US strikes on Iran nuclear sites are real-life test of hard power's limits
North Korea-style race for bomb is one possible scenario
VIENNA: US military strikes overnight in which President Donald Trump said Iran's main nuclear sites were 'obliterated' will put to the test the widely held view that such attacks can delay a nuclear program but not kill a determined push for atom bombs. As Iran's nuclear program has expanded and become more sophisticated over the past two decades, many officials and nuclear experts have warned: You can destroy or disable a nuclear program's physical infrastructure but it is very hard or impossible to eliminate the knowledge a country has acquired. Western powers including the United States have publicly suggested as much, complaining of the 'irreversible knowledge gain' Iran has made by carrying out activities they object to.
'Military strikes alone cannot destroy Iran's extensive nuclear knowledge,' the Washington-based Arms Control Association said in a statement after the US strikes with massive bunker-busting bombs on sites including Iran's two main underground enrichment plants at Natanz and Fordow. 'The strikes will set Iran's program back, but at the cost of strengthening Tehran's resolve to reconstitute its sensitive nuclear activities, possibly prompting it to consider withdrawing from the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, and possibly proceeding to weaponization.'
Zionist entity has also said it has killed Iranian nuclear scientists but, while little is known about the personnel side of Iran's nuclear program, officials have said they are sceptical about that having a serious impact on Iran's nuclear knowledge, even if it might slow progress in the near term. The West says there is no civilian justification for Iran's enrichment of uranium to near weapons-grade fissile purity. Iran says its nuclear objectives are solely peaceful and it has the right to enrich as much as it wants.
Iran's nuclear program has made rapid advances since Trump pulled the United States out of a 2015 nuclear deal between Tehran and major powers that placed strict limits on its atomic activities in exchange for sanctions relief. After the US withdrawal in 2018 and the re-imposition of US sanctions, Iran pushed past and then far beyond the limits imposed by the deal on items like the purity to which it can enrich uranium and how much it can stockpile.
At least until Zionist entity's first strikes against its enrichment installations on June 13, Iran was refining uranium to up to 60 percent purity, a short step from the roughly 90 percent that is bomb-grade, and far higher than the 3.67 percent cap imposed by the 2015 deal, which Iran respected until the year after Trump pulled out. The last report on May 31 by the International Atomic Energy Agency, the UN nuclear watchdog that inspects Iran's nuclear facilities, showed Iran had enough uranium enriched to up to 60 percent, if enriched further, for nine nuclear weapons, according to an IAEA yardstick.
It has more at lower levels like 20 percent and 5 percent. The exact impact of Zionist and US strikes on Iran's nuclear facilities and materials has yet to be determined. In addition to the enrichment sites, the US struck Isfahan, where officials have said much of Iran's most highly enriched uranium stock was stored underground. One important open question is how much highly enriched uranium Iran still has and whether it is all accounted for. A senior Iranian source told Reuters on Sunday most of the highly enriched uranium at Fordow, the site producing the bulk of Iran's uranium refined to up to 60 percent, had been moved to an undisclosed location before the US attack there. Deputy Foreign Minister Kazem Gharibabadi told state TV last weekend Iran would take measures to protect nuclear materials and equipment that would not be reported to the IAEA, and it would no longer cooperate with the IAEA as before.
The IAEA has not been able to carry out inspections in Iran since the first Zionist airstrikes nine days ago, but has said it is in contact with the Iranian authorities. What Iran will do next in terms of its nuclear program is also unclear. Its threat to pull out of the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty hints at a race for nuclear weapons, but Iran has maintained it has no intention of doing so. The only other country to announce its withdrawal from the NPT is North Korea in 2003. It expelled IAEA inspectors and went on to test nuclear weapons.
'Our biggest concern is that we end up with a North Korea scenario whereby these strikes convince the Iranians that the only way to save the regime is to go for the bomb. Nobody is bombing North Korea now, are they?' a European official said. Even if inspections continue, because of Trump's withdrawal in 2018 Iran had already scrapped extra IAEA oversight provided for by the 2015 deal. That means the agency no longer knows how many centrifuges Iran has at undeclared locations. The IAEA says that while it cannot guarantee Iran's aims are entirely peaceful, it also has no credible indication of a coordinated nuclear weapons program.
The Zionist and now US strikes have already raised fears among diplomats and other officials, however, that Iran will use those centrifuges to set up a secret enrichment site, since one could be built inside a relatively small and inconspicuous building like a warehouse.
'It is quite possible that there are enrichment sites that we don't know about. Iran is a big country,' a Western official said, while adding that Iran could also choose to bide its time. 'In two years, if Iran were to start from scratch, they would only need a few months to reconstitute a new program and to get back to where they were yesterday.' — Reuters
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Kuwait Times
5 hours ago
- Kuwait Times
Ankara slams Zionist assaults, UNRWA to open office in Turkey
ISTANBUL: The United Nations' Palestinian refugee agency UNRWA will open an office in Ankara, President Tayyip Erdogan said on Saturday, urging Muslim countries to give the agency more support after the Zionist entity banned it. Turkey has called the Zionist entity's assault on Gaza genocide and its move to ban UNRWA a violation of international law, particularly amid worsening humanitarian conditions in Gaza, which has been reduced to rubble with millions displaced. Addressing foreign ministers of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation in Istanbul, Erdogan said opening an Ankara UNRWA office would deepen Turkey's support for the agency. 'We must not allow UNRWA, which plays an irreplaceable role in terms of taking care of Palestinian refugees, to be paralyzed by (the Zionist entity). We expect our organization and each member state to provide financial and moral support to UNRWA to thwart (the Zionist entity's) games,' Erdogan said. A Turkish diplomatic source said Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan and UNRWA chief Philippe Lazzarini were expected to sign an accord on the sidelines of the OIC meeting in Istanbul on establishing the office. Turkey has given UNRWA $10 million a year between 2023 and 2025. In 2024, it also transferred $2 million and sent another $3 million from its AFAD disaster management authority. Fidan on Saturday accused the Zionist entity of leading the Middle East towards 'total disaster' by attacking Iran on June 13. Iran and Zionist entity have been at war for nine days after the Zionist entity, claiming the Islamic Republic was on the brink of acquiring a nuclear weapon, launched a massive wave of strikes on its archrival, triggering an immediate response from Tehran. '(The Zionist entity) is now leading the region to the brink of total disaster by attacking Iran, our neighbor,' Fidan told a meeting of top diplomats of the OIC. 'There is no Palestinian, Lebanese, Syrian, Yemeni or Iranian problem but there is clearly a (Zionist) problem,' he said. He called for an end to the 'unlimited aggression' against Iran. 'We must prevent the situation from deteriorating into a spiral of violence that would further jeopardize regional and global security,' he added. Speaking after Fidan, Erdogan accused Western leaders of providing 'unconditional support' to the Zionist entity. A trenchant critic of the Zionist entity's actions in both Gaza and Iran, Erdogan called for 'high-level peace talks' between Tehran and the United States, according to his office, adding that Turkey was ready to play a 'facilitator' role to help bring an end to the war. Erdogan, who met Iranian foreign minister Abbas Araghchi on the sidelines of Saturday's meeting, said Turkey would not allow borders in the Middle East to be redrawn 'in blood'. 'It is vital for us to show more solidarity to end (the Zionist entity's) banditry — not only in Palestine but also in Syria, in Lebanon and in Iran,' he told the OIC's 57 member countries. The OIC, founded in 1969, says its mission is to 'safeguard and protect the interests of the Muslim world in the spirit of promoting international peace and harmony'. According to Qatar's foreign ministry, Araghchi also met the Gulf state's top diplomat in Istanbul, who said he was working to bring the sides 'back to the path of dialogue'. – Agencies
Kuwait Times
5 hours ago
- Kuwait Times
Second flight brings more Kuwaitis home from Iran
KUWAIT: Relatives welcome their loved ones who were evacuated from Iran after they arrived at Kuwait International Airport (T4) on Sunday, as part of an ongoing emergency operation to return stranded nationals. — KUNA photos KUWAIT: A new group of citizens evacuated from Iran arrived at Kuwait International Airport (T4) on Sunday, as part of an ongoing emergency operation to return nationals stranded due to the Zionist entity's attack on Iran and Tehran's retaliation. 'In line with the State of Kuwait's keenness to ensure the safety of its citizens abroad and guarantee their safe return to the homeland, the second batch of evacuation flights carrying Kuwaiti citizens arriving from the Islamic Republic of Iran has landed today, Sunday, via the Republic of Turkmenistan,' Kuwait News Agency (KUNA) said Sunday. The operation is part of a large-scale evacuation plan being implemented by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in coordination with relevant authorities. The first evacuation flight arrived in Kuwait early Saturday, carrying 334 citizens who had been transported overland from cities across Iran to Ashgabat, the capital of Turkmenistan, before flying home aboard a Kuwait Airways plane. 'The concerned authorities continue around the clock to complete all stages of the evacuation and provide all necessary facilities, in translation of the political leadership's directives and its constant concern for the safety of citizens abroad and their safe return to the homeland,' said KUNA. Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Sheikh Jarrah Jaber Al-Ahmad Al-Sabah personally received the evacuees at Kuwait International Airport and praised the efforts of all agencies involved. The evacuations were prompted by intensifying conflict between the Zionist entity and Iran, now entering its second week. While no injuries have been reported among Kuwaiti nationals, the government activated a comprehensive evacuation strategy to safeguard citizens in Iran. 'The Ministry of Foreign Affairs has prepared a comprehensive emergency evacuation plan for Kuwaiti citizens in Iran in light of the accelerating developments in the region,' Minister Abdullah Al-Yahya told Kuwait News Agency last week. Assistant Foreign Minister for Asian Affairs Sameeh Hayat confirmed that over 1,000 Kuwaitis are expected to be evacuated 'as quickly as possible.' — Agencies
Kuwait Times
5 hours ago
- Kuwait Times
Iranian ambassador slams US and Zionist strikes as violation of international law
Envoy meets Kuwait Times Editor-in-Chief on visit to newspaper KUWAIT: Iranian Ambassador to Kuwait Mohammad Toutounchi strongly condemned on Sunday what he described as a 'coordinated and armed aggression' carried out by the Zionist entity and the United States, calling the attacks a flagrant violation of international law and the principles of the United Nations Charter. During a meeting with Kuwait Times Editor-in-Chief Dr M Ziad Al-Alyan, the ambassador insisted that Iran's recent actions were legitimate acts of self-defense. He noted that the initial Zionist strikes on Iranian facilities had failed to meet their objectives, prompting direct US intervention. 'We were certain from the beginning that Israel would not act without coordination with the United States,' he stated. 'What happened last night confirmed our expectations.' Toutounchi also criticized the failure of international organizations to condemn or respond to the escalation. 'These international institutions took no initiative or action to halt this assault. This exposes the fragility of the international system in the face of political pressure, particularly that exerted by the Zionist lobby in the United States,' he said. The ambassador went on to accuse both the United States and the Zionist entity — nuclear-armed states — of launching an attack on a country that does not possess such weapons, calling it a blatant violation of the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons. 'This aggression clearly shows that the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty has lost its true meaning in the face of American political interests,' he said. Praising the response of some Gulf states, including Kuwait, Toutounchi noted that there had been coordination and high-level communication between foreign ministries, which ensured the safe evacuation of Kuwaiti nationals from Iranian cities affected by the strikes. He expressed particular concern over the targeting of nuclear facilities, calling it 'a reckless gamble that disregards international treaties and conventions'. 'What happened indicates that these two regimes (the US and the Zionist entity) place no value on human life. Their only concern is imposing dominance, even if the price is a nuclear disaster in the region,' he added. In response to recent statements by US President Donald Trump claiming success in dismantling Iran's nuclear program, the ambassador dismissed the remarks as 'full of contradictions and typical media propaganda'. 'They were aiming to overthrow the Islamic system, but they have returned empty-handed and are now trying to cover up their failures with such falsified statements, which in reality reflect their defeat,' he said. Toutounchi reaffirmed that Iran's nuclear program is 'entirely national in origin' and remains unaffected by attacks. He stressed that all of Iran's peaceful nuclear activities are under the supervision and monitoring of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). 'All of Iran's actions are declared and under international oversight. No political or military pressure will deter us from continuing to develop our defensive capabilities,' he added. In a press statement, the ambassador reiterated that the attack represents an unprecedented and egregious violation of the UN Charter and international law. He held the US government 'fully responsible for the extremely serious consequences of this major crime'. He urged the United Nations, the Security Council, the UN Secretary-General, the IAEA and other relevant international bodies to take urgent action against what he described as a criminal breach of international law. 'Iran reminds the world that silence in the face of such blatant aggression puts global peace and security at unprecedented risk. As a founding member of the United Nations, the Islamic Republic of Iran expects the organization and its responsible members to fulfill their duties at a time when the world is witnessing a clear violation of the law by the United States,' Toutounchi concluded.
