Opinion: Cynicism masquerades as insight, but at heart, it's a defence of disengagement
Rick Bell's recent column (G7 protest in Calgary: One hell of a goat rodeo on the streets, June 15) is a classic entry in a long-standing tradition: the takedown of public expression of discontent. Whether it's community members gathering at city hall to protect an urban wild space they've come to know as a commons, or protesters rallying against injustice in Palestinian territories, this column performs the same move — it belittles them.
Article content
Article content
With phrases such as 'play-acting and posturing,' the writer seems to ask: What's the point?
Article content
Article content
Article content
But here's what's telling. In these dismissives, the heroic figure is always the one who does not. Not the one who protests. Not the one who speaks at city hall. Not the one who marches.
Article content
The hero is the one who stays home. Who says nothing. Who drinks their beer undisturbed while the world burns on the livestream in the background.
Article content
It's not insightful to mock protesters for being performative. All protest is performance. It always has been.
But it's also effort, presence and sometimes desperation. It's what people do when all the other doors are closed — when letters, meetings and 'appropriate channels' fail.
Article content
What Bell fails to address is the kind of dissent that erupted in Fort Macleod at the UCP 'town hall' on coal — where 70 per cent of the crowd took vivid, emancipatory glee in tearing apart the optics of a 'consultation,' whose real purpose was to manufacture a media image of monolithic consent.
Article content
Article content
That was protest in its unruly, disruptive form. And yet, even that kind of collective defiance is dismissed when it doesn't fit the right caricature.
Article content
And still, I find myself partially in agreement. A young Communist I met two weeks ago said something that stayed with me: That once upon a time, power didn't know what to do when the streets flooded with people. That unpredictability disturbed them.
Article content
Now, norms and containment define protest. Marches follow routes agreed upon with police. Cordiality reigns. The site is remote from where decisions are actually made — just as Calgary City Hall is from Kananaskis.
Article content
And yes, the recent protest was a bazaar of causes. That's what happens when people are told they have one designated chance to be heard — when the system reduces democratic expression to a side-stage act, offered once every few years.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
39 minutes ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
UK government says it will ban pro-Palestinian group after activists broke into military base
LONDON (AP) — Britain's government said Monday it will ban the pro-Palestinian activist group Palestine Action under anti-terrorism laws after the group's members broke into a military base and vandalized two planes last week. The measure means it will be a criminal offense to belong to or support the group, with a maximum of 14 years in prison. It came as protesters in support of Palestine Action clashed with police during a demonstration in central London. Officials said two of the group's members entered the Royal Air Force base in Brize Norton on Wednesday and damaged two planes with red paint. The group released video footage appearing to show one of the activists spraying the paint into a jet's turbine engines. The group alleged that Britain was continuing to 'send military cargo, fly spy planes over Gaza and refuel U.S./Israeli fighter jets,' and condemned the country as 'an active participant in the Gaza genocide and war crimes across the Middle East.' The base incident was being investigated by counter-terror police. Metropolitan Police chief Mark Rowley described Palestine Action as an 'organized extremist criminal group,' while Home Secretary Yvette Cooper said the protest at the airbase was the latest in the group's 'long history of unacceptable criminal damage.' She said the group's recent actions, including an attack against a defense factory in Glasgow in 2022, have resulted in damage that runs into millions of pounds. In March, Palestine Action targeted one of U.S. President Donald Trump's golf resorts in Scotland, painting 'Gaza is Not For Sale' in giant letters on the lawn in response to his proposal to empty the Gaza Strip of its Palestinian population. The government said a draft order will be laid in Parliament next week. Lawmakers still need to approve it. Britain's government has proscribed about 80 organizations, including Hamas and al-Qaida, and far-right groups such as National Action.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Mark Carney says he and Trump spoke about de-escalating conflict in the Middle East
Prime Minister Mark Carney listens as U.S. President Donald Trump speaks during a group photo at the G7 Summit, Monday, June 16, 2025, in Kananaskis, Canada. (AP Photo/Mark Schiefelbein) Prime Minister Mark Carney confirmed Monday he spoke with U.S. President Donald Trump on the ongoing wars in the Middle East. 'We focused on de-escalating the conflict in the Middle East, our shared commitment to a stronger NATO at this week's summit, and the progress in the ongoing trade negotiations between our countries,' Carney wrote in a social media post on X. I spoke with President Trump overnight. We focused on de-escalating the conflict in the Middle East, our shared commitment to a stronger NATO at this week's summit, and the progress in the ongoing trade negotiations between our countries. — Mark Carney (@MarkJCarney) June 23, 2025 The talk follows the U.S. strikes on Iran Saturday night. Trump said in a post on his Truth Social platform Sunday 'monumental damage' was done to the three nuclear sites in Iran that were targeted. Trump also said Saturday on Truth Social that any retaliation by Iran would be met with 'force far greater than what was witnessed tonight.' In response to the strikes, Carney in an X post Sunday called on all parties to 'return immediately to the negotiating table and reach a diplomatic solution to end this crisis.' 'As G7 leaders agreed in Kananaskis, the resolution of the Iranian crisis should lead to a broader de-escalation of hostilities in the Middle East, including a ceasefire in Gaza,' Carney wrote. The U.S. strikes come after Israel targeted Iranian nuclear and military sites on June 13, prompting Iran to retaliate with its own aerial attacks. Israel and Iran have been in an ongoing war since.
Global News
an hour ago
- Global News
Alberta voters to decide if NDP's Nenshi, separatists to hold legislature seats
Alberta NDP leader Naheed Nenshi is looking to finally win a seat in the legislature after a year of sitting on the sidelines. He's running in one of three provincial byelections today as a candidate in Edmonton-Strathcona, where his predecessor Rachel Notley last won 80 per cent of the vote. In Edmonton-Ellerslie, NDP candidate Gurtej Singh Brar could solidify the opposition party's hold on the city, but United Conservative Party candidate Naresh Bhardwaj is hoping to make an inroad. In rural central Alberta, the separatist Republican Party of Alberta is aiming to capitalize on discontent with Ottawa. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Republican leader Cameron Davies has been campaigning in Olds-Didsbury-Three Hills against the UCP's Tara Sawyer, the NDP's Bev Toews and Bill Tufts of the Wildrose Loyalty Coalition. The seat became vacant after former legislature speaker and long-time UCP member of the legislature Nathan Cooper resigned to take a post as Alberta's representative in Washington, D.C. Story continues below advertisement 1:56 Alberta voters to decide if NDP's Nenshi, separatists to hold legislature seats Also vying for the Edmonton-Strathcona seat are UCP candidate Darby Crouch, Republican Ravina Chand, Samuel Petrov of the Alberta Party, Liberal Don Slater and Wildrose Loyalty Coalition candidate Jesse Stretch. Candidates in Edmonton-Ellerslie include Caroline Currie of the Alberta Party, Pamela Henson from the Wildrose Loyalty Coalition, Fred Munn of the Republican Party and Liberal Manpreet Tiwana. The south-Edmonton riding had been represented by Rod Loyola under the NDP banner until he resigned to run in the federal election.
