service.
As more watched the film, some poked holes in it. GLAAD passed over 'Emilia Pérez' in its annual awards. The LGBTQ rights alliance declared the movie 'a profoundly retrograde portrayal of a trans woman' and 'a step backward for trans representation.'
Moviegoers in Mexico likewise weren't impressed, taking issue with the film's jumble of Spanish accents, its simplistic treatment of drug violence in the country and what some described as pervasive inauthenticity. The Mexican comedian and actor Eugenio Derbez called Gomez's accent 'indefensible' before later apologizing.
A group of Mexican filmmakers even responded with a payback parody short film titled 'Johanne Sacreblu,' described as 'a French-inspired film made entirely without a French cast or crew.'
Gascón's social media posts surface
In late January, the journalist Sarah Hagi captured old posts on X by Gascón disparaging Muslims, George Floyd and China. After an uproar, Gascón apologized Thursday in a statement provided by Netflix.
The posts dating back as far as 2016 included suggestions that Islam be banned and that Floyd, a Black man killed by a white Minneapolis police officer in 2020, was a drug addict who 'very few people ever cared' for.
'As someone in a marginalized community, I know this suffering all too well and I am deeply sorry to those I have caused pain,' Gascón said. 'All my life I have fought for a better world. I believe light will always triumph over darkness.'
Gascón's X account was subsequently deactivated.
What happens next
Just how much damage has been done to the Oscar chances of 'Emilia Pérez' remains to be seen. Gascón was seen as unlikely to win over best actress favorite Demi Moore ('The Substance'), but pundits believe the fallout could be wider for a movie that already had a lot of dings against it.
Other films, though, have weathered controversies on the way to Oscar glory. The divisive 2019 best picture winner 'Green Book' had many detractors but still pulled out the win. This year, it should be a close race, regardless. An unusually large number of films, including 'Anora,' 'Conclave,' 'The Brutalist,' 'Wicked' and 'A Complete Unknown,' are believed to have a legitimate chance.
Oscar voting begins Feb. 11. Before the Oscars in March, ceremonies by the Screen Actors Guild, the Producers Guild and BAFTA should provide some clues as to whether 'Emilia Pérez' is still the favorite or not.
Originally Published: January 31, 2025 at 3:31 PM CST
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Elle
an hour ago
- Elle
Meet the Real Family That Inspired Netflix's 'The Waterfront'
Said to be a blend of Succession, Outer Banks, and Ozark, Netflix's new eight part series The Waterfront follows the Buckley family living in the fictional coastal city of Haventown, North Carolina. After becoming a prominent force in the region due to their successful fishing and restaurant businesses, the Buckleys take drastic measures to survive when hardship strikes. The dark crime thriller is actually based on real events. Below, everything we know about the story that inspired The Waterfront. The official logline is as follows: 'For decades, the Buckley family has ruled Havenport, North Carolina, dominating everything from the local fishing industry to the town's restaurant scene. But their fishing empire has started to crumble as patriarch Harlan Buckley (Holt McCallany) recovers from two heart attacks, and his wife Belle (Maria Bello) and son Cane (Jake Weary) venture into the deep end to keep the family businesses afloat. 'As their attempts spiral out of control and into treacherous waters, Harlan steps back in to take command. Facing her own demons, Buckley daughter Bree (Melissa Benoist)—an addict in recovery who's lost custody of her son Diller (Brady Hepner)—finds herself entangled in a complicated relationship that could threaten the family's future forever.' Screenwriter and series creator Kevin Williamson (known for the Scream franchise) calls The Waterfront his most personal story yet, drawing directly from his own upbringing and family's past. 'I come from a long line of fishermen,' he told Netflix's Tudum. In the interview, he revealed that due to the fishing industry's collapse in the 1980s, his father was forced into making desperate and questionable choices. 'The fishing industry sort of upturned… my dad couldn't feed his family. So, someone came along and said, 'Hey, if you do this one thing, you can make all this money.' And it was hard to say no to.' His father became a drug runner, transporting them on his boat. 'My dad—a very, very good man—got tempted to do some things that weren't so legal…it put food on the table, helped me go to college.' As for the family dynamics seen in The Waterfront, many of the characteristics of his family members echo throughout the Buckley family. 'I had my dad in my head,' Williamson said of the character Harlan. Belle Buckley, the matriarch of the family, is based on his actual mother, William revealed. 'Mine kept everything going. I got to school and graduated college because of the fire she lit under my butt.'
USA Today
2 hours ago
- USA Today
'Elio' star Zoe Saldaña lives for winning 'cool mom points' with her kids
How does Zoe Saldaña follow up an Academy Award win? By starring in a Pixar animated movie. Her kids think one is cooler than the other, and it might not be the one you expect. 'Definitely winning an Oscar, because they're playing soccer right now,' Saldaña says. 'They're like, 'Mom! Oscar is like the World Cup!' And then my third son was like, 'What? You got it for supporting actress, right?' And I'm just like, 'Oh, Zen. Thank you for keeping me on my toes.' 'But they're always proud of the fact that I'm making an effort in wanting to cater to films that they can watch right now.' Saldaña has starred in big franchises like 'Guardians of the Galaxy' and 'Avatar' but also stayed busy in the animation space, with roles in the 'Maya and the Three' miniseries, 'Missing Link,' 'My Little Pony: The Movie' and now Pixar's 'Elio.' Saldaña voices Olga Solis, the aunt and guardian of an 11-year-old boy named Elio (Yonas Kibreab) who wishes he could be abducted by aliens and is picked up by a spaceship full of colorful creatures. The "Emilia Pérez" star always wants her sons – twins Cy and Bowie, 10, and Zen, 8 – to be proud of her, and 'my kids are absolutely revelations to me every single day,' Saldaña says. 'They're my biggest teachers. And obviously I say that behind their backs. I never want them to feel completely responsible for my growth, but they are teaching me a lot by just growing around me and evolving and setting their boundaries and claiming their space and revealing themselves to themselves.' By being in stories that appeal to younger audiences, 'it just contributes to my deeper education on wanting to know how to be a better mom to my kids,' she adds. 'I just want to be cool for a longer time than possible. In my mind, I feel like that this gives me cool mom points.' Her character in 'Elio,' though, has to figure out how to be a mom. Olga is an Air Force major who's put her dreams of being an astronaut on hold to care for her nephew, and they struggle to get along. When Elio gets beamed up to space and goes on his adventures there, a clone Elio is sent back to Earth to take his place. And this one, Elio 2.0, is agreeable, generally compliant and overall 'too perfect,' Saldaña says. 'That sounds in theory like a perfect Mother's Day, where the mom has a yes day,' Saldaña says. 'Can I make you some broccoli with that? Yes. Do you want to pick up after yourself? Absolutely. But if that were to happen in reality in my life, I would be like at the hospital with my kids, like there's something wrong with my child. Why he's saying yes to everything I'm proposing?! 'With Olga, even though everything on the surface was fine, something was unsettling. That woke up that maternal instinct in her to, to really say, 'OK, I may not understand my kid, but I love my kid so much so that I know when he's off, I know when he's not being himself.' ' Saldaña, who next stars in "Avatar: Fire and Ash" (in theaters Dec. 19), enjoys collaborating with kids on movie projects. 'It's shorter work hours when you work with children,' she says. 'You don't have to do those long 14-hour days. If all your scenes are with that child, you get to go home when they go home and I kind of love that. 'It's easier for me to work with other kids than to work with my own. I can't really imagine ever being able to work with my own kids because I wouldn't be able to separate being their mom at all times.' A couple of Saldaña's sons have expressed some interest in acting. She and husband Marco Perego 'would support our children if this is what they would want to pursue," Saldaña says. "But so far, the moment we go, 'Well, come on, let's wake up at 4 o'clock in the morning, let's get on the road for two hours, let's memorize these 10 pages,' they're like, 'Uh, I don't think so.' '
New York Post
3 hours ago
- New York Post
Jam expert Donna Collins trashes Meghan Markle's As Ever apricot spread: ‘There's no excuse for this'
The queen of jam has spoken. Jam expert Donna Collins trashed the new apricot spread from Meghan Markle's As Ever lifestyle brand. 'It's a real disappointment that Meghan is selling a fruit spread, which is what you make when your jam fails,' Collins said, according to the Daily Mail. 9 Donna Collins. The Jelly Queens 9 Meghan Markle cooking in her kitchen. Netflix 'In the jam industry a spread is what we call something that didn't work,' the Jelly Queens owner continued. 'It can have the best ingredients, but if I had a jam that was too runny, I'd slap a label on it and call it a spread.' 'There's no excuse for this,' Collins added. 'It should be perfect.' 9 Meghan Markle in an Instagram video. @meghan/Instagram 9 Meghan Markle making jam with her daughter, Lilibet. The 'MasterChef' alum, who has reportedly won over 40 world championship honors in jam-making competitions, also called out Markle, 43, for her 'conventionally grown apricots, which will have used pesticides.' 'And why is she using pectin, which is a gelling agent, unless it's because her spread was too runny?' Collins asked. 'Most spreads don't use pectin.' 9 Meghan Markle's homemade jam. @heatherdorak/Instagram On Friday, Markle released her new apricot spread in an individual jar for $9 and keepsake packaging for $14. Both items quickly sold out. 'Her apricot spread sold out in minutes, just like her earlier raspberry spread, which may mean they only made a small batch,' Collins surmised. 'I don't know who's making her spread,' the jam guru continued, 'but we all know it's not Meghan. It sounds like they really don't know what they are doing.' 9 Meghan Markle cooking in her kitchen. meghan/Instagram The Post has reached out to Markle's reps for comment. Markle revealed her plans to sell homemade jam after announcing her own lifestyle company last year. The 'Suits' alum even sent out lemon-filled gift baskets containing fresh fruit jam to 50 of her friends last summer. 9 Meghan Markle and Prince Harry at Beyonce's Cowboy Carter tour in Los Angeles. Instagram/@meghan 9 Meghan Markle's jam. She ended up releasing fruit spread instead of jam as part of the official launch of her lifestyle brand in April. The other products (which also all sold out) included a limited-edition $28 wildflower honey with honeycomb, $12 herbal teas (hibiscus, peppermint and lemon ginger), $14 crepe mix and shortbread cookies with $15 flower sprinkles. 9 Meghan Markle cooking in her kitchen. @aseverofficial/Instagram Earlier this month, The Sun reported that Markle is looking to add hotels and restaurants to her brand. Markle made her love of hosting known in her Netflix series 'With Love, Meghan' which debuted on the streamer in March. Despite negative reviews, the series was renewed for Season 2 as part of Markle and Prince Harry's $100 million deal with Netflix that they signed in 2020.
