NYC mayoral candidate draws criticism for ‘globalize the intifada' comparison to Warsaw uprising
New York City mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani is facing criticism over remarks he made in which he avoided denouncing the phrase 'globalize the intifada' and compared it to the Warsaw ghetto uprising during the Holocaust.
Mamdani appeared for an interview with The Bulwark, released on Tuesday, in which host Tim Miller asked him for his thoughts on the phrase, which has evoked strong emotions on both sides of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Many pro-Palestinian activists have said the phrase refers to Palestinians fighting for their own rights and opposing Israeli occupation, while pro-Israel activists and many Jewish people view the phrase as calling for a global uprising to commit violence against Zionists, who support Israel's existence, and Jews more broadly.
'To me, ultimately, what I hear in so many is a desperate desire for equality and equal rights in standing up for Palestinian human rights,' he said in comments first reported by Jewish Insider. 'And I think what's difficult also is that the very word has been used by the Holocaust Museum when translating the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising into Arabic, because it's a word that means struggle.'
Mamdani seemed to refer to the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, D.C.
But the museum issued a rare statement weighing in on a political issue on Wednesday, denouncing Mamdani's comparison.
'Exploiting the Museum and the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising to sanitize 'globalize the intifada' is outrageous and especially offensive to survivors,' the museum said in a post on X. 'Since 1987 Jews have been attacked and murdered under its banner. All leaders must condemn its use and the abuse of history.'
Intifada is an Arabic word literally meaning uprising, but many associate it with the First Intifada in the 1980s and 1990s and the Second Intifada in the early 2000s, during which Palestinians in the Palestinian territories and Israel took part in an uprising leading to significant violence in the area.
But pro-Palestinian activists maintain they only use the phrase to refer to Palestinian liberation.
The Warsaw Ghetto uprising took place during World War II when Jews in German-occupied Poland pushed back against the Nazis and some escaped.
Mamdani responded to the criticism he's faced in comments at a press conference on Wednesday, saying, 'There's no room for antisemitism in this city and this country.' The conference was initially held to announce former mayoral candidate Maya Wiley's endorsement of Mamdani's campaign.
'It pains me to be called an antisemite. It pains me to be painted as I'm somehow in opposition to the very Jewish New Yorkers that I know and love and that are such a key part of this city,' he said.
Throughout the campaign, Mamdani has faced criticism over his stances on Israel and accusations of antisemitism over some public statements he's made. He's been a sharp critic of Israel's war in Gaza and was challenged earlier this month over his unwillingness to say definitively that he supports Israel's right to exist as a Jewish state.
'I support Israel's right to exist as a state with equal rights,' he said in a local media interview. 'Because I'm not comfortable supporting any state that has a hierarchy of citizenship on the basis of religion or anything else. Equality should be enshrined in every county in the world.'
Former New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, who is the front-runner in the race, slammed Mamdani for saying the phrase about the intifada is 'subject to interpretation.' He called on all mayoral candidates to denounce the comment.
'That is not only wrong – it is dangerous,' he said in a post on X. 'At a time when we are seeing antisemitism on the rise and in fact witnessing once again violence against Jews resulting in their deaths in Washington DC or their burning in Denver – we know all too well that words matter. They fuel hate. They fuel murder. As the US Holocaust Museum so aptly said, all leaders or those running for office must condemn the use of this battle cry. There are no two sides here.'
During the press conference, he also referred to his own status as a Muslim political candidate and messages of hate he's received over it.
'I get messages that say, 'The only good Muslim is a dead Muslim.' I get threats on my life, on the people that I love, and I try not to talk about it,' he said, adding he wants to focus on making the city more affordable and one that 'every New Yorker sees themselves in.'
'The thing that's made me proudest in this campaign is that the strength of our movement is built on our ability to build something across Jewish and Muslim communities, across New Yorkers of all faiths and all backgrounds and all boroughs,' Mamdani said.
He addressed attacks he's received from other candidates over this issue, arguing it's been a political tool rather than a genuine attack.
'Antisemitism is such a real issue in this city, and it's been hard to see it weaponized by candidates who do not have any sincere interest in tackling but rather in using it as a pretext to make political points,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
15 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Yemen's Houthis mull how they can help ally Iran against Israel
As the war between Israel and Iran continues, Yemen's Houthi rebels say they are coordinating with Tehran. The Houthis, also known as Ansar Allah, have since 2023 launched attacks on Israel and shipping in the Red Sea in what they say is support for Palestinians in Gaza. The Houthis are also a close ally of Iran, and now they say that their latest attacks are on behalf of the 'Palestinian and Iranian peoples', according to the Telegram account of Houthi spokesperson Yahya Saree, who added that the Yemeni group were coordinating with 'the operations carried out by the Iranian army against the criminal Israeli enemy'. On Sunday, two days after Israel first attacked Iran in the early hours of June 13, the Houthis announced that they had targeted Israel. In a televised address, Saree said the group fired several ballistic missiles at Jaffa. The Houthis are timing their attacks with the Iranians, according to Hussain Albukhaiti, a pro-Houthi political commentator. The Houthis are launching missiles 'after Iran launched its missiles', Albukhaiti told Al Jazeera. 'This way the Zionist settlers [Israelis] keep going back and forth to their shelters so they can live a small fraction of the fear they caused the Palestinian people in Gaza.' The Houthi attacks are essentially a continuation of their previous periodic missile and drone attacks on Israel. The Israelis have mostly been able to intercept the attacks but some have gotten through, most notably an attack in early May on Ben Gurion airport that injured six people and led to a suspension of flights. But the Houthi attacks have also had another consequence for Israeli defences, according to Yemen expert Nicholas Brumfield. 'The constant threat of Houthi attacks coming from the south requires Israel to spread out its air defences rather than positioning them all to more effectively [defend] counterattacks coming from Iran,' he told Al November 2023, the Houthis began attacking ships they say were linked to Israel in the Red Sea. International ships that travel to the Red Sea are forced to pass Houthi-controlled areas of Yemen. The attacks have ceased in recent months, particularly after the Houthis and the United States came to an agreement to stop attacking each other in early May, following a US bombing campaign that is reported to have killed more than 200 people in Yemen. But the attacks could still resume, and the Houthis never agreed to stop targeting Israel, which itself has also continued to bomb Yemen. 'We had an agreement with the US to stop attacking each other, but Yemen will not obey this agreement if the US joins the Zionists in their attacks against Iran,' Albukhaiti said. 'We remember that Trump cancelled the nuclear deal between Iran and the US,' he said, referring to the US president's unilateral withdrawal from the nuclear deal between Iran and several Western countries in 2018. Albukhaiti accused Trump of cancelling the deal because it was not in Israel's interest. 'Yemen will do the same, and will cancel the agreement with the US, because it's not in the interest of Iran, which is an important ally of Yemen,' he said, referring to the Houthi rebel group as 'Yemen', although the group's government is not recognised internationally. Iran has also threatened to close the Strait of Hormuz, which lies between it and Oman. About 20 million barrels per day (BPD), or the equivalent of about 20 percent of global petroleum liquids consumed, pass through the Strait of Hormuz, according to the US Energy Information Administration (EIA). Analysts said the Houthis could potentially do the same in the Red Sea. Sea mines are 'very low-tech, easy-to-make mines that would nevertheless introduce considerable uncertainty for global shippers,' Brumfield said. 'I don't think that Iran or Yemen will hesitate to use sea mines if necessary to block the entire shipping lines in our region,' Albukhaiti are also fears that the conflict could drag in other countries in the region. The US has bases in a number of countries in the Middle East, and the Houthis have previously been involved in fighting with many of them, including Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates. If the current conflict spirals, Gulf countries may find themselves threatened by Houthi attacks. 'The Houthis are trying to recover from the US strikes we saw between mid-March and May, and probably aren't begging to restart those more intensive strikes if they don't have to,' Brumfield said. 'But I also think they'd be amenable to restarting them if they saw themselves as participating in a grand regional war between the US-Israel and the Axis of Resistance, especially if a lot of US military resources are diverted to Iran.' Albukhaiti said Houthi forces 'could also target US bases in the region', specifically those involved in the coalition against Yemen, such as Saudi Arabia and the UAE, because 'we are still at war with these countries', he said. The Saudi-led coalition intervened militarily in the war in Yemen between the Houthis and the country's internationally recognised government in 2015, unleashing a years-long campaign of air strikes. Saudi Arabia ceased hostilities in Yemen in 2022, but has yet to officially reach a deal with the Houthis. And before that, it had come under Houthi attack. In 2019, Saudi oil production was cut by around 50 percent after Houthi drone strikes on oil plants. Since then, analysts say the Saudis have worked hard to keep more stable relations with the Houthis in order to avoid further attacks. But despite these efforts, the detente could be forgotten if the Houthis see fit to resume hitting their northern neighbour. 'I don't think [attacks on Saudi Arabia are] off the table,' Brumfield said. 'If elements in Houthi leadership in favour of a military-first approach win out, it's plausible they would attack the Kingdom [of Saudi Arabia] as part of a general escalation in both the regional and Yemen conflict.' Brumfield added that the Houthis would, however, have to also keep in mind that Saudi Arabia has provided 'diplomatic cover' for the Houthis in the past few years, as it seeks to find a final deal to end the conflict in Yemen. Any attacks from the Houthis would likely make Saudi Arabia abandon that groups in Yemen have been watching events carefully over the past few months, as they sense an opportunity with the initial US campaign against the Houthis, and now the weakening of the Houthis' principal ally, Iran. 'The most [the Houthis are] capable of doing is continuing symbolic attacks on Israel or potentially restarting activity in the Red Sea,' Raiman Al-Hamdani, an independent Yemen analyst, told Al Jazeera. 'But doing so could provoke a renewed military response from the US, Israel, and the UK, which might weaken their position domestically and open space for anti-Houthi groups to exploit any resulting instability.' However, analysts say that few of the groups that oppose the Houthis, including the Yemeni government, are in a position to take and effectively govern territory from the Houthis. And, should those groups mobilise, the Houthis would likely respond, Albukhaiti said. Houthi forces could target any domestic opponents through 'oil and gas fields and platforms' as well as the 'airports and water distillation plants' of the countries he said backed the groups, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates.
Yahoo
44 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Deep divisions in NYC over Israel and Gaza prove thorny political ground for Cuomo, Mamdani
Zohran Mamdani stepped into a simmering political quagmire earlier this week when he was asked on a podcast about a term seen as deeply offensive by many Jews — the word 'intifada.' Mamdani explained during the interview with The Bulwark Tuesday that pro-Palestine protest chants like 'globalize the intifada,' to him signify a call for Palestinian human rights. He noted the word has been used by the U.S. Holocaust Museum when translating into Arabic the history of a Jewish uprising against the Nazis. It might seem a perplexing position: For decades, anyone with hopes of leading New York City, which has the largest Jewish population outside of Israel, has seen strong support of Israel as a given. But the ground has shifted in the wake of the Oct. 7 terror attacks by Hamas and Israel's subsequent military campaign in Gaza, particularly among younger voters. New York is sharply divided on the issue. The Democratic primary comes as antisemitic hate crimes have surged in New York City, outrage runs high over the killings of Palestinians in Gaza and the Trump administration is pulling funding from universities, claiming antisemitism concerns. Cuomo struck back at Mamdani on Wednesday, slamming him for saying the word intifada was 'subject to interpretation,' and the former governor has continued to hammer the issue. 'At a time when we are seeing antisemitism on the rise and in fact witnessing once again violence against Jews resulting in their deaths in Washington D.C. or their burning in Denver – we know all too well that words matter. 'They fuel hate,' Cuomo said in a statement. 'They fuel murder.' Mamdani, who would be the city's first Muslim mayor and was born in Uganda, said Wednesday that he feels 'an obligation to speak out against violence and against bad faith or misinformed efforts to manipulate language in ways that only contribute to the division we're seeking to overcome.' He's also spoken out about death threats amid an NYPD hate crimes investigation into allegations that a man threatened to blow up his car. Amid the deep division and latest flare up, though, more classic local issues such as political experience and the affordability of living in the city have by and large received more air time from candidates than the conflict in the Middle East. Cuomo has generally focused more on Mamdani's age and relative lack of experience. Meanwhile Mamdani has aimed his attacks on Cuomo's donor base for overlap with Trump supporters and slammed the ex-governor as part of a broken political machine that care little about working New Yorkers. The divisions over Israel and Gaza are unquestionably intense. The conflict has emerged as a classic wedge issue with the potential to drive turnout among the candidates' respective bases. At the same time, New Yorkers largely have such deeply held and sharply divided opinions on the question that it is tough for candidates to change minds. 'You can't win on Israel anymore,' said Hank Sheinkopf, a longtime pro-Israel Democratic strategist, who firm has done consulting work for a PAC in opposition to Mamdani. 'But you can win on experience, and you can win on policies that don't stand.' Over the last 18 months, large demonstrations on both sides of the issue have gripped New York. Hate crimes have surged. Support for Palestine has been particularly strong among younger, more progressive voters. Many establishment Democrats continue to voice strong support for Israel, including Reps. Chuck Schumer and Ritchie Torres in Washington, D.C., as well as Cuomo and Mayor Adams locally. Mamdani has taken a different approach. He has voiced strong support for the Palestinians in Gaza and sharp criticism of Israel's military efforts. He has used the term 'genocide' to describe Israel's actions — a term many find offensive. That approach comes amid a changing political landscape. A national Quinnipiac poll released last week found that an all-time high percentage of voters expressed that their sympathies lay more with Palestinians than Israelis, with 37% saying they supported Israelis more and 32% saying Palestinians. Among Democrats, just 12% said their sympathies lay with Israelis, with 60% saying they sided with Palestinians. Locally, a recent Emerson poll found that 46% of poll takers did not think it was important that the next mayor have a pro-Israel stance, compared to 33% who believed it important they do. Polls show a tightening race between the frontrunner Cuomo and Mamdani with just days before voting closes. Other candidates, including Comptroller Brad Lander, who's consistently polling in third and is seeing a boost in momentum following his arrest, are looking to break in amid high voter turnout. Over 212,00 have already cast their ballots in early voting as of Friday morning. In the final days, a super PAC backing Cuomo is sending mailers, airing TV advertisements and expanding their ground game, criticizing Mamdani's proposal to raise taxes on the wealthiest city residents to fund free buses and childcare. Mamdani, for his part, is painting Cuomo as part of the same old political establishment that has ignored the concerns of working people for years. Israel and Gaza are unquestionably critical to many voters, but that doesn't mean that — at this point in the game — they provide the best opportunity for candidates to win over undecided voters or flip those who've already made a decision, experts say. Bread and butter issues like affordability, housing and public safety will likely take take center stage in this race as Election Day nears, Democratic strategist Trip Yang told the Daily News. 'Certain communities and certain constituencies and certain activists certainly care about this a lot,' he said, 'but it's not the main factor citywide.' With Chris Sommerfeldt
Bloomberg
an hour ago
- Bloomberg
Democratic Socialism Is Dangerous, Summers Says
Former US Treasury Secretary Lawrence Summers says a Democratic socialist program would be very dangerous for New York City. He talks about the New York City Democratic mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani in an interview conducted on June 19 for "Wall Street Week." (Source: Bloomberg)
